17 ms·
Trolls break into meetings on Zoom
- guessbest 7y agoThey don't implement security by default to gain traction, both the service and the user groups. The expected happened unexpectedly.
- j-wags 7y agoI attended a PhD defense yesterday that got zoom bombed. They quickly moved it to an actively managed call and the presenter did a fine job of keeping their composure and getting back on track. Now we're circulating guides about how to set up secure rooms and webinars, so I don't anticipate this will happen again. Normally I'd wave this off as a childish prank, but both the URL and loading screen prominently indicated the name of a major medical school, and the contents of the presentation were proteins and chemical structures. Bombing this meeting in particular seems to be in especially bad taste during a pandemic.
- jchrisa 7y agoThis happened to a local political debate I was attending. Disturbing to say the least. It's not hard to defend against as a power-user host, but the default case might be better locked down. Maybe this preference should prominent in account setup.
- Alupis 7y ago> Bombing this meeting in particular seems to be in especially bad taste during a pandemic Either that... or it's a way to get high profile attention to blatant security issues in a commonly used business meeting tool where sometimes sensitive information is shared.
- tptacek 7y agoPeople are not trolling Zoom meetings as part of a high-minded awareness campaign.
- Alupis 7y agoMaybe... maybe not. It sure is bringing about awareness though, isn't it?
- edoceo 7y agoAhh yes, the old ends justifying the means.
- Alupis 7y agoNot going to defend a bunch of trolls, if that's what you're implying. However, if we don't secure our systems, what do we expect? If there were no bad-actors in the world, people like tptacek would be out of work. What a glorious world it would be, no need for locked doors, fences, passwords, pin codes and more - but that's not the world we live in. Instead, we're in a world where Zoom has laughable security for barging into potentially sensitive meetings being conducted by businesses and world leaders[1]. If it takes a few meetings getting trolled for Zoom to finally take action, I'm not going to feel much sympathy. Just be glad trolling is all they're doing right now. So, while I'm sorry your meeting got trolled, it will just continue to happen until you get mad at the people that made it possible - Zoom. [1] https://mobile.twitter.com/BorisJohnson/status/1244985949534199808 https://mobile.twitter.com/BorisJohnson/status/1244985949534...
- 7y ago
- roel_v 7y ago"Now we're circulating guides about how to set up secure rooms and webinars, so I don't anticipate this will happen again." My sarcasm calibration is a bit off lately, you surely didn't mean this seriously (I mean, you don't really think this won't happen again)?
- christianmann 7y ago> Bombing this meeting in particular seems to be in especially bad taste during a pandemic. For what it's worth, it likely wasn't targeted. My understanding is that the search space is so short that you can just cycle through it until you find something.
- woliveirajr 7y agoIn general PhD defenses are open to public, I mean, in some places it isn't even valid if it wasn't public announced (by a printed paper glued to some wall, for all it's worth) and the access is restricted to the public. Of course different times require different actions but I think that some challenges remain for the _formal_ part of it.
- mikorym 7y agoI think the progression here is "Zoom has privacy concerns" -> "Zoom operates like macOS malware" -> "Zoom gets trolled".
- annoyingnoob 7y agoVigilantes are not helpful.
- majormajor 7y agoNo, this has been ongoing. For instance, from six days ago: https://www.latimes.com/california/story/2020-03-25/zoombombing-usc-classes-interrupted-racist-remarks https://www.latimes.com/california/story/2020-03-25/zoombomb... The progression is "People start doing a ton of things over an insecure system" -> "trolls start harassing people". This isn't some sort of reaction to anything about Zoom the company or the software.
- Traster 7y agoI think it's more Microsoft in the early 2000s. "What do you mean there is an internet and people on the internet might not have your best interests at heart!"
- csunbird 7y agoThis is like 5th topic about Zoom today.
- Uehreka 7y agoWhen your product goes from being "a videoconferencing tool used in some workplaces" to "the primary way people communicate and gather for personal or professional reasons", it makes sense that there will be a lot of stories about it (good, bad and neutral) in the press.
- slg 7y ago>"the primary way people communicate and gather for personal or professional reasons", I would be curious to see an article about why this happened? Is Zoom better than their countless competitors? They all seem pretty similar in my experience so why is it Zoom that is blowing up because of this and not any of the other companies?
- EvanAnderson 7y agoI've used a fair amount of WebEx (hosting and attending "meetings"). I don't particularly like WebEx, but Zoom feels like a cheap knockoff in comparison. I think Zoom is doing a better job marketing to individuals than the older players in the market.
- r00fus 7y agoWebEx is challenging - I work with industry partners who use WebEx and it just seems clunky. I do think WebEx does some things better than Zoom (I like to share 2-3 apps - for Zoom it's 1 at a time or entire desktop) but Zoom has led to better client adoption for us.
- Uehreka 7y agoPart of it is that, (at least in my experience, maybe this has changed) Zoom can scale to a couple hundred people in a way that tools like Google Hangouts can't. But like, if we're being honest, it probably has a lot to do with how easy it is to start a Zoom call and invite people. You can host a 40 minute meeting for free. No one needs to sign up anywhere. It's super easy to install but also works in the browser if you can't install it. Computer on the fritz? You can call in from your phone. And yeah, they've also used some dirty tricks to make it as easy as possible, and some of those measures (like the auto-reinstall thing) were probably unnecessary. But they've clearly focused on being super super easy to start using, and when their moment came they were primed to seize it. Last weekend my family had a "month's mind mass" in memory of my grandfather who passed a month ago. We were able to get dozens of people, many of them very non-technical, into the call, and we started basically on time. There was no "it doesn't work on my old phone" or "you mean I have to sign up for gmail?" or "whoops I couldn't get in because I signed in with my work email". That's why Zoom is winning the game right now.
- ljm 7y agoZoom has open conferences by default. Even if you host one on your business plan, anyone who has the number can dial into it. You could be paying a shitload of money for that, including their 'Zoom Rooms' where they fit out your meeting room with cameras and mics and their special app... and any fuckwit can dial in if they grab the phone number, which is also a US-based one. I don't like to join company calls on an anon or personal account but Zoom makes absolutely zero effort to identify who you are and even if you're welcome. Most of the time I drop out and re-join under my corporate account. I cannot force other people to do the same, and their settings UI is insane. By all accounts, Zoom deserves this intense scrutiny and I hope they take it seriously. All I see them trying to do is get their software on as many machines as possible.
- luckydata 7y agoI had a quick feedback call set up by a common investor with Eric, Zoom's CEO a few years ago. I remember I pointed out a few of those issues, and his reply was that the only problem he could see with the app was that it wasn't "pretty enough" and it needed new icons. I hope Eric is learning something from this situation and will pay more attention in the future, every business gets those moments, maybe not that publicly.
- solidasparagus 7y agoSeems like Zoom was right that they were better off focusing on the UX aspects over the privacy ones?
- luckydata 7y agoIf you stretch the definition of UX and ignore the clear lesson in this story, sure.
- solidasparagus 7y agoWhat clear lesson? Zoom is not in a bad situation right now.
- spsrich2 7y agoMaking fun of people in AA. Beneath contempt.
- Wmamouth 7y agoCrashing random online classes: https://youtu.be/wUQJvBreues https://youtu.be/wUQJvBreues I must say, this was pretty well done.
- megous 7y agoNot bad. Actual zoom calls start at around the middle of the video.
- verytrivial 7y agohttps://mobile.twitter.com/BorisJohnson/status/1244985949534199808 https://mobile.twitter.com/BorisJohnson/status/1244985949534... Yes, shared by the Prime Minister, number and all. What a time to be alive.
- Traster 7y agoThat's not the only security leak in that photo.
- thinkingemote 7y agoWhat else?
- GordonS 7y agoFor one, Michael Gove's username appears to be the first part of an email address...
- billfruit 7y agoWhose role in the Cabinet is as the 'Chancellor of the Duchy of Lancaster', which today essentially means a minister without portfolio.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- chaps 7y agoWhy is the exposing of a government employee's email address a security risk to you? Edit, because downvotes: government email addresses can be retrieved easily through public records laws, and is done routinely, and can easily be scraped or inferred. I've done both many, many times, and it's trivial.
- Traster 7y ago
- freepor 7y agoThe fact is that with these meeting/group products, the one that makes it easiest to join is the one that succeeds, because there's always one bozo who can't figure out how to type a password, so there's an incentive towards insecure product behaviors.
- pjkundert 7y agoI just set up passwords on Zoom rooms for a little room automation project I'm building. There's no drawbacks; you can send out a link that includes the password, so nobody gets left out (no matter how technically challenged). And, someone who "stumbles upon" the room can't just get access. All in all, Zoom has done a lot of things right, given the extremely challenging competitive environment they're in.
- bostonvaulter2 7y agoIs including the password in the link always enabled? If you're looking at a link is there a way to tell if it has a password or not? I've had issues in the past where people with the link were unable to join since they didn't know the password.
- rmccue 7y agoYes, it has a ?pwd query string (which appears to be a base 64 encode of the password)
- eat_veggies 7y agoThe pwd parameter is always 32 characters long, so I assume it's either a hash or a random nonce, rather than a direct encoding of the password.
- rblatz 7y agoTotal pain in the ass to join from a zoom room though
- kart23 7y agoThe password doesnt do anything for teachers who dont know how to use zoom. And people are not stumbling upon links. What happens is one kid sends the link to a bunch of other people, with the password, who can then join since zoom doesnt require accounts. There are obviously ways to alleviate this like the waiting room feature, or muting everyone and turning chat off, but the problem is that most teachers arent trained well with zooms capabilities and weaknesses.
- Wowfunhappy 7y agoI know it's beside the point, but who are these people heartless enough to break into Alcoholics Anonymous meetings to tell them how good Alchohol is? There isn't even any monetary benefit. Who the heck thinks this is funny?
- zionic 7y ago4chan
- Wowfunhappy 7y agoI should have phrased that differently. I know it's largely parts of the 4chan crowd. But who are those boards? Why are the people who go there so nuts? Do you ever wonder if you've unknowingly met these people in real life? Chances are we all have, right? How do they manage to be so terrible and then go on with their lives?
- snazz 7y agoI recently finished reading We Are the Nerds, which is about the history of Reddit (the company) and its community. One of the interesting parts was about the moderator of a bunch of subreddits that were full of all kinds of borderline illegal and definitely illegal content (u/violentacrez, if you feel the need to Google for yourself). If you're a long-time Reddit user, you probably already know this, but here goes: He was eventually exposed by a journalist. Surprisingly, he is actually a pretty normal middle-aged man. He worked as a programmer (and was immediately fired when the news aired). He has a disabled wife for whom he is the sole financial support. If I remember correctly, he has adult children, who were aware of what he did on Reddit and had usernames that referenced their relationship with him. Apparently, he used his time on Reddit as a way to relieve stress, or something like that. I'm not entirely certain what motivates people to act like that online when they're relatively normal offline, but it seems to be a somewhat common occurrence.
- gnulinux 7y ago> I'm not entirely certain what motivates people to act like that online when they're relatively normal offline, but it seems to be a somewhat common occurrence. Anonymity probably? I'm a pretty normal dude offline, your average American programmer. On reddit I'm in all socialist/communist subreddits talking about revolution 24/7. Intellectually I agree with intersectional Marxism, but I don't feel comfortable enough to discuss these in real life, and I don't care enough to (or am too lazy to) act upon these ideas in real life. So, when I go to reddit I become "a different person", not because I try to be this person, but the comfort of anonymity allows me to express my ideas easier.
- throwaway5752 7y agoZoom lets you require passwords or require the host admit guests in meeting settings. This is the same as anything else you might find on Shodan. Secure defaults hurt mass adoption, and insecure defaults result in this. Zoom is part of one of our oldest industry traditions in this respect.
- tqi 7y agoIt feels like the tech news cycle is so predictable... Stage 1: This company you probably hadn't heard of before is blowing up / changing the world! Stage 2 (current stage): Actually it turns out this company has some unexpected problems! Stage 3: Actually this company is actively contributing to society's One Big Problem! Stage 4: Actually here is why Zoom actually isn't as bad as everyone thinks! Stage 5: This OTHER company you probably hadn't heard of before is blowing up / changing the world!
- vosper 7y agoFacebook must be enjoying getting a few weeks off
- malandrew 7y agoJournalists are like locusts. They move on to the next juicy victim, but time to time return to ravage those few cash cow targets.
- syockit 7y agoI am out of the loop as to why Zoom is suddenly "blowing up". Even my workplace is using it now. Previously, we were using either Skype, Webex, or Jitsi. What does Zoom offer that the other three doesn't?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- dewey 7y agoZoom’s CEO says they are going to fix it and change the defaults: https://twitter.com/ericsyuan/status/1245110791772073985?s=21 https://twitter.com/ericsyuan/status/1245110791772073985?s=2...
- crazygringo 7y agoThis is a feature not a bug, to make joining meetings frictionless. (And in videoconferencing there's little distinction between meeting ID and password anyways -- they form a single access credential.) To prevent unwanted people from joining, the host simply has to turn on the waiting room feature -- where people who have dialed in have to be explicitly accepted by the host, which can be done individually or en masse. Overall I'd say the system works pretty well.
- wlesieutre 7y agoYou could have a second access code included in the invite but not printed right on the window in screenshots. It would be similar to how a credit card number and CCV code are functionally the same as one longer number, except that you don’t go writing the CCV code alongside the credit card number, and that keeps it more secret. Still not as frictionless as “anyone with the number can join,” but if this continues to be a problem it might be worth doing.
- topher515 7y agoI believe Zoom has the exact feature you’re describing—passwords for meetings. https://support.zoom.us/hc/en-us/articles/360033559832-Meeting-and-Webinar-Passwords-?mobile_site=true https://support.zoom.us/hc/en-us/articles/360033559832-Meeti...
- the8472 7y agoIf the trolls are just guessing the ID then it seems to be too low-entropy to serve as an access credential.
- dzonga 7y agoif FB didn't have privacy nightmares. They're well equipped to providing the solutions to the enterprise market. given that they probably have the most stable live video platforms which could be modified to support secure meetings
- consultutah 7y agoRight now zoom is going through a honeymoon phase. Only us geeks care about its security and privacy. After this is over though, people will start thinking it through and things will look a lot more like how FaceBook is viewed right now...
- void445be54d48a 7y agoI dunno. My boss is an incredibly tech savvy developer and he loves Zoom and thinks it's fantastic so I don't really see it going anywhere for a while.
- solidasparagus 7y agoI'll happily trade my privacy for a video call that works properly. None of the various Zoom issues have been privacy problems that I really care about.
- overgard 7y agoI'm not really sure this should be called trolling, it's more just harassing/bullying/trespassing. When I think of trolling, at least when it's done well, it's more taking on overly self serious people to get a funny reaction (even if it's obnoxious). It's like a cousin of pranking, it shouldn't be cruel. There can be cruel pranks of course, but that's not the fundamental nature. Like Ken M leaving a really oblivious comments on facebook, or Something Awful forum members joining an online game chatroom as a weird cult ("the path is grey" :D ). Weird, funny, mostly harmless. I mean things like that are obnoxious sometimes but they can be funny and work as satire or social commentary. There's no cleverness to this. (probably the wrong thing to write on HN since this place is uh not known for its sense of humor)
- CobrastanJorji 7y agoAh, that is problematic. I saw a documentary on Netflix about the British IT crowd. They were not an impressive bunch.
- zdw 7y agoI saw that ludicrous display last night.
- rmason 7y agoYou're not referring to this show perhaps are you? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_IT_Crowd https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_IT_Crowd It is of course a comedy. The Brits in IT that I've met can compete with anyone on the planet.
- bschwindHN 7y agoYes that is the joke.
- jshevek 7y agoThe culture and character of this site is being increasingly damaged by attempts at humor in a style common on another popular site, but the site rules discourage us from discussing this.
- dang 7y agoWe detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22743840 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22743840.
- sys_64738 7y agoThe news stations here are saying make your zoom session private and make sure desktop sharing is host only.
- strategarius 7y ago4 chan exist like 20 years or something. Does anyone ever thought about a legal way to shut it down and lock up couple of admins? I'm sure their stupid troll raids cost billions since it started.
- cc-d 7y ago> Does anyone ever thought about a legal way to shut it down and lock up couple of admins? Why on earth do you feel like this is an appropriate response to some people joining random zoom meetings?
- strategarius 7y agoRead my message again. I have serious concerns about your cognitive abilities.
- fl0wenol 7y ago15 years old. Admins grip the banhammer tight on raiding threads, comply with warrants, so it stays up. That activity was driven to other sites set up for that purpose.
- strategarius 7y agoI guess. After all, there's Telegram, fortress of privacy
- pubstik 7y agoSurely anyone I disagree with should be in jail.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- Kayou 7y agoYes, and don't forget to shutdown Discord too! They will never be able to use another tool to organize these raids, this is genius. (this is sarcasm, of course)
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- jacquesm 7y agoIt's a pretty low bar for the word 'break'. By the same token you could walk up to a bunch of people in a restaurant and start yelling at them while they're having dinner. That's also not a break. It's just a nuisance and proof that you're a jerk, and if you did it in person you'd likely end up with some dental work.
- DarkWiiPlayer 7y agoExcept users don't realize that. They think they're sitting in a locked room that nobody else knows about, when in reality they're sitting at a restaurant table and most people just don't care to go bother them.
- alexcpn 7y agohappened to my elder sister who is a teacher hosting video class due to lockdown in India. Some idiots think it is fun and the worst thing is that they put a video grab of this in their youtube channel - themed disruption or something - to drive traffic - yuck , the state of minds! and those who follow such channel. ( It is reported to local cybercell , but it left my sister who is bit older to all this technology very rattled)
- kzrdude 7y agoWhy has Zoom picked up so much? Hangouts, Skype, facebook all are established with video group calling functionality
- mlyle 7y agoFew things that are "free" handle massive numbers of participants well. Yes, Skype for Business etc can, but those options are commercial. There's also less usable, obscure stuff that does OK.
- orthoxerox 7y agoSkype for Business is a dumpster fire. We use it at work and it's terrible at graceful degradation, even for voice.
- kzrdude 7y agoSkype for business + outlook integration doesn't even manage to handle chat history correctly, not without glitches that lose you the history for chats ever so often. Not fit for purpose.
- buboard 7y agothis happened repeatedly and badly in a conference with 2500 people. The root of the cause was that zoom invite links, by default, contain the password, which then people share, making the password useless. otherwise it worked great
- k__ 7y agoI broke into a meeting by accident once. Someone sent me a meeting URL and I clicked it, to see if everything was right. Little did I know that people just get one Zoom URL for ALL of their meetings.
- auscompgeek 7y agoEach meeting gets its own ID. Of course, nothing prevents someone from reusing a meeting ID though.
- tikkabhuna 7y agoYou get a "Personal" meeting room, which keeps the same ID. You can then create other "named" meetings which gets a separate one. That then lets you have different passwords for different meetings.
- thrownaway954 7y agomy homegroup switched over to zoom a couple of weeks ago and i have to say, i love it. like most of you, i'm sitting all day and to be able to join in an aa meeting while walking outside is AMAZING! i can finally get some exercise and not feel like i have to sacrifice one or the other. to the people of zoom, thank you for making this time in our life a lot more pleasurable.
- yoda222 7y agoSeveral people in other comments explain that you could have a password protected session, or a session in which users must be waiting in a lobby until someone approves their admission. This seems pretty normal, and I think here Zoom may not be able to do much more. But I have the feeling that this is difficult in pratice to use for a AA meeting. I'm actually lucky enough to not to have the need to participate to such a meeting, but from what I understand from it, the anonymous part is important, as well as the possibility for newcomers to participate. I doubt for these reasons that AA meeting groups have a list of participant clearly identified, to whom they can send a password protected link, or that they could use such a list to check that people are someone part of the group. Unfortunately, I'm not sure that this kind of problem can be fixed (technologicaly. On the non-technology side, we could hope for a world without asshole, but that's only a dream)