8 ms·
They may still get into the business, and it would make sense for them to do so, and may even solve their privacy problem while they are at it. Amazon did it a
by jedberg 7y ago
They may still get into the business, and it would make sense for them to do so, and may even solve their privacy problem while they are at it.
Amazon did it a long time ago, and when they started, they had no sales team. They had to build that capability slowly over time, but they had the first mover advantage, so they had time to learn. Now they are number one.
Microsoft already had the enterprise sales team, they had to learn how to sell cloud. They had some trouble with the shift, and with the technology, but now they are knocking it out of the park, and are solidly in the number two spot behind Amazon.
Google is struggling with their cloud business. While what they offer is technically superior to all their competitors, they don’t have the sales team, nor the experience in building one. They are trying, but they haven’t gotten the hang of it yet, and in the meantime, Amazon and Microsoft just keep growing.
This is the position Facebook would be in. They probably have the technology, or can at least attract the necessary talent to build it (I know that I would at least listen if they said, “Come build a new cloud with us from the ground up”). But they don’t have the enterprise sales team, just like Google.
Now, in Google’s defense, they have realized they are coming from behind, and as such have focused on selling their higher level services. If you want to do AI and Machine Learning, Google’s cloud is the place to do it! And then maybe while you’re there, if your core business is AI, maybe you’ll use some of their other services as well, since your data is already there.
Facebook could make a similar play. They could build a cloud and then require any 3rd party apps that work with Facebook to use their cloud. This would jumpstart their adoption, and could potentially help them solve their privacy issues. They could require that you never send any personal Facebook data out of their cloud, and could closely monitor all the outbound traffic. Then they could theoretically allow even more access to Facebook data, if they knew they could control what happens to that data after the 3rd party gets hold of it.
In other words they could launch a cloud that lets you run your 3rd party Facebook apps in a controlled and audited way, and even give you building blocks to do it quickly and efficiently. It would boost their bottom line, because there is good margins in compute and storage, and at the same time give them more control of their own data.
- dilyevsky 7y agoGoogle didn’t have sales team? Uh who do you think selling all those ads?
- kardos 7y ago> But they don’t have the enterprise sales team, just like Google. Paraphrasing OP: Google knew how to sell ads, not how to sell cloud...
- dilyevsky 7y agoAnd msft sales knew how to sell cloud because they’ve been selling AD and office?
- jedberg 7y agoThey had been selling infrastructure (Windows Servers). They already knew how to sell infrastructure. In fact, most of the first sales of Azure were just as an add on to their existing enterprise contracts.
- WorldMaker 7y ago- SQL Server - The Dynamics suite - Visual Studio / TFS - Windows Server family products All of those were "cloud-adjacent" even in their proto-forms as on-premises–only offerings. Even if they weren't "real cloud infrastructure" they were big Capital-E Enterprise products and a lot of selling cloud is still B2B Capital-E Enterprise work at the end of the day.
- discreteevent 7y agoI remember in the late 90s (I think) articles about how MS just didn't get enterprise and would never break in.
- dilyevsky 7y agoYeah these are on prem software licenses. Completely different from metered virtual infrastructure.
- WorldMaker 7y agoSure, but the point remains that this was a sales engine that was very similar. It certainly was a faster path for Microsoft to bootstrap cloud sales teams than whatever Google's long, winding path from ad sales to whatever it is they think they are doing with GCP sales. (Though it hasn't seemed to work effectively for IBM. That may just be IBM incompetence as old school commodity-priced Mainframe mentality should be exactly the same as cloud sales. There's probably an amusing alternate world where IBM Cloud is using something like 1950s presentations only slightly modified to sell "cloud" in 2020, just because they could.)
- yjftsjthsd-h 7y ago> They could build a cloud and then require any 3rd party apps that work with Facebook to use their cloud That sounds like an antitrust investigation waiting to happen. (Or it should; that Google hasn't been murdered by prosecutors suggests that the system isn't working as it should)
- the_watcher 7y agoYea, this actually seems to fall pretty specifically into the Microsoft case. AFAIK, Google does not require third parties working with Google to use GCP
- yjftsjthsd-h 7y ago> AFAIK, Google does not require third parties working with Google to use GCP Oh no, I don't think so; I was thinking of their exploiting their search dominance to push Chrome.
- folmar 7y agoThat sounds like Firebase on Android.
- oarabbus_ 7y ago>Google is struggling with their cloud business. While what they offer is technically superior to all their competitors, they don’t have the sales team, nor the experience in building one. They are trying, but they haven’t gotten the hang of it yet, and in the meantime, Amazon and Microsoft just keep growing. Don't forget the support. I used to work at a Series B startup, and AWS provided excellent support. We probably tossed them a few million a year, so I can only imagine what kind of white-glove top-tier support a big enterprise spender would've received. We got responses for anything ranging from general UI questions to highly-in-the-weeds Redshift technical questions within 1 business day. >90% of the time, the issue was resolved upon the first response. Google on the other hand, has very poor support. Facebook is by no means a support paragon either. For this reason alone, I see a Microsoft-Amazon cloud duopoly with anyone else being a minor player as the only outcome. When shit hits the fan (as it is now) you need enterprise support capabilities.
- kenhwang 7y agoWe're owned by one of AWS's biggest clients and we get to straight up request features every other month and have their teams build it for us. We have a few humans assigned to our account that will physically come into our office when we have problems worth discussing. We also get access to quite a lot of price/billing advantages. Google we can't even get them to answer an email.
- eitally 7y agoBut you're not one of googled biggest customers, so.... If you were, your experience night be very different.
- kenhwang 7y agoWe're smack on the frontpage of https://cloud.google.com/customers/ https://cloud.google.com/customers/ Google is more important to our parent org than Amazon; Google is a strategic partner, Amazon is simply another tech vendor. We might be part of a 11-12 figure megacorp now, but Amazon hasn't treated us too differently from since we were a tiny startup with not much spend, and neither has Google.
- tonystubblebine 7y agoGoogle has a real trust issue with me that's twofold. One is that you can't trust them to stick with a product offering. They are driven by a throw things at the wall and see what sticks strategy rather than some deeper vision for the world. So I'm always suspicious that they will abandon anything they launch. Two is that they don't believe in offering quality support. I had this issue with an Android app recently. It got flagged incorrectly for a compliance concern and I was not able to reach a knowledgable human under any circumstances, including getting it escalated by internal Google staff. I would have easily paid a support contract, $1k or more, to get access to a human. In the end, I had to guess at what their algorithm was flagging and just ended up tricking it through trial and error.
- tsycho 7y agoGoogle absolutely needs to fix their trust problem, but it is also completely wrong to compare support between their paid GCP customers vs their mostly free Android app developers. Fwiw, I recently called Google customer support to fix a billing problem and was pleasantly surprised that I talked to a real human quickly, AND they were able to resolve my problem and issue a refund. So maybe they are improving on that end too.
- tw04 7y ago>vs their mostly free Android app developers. But why? Per OP - they'd be willing to pay for an enterprise support contract. Why should a mom and pop shop expect that their experience being a small fish will be any different in GCP than literally EVERY OTHER GOOGLE SERVICE? It's one thing to tell people using a free service that their only option is automated support - it's quite another to tell customers you just flat-out refuse to offer a paid support model. That tells me that you are organizationally deficient at providing customer support. I've yet to hear anyone using paid g suite speak praises about their support experience if they ever have issues. Quite the opposite.
- dodobirdlord 7y ago> Why should a mom and pop shop expect that their experience being a small fish will be any different in GCP than literally EVERY OTHER GOOGLE SERVICE? Well, for one thing, everyone you ask except apparently the HN comment section will tell you. I've probably seen this exact conversation play out 10+ times now. Someone says that GCP has poor customer support by analogy to other, mostly free services. Someone who actually uses GCP customer support claims that this is not the case. Some third (or perhaps the original) person blows them off and insists that Google's behavior toward the statistically adversarial and free users of other services must be representative of Google's behavior toward an entirely different group of users. It's baffling.
- hitpointdrew 7y ago> Microsoft already had the enterprise sales team, they had to learn how to sell cloud. They also had to grit there teeth and embrace Linux, which would have never happened if Ballmer was still there. There is just no demand/need for Windows only cloud offering. You want to be in cloud? You better embrace Linux.
- hintymad 7y agoBased on my conversation with my FB friends, FB's major challenge to tapping into cloud business is their "moving fast and breaking things" culture, and their arguably cut-throat impact-oriented perf system. We have to admit that not all tasks in development are glorious. Someone has to be on call. Someone has to fix all the important bugs. Someone has to implement features that customers ask for, even though the features may not be glorious. I personally even enjoy bug fixing, as it is closest to scientific investigation. However, would I prioritize bug fix if I were in FB? Hell no. I would launch launch launch, and show impact impact and impact. Would that be good for cloud customers or the business? Of course not. Would that erode customer trust in the long run? Oh yeah. Sometime somewhere a nasty bug will show up in this type of culture.
- JJMcJ 7y agoGoogle has something similar and promotion is tied more to novelty than to keeping the lights on. That tends to promote product churn. Don't forget that Amazon is essentially a retailer, and their a certain amount of customer trust is essential.
- ttul 7y agoAnd Amazon has “customer obsession” as a core value. I just don’t see that at Facebook or Google.
- kccqzy 7y agoBecause most of the time, a Facebook user or a Google user doesn't pay at all. Only advertisers do. And that's why these two companies generally don't have a customer-obsession culture.
- mcqueenjordan 7y agoThere's a reason FB and Google call them users instead of customers. I remember an old joke... "there's only one other industry that calls its customers users."
- basch 7y agoIve thought they should break into the "social network services" market for a long time. You want to build the next reddit or facebook, facebook is equipped to handle a lot of the heavy lifting. Facebook could profit off the competition, by selling them engineering and compute as a service, without having to gobble up every threat. https://telegra.ph/Facebook-Social-Services-FbSS-a-missed-opportunity-02-03 https://telegra.ph/Facebook-Social-Services-FbSS-a-missed-op...
- lioeters 7y ago"Build the next Reddit or Facebook, on Facebook Social Services" That does sound good, even for someone like me who has spent considerable effort ridding my life of FB's influence. The killer product they have is their users and the data mined from them. Allowing third-party apps to leverage their infrastructure as a service would be brilliant.
- notyourwork 7y ago> While what they offer is technically superior to all their competitors I don't have exposure to their offerings but I've heard this and it is rarely qualified with specifics. What is it they have that is superior?
- jedberg 7y agoNamely their network and load balancer. The network is more stable and higher bandwidth and the load balancer is less pathological. Edit: Amusingly I was downvoted for providing specifics. So I guess others don't agree with my assessment?
- herostratus101 7y agoAWS offers hundreds of very mature, extremely reliable services, many of which have either no competition or half-assed clones with few of the same features. Serverless is a great example of this. GCP and Azure both have serverless offerings, but neither of them has the equivalent of Lambda Layers, which has been groundbreaking. Even if we grant that Google's network is better, how can you point to that single dimension and claim that GCP is a better cloud platform? For most business's use cases it would be professional malpractice to recommend GCP over AWS or Azure.
- jedberg 7y agoThe products that Google does offer are technically superior to their equivalent products at AWS. AWS has a much bigger breadth of offerings, and I 100% agree with you that it would be malpractice to recommend GCP over AWS, for myriad reasons. But by mentioning Lambda layers, for example, you're not making an oranges to oranges comparison. For the actual functions offering, for example, the Google one is cheaper, has more consistent network access to the data stores, and starts up faster. Technically superior in every way. But I would never use GCP's serverless offering unless I had to.
- herostratus101 7y ago
- mbesto 7y ago> Google is struggling with their cloud business. While what they offer is technically superior to all their competitors, they don’t have the sales team You sure about that? GCP has hired (or acquihired - Diane Greene for example) sales/management execs from all of the big boys in the industry (VMWare, SAP, Oracle, etc). 1) I see no indication it's "failing", just lagging behind the others. 2) My theory as to why its been lagging behind AWS/Azure is because of trust. AWS was first and is now the "no one got fired for using AWS" of cloud computing. Microsoft is simply entrenched. Oh you want to migrate your on-premise Hyper-V Windows OS's to Azure, we'll gladly help you click this button. Google is notorious for lack of "can I call a person?" support and I think that's permeated itself into its enterprise sales.
- nonfamous 7y agoDiane Greene was fired.
- fragmede 7y agoGCP did $9 billion in revenue in 2019. Amazon and Microsoft may be ahead of them, but saying GCP is "struggling" is a weird way to put it.
- jedberg 7y agoGCP did not do $9B in revenue. Google Cloud did. That includes GApps. And by struggling I mean struggling to keep up with Amazon and Microsoft, whose cloud computing units are significantly larger and growing faster in both absolute dollars and by percentage. In other words they are behind and falling father behind.
- mbesto 7y ago> larger and growing faster in both absolute dollars and by percentage. Where are those specific numbers? AFAIK they don't split it out from all of Google Cloud.
- 7y ago
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- tootie 7y agoFacebook may be too late to the IaaS game which is already a crowded field. I think they could easily do PaaS/SaaS based on their bread and butter domains. Between FB, Insta and WhatsApp they are probably the top mobile developer in the world, handle more user-generated content than anyone and messaging. These are super valuable services. Imagine spinning up a business and subscribing to Facebook's content moderation tools or app deployment pipeline? Those would be extremely valuable and don't have an outright market leader right now.
- herostratus101 7y ago> While what they offer is technically superior to all their competitors No it's not...