7 ms·
Mass amateurization
- ipython 7y agoI have to confess, the first time I heard about Wikipedia I was skeptical that such a thing could thrive. However this article pits institutions against the idea of “mass amateurization” when in fact I think the major reason Wikipedia has succeeded is because of institutions and process put in place to keep the community moderated and in check. For more information listen to the excellent podcast episode of “how I built this” featuring jimmy wales. [0] [0] https://www.stitcher.com/podcast/national-public-radio/how-i-built-this/e/53468668 https://www.stitcher.com/podcast/national-public-radio/how-i...
- thristian 7y agoI don't think "mass amateurization" and "institutions" are opposed. Traditionally you needed major institutional support to set up, say, a TV channel; today you can get a YouTube channel for free. If you start a YouTube channel and it gets successful you can certainly set up institutions and processes to keep it successful, but those things aren't necessary to get started.
- simonh 7y agoAnd of course Youtube itself is an institution. There was an article here about a library built in Minecraft by volunteers to bypass censorship, but Microsoft is an institution. As you say these are not opposed, they are just different relationships between creators and distributors.
- raxxorrax 7y agoI think I disagree. The reason Wikipedia worked is because of random contributors interested in sharing the knowledge. The classic form on the other hand is getting less engagement as you see with encyclopedias. You need moderation on charged topics and the results aren't that impressive. Sure, there might be vandals, but they focus on the buzzing topics, for which Wikipedia might not be the correct platform. Articles that require intervention do mostly regress to the lowest common denominator. Only minimal content on different perspectives because it would inflame more bickering. I think a system that just slows down contribution and forces people to settle emotions would be more effective. Because moderation intervention will not be accepted by many people if it doesn't cater to their point of view. As for institutions to regulate content, the negative outweighs the positive on most cases. Wikipedia is successful because of its lack of central authority. The early strategy to just flag an article as controversial was the best way in my opinion. Because it informs the reader.
- msla 7y ago> The early strategy to just flag an article as controversial was the best way in my opinion. Because it informs the reader. It informs the reader that someone thinks the information is controversial. Well, whoopty-shit. Some people think evolution is a myth. Some people think the existence of trans people is a myth. Some people think the existence of disease-causing bacteria is a myth. Those topics are all, therefore, controversial, in that someone would flag the article for being such simply because it presented the reality-based view on those subjects as being real. If there's one thing the history of all humanity teaches us, it's that there are people willing to screech idiocy at reality until they fall down dead; they're wrong, they can be shown to be wrong, but they'll never admit they're wrong so trying to compromise with them is futile. That's why Wikipedia's NPOV policy is biased in favor of the scientific consensus, and why tags based on bullshit and nothing aren't allowed to stay on articles.
- raxxorrax 7y agoHistory tells me that authority creates facts far more often than scientific consensus and reality better conforms. We certainly had different teachers. These "idiots" as you call them are just not relevant. Their main advantage is not their ideas that have difficulties on their own. It is the animosity from people humping their legs that many other people avert their eyes in shame. The encyclopedia is dead and community resources are evidently the future. Fact checking has become a bit more important but I don't see the advantage in creating any authority that will fail at some point again. My criticism wasn't directed at articles about evolution, it was directed at political hot-button topics, which are notoriously bad on Wikipedia. To which degree that is the fault of users or moderators, I cannot say. Doesn't matter, because reading them isn't that much important anyway.
- mlthoughts2018 7y agoThis kind of reminds me of Joel Spolsky’s business principle “commoditize your complement.” It’s a benefit to a hosting & streaming platform, like YouTube, if the content is amateur, commodity and mass produced, since they dominate the complement (the infrastructure to host, serve and administer traffic to it). It’s great for automakers if roads are cheap and ubiquitous.
- ImaCake 7y agoIt occurs to me that there is a whole supply chain of these companies for youtubers and podcasters. Firstly, the content creator uses one (or many) of a selection of traditional and web-based tools to produce content not possible three decades ago, then youtube, or a syndication service, gets your content in the right places, there it is discovered by users, the content creator is then rewarded with ad revenue, subscribers through patreon, or through sales of merch through yet another platform. Even as someone who mostly consumes this kind of content rather than creating it, I feel I benefit massively from this complex of buisnesses and tools. The web is a vibrant and encouraging place so long as you look past some of its worst festering piles of madness.
- quickthrower2 7y agoThe video creators should do the same and commod their comps! Don’t stick to YouTube. Distribute wide. Reuse parts of your udemy course on vimeo. Brand yourself and build a list of followers by email, Twitter etc.
- zxcmx 7y agoInteresting that open source software is not discussed, it seems like one of the most radically successful embodiments of this.
- amelius 7y agoLots of open source is paid for, or at least the developers have real jobs as developers, and therefore they shouldn't be called amateurs.
- Nasrudith 7y agoIt arguably still counts as amateurized though not because of the participants but because it does away with the hierarchy and credibility. Nobody really cares if the software writer is a Harvard or MIT professor in full academic dress or it was written in their mom's basement by a guy not wearing pants.
- themodelplumber 7y agoI wonder if Mass Amateurization (Swype fail, tap tap tap) has furthered the obsolescence of terms like "citizen science," (the term may no longer be as special as it once was, since it happens all the time thanks to Amateurization) or made those terms more relevant (can we somehow improve on Amateurization with an eye to the strengths of existing citizen science community institutions?). Either way, one of its strengths seems to be helping science & tech when institutions may otherwise lack resources: > There is no institutional hierarchy in mass amateurization. There is only an informal group of collaborators working to solve a problem. Due to mass amateurization, amateurs are able to collaborate without the interference from the inherent obstacles associated with institutions. These obstacles include the costs that an institution incurs while educating, training, directing, coaching, advising, and organizing its members.
- profmonocle 7y agoThis is my favorite thing to come from the Internet. A lot of my entertainment comes from YouTube channels or podcasts whose audiences are way too small for them to be viable on TV or radio.
- matheusmoreira 7y agoSome activities lend themselves well to amateurization. It's hard to imagine a world where people need a professional license to write computer programs or publish articles. Not all professions are this accessible though. Perhaps amateurization is correlated with benign consequences for being wrong. We don't see amateur engineers, doctors, lawyers...
- TheUndead96 7y agoThis is the exact point that I believe is understated. The gig economy is pure supply-and-demand. Customers are saying that they do not need a professional hotel or taxi service. The historic prestige of these services is predicated on the fact that before the internet there was no better way to connect customers and service providers. If there was a tier below Economy on planes, people would use it. This is because there will always be a portion of the population (maybe even a majority) who strictly only care about the service rendered and the outcome achieved.
- mellavora 7y agoWell, there are factors like health and safety risk in these industries. The gig economy works because these costs are ignored. How many Uber drivers have commercial insurance? If they don't have commercial insurance, does their insurance company cover the damages (including medical bills of passengers) in the case of an accident while the vehicle is in commercial use? Or, what is the Air BnB host's personal liability in the case that Air BnB requires hosts to refund bookings cancelled due to COVID? A hotel is a corporation, as an Air-BnB host do you have similar limitation on personal financial liability? The gig economy is supply-and-demand combined with dodging regulatory costs. Which is great until you run into the situation the regulation is designed to protect against.
- clairity 7y agoamateur engineers are abundant across garages in the US. everyone is an amateur doctor, especially parents and any caregiver. and you can certainly represent yourself in court without a lawyer. i'd even go so far as to argue law to be the least "technical" profession (in the sense of having specialized knowledge) of those options--you mainly need to know how to construct a good argument and deconstruct bad ones (most law education seems to be learning a canon of past cases and rationales so you'd be better prepared for that. and writing a lot.).
- rijoja 7y agoWouldn't an amateur by definition be unpaid meaning that an Airbnb host really has nothing to do on this list. People seem to misstake being an amateur with being subpar which would be far from the truth. Famous tennis player Björn Borg won 5 Wimbledon as an amateur for example since being paid at that time would've been forbidden.
- michaelt 7y agoIn common use, the way 'professional' is used seems to vary heavily. Is someone who makes a hundred bucks a month streaming on Twitch a professional gamer? What about someone starting their own architecture business, which is currently unprofitable? Is the shop assistant who does all the cake decoration a professional cake decorator, despite having many other duties? Do state regulation and professional bodies come into it, and if so what happens in jobs without professional bodies? Is an accountant who works 2 days a week and is a stay-at-home parent 3 days a week different from a dancer who works 4 months a year as a dancer, and 8 months a year as a shop assistant?
- d-d 7y agoRandom guys on YouTube have saved me at least a dozen trips to the car repair shop; but there's all that noise I gotta sift through. Good luck and Godspeed sorting through all the quackery if you ever come down with a rare health issue. There are so many junior-whatevers that flat out shouldn't be putting out content for anyone anywhere; much less the internet. It's a double edged sword.
- weavie 7y agoOveranxious patients coming into hospital thinking they have some horrendous terminal disease because they googled their symptoms is a well known phenomena.
- toyg 7y agoMaybe some topics should simply be legislated away as incompatible with “youtubery”: health and history, imho. Forbidding those would remove 90% of the problematic content (quacks, antivaxx, holocaust deniers, truthers etc). Health has specific laws to deal with digital storage, it’s not inconceivable to admit that it needs extra protection on social platforms too.
- HeyLaughingBoy 7y agosimply be legislated away This is one of the most dangerous phrases I've read in a long time.
- toyg 7y agoGermany and Italy have had bans on specific material since 1946 and the sky has not fallen. I understand the concern, but the ban doesn’t need to cover all media, only the ones that are extremely accessible. A bit like pornography is forbidden on mainstream tv during the day, but you can still buy it freely elsewhere at all times.
- HeyLaughingBoy 7y agoIt's not about the specifics about your comment. It's a concern based on using the words "simply" and "legislated" in the same sentence. I'm of the belief that legislation is not something to be entered into lightly and should generally be considered a last resort if better solutions don't exist.
- jonathanstrange 7y agoThis term is new to me, and I find it funny that basically the same phenomenon was called "crowd wisdom" ten years ago.
- Nasrudith 7y agoI thought crowd wisdom had more of an "exploratory value" to it in that the discovered obviously knew about it first but the discoverer was the one who got credited.
- Damogran6 7y agoWhen everybody can do the thing, the thing becomes less valuable...Case in point: We watch RV content on Youtube. There's a half dozen publishers with truly compelling content, and 100 more with polished video, trying to self-support their RV hobby through Youtube. Likewise, the amount of music on Youtube is boundless, because everyone with a Mac has a sound studio, for free. makeing the amount of revenue each person is potentially worth...less. This isn't good or bad, it just is. There's 10,000 people making Hundreds instead of 10 or 100 people making millions.