8 ms·
TSMC Details 5 nm
- jonplackett 7y agoI’m starting to (almost) feel sorry for Intel now.
- jokowueu 7y agoAnd 3nm planned for 2022 . They are moving at an incredible pace. They will definitely hit a wall soon at this speed
- baybal2 7y agoWhich is their plan, as many people believe. They want to drive the few competitors they have out of business quickly before that happens. Hence them accelerating node transitions in spite of not being able to recover as much RnD money as they can. Only really high margin products contend for <14nm node capacity, and nothing else. For as long as they maintain such high pace, and wide lead over competition, competitors get nothing, while still having to spend the same astronomical sums on fab retooling.
- api 7y agoWhere are they getting the money? Are they that profitable or state sponsored?
- Arnt 7y agoProfitable. Would be very profitable, if they had the income from their advanced processes without the R+D expense for those processes.
- AgloeDreams 7y agoThey produce the entirety of Apple's Ax chips and AMD's lineup, plus the latest Snapdragons. They are shipping many units per each Intel CPU shipping and offer things nobody else can offer. I imagine that makes them really profitable.
- ksec 7y ago> Are they that profitable or state sponsored? The world now ships ~1.2B Smartphone every year, most of them Fabbed on TSMC. That is Apple, Huawei, Qualcomm, Mediatek. These four along is likely 80%+ of the market. Along with Modem, WiFi and dozen of other smaller components. That is excluding BitCoin, ASIC, FPGA, Gaming GPU, GPGPU, Network Processors etc all these market have exploded in the past 10 years and requires leading edge Fab all coming from TSMC. ( Well at least most part of it ). The market is so much bigger than Intel's 200M+ PC market and Server Market in unit volume, TSMC has been able to benefit from it. And once you spread the R&D over a much larger volume of products, your unit cost economics drops. Hence benefiting everyone in the industry.
- mantap 7y agoSurely they know that USG would never let Intel go out of business? It's too important from defence perspective. And Samsung isn't going anywhere either.
- baybal2 7y agoIt only takes to blunt competition's resolve to make them drop from the race for the bleeding edge, and they will never close the gap again. They will have to throw staggering amount of cash to close the gap of multiple <14nm nodes, but there will be no Qualcomms, Apples and AMDs to pay them for that if they are few years late. In fact, even sub-40nm nodes are already a barren ground without much clients left. Those who still hang onto 22nm, 14nm only do legacy products, and they will inevitably move on, leaving 22 and 14 only fabs without much business. Both 22 and 14 still require extremely costly mask sets, high cycle times, and large MOQs. Need very different equipment from 40nm+. And they can't support analog, embedded flash, power, ulp devices as good as 40nm+, which makes them unattractive to microcontroller makers. For 99% of companies in semi industry, the scaling ended at 40nm. That's cold hard truth to it.
- GregarianChild 7y agoI imagine that a Chinese manufacturer will eventually also play a role, since it's a strategic priority for the PRC to be self sufficient in terms of semi-conductor production. The PRC (most probably) has the 'advantage' of a vast spy network in Taiwan, and (likely) in TSMC. Not to mention that salaries in China tend to be higher, leading to a brain-drain TW -> CN.
- bsder 7y agoEverybody in the business knows the secrets anyway. Institutional knowledge is the thing that is terribly difficult to transfer. Putting together a fab is money, money and more money combined with enough smart folks providing continuous effort to actually solve problems. It's the "solve problems" rather than "cover up problems" where China often breaks down. People forget that the US didn't just magically become a semiconductor powerhouse. It was thanks to VHSIC, the VLSI Project, and other initiatives--a multi-year concerted effort by all the US semiconductor industry and the US Federal Government--because they were terrified of (don't laugh now) the Japanese. DARPA gets all the press for the Internet, but the actual semiconductor technology that made the chips that powered the computers and equipment behind the Internet was probably far more important.
- philjohn 7y agoGF already bowed out ... only really Samsung and Intel left now, no?
- ksec 7y ago>They want to drive the few competitors they have out of business quickly before that happens. Hence them accelerating node transitions in spite of not being able to recover as much RnD money as they can. That is lots of accusation with little to no evidence. If you have read any of their investor note, meetings, They have been extremely conservative, and executing to perfection . They are profitable, and does not mind competing. Every single leading node they are charging more to their customers to recoup their R&D. Hence the theory why Moore's law will stop working once their customers can no longer afford leading node. There is nothing high pace about it, they are having a new node every two year, exactly as you would have expected from Intel. The only difference is Intel messed it up since 2015 / 2016. And now they are in the lead. Compared to Samsung which is basically funding their Foundry with NAND and DRAM Profits. I dont see how TSMC can be blamed for anything.
- baybal2 7y ago> There is nothing high pace about it, 16FFC - late 2016 12FF - Summer 2017 10FF - Late summer - autumn 2017 N7 - April 2018 N7+ (which is really like a standalone node) - Early 2019 N5 risk production - March-April 2019 N5 mass production - very likely first tapeouts were to take place in coming weeks if not for the virus. > If you have read any of their investor note, meetings, They have been extremely conservative, and executing to perfection Why do you privy somebody like investors to your most important strategies? While they were a company with reputation of squeezing out everything from a given node, they truly shifted focus to HPC and top of the cream orders now for sub-40nm market. Anything below 40nm other than the latest node is not getting anywhere near as much attention from them as when they were a "mainstream" fab. This is the most logical strategy now because there are very few companies in the whole world with money for sub-40nm tapeouts. It makes sense to keep these clients captive at all costs, to not to let competitors any part of this very small pie.
- ksec 7y ago>16FFC - late 2016...... 2012 28nm 2014 20nm 2016 16nm 2018 7nm 2020 5nm 2022 3nm* ( Non-GAA ) Every node is full 2 year cadence in accordance to their customer ( Lately Apple ) iPhone releases. 10nm is Pre 7nm, 12nm is 16nm's optimisation node. Nothing High pace about it. As they have been doing this prior to becoming a "leading" node manufacture.
- AntonStratiev 7y agoNot only that, but the population of Taiwan itself is shrinking and aging rapidly. The fertility rate is only 1.13. Eventually, there just won't be enough Taiwanese engineers left to continue development. High IQ is linked to lower fertility around the world (dysgenics) and average IQ is already declining in some Western countries, so it makes sense to develop high-tech products now, and ride the advantage for the rest of human civilisation.* *Until we accept and carry out human genetic engineering on a widespread basis and target high-IQ traits in engineered offspring.
- exikyut 7y ago> High IQ is linked to lower fertility around the world (dysgenics) Idiocracy really had a lot of things figured out a decade ago :(
- exikyut 7y ago(I'm not sure why, but the parent comment is currently at -3. I have decided to find this both ironically and non-ironically hilarious.)
- Arnt 7y agoWhy don't you graph TMSC's historical node sizes and forecast what their size will be when Taiwan's population shrinks to, say, 10m. Will it be below the size of a single electron already? Then look up RAA in Wikipedia and consider whether there might be anything wrong with your initial argument.
- alkonaut 7y agoGuess: declining iq is measurement issues or simply globalization (people move around). Fertility rates seem to do ok where there is an ambition to keep them up e.g with long tax funded parental leave. Taiwan seems like it’s got the “Japan sickness”.
- ksec 7y agoPlease Dont. They have plenty of cash, still the lead in IPC, (for now), Marketing Power to defend their position, long term contract and business relationship in Sever Market, and incentives to partners should AMD inches closer. For the first time Intel's new CFO finally admitted their 10nm wont be as profitable. But that doesn't mean they are not profitable as some media is trying to spin it. They expect WillowCove to be ~15% faster than their Icelake, speeding up ( cough ) their 7nm introduction in 2021. ( That is marketing speak for higher 7nm product volume launch ) and moving to 5nm GAA in ( late ) 2023, roughly a year earlier than TSMC 2nm GAA. Their 14nm+++ is the 2nd highest performance node to date ( I think highest performance honour goes to GF with their IBM / 14nm node ), and plenty of capacity coming up shortly. So while they may not be in node's leadership and likely wont regain that anytime soon. They are definitely capable to compete. If anything I felt sorry for AMD not getting higher Server Market Shares and higher Profits / Revenue. They have been working so hard and deserve a lot more.
- crakenzak 7y agoGame, set, match. it's over for Intel. They sat on their asses for too long and now are getting eaten by the previous underdogs. This shift is great news for literally everyone except Intel's execs' bonus packages.
- NicoJuicy 7y agoWasn't Intel planning to become a customer of TSMC?
- baybal2 7y agoIntel CEO was seen in Hsinchu last year. There could've been only one company for him to visit there.
- spectramax 7y agoI don't understand callous contempful comments against Intel's manufacturing capabilities. There are incredible people making things possible fomr both sides in one of the most advanced manufacturing processes in the world. I've worked inside a fab and I can tell you that the industry is much more appreciative of each other's competitors than the outside fanboys who are largely pissed off at the executive decisions (lawsuits , etc). This article is about TSMC's technical achievements and your comment has not added anything to the discussion, time and again I see this rooting for "underdog" behavior all too the same (just flipped the sides) from 2006. I wrote about it here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22515546 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22515546 If you'd like to know what goes into shriking a process node from lithography standpoint, I implore you to watch this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=f0gMdGrVteI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=f0gMdGrVteI and be in complete utter awe... Tell me if they are "Sitting on their asses"?
- yason 7y agoI don't understand callous contempful comments against Intel's manufacturing capabilities. There are incredible people making things possible fomr both sides in one of the most advanced manufacturing processes in the world. I've worked inside a fab and I can tell you that the industry is much more appreciative of each other's competitors than the outside fanboys Where did you read contemptful? The OP was merely stating a fact that Intel has lost the manufacturing race big time which is hard to refute given TSMC's progress. Sitting on their asses is just a illustrative way of saying that. It does not mean Intel people were stupid or they didn't appreciate their competing colleagues or that Intel would now be worthless. If anything it just makes more sense for a chip company to focus their efforts on designing chips and outsource manufacturing which basically is a separate business anyway -- unless they happen to have an edge also in that which Intel did have earlier.
- danaos 7y agoThe title is kind of misleading. > TSMC made every effort to avoid detailing the actual properties of that channel (every related question was met with the tautology: “those who know, know”). [...] We believe TSMC is employing a SiGe channel for the pMOS devices
- baybal2 7y agoThere is only one known high mobility material availing to easy integration with silicon MOS process None of InP, SiC, GaN, GaAs or other 3-5 materials been ever integrated with silicon in a fab setting for IC production. And only one material out there makes sense to use specifically for pMOS production: high hole mobility is much rarer trait than high electron mobility.
- grosswait 7y agoAnd that material is what?
- nicoburns 7y agoGermanium presumably, as that is the material that it is mentioned that they are using.
- madengr 7y agoIsn’t MACOMs process GaN on Si, which is cheaper, but lousy thermal performance compared to GaN on SiC. I thought they were touting GaN integration with CMOS?
- baybal2 7y agoGaN on Si is a thing from a completely different ballpark. Here we talk about material integration per-device basis, not entire wafer surface.
- exikyut 7y agoSounds like the details are still under NDA. Military contracts come to mind - conservatively long, too long, and sufficiently bureaucratically mired that the company's own announcement came before the red tape had properly moved out of the way. Or something.
- npunt 7y ago171.3 million transistors per mm^2 is mind boggling. Were Apple's A14 to have the same area as their A13 (98.48mm^2) and maintain that density throughout, you're looking at ~16+ billion transistors. Some comparisons: - Apple A13: 8.5 billion - Apple A12X: 10 billion (iPad Pro) - Nvidia Titan RTX: 18.6 billion I wonder what kind of use cases are unlocked with 16 billion transistors in your pocket. This node might be the one that gets us to AR.
- jp555 7y agoThere is no Moore's Law in optics & batteries. The AR everyone imagines is much further away than most realize.
- solinent 7y ago> There is no Moore's Law in optics & batteries. Our optics are already quite good, I don't think we need higher resolution cameras, just higher-speed cameras. I don't think this is impossible, we just don't have the processing power to deal with them yet. For batteries, we already have some hope with the solid-state batteries of Goodenough. We would still need more compute than this I believe, but this should get us close.
- npunt 7y agoAR's optics limitation is not cameras, it's the display. That's a tough optics challenge because you have to block incoming light (very hard) and display the data very close to the eye (hard) in a form factor that is appealing (very hard).
- nitrogen 7y agoIf you had an extremely low latency lightfield display and camera that allowed the eye to do the focusing then you could skip the light blocking part (not that that makes the optics challenge easier).
- 7y ago
- exikyut 7y ago> Our current estimates remain at 48 nm poly pitch and 30 nm metal pitch. Those dimensions yield an estimated device density of 171.3 MTr/mm². I just sized up 1mm between my fingers. Um. WOW. Really. Wow.
- raverbashing 7y agoFor reference a 64-bit Pentium 4 core was (drum roll) 125Million transistors. And it was 100x bigger (112mm^2)
- exikyut 7y agoWow at that too. To be honest, one of the things I was considering when posting the GP was the sheer impossibility of leveling anything more precise than hand-wavy, drunk opinions about the end-to-end security state of that much, well, entropy. It's gotten almost like a bizarre version of inverted quicksand, where instead of it being bad because you're sinking into sand, it's bad because the sand is shrinking into nothingness from between your fingers. The next few years are going to be VERY interesting, I think. IIUC, OOo and branch prediction have kind of been the CPU engineering meal ticket workaround to "solving" the memory latency problem (IIUC), and now everyone apparently has to rethink that. My favorite would be the "disappearance" of the A20 line though. As in, it's there, it's doing it's thing, but everyone collectively forgot it existed, and now everybody needs a microcode update and an SGX cert respin AGAIN. And all this without access to specialized tooling (the kind that evolves over a decade, regardless of knowledge), AND the fact that we're (apparently?) only forgetting about (seemingly?) little things at this point. Haha...ha...
- Symmetry 7y agoThe thing that really jumped out at me was making the channel partially out of germanium. Velocity saturation has been a limiting factor in our tiny modern transistors for a while, playing its own minor part in the breakdown of Dennard scaling. The article didn't say if the increase applied equally to both electron mobility and hole mobility. Germanium tends to be better for both but I my materials science background isn't good enough for me to guess what it'll be in a Silicon/Germanium lattice. Temperature dependence is also an equally interesting question since Germanium tends to deal with high temperatures a bit better. This won't help with leakage issues or the increasing importance of wire as opposed to transistor capacitance. But it does look like a nice little win. Speaking of wires, is TSMC still using straight copper or are they thinking of incorporating cobalt? Or did Intel's experience with that scare them off? EDIT: And speaking of cobalt again, I really hope they aren't being too ambitious with this and that being too innovative doesn't bit them the way it did with Intel at 10nm. Though the rumor mill isn't sure if it was the cobalt wires or the Contact Over Active Gate (COAG) that was their main problem.
- baybal2 7y ago> The article didn't say if the increase applied equally to both electron mobility and hole mobility. Electron mobility is not high in silicon, but it has never been a "blocker" before. In fact, the utilisation of strained silicon has gone down from 40nm in later nodes. Silicon however has truly terrible hole mobility, and the wider industry has just started to realise that they have lost many years to fruitless pursuit of high electron mobility, when the real blocker has always been a pFET. It was very prudent of TSMC to quietly continue pFET RnD, despite industry's fixation of HEMTs and 3-5 devices. p.s. 5N is a COAG process from what they have just said.
- brennanpeterson 7y agoThe amount of Ge and thus strain has increased every node. All to make hole mobility better. No one in industry was confused about HEMTs, and the needs of pfets were well known.
- 7y ago
- jl6 7y agoOn the other hand, I keep hearing people saying than nm is increasingly just a marketing number - and indeed, for all of Intel’s difficulties I don’t see too many chips beating Intel in single-threaded performance. I say this as someone who bought a Ryzen-based system last year after significant research.
- gameswithgo 7y agothe transistors are actually getting smaller, that just doesn’t lead to more clock rate any more
- navaati 7y agoBut less heat, which allows you to cram more stuff in a package, which is a win !
- lonelappde 7y agoBut nm isn't measuring transistor sie. nm refers to size of an ambiguous "feature".
- jdietrich 7y agoIntel's advantage is architectural, not process. That architectural advantage has started to look extremely shaky after Meltdown/Spectre/Spoiler/etc - Intel gained a lot of performance through speculative execution at the cost of correctness.
- unlinked_dll 7y agoThis is purely speculative but based on my own experience. I firmly believe that real world performance is bottlenecked by cache before the slight difference in OoE/pipelines/speculation between Intel and AMD's CPUs. And the metric I really care about is the time it takes to read a cache line and the cache miss penalty. Those two fundamental pieces of the system are the ultimate bottleneck that developers can't deal with. It's really easy to construct cases where one CPU beats another in either single or multithreaded performance. The hard thing to make a judgement on is how it looks in real world software, and the more cumulative benchmarks are more telling of the quality of the software you bench other than the CPU. Particularly because optimizing for cache is so difficult. It's trivial to hit the memory wall and decide that's it, but it's really hard to decide that your entire architecture was flawed, choice of language was wrong, choice of algorithm or data structure was wrong, etc, A/B two different implementations and pick one that's slightly faster. The ROI isn't there. There's a philosophical point here though about the nature of "better" as it applies to the real world that makes my belief moot, because even if I'm right it when X% of software that people use runs Y% faster on a particular architecture it doesn't matter if it's because developers wrote and benched their code on that architecture. It's still "better." All that said, I'm very happy with my Zen2 purchase.
- georgeburdell 7y agoAnd Intel is now headed by someone with a 100% finance/business background. Intel is nipping at the heels of Boeing. Tens of billions of dollars in dividends and stock buybacks announced that should be going to saving their (and by proxy, the U.S.'s) manufacturing capability.
- gameswithgo 7y agothey have jim keller though
- sq_ 7y agoTrue, but it seems to me that he's been most successful at companies that are willing to place big bets on his team and put a lot of institutional weight behind him. His work at Apple, AMD, and Tesla all seem to point towards that conclusion. One wonders if an Intel that's less focused on hardware innovation will see the same effects.
- magicalhippo 7y agoI remember reading a lot about a "brick wall" when they pushed towards EUV, how challenging it would be to reduce feature size further etc etc. But it seems they're moving along just fine. What happened?
- sytelus 7y agoTo put it into perspective, Coronavirus would just fit in 25 transistors long at this scale! However, to be fair, it has 30 kilobases where each base is 2.5nm X 0.3nm. So we still have some way to go...