14 ms·
There are a lot of things about this pandemic that have left me depressed. But the fact that as the world's richest country, we don't even have the administrat
by crazygringo 7y ago
There are a lot of things about this pandemic that have left me depressed.
But the fact that as the world's richest country, we don't even have the administrative ability to keep a national emergency stockpile of essential medical supplies like face masks to get to hospitals immediately is just... I can't even.
By sheer coincidence, I happened to spend a week in Mexico City the day swine flu hit it, a decade ago. For the next several days, there were policemen everywhere distributing masks to the public. Instant response, zero shortage.
I am genuinely curious what the root cause is here, if you did a "five whys" analysis. Not a knee-jerk thing, but the real answer.
Is it that political squabbling has left things unfunded? Unappointed administrators have left things undone, unmaintained, or backlogged? Was it a conscious decision to decentralize and expect each hospital to be responsible for maintaining its own emergency supply? A belief that supply chains would handle it and stockpiling not needed? Is there a stockpile somewhere that isn't being released?
I'm really looking forward to a newspaper exposé on this one, because it's a true scandal.
- esyir 7y agoThe US had a stockpile, but it was for bioterrorism scale and not pandemic scale.
- gojomo 7y agoWhy would "bioterrorism scale" & "pandemic scale" be different, especially if a bioterror agent was crafted to be contagious (& thus create pandemic conditions)?
- marcosdumay 7y agoJust to add, but why would a bioterror agent not be crafted to be contagious? Spread is the big differential on bioterror, and most other forms of terrorism do not require a team with members that have 2 PHDs each.
- smacktoward 7y agoA bioterrorist cell would not have the resources to craft a perfectly engineered biological weapon. They'd be more likely to have access to limited quantities of some pre-existing biological agent (like anthrax, say). So what you'd see in that scenario is attacks that cause a bunch of casualties in a few locations in one big splash, and then quickly peter out after that. It's like, what's the difference between a terrorist nuclear attack and a full-scale nuclear war? In the former scenario, you're talking a small number of low-yield devices triggered in one country; the rest of the world still stands able to provide assistance. In the latter scenario, there's nobody left to help who hasn't also been blown to ashes.
- dillonmckay 7y agoI think you would re-evaluate this reasoning after watching the show ‘Jericho’. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jericho_(2006_TV_series) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jericho_(2006_TV_series)
- RegnisGnaw 7y agoOntario (Canada) stockpiled a lot after the whole SARS thing. Unfortunately they never planned rotating the supply or budgeted for it. So out of the 55 million masks we stocked, 80% have expired. https://www.reuters.com/article/us-health-coronavirus-canada-supplies-ex/exclusive-millions-of-masks-stockpiled-in-canadas-ontario-expired-before-coronavirus-hit-idUSKBN20W2OG https://www.reuters.com/article/us-health-coronavirus-canada...
- pjkundert 7y agoI'm certain the people unnecessarily infected with Covid-19 will be glad, as they pass away, that the cough that killed them wasn't suppressed by an out-of-date mask.
- bdamm 7y ago"Expired" might mean that the mask material has disintegrated and could itself be sucked into the lungs. Or perhaps it means that fungal infections could have grown in the masks. Or maybe the government really made a decision based on short term thinking and tossed the masks to make room for piles of salt or something. Or maybe the cost of storing masks really isn't worth it because there's lots of things that can decimate society (nuclear war?) and we needed to more urgently spend money there. Who knows, right?
- spectramax 7y agoAlong those lines, Meltblown fabric used in N95 respirators is made from plastic by some incredibly high tech machines. Each costing $5m per machine (line): https://www.reicofil.com/en/pages/meltblown_lines https://www.reicofil.com/en/pages/meltblown_lines You’re absolutely right. When a mask is expired, it should not be used. There is a reason for the expiration date and it’s not just for profiteering or some malicious motive. Lot of expiration dates you see in medicines is FDA regulated and should be taken seriously.
- gojomo 7y ago
- mikeyouse 7y agoUnfortunately putting incompetent people in charge of the Federal government has had predictable results -- We don't have enough masks (they're sending 1/10th the number that states are requesting) and the majority of the stockpiled gear is expired: https://twitter.com/hshaban/status/1240114213009358852 https://twitter.com/hshaban/status/1240114213009358852
- rlt 7y agoIn case you're suggesting the current administration is entirely at fault, the mask stockpile was depleted in 2009 and never replenished https://www.washingtonpost.com/investigations/face-masks-in-national-stockpile-have-not-been-substantially-replenished-since-2009/2020/03/10/57e57316-60c9-11ea-8baf-519cedb6ccd9_story.html https://www.washingtonpost.com/investigations/face-masks-in-...
- dchyrdvh 7y agoIsn't the reason obvious? Healthcare in the US is an insanely profitable and powerful business. If everybody gets infected, tens of millions will need expensive treatment the rest of their lives. Healthcare will make tens of trillions dollars. Remember the anecdote that there are no laws that big capital wouldn't break for the 3x profit? Here we are talking about profits comparable with the entire world's wealth. We have an opportunity to witness this sociopathic system in its nature state: the virus needs 1-2 months to spread everywhere and during this short period, the healthcare system is going to openly block any attempts to prevent its spread. After that it's going to open the gates and let the tests, masks and vaccines flood the market.
- scrollaway 7y agoThere aren't "tens of trillions of dollars" people can spend on healthcare. Making everyone sick collapses the economy, and these companies would be negatively impacted by it. Face masks are running out in many countries, not just the US. This isn't really a product of the atrocious healthcare system the US has, it's just a product of not being well-prepared for disaster scenarios. Think about how most companies don't check whether their backups work. Now, replace "working backups" with "stocked-up pandemic supplies".
- dchyrdvh 7y agoI'm not going to argue. We only need to wait for 2 months to see who's right.
- scrollaway 7y agoYou don't need to wait to do some basic logic checking on your post. You said it yourself: "Here we are talking about profits comparable with the entire world's wealth". What do you exactly think is going to happen if americans try to spend "the entire world's wealth" on health care? I don't believe your implications but even I could make a more convincing case for them than that.
- kevin_thibedeau 7y agoWe had to be certain no facemasks would be used for abortions. Once that top priority is met the coffers will flow.
- tomcam 7y agoCould you elaborate?
- JohnTHaller 7y agoThe GOP held up one of the bills to ensure that language to ban federal funding of abortions was added. Even though that is already in effect.
- ghostpepper 7y agoOne of the N95 respirator stockpiling bills?
- maxerickson 7y agoPretty much, a big portion of the country (not just the predatory elements of the GOP) sees corrupting government for personal gain as quite the sport, and people generally don't think they are doing it. Like how the fuck does any serious person vote to approve Betsy Devos as Secretary of Education. Even for an ardent believer in privatization of grade school education it's ridiculous. Yes, I'm calling almost the entire GOP membership of the Senate predatory. Fight me. I'm not saying it's limited to them.
- spectramax 7y agoYou might get flagged for flame war comment, despite of making too much sense. I’m with you. There are certain things that I, too, want to rant about but we’ve created a soft spoken courteous society where falsehood and mediocrity prevails - some of it essential for us to be able to have free speech but sigh... there are so many things in the world that are profoundly fucked up. My guess for blaming all of this is on education. Uneducated or poorly educated people do not set a good course for the country to propel into the future.
- perilunar 7y ago> we’ve created a soft spoken courteous society From outside the USA it appears to be anything but.
- tjohns 7y agoFrom what I read, it seems there was a cache of N95 respirators in the Strategic National Stockpile. However, it was depleted during the 2009 H1N1 outbreak and never replenished. Instead, their budget was used for what they thought were more pressing concerns at the time — stockpiling drugs/equipment for other emerging diseases. Source: https://www.washingtonpost.com/investigations/face-masks-in-national-stockpile-have-not-been-substantially-replenished-since-2009/2020/03/10/57e57316-60c9-11ea-8baf-519cedb6ccd9_story.html https://www.washingtonpost.com/investigations/face-masks-in-...
- mirimir 7y agoWith a larger budget, they could have done both. And why was their budget so limited?
- Rebelgecko 7y agoProbably in part due to the 2012 sequester
- mirimir 7y agoMore generally, the Budget Control Act of 2011.
- tzfld 7y agoHow much of a budget would you need to stockpile like 10 million masks? I don't think it is a cost problem.
- mirimir 7y agoNo, it's not a cost issue. But I suspect that it was a consequence of meeting fixed cost reduction targets, and being something where cutting had no immediate impact.
- shard972 7y agoYou won't find an easy answer and that is the point of liberalism. Divy up the responsibility of absolute power so that nobody really knows who to blame.
- mirimir 7y agoI suspect that federal stockpiles of medical supplies were sacrificed to give money to the wealthy. Likely because there was no constituency for them. Edit: So how are stockpiles of masks somehow not part of downsizing the federal government?
- briandear 7y agoStockpiles weren’t replenished under the Obama admin. Unless he passed a tax cut I missed, you can blame him for the de-prioritization of mask stockpiles. Let’s not forget the CDC has been working on “diseases” such as gun violence and climate change. They should have stuck to their core competency of infectious diseases.
- grugagag 7y agoWe’re almost 80% into Trump’s term. Why blame Obama for it? What stopped Trump from doing the right thing? His poor tweeting habit? Let’s face it, this administration is ill prepared for such an event. This will cost them dearly in November.
- jfim 7y ago> Let’s face it, this administration is ill prepared for such an event. This will cost them dearly in November. That still remains to be seen. Right now the states with the most cases (CA, WA, NY, see [0]) are firmly Democrat, with much fewer cases in Republican and swing states. It's possible that the number of cases in those states won't rise to critical numbers, and thus have limited effect on his reelection odds. [0] https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/cases-updates/cases-in-us.html https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/cases-updates/case...
- pacman83 7y agoMost urban counties are blue. Cannot blame Dems for infectious disease based on density of cases.
- mindslight 7y agoPrivatization means surplus gets extracted to investors, rather than saved for good times. Pervasive managerial culture causes oversight to become opaque, phrasing it in terms of vague financials instead of specific structure by domain experts. Economic annealing makes margins thinner and thinner ("cost cutting"), leaving no slack for any change in conditions. These trends are happening to individual private institutions, as well as at the government level. Stockpiling masks is impossible if it's no longer in your vocabulary. As soon as a metric becomes a target, it ceases to be a good metric. The market is a large part of our national religion, appointing metrics supreme in a circular fashion.
- x0x0 7y agoIsn't it stunning that even three months ago, no one in the federal disaster preparation programs thought about supply chains for masks? I simply don't know how to process the news that we both waste $1 trillion dollars per year on our military, and we haven't built a $5m (or hell, $50m) machine that can allow us to totally source N95 masks from the raw materials up. Does Walmart seriously think more deeply about supply chains than our disaster prep and military?
- globular-toast 7y ago> But the fact that as the world's richest country... It's at times like these you should question whether it really is the "world's richest country". I'm sure you can find certain metrics where it is, but that's irrelevant if the country is unable to respond to disasters like a hurricane or an epidemic.
- tinus_hn 7y agoIn the news it was said that normal procedures require about 30 masks per IC patient per day. That’s a lot of masks to stockpile and even then it wouldn’t last too long. Still difficult to understand how in Japan everyone wears these masks every day and in the West they can’t be produced.
- malandrew 7y agoThe strategic stockpile shouldn't just be masks. It should also be an assembly line to make more masks should the stockpile run out.