23 ms·
The ‘Blurred Lines’ case scared songwriters, but its time may be up
- FriendlyNormie 7y agoIf I repeatedly linked to my own site with a title that interested you but all you could see on my page was an unskippable ad demanding that you sign up and pay for my unrelated product, wouldn’t my site be banned from HN? Why do sites like nytimes get a free pass with their paywalls?
- jessaustin 7y agoLots of us have already turned off javascript for NYT, so we're not seeing that.
- tyingq 7y agoI feel the same way. My intuition tells me only some small percentage of HN readers have a NYT subscription, so these posts are of little use. Though the posts keep appearing, so perhaps I'm wrong, and it's really substantial...like at least 25%? What's the threshold where it makes sense?
- tzs 7y agoThe value in HN is mostly in the comments, not in its role as a link aggregator. A good 90% of the time when the link is to something I cannot access I can still get all the salient points necessary to understand and benefit from the discussion just from reading the comments. (Also, if it is a story on some reasonably current event or some well known subject there is a good chance a quick visit to a search engine will find some other article that covers nearly everything in the submitted article but that I can read). I think of HN as like a social gathering. Each discussion thread is like a small group of people at a party standing around talking about some topic. It's a big party, and there are dozens of such small groups, constantly forming and breaking up, as people move from group to group. If I'm at a party, and I see a group discussing a book they have read and I have not, I'm either going to ignore their discussion completely if I'm not interested in the topic or am planning on reading the book later and want to avoid spoilers, or go ahead and join in if I'm interested in the topic and and not worried about spoilers and they are discussing it in general enough terms. I'm not going to try to tell everyone at the party that they should only talk about books that everyone there has read. If there is some particular site(s) that someone just does not want to see on HN at all, it's easy to address that with a couple bookmarklets. Here's one that will hide NY Times articles from the listings: javascript: (function () { var stories = document.getElementsByClassName('storylink'); for (var i = 0; i < stories.length; ++i) if (stories[i].href.includes('://www.nytimes')) stories[i].parentNode.parentNode.hidden = 'hidden'; })() It would be easy to expand it to cover multiple sites. Here's one to unhide them: javascript:(function () { var stories = document.getElementsByClassName('storylink'); for (var i = 0; i < stories.length; ++i) stories[i].parentNode.parentNode.hidden = ''; })() Stick those bookmarklets someplace easy to invoke, and then at the cost of one click per page of 30 links you don't have to see the site(s) again.
- Igelau 7y ago> Why do sites like nytimes get a free pass with their paywalls? Because the pass probably isn't free.
- yodon 7y agoCount the number of unicorns ycombinator has invested in and compare those returns to the returns that could be generated by trying to secretly take payment from advertisers. Why would ycombinator waste even a single minute of a single employees time on such an unprofitable activity when it could instead have that same employee spend that same time helping to find and grow the next unicorn. No one is getting rich selling ad space on their own website. Pg is more than smart enough to know this.
- tomhoward 7y agoPaywalled articles are accepted on HN if there's a known workaround: https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&query=by%3Adang%20paywall%20workaround&sort=byPopularity&type=comment https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que... https://news.ycombinator.com/newsfaq.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsfaq.html If it's hard paywall with no workaround, it shouldn't be on HN and you should flag it or email the mods.
- viraptor 7y agoI don't pay for this site, but can see the full article just fine. I don't know what the rules are exactly, but some of us do have access (and ublock takes care of ads)
- nogabebop23 7y agowhat browser, etc are you using? I'm on FF with uBlock in Canada and always get the NYT's own login/subscribe overlay that while not an ad is essentially a redirect to a login or register page. I guess it works though; I'm not about to sign up to the NYT or WSJ and I don't even bother clicking their links, so mission accomplished!
- dr_orpheus 7y agoUse ublock to disable javascript
- taftster 7y agoThanks - I run ublock origin but haven't really played with options like that. Worked great!
- 1123581321 7y agoPapers of record/highly reputable sources should be held to a different standard.
- taormina 7y agoI'll take the bait. It's 2020, is the NYT still considered highly reputable? Or is it just a "loveable brand name" at this point?
- Applejinx 7y agoThat is a fair question, in my opinion. Depending on the topic, the New York Times isn't always reputable.
- 1123581321 7y agoFair question. My response wasn’t meant to be trollish or beg the question. You can read a summary of the New York Times’ reputation in its WP article. In summary, it is still well regarded for accuracy and thoroughness by its peers. Popular opinion is still high relative to its peers but has lowered. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_New_York_Times#Reputation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_New_York_Times#Reputation The WP article also links to the paper of record article. Papers of record can be important even if they are disliked because of the sources they have access to, and the extent to which they influence stories by reporting on them. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Newspaper_of_record https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Newspaper_of_record
- colinmhayes 7y agoI have never seen a nyt article that wasn't an op-ed or maybe magazine that wasn't reputable.
- oh_sigh 7y agoI wonder why they had to "rededicate [them]selves to the fundamental mission of Times journalism" after Trump was elected? https://www.nytimes.com/2016/11/13/us/elections/to-our-readers-from-the-publisher-and-executive-editor.html https://www.nytimes.com/2016/11/13/us/elections/to-our-reade...
- johnr2 7y ago> Why do sites like nytimes get a free pass with their paywalls? I've never encountered a paywall on the NYT links on HN and I'm not a subscriber. I'm guessing the complaints here are from people who only have access to browsers with no means of blocking (or ignoring) JavaScript.
- empath75 7y agoZeppelin have long been known to be notorious plagiarists: https://www.rollingstone.com/music/music-news/led-zeppelins-10-boldest-rip-offs-223419/ https://www.rollingstone.com/music/music-news/led-zeppelins-...
- agumonkey 7y agoI think I saw a news recently that they've been dismissed for gateway to heaven
- klodolph 7y agoStairway is not a ripoff of Taurus and it never was going to be, but there are plenty of other accusations against Led Zeppelin that are more credible. I have Spirit’s eponymous album, the part in question that is “ripped off” is so basic and found in so many songs you’d die before you could list them all. (FYI—You the news you “think you saw recently” is in the linked article above the fold, which features a photo of Robert Plant right next to the headline.)
- Applejinx 7y agoStairway to Heaven has contrary motion in the top voice of the guitar arpeggio, which I consider a really substantial change. They did grab lots of blues songs, occasionally gave some form of credit, otherwise not. It's an interesting question: blues is mostly delivery, so if you take a concept like 'lemon' or 'leave me' and deliver it in shrieky overwrought British rock star fashion, aren't you rewriting it, perhaps significantly? You can't copyright the pentatonic scale. It'd be like someone copyrighting the monotonic drone and then filing suit against half of EDM. I performed for a livestream recently and used a riff from Plastikman 'Marbles', except that riff is only note-note-rest-note-note-rest repeated infinitely on one note. Part of it is the tone and context, and I wasn't cloning that, just the way the extremely brief three-note chunk cycles over a 4/4 beat. Plagiarism? Plagiarism because I know of 'Marbles' and found it inspiring? What if I picked a simple repeating pulse because I'd heard that in some minimal techno, and intentionally did my own take on that because I'd liked it?
- moomin 7y agoMy (least) favourite example of this is that Iggy Azalea gets a song-writing credit for Classic Man. http://www.mtv.com/news/2215334/iggy-azalea-fancy-classic-man-jidenna/ http://www.mtv.com/news/2215334/iggy-azalea-fancy-classic-ma... If you listen to the two, you can spot the similarity but... it’s nowhere close to sampling or plagiarism. They’ve got different melodies, different feels, just a similar prominent keyboard sound. But no-one wants a court case, so the writers of Fancy get a cut.
- midgetjones 7y agoMy least favourite was Quentin Tarantino demanding a songwriting credit for Fun Lovin' Criminals' Scooby Snacks, just because it sampled a few seconds of dialogue from Pulp Fiction.
- dspillett 7y agoWould you prefer he demanded royalties instead, as their label would if he used a few seconds of their output in one of his films? Or that they just be able to use the sample without credit or royalty?
- midgetjones 7y agoHe did demand royalties, he gets a 40% cut as well.
- gamblor956 7y agoRoughly 40% of the lyrics are dialogue from two of his movies or describing scenes from those movies (Pulp Fiction and Reservoir Dogs), so a 40% cut of the songwriters' share of royalties is appropriate.
- onion2k 7y agoHe didn't write any of the song. He just made something that contributed to it. Saying he wrote part of it is like the person who mixed Davinci's paint claiming to have painted part of the Mona Lisa.
- kstenerud 7y agoI wonder how well the 1987 album [1] would do in this new climate? [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1987_(What_the_Fuck_Is_Going_On%3F) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1987_(What_the_Fuck_Is_Going_O...
- svantana 7y agoAt least with streaming you won't have to go through the trouble of pulling physical copies from stores and destroying them. It's sad though that file sharing is no longer a big thing, since that allowed illegal remix culture to really thrive.
- iscrewyou 7y agoI find plenty of remixes on YouTube now. Yes they get taken down but there’s ways to take those offline.
- acomjean 7y agoIn the 80s sampling was kinda a gray area. But by the 90s all samples were cleared, or too obtuse to figure out the source.... I guess the British were ahead of the US in this. "In 1991, songwriter Gilbert O'Sullivan sued rapper Biz Markie after he sampled O'Sullivan's "Alone Again (Naturally)" on the album I Need a Haircut. The court ruled that sampling without permission infringed copyright. Instead of asking for royalties, O'Sullivan forced Biz Markie's label Warner Bros to recall the album until the song was removed. Nelson George described it as the "most damaging example of anti-hip hop vindictiveness", which "sent a chill through the industry that is still felt".[39] The Washington Post wrote in 2018 that "no court decision has changed the sound of pop music as much as this", likening it to banning a musical instrument" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sampling_(music)#Legal_and_ethical_issues https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sampling_(music)#Legal_and_eth...
- ilamont 7y agoI've told this story before. In the early 1990s I worked for Jimmy Cauty and Bill Drummond's record label, back when they were dominating the UK and European pop charts as The KLF (https://www.npr.org/sections/therecord/2017/07/20/537708922/how-three-austrian-unknowns-misunderstood-klf-s-the-manual https://www.npr.org/sections/therecord/2017/07/20/537708922/...). One day we received in the mail a cassette tape and a letter from a law firm representing a composer or publisher (I can't remember which) of a famous Broadway soundtrack from the 1960s. The letter accused the KLF of infringement. The cassette contained one of the songs on the Broadway soundtrack, an instrumental section of which repeated a three note riff that sounded a lot like the same three-note sequence from one of the KLFs biggest hits. The rhythms and song structures were otherwise nothing alike. It didn't seem like an obvious example of copying, and it was quite possible it was a coincidence or some obscure influence on The KLF or their core musical collaborators, who would have been youths when the Broadway soundtrack was released. "Are you going to fight this?" I asked the label's president. Her answer: "No." From The KLF's perspective, it wasn't worth a long, expensive legal fight they might lose. I think a lot of it related to the problems it encountered with the "1987" album you mentioned, which had been partly done to ridicule the record industry but really took a lot of energy to deal with when the legal troubles emerged. Also, the label president didn't say it, but potential bad press could have also been on her mind. At the time, the KLF had the British music press eating out of their hands, and a public legal fight could change the narrative of the KLF as being brilliant pop iconoclasts to something less favorable.
- merricksb 7y agohttp://archive.md/e2Kih http://archive.md/e2Kih
- nogabebop23 7y agoAll of these NYT stories bring up a blocking modal dialog requiring me to log in or create an account (I guess this is a slight improvement from making me pay). Is this the same for everyone else? Why do other sites that show a dismissable overlay get raked over the coals as if they are criminals? What value is there in posting a link on HN if it's behind a pay (or temporarily free) wall? This goes double for the WSJ. Let's not debate business models here, but asking what's the intent/requirements, and why the double standard?
- re-actor 7y agoClear your cookies
- boomboomsubban 7y agoThere is no rule against pay walled content, and most NYT stories have numerous people complaining about it. The NYT and WSJ posts still get votes because they're large enough that many people are subscribers, and their paywalls are trivial to bypass.
- emanuensis 7y agoThe workarounds for WSJ do not work anymore for me, eg the redirect from FarceBorg will still get the "subscribe" page. Also FT. They appear to have removed workarounds. Are they STILL valid HN submissions ... even when there is NO workaround? Or maybe there is one and i haven't twigged to it yet:-)>
- boomboomsubban 7y agohttps://github.com/iamadamdev/bypass-paywalls-firefox https://github.com/iamadamdev/bypass-paywalls-firefox
- emanuensis 7y agoAh yes, "Bypass Paywalls" i do have this extension installed and have been using it for months. WSJ seems to have wizened to his workarounds, and others like the FB redirect. Eg it does not work for https://www.wsj.com/articles/rbc-sheds-light-on-chinas-rebound-after-coronavirus-11585128601 https://www.wsj.com/articles/rbc-sheds-light-on-chinas-rebou... But i will submit a request at his github site. In the meantime, AFAIK, there is no workaround for WSJ. Is it still OK to submit them to HN? i do notice there have been few recently.
- Balanceinfinity 7y agoShocked the story didn't mention the Fogerty suit - the strangest copyright -music case of all https://www.mentalfloss.com/article/27501/time-john-fogerty-was-sued-ripping-john-fogerty https://www.mentalfloss.com/article/27501/time-john-fogerty-...
- g-erson 7y agoSomething weird going on with that page! The article number in the URL changes back and forward between 2 numbers as you scroll! Makes coming back to HN a bit tricky! Interesting read though
- cyxxon 7y agoIn my case it changes when the next article comes up. This is a really weird page format some online news magazines have adopted, where they simply add different articles at the bottom of your original page, infinite scrolling style. If you scroll back up though, it switches back.
- philipov 7y agoI hate it when pages do that.
- oh_sigh 7y agoThat page put about 1000 entries of itself in my history
- ThomPete 7y agoWhat really interesting about Blurred Lines is that it was more the feeling of the music than the actual note for note, which was the center of the discussion. If you don't understand music and what it entails you could be convinced that it was the same. Such an interesting case.
- BurningFrog 7y agoYeah, it was getting close to copyrighting a genre. Very dangerous stuff.
- djmips 7y agoExactly, I immediately thought of all the bog standard country, rock and blues songs.
- sushisource 7y agoThis might be one of the stupidest arguments I've ever heard: “Thin copyright might apply to a doll or a painting because, for example, there are just so many ways to paint a tomato,” Busch said. “Creative choices are limited. It has never applied to music because there are literally an infinite number of creative choices in creating a song.” ... So you're saying there aren't infinite ways to paint a tomato?
- jgwil2 7y agoIt is indeed stupid. Color and space exist on a continuum whereas musical notes and rhythms are discrete (at least within a given musical tradition), so if anything there are more creative choices in painting a tomato than in creating a song.
- sorokod 7y agoThat there is continuum is irrelevant when the human comprehension is discreet. For example, panton colours contain less then 2k values.
- nicholassmith 7y agoThat's a terrible argument isn't it? There's a finite number of musical notes, a finite structure to them and a finite number of effects. We're guaranteed to end up with doppelgänger choruses and melodies sooner rather than later.
- patrickthebold 7y agoI hear what you are saying but 'finite' isn't that restrictive. There are some pretty big numbers that are still finite.
- wahern 7y ago> We're guaranteed to end up with doppelgänger choruses and melodies sooner rather than later. Technically that's fine. Copyright only protects originality, not novelty as with patents. Coincidentally creating the same melody as someone else doesn't violate their copyright. If they sued they'd have to prove that it wasn't coincidental with evidence that you heard the original melody, a prerequisite for proving that your melody was derivative. That's the theory. In practice the first person to publish the melody often wins, especially if their version was popular--e.g. a radio hit, which by itself provides circumstantial evidence that you had heard it.
- arduinomancer 7y agoCan't read the article. I feel like this just encourages low effort comments from people skimming the headlines.
- jgwil2 7y agoThere are several easy workarounds already mentioned in the comments: hit escape, disable javascript, clear your cookies, or visit the archived version at http://archive.md/e2Kih http://archive.md/e2Kih
- WalterBright 7y agoA reasonable thing would be to consider "fair use" as any clip less than, say, 10 seconds.
- UncleMeat 7y agoWould it? Could a movie include a 10 second clip from Star Wars without trouble? Even something iconic like the title card?
- WalterBright 7y agoSure.
- heyoo 7y agoProbably. Would it hurt Star Wars?
- WalterBright 7y agoNope. In fact, it would be good advertising for Star Wars.
- gota 7y agoWhat if the entire piece of media is really short and 10 seconds is most or all of it? I'm not sure there are simple and reasonable solutions like this. Everything will be gamed or cause terrible edge case issues
- WalterBright 7y ago> What if the entire piece of media is really short and 10 seconds is most or all of it? If the creator cared, he'd make it longer. Seriously, why should a 5 second movie be worthy of major copyright protection? For example, if I wrote a 100 line computer program, should that be worthy of copyright protection. I'd say "no". A creator of a 10-second movie should consider it advertising for his skills, and hope and pray people copy it and use it all over the place. I've also made my code Boost licensed, which is equivalent to "no copyright protection". If people use it for whatever, I figure it's great advertising for my (very expensive) consulting rates.
- wgj 7y agoNYT draws the wrong conclusions. In each of these cases, the jury sided with the more popular and well known party. These were all jury cases where perceived career accomplishment is the common thread, as the law itself twists in any way necessary.
- wwweston 7y agoThe “Dark Horse” case didn’t seem to break for Katy Perry...