6 ms·
The competence of private companies in the U.S. shouldn't enrage you, that's one of the U.S.'s strengths.
by chrisco255 7y ago
The competence of private companies in the U.S. shouldn't enrage you, that's one of the U.S.'s strengths.
- throwaway5752 7y agoI'm obviously enraged by the incompetence of the federal response, not the strength of H-E-B's.
- jonfw 7y agoThat's government work for you
- nicoburns 7y agoNot everywhere though. Governments in Singapore, Japan, South Korea amongst other places have had an excellent response.
- jonfw 7y agoI feel that the successes in those countries result more from their cultures than their governments. One of the common criticisms of those countries is the singular culture that creates social pressure. Social pressure can go a long way in these sorts of events. Taking these tiny, mono-cultural, rich countries and comparing them to the world's leading superpower does not make a strong argument.
- nicoburns 7y agoHow do you explain the early government-enforced shutdowns, and expansive testing programs? I think the response from the general population has also been better in some of these countries, but there is a marked difference in the government responses.
- jonfw 7y agoIn democracies, governments are lead by their people. The government will generally do what its people want it to do. Americans did not give a damn about corona-virus for a long time. If the people wanted shutdowns, they would have gotten them.
- azmodeus 7y agoComparing a large multicultural richer country does seem weird. Indeed a tiny 126 million soul tiny country can not be compared with a country of 330 million souls. Also the USA having 1.5x the GDP / Capita does make Japan the richer country. These countries unlike the USA have more economically and socially interventionist governments. I do wonder if the culture of Germany is closer to Japan or USA. To tackle a pandemic do you need more leadership or culture? I mean beyond national security where is USA leadership?
- lonelappde 7y ago> the USA having 1.5x the GDP / Capita does make Japan the richer country. ???
- adventured 7y agoI'd guess they made a mistake in thinking that because the population ratio is greater than 1.5 (it's 2.6), therefore the GDP / Capita ratio they reference is then favoring Japan. That of course would need to be run against actual national GDP, not per capita. US per capita GDP was about 60% higher than Japan as of the end of 2019.
- jbay808 7y agoNo, I think it was intended as sarcasm; 126 million is also not much less than 330 million.
- jonfw 7y agoJapan has high population density but a small piece of land, and it is probably the most mono-cultural population of it's size in the world. I agree that we need in America is stronger leadership. But we shouldn't be looking to the government for leadership. The government should follow the will of the people, not lead it. Democratic governments act when they feel the people want them to act. The reason the US government didn't act early is because the majority of Americans were not yet concerned about the coronavirus until recently, and it would have been unpopular. Japan would not have acted so strictly and so early if their culture and respect for community weren't strong. It would have been unpopular and ineffective. What's needed for Americans to tackle these types of issues better is more trust in the community and stronger citizen leadership.
- kube-system 7y agoThe social difference is only relevant in that it results in a different governing style. US style lock-downs have so far been very voluntary in nature compared to what several other countries are doing.
- anbop 7y agoSingapore is anything but a mono-cultural country and is only recently rich. Basically through extreme government competence they made themselves rich and yes, their society definitely has Chinese at the top but unlike the US, the society is not completely riven by racial strife.
- adventured 7y agoSingapore has been in the 'first-world' economic tier for at least 30 years. Their economic success is not recent. 30 years ago their GDP per capita was on par with Hong Kong and Spain, ahead of Greece, and far ahead of Portugal or South Korea (and it was nearly 40 times higher than China). China is a legitimate story of recent economic success. China is only now at a stage of median development that Singapore reached in the 1970s and 1980s.
- chrisco255 7y agoSingapore is basically run like a business though, isn't it? Also, it's more of a city-state than a nation, in my mind. Same for Taiwan and Hong Kong.
- fragmede 7y ago> That's government work for you > Here are some government's where it worked > Those don't count because otherwise I'd have to retire my tired old screed from the 90's that the government can't do anything right. The government should be run like a business, dagnabit. Did my summary miss anything?
- jonfw 7y agoCountries =/= governments. In fact, countries are primarily made up by non-government people and non-government organizations. Sometimes the great things that a country accomplishes are due to it's great people.
- jbay808 7y agoThat's your government's work for you.
- heliodor 7y agoYou get what you pay for, basically. If governments were to pay top dollar and actually fire incompetent people, I'm sure our world would be a much better place.
- malandrew 7y ago> The competence of private companies shouldn't enrage you, that's one of the their strengths. When you have to compete, you have to develop competence to survive. Only those that don't have to compete (monopolies) or those that survive despite incompetence (bailouts) are the exceptions.
- worldsoup 7y agoneed to throw the federal bureaucracy into the 'don't have to compete to survive bucket'
- pjscott 7y agoThey fall under the category of monopolies.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- fzeroracer 7y agoThis seems like a bit of an odd concession, considering the businesses that are being impacted the most by the coronavirus are smaller, local businesses which run on thin margins. These local businesses are also often the most competitive because of having to compete with both other local businesses and larger ones. The competence of private companies only really applies to a very narrow subset of corporations.
- ardy42 7y ago> The competence of private companies in the U.S. shouldn't enrage you, that's one of the U.S.'s strengths. That's a misleading and false generalization. You can't cherrypick one of the better prepared companies to make a statement about companies in general. Especially when there's nonsense all over the news about other companies like GameStop and Guitar Center claiming to be essential retail against all reason: https://www.nytimes.com/2020/03/25/business/coronavirus-essential-retailers.html https://www.nytimes.com/2020/03/25/business/coronavirus-esse....
- kortilla 7y agoHow is finding an anecdote a invalidate a generalization? The majority of the most powerful global corporations are US companies. They don’t (in general) get that way by being incompetent.
- Chai-T-Rex 7y agoYou can't support a point about private companies in the US in general with a point solely about powerful global corporations that are US companies.
- fzeroracer 7y agoI'd argue that once you reach a certain level of size, it's very easy to fail upwards. See: Amazon. They are incompetent in many aspects of their business, but due to their sheer size that incompetence is shielded by their other investments.
- giggles_giggles 7y agoThis is interesting because the GP, I think, didn't intend to say "private" to mean "privately held", but I think it's worthwhile to note that GameStop and Guitar Center are publicly traded while H-E-B is still family owned. H-E-B does a lot of things that are more benevolent than the kind of behavior that we're used to seeing from publicly-traded organizations and I can't help but wonder if the private ownership (truly private, as opposed to publicly-traded) has something to do with that. H-E-B is one of the things I will really miss if I ever have to leave Texas. They're always there any time there is any kind of disaster, to provide relief. I've even heard that they treat their software engineers well (they bought Favor). They're really a one-of-a-kind company. I hope they never IPO.
- joe_the_user 7y agoI don't think the GP is enraged that there are competent private sector actors. I'd guess they're enraged that this competence can't be transferred to the places where it could matter 10x or 100x more. I feel kind of similarly. An obvious example is that the president could have picked a highly competent, non-partisan manager as the head of his coronavirus team. Regardless of his competence, Vice President Pence is clearly a polarizing figure without a track record of dealing with crises of this scale. This crisis could really benefit from a highly competent manager who could bust heads and sweep away bureaucratic hurdles. But that person would need to be someone honestly trusted by all stakeholders. We're seeing lots of actors maneuvering to gain ideological advantage even in the midst of these terrible events (shame on them). I don't even know if such a person exists any more but their non-existence would mean the US is in for serious trouble.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- krapp 7y agoThe problem is, if that competent manager existed, Americans would never elect them or trust them. Americans have been taught to trust in the benevolence and competence of corporations, and that government is incapable of anything but cruelty and incompetence. You can never have a truly functional government in a country with an amendment to their Constitution that guarantees its people the opportunity to shoot it dead if they want. As soon as it even began to coalesce, Americans would hamstring it, strip it down and try to starve it to the point that it could be drowned in a bathtub.
- smallnamespace 7y agoThe public sector also has a fixed pay scale for seniority that tops out around 160k a year salary. We could pay government employees more, but then voters would complain.
- vikramkr 7y agoDr. Fauci is pretty popular as a choice like that right now
- deleted 7y ago
- nikofeyn 7y agothat is quite the leap from a single corporation's actions.