13 ms·
I'm also hearing this morning that we've hit the 10% mark. I also heard the same economist say "The economy is collapsing, and it's a global collapse". I don't
by airstrike 7y ago
I'm also hearing this morning that we've hit the 10% mark. I also heard the same economist say "The economy is collapsing, and it's a global collapse". I don't even need coffee to be alert the rest of the day...
- mehrdadn 7y agoWould you have a link to more reading from that economist about this?
- airstrike 7y agoNot really, sadly. I just heard him on an internal conference call we have twice a week, so don't really have a link to provide but don't think he's published his views in writing just yet. I expect a lot of similar predictions to come out now that the unemployment claims number is out (as of ~1 hour ago) For general views of very smart people on the economy and markets, I recommend Bloomberg Surveillance every morning on the Bloomberg app, radio and on your favorite podcast app
- mehrdadn 7y agoAh I see, okay thank you.
- wayoutthere 7y agoThis kind of info usually circulates in the corporate world for a week before it hits the wider media zeitgeist. My company has been holding weekly analyst briefings on what to expect. Right now, the sources I have say to expect to be WFH and "socially distanced" until July or August at the earliest. Restaurants will probably start slowly opening back up around then, but conferences or sporting events are going to be cancelled through at least the end of the year. A single sporting event or conference can lead to thousands of new infections, so none of that stuff is coming back for a long time. Past that, we were told to expect 3 waves of economic pain: one right now when everyone loses their job, another big layoff cycle in 3 months once companies that can WFH start to adjust for structural changes, and a third wave near the end of the year after people start to seriously curtail consumption in response to the first two waves and global demand falls off a cliff. This information has been getting priced into the market for a few weeks, so none of it is new. But these numbers are just starting to hit the wider media and your average American is starting to panic because we're looking at a decade or more of hurt before this is all over.
- grey-area 7y agoI'm more pessimistic in the short term than this (particularly for the US, which still doesn't have a national lockdown), but more optimistic in the long term. Despite our best efforts, this thing is burning through entire populations, and will do so quickly (within a couple of months globally, except some places in asia who escaped the first wave but are now seeing more). Every active person leaving home is going to be exposed in short order, thus infecting their household, and even in lockdowns people need to eat. Almost every country waited too long to lock down, and large countries still haven't effectively done so. The downside of that is a horrific global death toll (1 million confirmed cases this month, maybe 10 million infected? megadeath next month?). The upside is that we will at some point reach herd immunity and/or develop and manufacture a vaccine and economies will restart. Looking at Italy I find it hard to believe that almost every household has not been exposed by now - all it takes is one infected during the lockdown and the entire household gets it. Their new cases are declining and their deaths are flat already. There will be substantial economic damage but I think the recovery may be quite fast as there will be a clear cause which has been addressed (probably by a rushed vaccine currently in trials - there are lots globally). I don't believe a lockdown of more than 2 months is acceptable to most, even with a 1% risk of death, and such lockdowns require the consent of the population to function.
- standardUser 7y ago"Every active person leaving home is going to be exposed in short order" This virus is not transmitted via magic. Even basic precautions lower the transmission rate considerable. Most places are now taking precautions that are far beyond basic.
- grey-area 7y agoMost places are seeing increasing rates of infection, even in spite of extreme measures. I'm not suggesting it's magic, just that it's more infectious than a common cold, which is pretty hard to avoid in winter where I live at least. I agree that could be worded better (I'll leave it up since you've replied), but I meant it's hard to avoid if you're going shopping every few days - people are not good at infection control and many are pretty much asymptomatic for a long period. Lockdowns are controlling the rate of spread, not stopping it, despite best efforts, and will I suspect be released after a few months for that reason - because it has infected > 50% anyway and those people are allowed out after testing.
- buzzkillington 7y agoAnd all this for a virus that kills around 1% of the people who get it, and the majority of them are retired. Future generations will look at us and wonder how we were this stupid.
- AlexandrB 7y agoYou should check the numbers coming out of Italy. It’s not 1% if the medical system is overwhelmed. Moreover, you do realize that’s 3 million dead in the US alone?
- x0x0 7y agoIt's universally true that the people eager to feed the olds (and a bunch of non-olds, too) into the wood chipper never seem to have their, and their parents', do-not-treat orders signed.
- nostrebored 7y agoIt's also not the reported number in Italy. The sources of error in the data are enough to make the data fairly meaningless. 1. We have no idea how many people were infected 2. We have no idea how many people who have died died from Covid 19 3. The population pyramid in Italy is extremely disparate from the rest of the world. The medical system being overwhelmed is a portion of the contribution, and what it means to be 'overwhelmed' is about as clear as what it means to have an error in your application. Are you overwhelmed due to lack of beds? Lack of ventilator access? Lack of doctors? What are the numbers for these in the remainder of the world? Treating any modeling we have of the impact of Covid 19 as reliable is an exercise in insanity. EDIT: To be clear this isn't to say that the responses are unwarranted. It's just to say that they are conservative and acting on knowingly incorrect information. If they were the right decisions remains to be seen. The impact of global financial collapse isn't just 'stocks down', but has tangible impacts on life expectancy, healthcare quality, and quality of life globally. Time will tell.
- Majromax 7y ago> Treating any modeling we have of the impact of Covid 19 as reliable is an exercise in insanity. In detail, yes. In general, you can still make some good back-of-an-envelope calculations. Conservative estimates are that the coronavirus has a CFR of about 1% given adequate medical care (South Korea's statistics, where testing has been comprehensive enough that we should have identified any wide pool of asymptomatic cases), and another low estimate of its R0 factor is 2. Left unsuppressed, this implies that the disease would spread to infect about half of the population, and it would kill 1% of those infected. For the United States, that implies that a "flattened curve" -- where mitigation prevents medical resources from being overwhelmed but does not fully suppress the disease's spread -- will kill about 1.6 million people. Beyond that, we know that the disease requires intensive care at some multiple of the death rate (say 2x) and hospitalization at another multiple (say a further 3x). These estimates are reasonably consistent with New York's numbers (https://nymag.com/intelligencer/article/new-york-coronavirus-cases-updates.html https://nymag.com/intelligencer/article/new-york-coronavirus...). Testing shortfalls could make these multiples worse, if there are hospitalized or ICU patients positive for the virus but not included in these totals. Given overwhelmed medical services, we can presume that a large fraction (say half?) of ICU patients would die for want of care, and a smaller but still significant fraction of hospitalized patients would do the same (1/8?). This implies that an un-flattened curve would have roughly triple the death rate, with the excess caused by inadequate care. With a 3% inadequate-care CFR, if left to run its course the disease would then kill about 4.8 million Americans. > It's just to say that they are conservative and acting on knowingly incorrect information. If policymakers are acting on "knowingly incorrect information," it's because their assumptions are too benign rather than too severe. I believe that my estimates above should be uncontroversial, and to the extent they err I've tried to err on the less-deadly, less-contagious side.
- TeMPOraL 7y agoAny speculations on how bad is this going to get? Should I stock up on TP, on food, or on vodka and ammo?
- techdevangelist 7y agoThe three A’s of the apocalypse; ammo, alcohol and antibiotics..
- samstave 7y agoFour A's: AU
- jfk13 7y agoNo.
- toomuchtodo 7y agoFood, non-perishables, fuel? Yes. Firearms and ammo? To each their own. We did, but we're more rural. Our concern is a supply chain meltdown when you have millions infected and sick. I would rather be prepared and not need something, then need something and not be prepared.
- TheOtherHobbes 7y agoThat's a reasonable concern, IMO.
- MiroF 7y ago> Our concern is a supply chain meltdown when you have millions infected and sick. This is an absurdist prediction - we are looking at maximum 2 million 75+ year olds dying with some much smaller number of people of different ages. This is the group least likely to be involved in the day-to-day functioning of our supply chains. Honestly, where are people coming up with these doomsday predictions?
- TeMPOraL 7y ago