11 ms·
Traffic and Pollution Plummet as U.S. Cities Shut Down
- mmhsieh 7y agomost commutes are BS. a lot of work does not need to be done in an office. a lot of office politics can be cut down when communications are proportionately more heavily documented. typical overhead for a single seat in the metro where I work is $50K a year. there was already a move to hoteling and telework. tremendous efficiencies gained in this should be retained. better for the environment, bottom lines, quality of life of workers. managers with the 20th century face-time attitude: deal with it.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- nicoburns 7y agoIs anyone else wondering if the shutdown for COVID-19 will have a significant impact on carbon emissions? If it does, then it could actually save far more lives than it takes.
- admax88q 7y agoI doubt the shutdown will be long enough to have significant long term impact. But maybe it will give people an appreciation for how nice the world can be with less pollution. A shift in attitude could cause long term changes in our tolerance for pollution.
- convolvatron 7y agomaybe it will also serve as a reminder that there are things outside the economy that we should really be taking care of
- ntsplnkv2 7y agoAnd as a reminder that we don't need as much "stuff" as we think we do.
- gkfasdfasdf 7y agoThe lower traffic has been great for running - much easier to cross busy intersections.
- Proven 7y agoExcellent thinking! Now if we could only make sure it strikes the right people it'd be a perfect solution to major problems facing humanity
- zaroth 7y agoA population’s physical health is very highly correlated with their economic health. [1] If COVID-19 has a significant impact on carbon emissions it’s because it caused significant economic depression. A significant economic depression dramatically increases poverty levels, and increasing poverty would cost significantly more lives even than will be lost to COVID itself. [2] The life expectancy gap between the poorest and wealthiest Americans is about 15 years. [3] [1] - https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/poverty-vs-life-expectancy?time=1981..2014 https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/poverty-vs-life-expectanc... [2] - https://twitter.com/ballouxfrancois/status/1238837173111140352?s=21 https://twitter.com/ballouxfrancois/status/12388371731111403... [3] - http://news.mit.edu/2016/study-rich-poor-huge-mortality-gap-us-0411 http://news.mit.edu/2016/study-rich-poor-huge-mortality-gap-...
- nicoburns 7y agoYes, but still not nearly as many as if say bangladesh floods.
- _bxg1 7y ago> The life expectancy gap between the poorest and wealthiest Americans is about 15 years. That's a function of our broken system, not our overall wealth as a nation. Poverty in the U.S. has been increasing alongside GDP for years now. Restoring the economy to the way it was won't solve that.
- zaroth 7y agoThe life expectancy versus poverty correlation is observed consistently worldwide. Poverty rates in the US peaked at 15% in 2010 and have been going down since. Last year 11.8%. [1] Poverty causes a lot of damage, see for example, opioid deaths. [1] - https://www.statista.com/statistics/200463/us-poverty-rate-since-1990/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/200463/us-poverty-rate-s...
- alok-g 7y agoThanks. This is such a useful and insightful comment, @zaroth.
- 7y ago
- dgellow 7y agoDepends how things play out once we are done with the virus crisis. It's possible that we will see crazy level of production and consumption to compensate the down time, resulting in way more carbon emissions. And governments will surely want to boost their economy at any cost, that could be quite bad for ecological policies. Definitely not what I personally want, I'm in Europe and hope that EU members use the current situation as a way to work closer together and come with even stronger environmental regulation.
- iso1210 7y ago> EU members use the current situation as a way to work closer together EU members are shouting "Every country for itself" Pretty similar to the US states actually, other than US states can't close borders (but can enforce no travelling, which is basically a superset of closed borders)
- dgellow 7y agoNot really, no. They closed their borders but there is some level of collaboration at the moment, for example german states at the French border (e.g: Baden-Würtemberg) started to take in charge French patients who cannot be handled by the French healthcare system. Comparing the US and the EU doesn’t often make sense IMHO, they have different and incompatible institutions with different goals. In any case, what is happening now doesn’t define how countries will react after the crisis.
- jl2718 7y agoAlso traffic fatalities.
- jobigoud 7y agoHowever with everyone stuck at home all day long there is an increase in domestic accidents and unfortunately also an increase in domestic violence.
- sixdimensional 7y agoYes, and I am waiting for the next updates on CO2 from Mauna Loa, HI to see if there is even a tiny blip in the rate of increase during the shutdown. So far, I can’t tell if there has been any meaningful change to the pattern. https://www.esrl.noaa.gov/gmd/ccgg/trends/monthly.html https://www.esrl.noaa.gov/gmd/ccgg/trends/monthly.html
- briefcomment 7y agoWhile the effects on CO2 may be significant and possibly beneficial, I think we should focus on particulate matter, CO, NO and other pollutants directly poisonous to the human body.
- gdubs 7y agoI’ve been thinking a lot about the next looming crisis: Climate Change. On Bloomberg radio a few weeks ago, an analyst / money manager was talking about how his firm was looking at satellite imagery of pollution in China to measure their economic recovery. More pollution == “better”. Something is clearly unsustainable with that formula. Like the virus, the longer we wait to take action, the more expensive it is and the narrower our options become. It seems more and more that there’s an illusion of public debate, while behind the scenes a decision has been made in favor of [adaptation]. I find that deeply sad. The world has pressed the pause button for a moment. What it looks like on the other side of this crisis is in question. My (fools?) hope is that it makes us reflect on the fragility of the system we’ve created, the importance of global cooperation, democratic values, and what kind of future we want for ourselves and our kids.
- perfunctory 7y ago> while behind the scenes a decision has been made in favor of mitigation You probably mean adaptation?
- gdubs 7y agoThanks, it’s early here. Fixed.
- asdfasgasdgasdg 7y agoWow. Wouldn't want to invest with that money manager. If that signal wasn't already well known, giving away secret sauce in a public interview is not a recipe for outsize returns. But it is a well known signal so it's even less useful for investing. If I've learned anything about the climate crisis from COVID-19, it's that we aren't going to solve the climate crisis unless it's more convenient to do so than not. COVID is a much more pressing problem than climate change and we didn't do anything about it until after it was already a catastrophe.
- leetcrew 7y agosatellite imagery is already a common tool used by hedge funds. the correlation between pollution and productivity is also an obvious one. it's an interesting tidbit for laymen, but he's not giving away anything specific enough to be used by adversaries.
- Noos 7y agoWell yeah, more or less cripple the economy by forcing large amounts of people out of work for extended periods, as well as shutting down many businesses would reduce those things. I doubt really anyone here would like the long term cost of this.
- deevolution 7y agoSo far, the COVID-19 pandemic is showing us that People, rather than Consumption, matter most. We need consumption to support people, yes, but Economic expansion and increasing consumption can't go on infinitely. Most people shouldn't be able to afford a car - they should be taking public transit - but they can obtain one because they take out loans. The american fracking industry shouldn't exist, but it can because it has access to cheap, infinite lines of credit. Our health suffers for it. So many people and businesses are able to live beyond their means because of access to credit. If we eliminate the ability to create credit, then consumption would drop to a sustainable level and pollution would also drop and we would see an end to wasteful businesses, products, processes, and ways of life.
- lol768 7y ago> So many people and businesses are able to live beyond their means because of access to credit. If we eliminate the ability to create credit, then consumption would drop to a sustainable level and pollution would also drop and we would see an end to wasteful businesses, products, processes, and ways of life. What about housing? A mortgage is going to be the only way for a lot of people to ever afford their own home.
- losteric 7y agoWell, to question your premise - Why is universal home ownership desirable or necessary?
- Sileni 7y agoIt's either (near) universal or communal. Anything in between gives elites so much power over the less advantaged that you see a stratification of society similar to, well, what we're seeing now. Here's a quarantine project for you: build a model that lets you push around the %age of renters vs land owners. Virtually any model that contains a significant number of renters will eventually have one land owner and many renters, unless you see significant economic disasters in the model.
- 7y ago
- xyst 7y agoNow we need to start fining companies (per worker) that unnecessarily require people to commute to work.
- leetcrew 7y agobusinesses already face significant incentives to let people WFH when possible. they just need to be convinced it won't be a severe hit to productivity. after the current crisis runs its course, I bet we'll see a lot of companies realize they are wasting a lot of money on their office lease.
- Shivetya 7y agoand auto insurance companies are probably benefiting as well
- fyrefoxboy12 7y agounintended good news consequence. earth is gonna have a great few months now. maybe a year. less consumption, less traveling, less pollution. nature rejoices
- _bxg1 7y agoWho knows, if effects from this last 18 months from now like some are saying maybe it'll put a dent in climate change.
- jrobn 7y agoThis event will be a good mine in refining and implementing models for pollution control and reduction. Never have we had events as large as this to observe.
- vinniejames 7y agoLooks like we've found the solution to global warning. All it took was a government mandate that folks who can and should be working from home do so. Hopefully we all have the common sense to continue this long term, mother earth deserves a break
- erik_seaberg 7y agoI think the people working from home are outnumbered by the people who can't work and are quickly going broke.
- briefcomment 7y agoNo one's disputing that. It makes sense that if people who can work home do so, the environment will be better than if they don't work from home. Also, many people who cannot work from home at the moment are still driving to work (restaurant workers, grocery store workers, other retail). This current situation isn't too far off from a state where just those who can work from home do so, and the rest drive to work. And anecdotally, the air where I live has gone from one of the worst in the nation to delightful.
- leetcrew 7y ago> This current situation isn't too far off from a state where just those who can work from home do so, and the rest drive to work. it seems pretty very far off to me. I'm having a nice time working from home, but all my friends that don't work at a grocery store (restaurant workers, tutors, social workers, theater techs) are sitting at home not getting paid. I'm not sure how to estimate what fraction of the workforce actually needs to commute to work, but it seems like they make up a pretty significant amount of the people that are not driving right now.
- briefcomment 7y agoI was comparing the current situation with the state where everyone is forced to stay at home. Right now, everyone is not forced to stay at home. If you're saying that the current situation is closer to everyone staying at home than to business as usual, you're probably right. However, where I live, a majority of the restaurants are open (just doing drive through). Tutoring is possibly something that can be done online. I've known many high quality tutors running business entirely from home. Theater techs, social workers, and other similar jobs probably make up a very small fraction of the workforce compared to restaurant, retail (I believe the majority of retail stores in my area are open), and grocery workers. So I still think the current situation can give us a decent idea of what driving volume and pollution levels will look like in a situation where people that can work from home do so. The current situation is definitely biased towards less driving though.
- starpilot 7y agoWe can live in villages! Start over!
- karmakaze 7y agoOT: Felt bad having to click 'Collapse' on the banner below this story page.
- ciconia 7y agoDespite the loss of human life, and the economic suffering of a great chunk of our species, a lot of good may come of the present pandemic. I believe this crisis has the potential to bring about a fundamental change in the way we relate to the world and to each other. It's as if humanity is at a crossroads: everything is possible, and we need to make a choice. I read this morning something that struck me as true: "We were in the process of losing our humanity, but a virus one thousands of a micron has has just given it back to us." [1] [1] https://www.causeur.fr/coronavirus-covid-19-guillaume-bigot-174274 https://www.causeur.fr/coronavirus-covid-19-guillaume-bigot-...
- tjr225 7y agoA beautiful quote. I think it’s a little goofy that you’re being downvoted just for saying something vaguely positive. Please, people- keep your wits about you.
- thulecitizen 7y agoThank you for shining a light on something that you found beautiful. I bid you a safe journey also, my dear friend.
- phyzome 7y ago1/5th to 1/20th of a micron, though. :-)
- siruncledrew 7y agoFor all the bad that has happened, this has been an interesting time to reflect and gather a new perspective about some of the newfound good. It’s like being thrown into a worldwide experiment that would otherwise never realistically happen. There’s so many understandings to gain from the results of our actions, habits, and lifestyles. The world is changing before our eyes as a result of the changes in our behaviors. We can see how even when we slow down, the world keeps going. It’s an incredibly unique, enlightening circumstance. Hopefully, as we move forward, we actually learn from the history unfolding today, and don’t just discredit it all to go back to the way things were for our own ego at the expense of the rest of the world.
- ipodopt 7y agoMy understanding is that pollution has a short term (~weeks) cooling effect due to global dimming, and a long term (~decades) warming effect due to the greenhouse effect. So this may cause a short term spike in global temperatures over the next few months. If this goes on long enough it could paradoxically accelerate climate change. Maybe we need a well place and timed nuke on the moon to compensate. EDIT: On the other hand increased sunlight may boost photosynthesis. All in all should be intresting to see the effect. Because it may show that we need to be more careful about mitigating certain types to pollutants (CO2) first and leaving others for later.
- gumby 7y agoI remember this effect in September 2001: suburban outdoors was much quieter with no air traffic and a much reduced road traffic. It was around this time that I started backpacking again. I had forgotten how much urban din there even when not in a city.
- v8engine 7y agoCan someone please tell me what the name for the technology used to create the graphics is? The text for the place names over the image is highlightable. I know you can handcraft these by having the text overlay over an exact X,Y on an image but that seems overblown for just these maps than having the text rastered into the image loaded. So, is there some tool like an SVG creator that helps create these with the responsiveness and everything handled?
- wffurr 7y agoThere's some interesting HTML comments in the source. "ai2html" sounds like the source is Adobe Illustrator and probably refers to this tool: https://github.com/newsdev/ai2html https://github.com/newsdev/ai2html Not sure what "freebird" is, some internal software. I can't find much about it with Google search. <!-- data processed in process/freebird/process-graphic.js --> <!-- asset wrapper : start --> <!-- ASSET : START --> <div class="g-asset g-graphic" style="max-width: 945px"> <!-- Intro elements --> <!-- inner graphic element --> <!-- print .html file --> <!-- Generated by ai2html v0.100.0 - 2020-03-22 00:19 --> <!-- ai file: maps_la.ai --> <!-- preview: 2020-03-19-coronavirus-us-cities-shutdown --> <!-- scoop: coronavirus-usa-traffic -->
- v8engine 7y agoYup. ai2html seems to what I was looking for. Didn't spot that because of all the freebird comments. As for freebird, my search led me to this. https://github.com/freebirdjs/freebird https://github.com/freebirdjs/freebird Seems to be the NYT has an array of pollution sensor IOT across the cities and they are using Freebird to control them. Just my guess.
- boulos 7y agoSlightly off-topic but the analyses here come from the nice folks at Descartes Labs (Disclosure: I work on Google Cloud and with the Descartes Labs folks, we’ve even been skiing together in Taos). If you’re into GIS or large-scale imagery processing, you should hit them up [1] especially if you’d like to live in Santa Fe (where the core team is). They also hire outside of Santa Fe, but as the core team is there, they strongly suggest you consider it. [1] https://jobs.lever.co/descarteslabs.com/55bcc68b-f7ba-448f-bb02-033537547b33 https://jobs.lever.co/descarteslabs.com/55bcc68b-f7ba-448f-b...
- dhosek 7y agoI found this snapshot of traffic conditions in greater L.A. from Friday afternoon to be rather stunning. I've never seen so much green except during the night. https://www.motherjones.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/blog_405_traffic_map_2020_03_20.jpg?resize=990,638 https://www.motherjones.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/blog_...
- neonate 7y agohttps://archive.md/8zX7h https://archive.md/8zX7h
- twblalock 7y agoThis situation makes me more pessimistic about solving global climate change. The economic damage caused by "shelter in place" falls disproportionately on the poor and the lower middle class, who work in fields where working from home is not possible. Emission regulations and fuel taxes also fall disproportionately on the same people, because they can't afford newer cars which are more efficient. When the French government raised fuel taxes in order to ameliorate climate change, there were mass street protests. What started as a protest against fuel taxes developed into a widespread expression of grievance against inequality. We can expect a lot more of that if we do what it really takes to make a big impact on climate change. If climate policy is not balanced against economic inequality, there is a real risk that such anger will channel into support for populist political parties, who would roll back climate policy when elected.
- njarboe 7y agoI don't think people working in fields are being told to not go to work. Food production is critical work and is still allowed. It is the service industry (bars, restaurants, hotels, travel, sports, concerts, etc.) that is taking the hit, but it also has lots of low wage jobs. If a carbon tax was applied to whole countries and the funds collected given back as a per person dividend instead of going into the general budget, I think most people would support that. There are ways forward. We just have to support ways that work with the system we have instead of using climate change as a crisis to implement the utopian ideas of a few.
- twblalock 7y ago> I don't think people working in fields are being told to not go to work. I didn't mean literal field workers. I mean field as in "job field".
- tomp 7y agoThe answer is, obviously, combining climate policy with populism. Tax CO2 / fuel / packaging / consumption / transport as much as you want, but spend that tax money on a UBI-like benefit. That by definition helps lowest earners the most, plus makes sure the government doesn’t waste the money.
- evo_9 7y agoAfter this current crisis is contained the world governments should mandate a mandatory work-from-home 6 week period starting each new year. This would allow for an annual 'Earth Reset' and the effect of which might just be enough to turn things around, or hell, maybe even reverse course. It's remarkable how quickly nature has rebounded during all this.
- dzhiurgis 7y agoNow is a great timing to implement obvious decisions people were waiting for decades: - Close city centers for any traffic where possible (European downtowns are most suitable) - Close city centers for non-electric cars (and double subsidies for purchasing them) - Drastically expand bike lanes - Drastically expand public transport (e-buses obvs) - Ban sale/smoking of tobacco - Drastically raise taxes on animal products (after all they are the sources of so many pandemics) - Make contactless payments mandatory - Implement contactless sign-in (I was just asked to sign in KFC using a pent that's been sitting there for days) What else I am missing?
- naasking 7y agoThis pandemic is now a grand experiment on so many levels, social, political, medical, economic, environmental, and more. These events will be studied for decades to come, and it will shape policy for longer still. On the bright side, it will provide irrefutable evidence of anthropogenic climate change, and proof that drastic changes can produce immediate and drastic ecological improvements, and also the social and economic importance of vaccination. Hopefully science will be taken more seriously by the business minded that have been primarily driving policy. Then again, we didn't learn much from the last crisis, so maybe I shouldn't get my hopes up that we can make a lot of positive global changes from this disaster.
- birdyrooster 7y agohttps://web.archive.org/web/20200322052837/https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2020/03/22/climate/coronavirus-usa-traffic.html https://web.archive.org/web/20200322052837/https://www.nytim...