16 ms·
Merkel bans meetings of more than two people to slow coronavirus
- Simulacra 7y ago"two is a coincidence three is a conspiracy"
- angel_j 7y agoCoronavirus is perfectly okay with co-incidence.
- randyrand 7y agoThe number of lives saved by these actions will be minuscule compared to deaths per year. 0.8% of people die every year and corona has a 1.4% or lower death rate even with makeshift health care. https://www.nytimes.com/2020/03/19/health/wuhan-coronavirus-deaths.html https://www.nytimes.com/2020/03/19/health/wuhan-coronavirus-... Even with these actions, most people will still get corona. And nearly the same number will die with or without care. Seems like an overreaction.
- whymauri 7y agoFor the love of God, why don't people understand yet that healthcare systems are not ready to be over-run by the sheer number of patients in the worst case? That the death rate of just the virus is not a good indicator of potential casualties with an over-burdened healthcare network? That even if that wasn't true, that the preventable deaths of people due to incompetent governance and leadership are still a cause for concern? I see this sentiment, this statistic, and this comment several times, every day. And I see it debunked several times, every day. Why do people keep saying this?
- scrollaway 7y agoBecause some people are dying to defend whatever their politician-of-choice's line of thinking is.
- dang 7y agoPlease don't post shallow dismissals or flamebait here. No one knows what's happening right now, so it's natural and inevitable that are different views. As long as people express their views thoughtfully and respectfully, that's within the site guidelines. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- scrollaway 7y agoOk, sorry.
- randyrand 7y agoMaybe you should read the NYT article I sent. That is the death rate of Wuhan, where “care” meant being forcible quarantined on a stadium floor. 1.4% figure is the death rate with terrible care. Compare that to the non-corona USA death rate of of 0.8% In other words, even with terrible care the death rate of people with corona is only twice the death rate of people without corona. That’s not very alarming to me. And hardly worth these totalitarian economy stopping measures.
- oaiey 7y agoSo we do not trust Italy either. Especially northern Italy where hospitals are on US/European level?
- bobjob 7y agoThat is not true. People that needed intensive care got it. They build new medical centers for a reason. Not everything China does is bad, we simply don't understand the cultural reasons for the way they sometimes act because it is different!
- endorphone 7y agoThis completely specious position is useful for all arguments! Gun deaths, drunk driving, terrorism, opioid deaths, suicides -- just compare them to the natural death rate and call it a day. I mean, those ones all pale compared to COVID-19, so apparently they're complete non-issues.
- randyrand 7y agoThat’s not a terrible argument. But people are more upset about murder drunk driving, terrorism, opiod, and suicide than dying of disease because it’s human caused. It would make most sense to compare CoVID19 to deaths caused by disease per year in the USA, as that is apples to apples. I don’t have those numbers off hand. Edit: https://ourworldindata.org/causes-of-death https://ourworldindata.org/causes-of-death The overall rate is roughly the same as the death rate from disease.
- 7y ago
- zaroth 7y agoI think people are searching for answers that no one has yet, and also for leaders to gauge both sides of the impact of any response. We must admit that a severe economic impact is also a severe health impact. That much is settled science. So one reasonable question becomes how much damage, not just in terms of dollars, but in terms of lives, would for example a GDP of -25% cause? The impact of the virus to the percentage of the population that requires treatment is magnified significantly by an overrun healthcare system. That is a salient point. It means that spreading out infections over a longer time will allow better treatment for hospitalized COVID patients on average and save lives. But graphics like the famous “flatten the curve” animation [1] are unfortunately quite misleading. The “capacity” line is drawn crossing some point on the y-axis which makes the graphic look compelling. The true ICU/ventilator capacity line is perhaps 4 pixels off the y-axis on that chart. We also don’t have any x-axis units, how many months would the curve have to stretch to keep the number of cases under capacity? And there’s another factor, for as long as hospital ICUs and healthcare dollar spend is dominated by COVID cases, there are all the other healthcare needs of the country / world which are suffering. It’s reasonable to expect a macro level analysis of the net health impact of non-pharmaceutical interventions (NPI) such as widespread and long-term suppression. I have yet to see a compelling scientific analysis on this topic. Even the UK Imperial College report admits that there is not a clear cut moral or ethical “answer” based on the severe economic and health impacts of taking dramatic action to populations that otherwise would not be severely impacted by COVID. The thing right now that’s confounding me is trying to comprehend how China and South Korea were able to, not flatten, but stop exponential growth, given the level of spread that we would expect to have occurred before suppressive measures were taken, based on the unmitigated R0 range. There were a lot of people traveling out of Wuhan before the lockdown [2], and yet the impact to greater China was relatively minimal, while most of China is now back to work. Frankly it gives me hope that there’s reason to believe, particularly with warmer weather coming, that it’s easier to get R0 below 1 than we might otherwise suspect. It would be a welcome relief to be spared having to make the extremely difficult choice for or against long-term suppressive measures. [1] - https://images.app.goo.gl/FtdN3kYowN2bSD3HA https://images.app.goo.gl/FtdN3kYowN2bSD3HA [2] - https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2020/03/22/world/coronavirus-spread.html https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2020/03/22/world/coronav...
- abnry 7y agoCan a government even function with meetings of 2 or fewer?
- eh78ssxv2f 7y agoThey could use video conferencing.
- tastroder 7y agoThe government isn't meeting in a public space, which these rules apply to. And they are able to use phone and video conferencing (which is how they coordinated these rules according to the original press conference on this).
- oaiey 7y agoWell, the government is a working place. This regulation is not addressing working places but only the public places. Aside, members of Parlament are similar protected like journalists.
- pvorb 7y agoProtected from fines, but actually unprotected in this case.
- 1123581321 7y agoThe article said the government didn’t specify punishment for breaking this rule, but what would the existing statutory consequences be for disobeying an order like this?
- bobjob 7y agoUp to 15,000€ as far as I understand.
- tastroder 7y agoMerkel explicitly said (in the press conference, answering a reporters question) that they did not discuss the issue of specific consequences today. edit: Ah, yeah that might well apply. Would be an upper bound though.
- bobjob 7y agoThen the 15,000€ fines are a thing for breaking specific federal rules and I mixed things up. In in Bavaria we have those rules and Saarland has similar rules.
- oaiey 7y agoThey avoid talking about it. In Bavaria we have a up to 25k € fine on violations (which I presume is backed by a German wide law). I think mention this fine is a next escalation.
- cygned 7y agoYeah that’s § 73 (2) IfSG: https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/ifsg/__73.html https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/ifsg/__73.html I guess they will escalate over time and fine only those people breaking the rules multiple times.
- blattimwind 7y ago§ 113 StGB could be applicable if you resist officers enforcing the ban. Fine or up to three years. § 111 StGB could be applicable if you make Facebook posts calling for people to ignore the ban. Fine or up to five years.
- djdkrkfkgk 7y agoI'm very curious if all this social distancing, hand washing and mask wearing on a global scale will have an effect on the next flu season. Could this be the first year with very little flu going around?
- Barrin92 7y agothat is already happening, there's been a sharp drop in flu cases in hongkong this season. https://www.ft.com/content/ad7ae6b4-5eab-11ea-b0ab-339c2307bcd4 https://www.ft.com/content/ad7ae6b4-5eab-11ea-b0ab-339c2307b...
- __s 7y agoWish it was acceptable for me stow away like this every flu season
- RalfWausE 7y agoI think this is fair. The problem in most western democracies is, that it is nearly impossible to enforce a law that is not accepted by the people, at least not for a long time. A complete shutdown in Wuhan-style may be more effective, but in any western country the people would, after two or three weeks, start to find loopholes. So i think its better to make a law that is a bit less effective but accepted by the people instead of a law that invites people to get "creative"
- bobjob 7y agoI think that this and our lack in 'hands on' experience with pandemics play a role in how western governments act. It is sad that the population has to learn via a death toll that certain things have to be done. I wish I could say it wetter, but I'm lacking the right words/phrases.
- oaiey 7y agoIn Bavaria we have these rules already a few days. They are quite acceptable. It leaves options to go jogging alone, to go out with the kids and have a chat with the neighbors over the street. 1.5m is IMHO a bit too close, but it seems the recommendation. However, I live a villagers life. Wuhan is a huge city with much less public space. So I argue, it is not only democratic vs. Non democratic society but also depends on the location dramatically.
- pachico 7y agoIn general, I think it also depends on society maturity (given there are many ways to get to that state). In Spain and Italy, the countries I know best, thousands of citizens are trying to cut corners and bypass any quarantine obligation.
- oaiey 7y agoI would be very careful with the wording maturity in context of society. Italy and Spain have a society which is far more family friendly, elder friendly and outgoing culture than Germany. That is usually much better. Just not now.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- pachico 7y agoI read an interesting article describing how cultural factors are affecting virus spreading. Among many things, the family configuration is radically different in Germany than in Italy or Spain and this is one of the key factors (besides Germany being able to buy and execute tests to confine who needed to be confined in time). It looks like many Italians (also many Spaniards but not so many) live with their parents even when they are 30-40 years old. In addition, many grandparents take care of children in daily or regular basis. This means that very socially active slices of society are in constant contact with the the population which is most at risk.
- superzamp 7y agoThat would be an interesting factor, do you still have the link to the article?
- rihegher 7y agohttps://elpais.com/sociedad/2020/03/20/actualidad/1584729408_422864.html https://elpais.com/sociedad/2020/03/20/actualidad/1584729408...
- pachico 7y agoI also found this related to the same: https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.lanacion.com.ar/el-mundo/los-fuertes-lazos-entre-abuelos-y-nietos-un-factor-de-la-alta-letalidad-nid2346106/amp https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.lanacion.com.ar/el-mundo/lo...
- baxtr 7y agoVery interesting. In Germany, many deaths occurred in retirement homes...
- nemo44x 7y agoSo far the median age of German cases is 47. It is 63 for Italy. Also, Germany isn’t doing postmortem testing on people that are dying from preexisting conditions that could be suspicious. Italy has tested corpses that weren’t initially tested. Global numbers are so tough to compare with different countries testing differently, reporting differently, and of course demographic differences.
- qzxan 7y agoBanning meetings for two weeks is fine. But a total curfew that some politicians want to impose is counterproductive. Most infections occur inside the home. Many German cities with high rents have very high number of shared apartments. I caught the worst flu of my life inside such a shared apartment. The following years, whenever some flatmate had symptoms, I immeadiately escaped to a hotel. Never had the flu again. Also, people sitting at home affects their immune system. Politicians with large houses stolen from the population are fine of course. We see in Italy that a total lockdown does not work. People absolutely need to go out for solitary activities.
- onetimemanytime 7y ago>>Most infections occur inside the home. Many German cities with high rents have very high number of shared apartments. If you don't have the virus you cannot infect wife. Now if you go out and come back home you might pick up something from outside. >>We see in Italy that a total lockdown does not work. Italy closed the barn door too late
- vlogxx 7y agoThe comment you reply to mentions shared apartments, like students use. In big expensive cities many non-students are also in this situation. So it is not about "you cannot infect wife [sic]". It is about an escape hatch of being outside alone so these shared apartments don't turn into the Diamond Princess. You cannot infect yourself outside if you keep a distance of 5m to everyone. In Germany, the streets are empty enough to allow that without a curfew. You also very unlikely to infect yourself if you go to a hotel without air conditioning, clean the room yourself, don't go to breakfast and just use the room as an isolated office and keep a frigging distance to everyone.
- marcinzm 7y ago>It is about an escape hatch of being outside alone so these shared apartments don't turn into the Diamond Princess. A contained infection is fine, it's uncontained infection which aren't. Thus this whole thing. >You cannot infect yourself outside if you keep a distance of 5m to everyone Sure you can, careful on what you touch, virus lives for three days on steel and plastic. >You also very unlikely to infect yourself if you go to a hotel without air conditioning, clean the room yourself, don't go to breakfast and just use the room as an isolated office and keep a frigging distance to everyone. If you know your flat mate is sick then you're probably already sick. There's a multi day incubation period without symptoms and this strain seems decently infectious. So going to a hotel will just expose other people to YOU.
- draugadrotten 7y agoAFP just announced Merkel herself has Corona https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2020-03-21/congress-works-on-aid-deal-spain-cases-to-worsen-virus-update https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2020-03-21/congress-...
- FlorianRappl 7y agoThis is wrong. She had contact with somebody and needs to go into quarantine as a precaution mechanism. Nothing proven yet.
- nodesocket 7y agoIn quarantine, not confirmed. https://www.cnbc.com/2020/03/22/chancellor-angela-merkel-in-quarantine-after-contact-with-doctor-who-tested-positive-for-coronavirus.html https://www.cnbc.com/2020/03/22/chancellor-angela-merkel-in-...
- IAmEveryone 7y agoI’m reading she is self-quarantining because she interacted with someone who later tested positive.
- tpush 7y agoOne of her doctors has Corona, she's just in quarantine for now.
- andruby 7y agoShe’s in quarantine after having been in contact with an infected person. The article does not mention that she tested positive
- chris_engel 7y agoI wonder how this should help while people still need to go to work in factories or large space offices. A friend of mine posted a pic of a sign in the lunchroom at Siemens that demands people to keep their distance to eachother while eating. In the meantime two or more people work together at a workbench, sharing tools, etc. But I guess every small bit helps somewhat. I am glad that the client I currently work for closed all offices and sent all people to ull remote work two weeks ago.
- baxtr 7y agoStory from a very good friend of mine in Germany, we talk almost every day: There was a suspected case in his kid’s school class, first grader. So they closed the class and tested the other kid. That was 11 days ago. The result came in today (I.e. the other parents were informed today): Positive. There is no way you can stop this virus from spreading if you inform contacts almost 2 weeks later.
- chris_engel 7y agoBut if they closed down the class because of that all parents should have been aware that their kids could possibly be infected.
- s9w 7y agoThat seems strange. Most results are ready in 24h in Germany I think.
- VyperCard 7y agoNo. My colleague was tested on Wednesday, still no result.
- dmix 7y agoIn Canada it used to be 24hrs, but there is now a 4-5 day waiting period to get results after you get swabbed or blood tested, due to a large backlog of tests. So most results we see today are about ~9-10 days old if we combine that with “when did first symptoms appear?” survey in the Chinese study (results were often 5-10 days before visiting the hospital when the tests are first initiated). Then on top of that some people take up to 5 days to show the first symptom. So any data you see today could easily be 2 weeks old. 1 week would be an ideal target in the short term, depending on where your goalposts are...
- fabian2k 7y agoMost stuff related to the pandemic like testing is not centrally organized in Germany, this is all on the state or local level. So I can easily imagine that there are very large differences depending on where exactly you are.
- FlorianRappl 7y agoGermany is still missing out on some very basic things that have been done right in countries like South Korea: Namely: constant cleanup, constant testing, identification and information about potential hot spots. The government reacted really slow (we had the first case ~mid of February and nothing happened for another 3 weeks) it now does a lot of actions but mostly destructive ones like shutting down the economy. Yes, social distancing is good, and yes we need to flatten the curve, but there are other possibilities, too? Protecting people above 65 (i.e., retired) and with medical conditions would have been easier. Now there is fear everywhere. Still, I hear from a lot of people that they indeed show (mild) symptoms, but are not tested - even upon request. How can that work? I was riding the subway here in Munich last Friday. Quite empty - still very dirty. No where anyone with sanitizing spray or anything.
- alkonaut 7y ago> Still, I hear from a lot of people that they indeed show (mild) symptoms, but are not tested - even upon request. How can that work? Why would you test everyone with mild symptoms? 90% or more of those people are going to have the flu or a common cold. And they’d use a test that can be used on someone where it makes a difference: someone admitted to hospital, or someone working at a hospital. Everyone else with symptoms can just act as if it is covid and isolate for 14 days. When you have exponential growing, testing capability can never keep up.
- Gene_Parmesan 7y agoGiven the long incubation period, as well as the fact that many people who are carriers are completely asymptomatic, blanket testing has been tentatively shown to be an effective way to halt the spread of the virus. See: the whole of South Korea's approach, as well as https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/europe/coronavirus-vo-euganeo-blanket-testing-veneto-luca-zaia-a9411201.html https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/europe/coronavirus-...
- alkonaut 7y agoMy point wasn’t that fewer than possible should be tested, my point was that given the constraints (staff, equipment, time) it’s best to test people that it makes a difference for, such as those who must be in contact with people - in healthcare. If you could test everyone with symptoms (or everyone full stop) then go for it. That’s not possible though.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- billfruit 7y agoI heard an exception is made if the meeting is 'work-related'.
- archi42 7y agoIt's absolutley frustrating that this is even necessary - after all that's happening worldwide, people should just stay at home and avoid meeting people. A lot of us are not THAT relevant for society to not collapse at an instant, and a lot of our pasttime are even less so. Still, a few think that all this wouldn't apply to them. Or think this is the problem of the risk groups, who should stay at home while all others act as if nothing happened. Just had that discussion with a friend, who wanted to host a game night and used that very "argument". Well, egoism rules supreme :( Thanks to people like these, some of our basic rights now have to be suspended.
- knocte 7y agoI agree with what you're saying but then there's the other example of Asian countries that are not China, who have flattened the exponential curve without forced lockdowns. Governments in the west should just speedup mass production of masks because this is IMO the key to this flattening (and even if they still prefer forced lockdown, masks would be a good measure for when the lockdown is lifted).
- aledalgrande 7y agoI think the key is massive testing and ability to track cases fast and efficiently. If we could do that in the West, people could go out tomorrow. Perfection would be self testing at home, with self reporting on a gov website. But we're faaar from that...
- archi42 7y agoI agree with you: We could have impactful measures without a forced lockdown. However, people in these other countries, did they act like usual or did they practice a strict regime of (voluntary) social distancing? After all, as long as the data is lacking, social distancing is one of the most simple, yet impactful measures. This makes a huge difference. Though I am seeing a non-negligible portion of the population believing they could just act as if nothing happened. I know it sucks, but not meeting people for a while isn't the end of the world. And it would be easily possible without any laws, giving law- & policy-makers time to gather data and make a better, well-informed decision. I see this (voluntary, not-enforced-via-the-law-like-this-lockdown) as my democratic responsibility. Edit: I see two interpretations for this lockdown: 1. "Shit, this is out of control and oh god, plenty of our people will die". (as a side note, the parties in power tend to be strong with the elderly; though I believe this isn't a major factor for this decision) 2. "Oh, what a nice chance to fk democracy and get more power". I'm tending to the 1., as long as the measures are not enacted for too long. Problem is: Relaxing too early will be bad for the people, relaxing to late will bad for getting re-elected. So I'm very happy right now I didn't enter politics. (end edit) Also, the government can't just ramp up mask production. You need raw materials for that, factories, a supply chain. You need to make sure the masks are safe to various standards, else - even if you're the government - you're in a huge legal mess. Oh, and train people for all that. Germany isn't strictly free market economy, but it's not too far away from that ("social market economy"). And under that system, the state isn't meant to spontaneously interfere massively with markets by becoming a producer. So if they did, that would open just another pandoras box. Yes, we have food and other critical supplies, but masks and other medical equipment is a wholly different league. The "ruleset" is too complex, there is no obviously best decision right now :(
- p1mrx 7y agoIt seems reasonable to allow meetings of 2, because orders like California's amount to weeks/months of solitary confinement for people who live alone. We may have to deal with a suicide epidemic alongside the regular one. (I'll be fine, but there are probably a lot of people going through much worse.)
- AstroBoy69 7y agoLearning to be alone with yourself is a very important life skill. Maybe you should figure out why you are so uncomfortable being alone :)
- ma2rten 7y agoI am not sure that European countries are acting strongly enough. California and New York's shelter-in-place order includes not going to work for non-essential workers. In Germany (and even in Italy until recently) people are still going to work. Also, German politicians don't want to use words like curfew ("Ausgangssperre") because of East Germany's history. There was a lot of talk if a curfew is even constitutional. EDIT: I really don't understand why this is getting downvoted. Maybe consider commenting if you disagree?
- m4rtink 7y agoIn Czech Republic you can go outside only for work shopping or excecise on condition you don'c come close to anyone else. Also masks (including self made) are mandatory in public. All non essential shops are closec, borders are closed. All this is enforced and the few people who for some reason break these rules have been fined pretty heavily. Also if you are in quaratine as infected or potentially infected and go out, you might get a multi year jail sentance.
- ma2rten 7y agoThat's pretty strong action. In California I think you could technically go to jail for going outside, but it's not enforced yet. I hope other countries follow the Czech Republic's example, otherwise many areas of the world will look like Italy soon.
- jansan 7y agoIn my region in Germany a stupid lady who was supposed to be under quarantine caused a traffic accident. Dear god, how stupid can people be?
- Tomte 7y agoShe "caused" it by being there. The other driver was at fault, swerving onto the opposite direction lane and hitting her. She shouldn't have been outside, but your version of the story is preposterously wrong.
- vanniv 7y agoIsn't it interesting how, in every country, the only methods being considered or implemented to aid this "crisis" are the ones that are identical to the behaviors of authoritarians?
- lawlorino 7y agoWhat's your suggestion?
- vanniv 7y agoSeeing as even locking everyone in their houses doesn't slow down the virus in the slightest (see Italy, where the exponential growth is still full steam ahead, and will clearly only slow at this point once the virus runs out of new people to infect), honestly the UK's original plan is clearly the best one: just let everyone be exposed, it'll be over the fastest and there will be herd immunity to prevent new waves every few weeks for the rest of our lives. Even if the worst-case estimates were true (which they basically can't be at this point), you're looking at 0.25-0.5% of the population dying. Compare that with the effect that the permanent collapse of our free and prosperous societies, converting the world into Venezuela will have. If we don't change course, the living will envy the dead
- pvaldes 7y ago> honestly the UK's original plan is clearly the best one: just let everyone be exposed, But then your father or your grandmother would die as probable outcome, and this plan will not look so clever then. > Converting the world into Venezuela A beautiful country with astonishing nature?
- lolc 7y agoThis is not true. Government reactions include educating people about appropriate hygiene. That is not an authoritarian but actually a humanistic tradition. Also note that democracies do include exceptions to guaranteed rights, allowing control of infectuous diseases. As long as these exceptions are not abused, they cannot be said to be authoritarian. Or rather, you'd have to take a very libertarian position to call them authoritarian.
- idclip 7y agoGermany is treating this pretty badly. Many People here dont care. The FAZ (popular conservative newspaper) is calling the german reaction “resembling ancient roman decadence”
- elric 7y agoThis has been the case in Belgium for over a week now. Along with the closure of the obvious gathering spots, like pubs and restaurans and whatnot.
- ericmcer 7y agoI am currently sitting in my room across the street from a church that is in full swing, 100+ people singing together in a single room. I don’t live in the middle of nowhere, I am in Oakland CA. We have many confirmed cases and have been getting quarantine and stay in place messages for the last 9ish days? It is totally baffling, do people really need military and police intervention to force them to not get a deadly virus?
- lalaland1125 7y agoPlease send a message to the police with details. (510) 777-3333 is the correct non emergency number for Oakland.
- neurologic 7y agoIt looks this way, which means that military and police intervention is what we'll get.
- lisper 7y agoSome people genuinely believe that God will protect them. I have no idea how to get through to such people, but if you happen to have an opportunity to engage with someone like that here's an experiment that I would love to see someone try: tell them to read Exodus 12:29 and suggest that maybe this time we are Egypt.
- Mountain_Skies 7y agoChurches have closed during other pandemics. Maybe use those incidents as examples so they know it is ok to close down while also not feeling like they're showing a lack of faith. When I checked the webpage of the Catholic diocese I'm located it, it mentioned that Catholics have been released from their obligation to attend mass and this has happened before. Hopefully other churches will have the same attitude.
- exegete 7y agoI think most have the right attitude. I’m in the NYC area and most had closed even before any official request or order. Although there are always some members who don’t get it. I was actually able to get our church to use Zoom for the time being until we can meet in person again.
- hintymad 7y agoInterestingly, Merkel herself is in quarantine because her doctor is tested positive. Why did German think that social distance was not okay, or even harmful, when it was clear that covid-19 was highly contagious? And why are people so resistant to wearing masks? How do I know for sure that people around me are not contagious? How do I know for sure that myself is not contagious, under the current pandemic situation? Yet people freak out when they see a person wear a mask. Just saw this paragraph in the article "The politics of pandemics" in The Economist: "To see what is to come look to Lombardy, the affluent Italian region at the heart of the covid-19 outbreak in Europe. Its hospitals provide world-class health care. Until last week they thought they would cope with the disease -- then waves of people began turning up with pneumonia. Having run out of ventilators and oxygen, exhausted staff at some hospitals are being forced to leave untreated patients to die". So, this article is telling people that Italians thought that they were so good that exponential contagion was no big deal? An honest question: isn't what the Europeans have been doing a classical example for the quote "Weakness and ignorance are not barriers to survival, but arrogance is"?
- nokcha 7y ago>And why are people so resistant to wearing masks? In the US, there is a severe shortage of masks. Even hospitals are struggling to get enough masks for health-care workers.
- dmix 7y agoI’m sure way more people would be wearing a mask if they had one. It’s going to be a common household item soon the way it already is in Asia. The only reason I was able to get one is because I know people who live in China and already had boxes of them before COVID-19.
- hintymad 7y agoYes, that's a perfectly good reason. What I was asking about is people's general attitude toward wearing masks, when shortage of the supply is not in the equation.
- robocat 7y ago
- dijit 7y agoI just heard Boris Johnson on television urging people to take responsibility and stay indoors, this is after the government had to force shut certain pubs. (notably Tim Martins' Wetherspoons where Tim Martin himself said he would not close[0]) In Sweden, I see more people on the street now than before the pandemic was announced, although I definitely see a downtrend in Restaurants. People are not staying inside, and I lament this. Failure to prevent the spread of this virus will only lead to harsher regulations and a lengthening of the quarantine period. But it seems like for a certain part of the population legal force is actually necessary. I can only assume that this is driven from "individualist" mentalities that often come with delusions of being above rules or communal responsibility. If that's the case then if Sweden can't follow such simple rules then I have no hope for the UK and even less hope for the USA. [0]: (Sorry about daily mail) https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-8133303/Pubs-packed-revellers-despite-calls-social-distancing.html https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-8133303/Pubs-packed...
- ohp2veeJ 7y agoWhy don't you want to see people outside? Indoors is more crowded, and outside sunlight makes short work of pathogens and otherwise the wind will disperse them anyway. Of course, as long as the people don't flock together. People need to take responsibility of course, but they also need to protect their physical and mental well being, and being outside contributes to that. Covid-19 isn't the only challenge people face. What I mean is, you can't just let it become a Pyhrric victory.
- beatgammit 7y agoExactly. We should be encouraging responsible outdoor activities. If you can maintain a safe distance from others, making sure to account for wind, your added risk of going outside is pretty low and you get a ton of mental and physical health benefits.
- l_davis 7y agoWHO is, I believe, encouraging outdoor exercise as well, with appropriate distancing. Lots of discussion here on mask wearing, which I think is great and would help slow spread of this (reusable ones for those who aren't health professionals). Not a lot of discussion that I've seen on how to improve health and function of the immune system, which might not stop spread but could certainly improve the percentage of those who don't get critically ill. I'm talking mainstream advice like getting rest, exercise, eating nutritious food, not smoking. I've also seen a reputable study that states that vitamin d supplements can lower odds of getting respiratory infections. So a low cost way of improving odds. I'm glad I take vitamin d already.