31 ms·
Koenigsegg’s 2.0-liter no-camshaft engine makes 600 horsepower
- gh123man 7y agoIt's even more impressive that this is only a three-cylinder engine. It is super exciting to see Freevalve in a production car (even though it is generally unobtainable for the vast majority of people). I have high hopes that this tech will be licensed out and used in more affordable ICE cars.
- yummypaint 7y agoYeah it seems like the tech could be used to target efficiency instead of performance and perhaps improve the small engines in hybrid cars.
- JanSolo 7y agoIt's interesting that in naturally aspirated mode, the engine creates around 280hp. That's right around what SUVs and Crossovers are currently producing. This engine has a real potential to be a game-changer; if the freevalve tech can be made cheap enough and reliable enough for mass production, it could really improve average efficiency and emissions for a large number of cars. Great Tech!
- ehnto 7y agoThe turbocharged peak power was said to come at 7500rpm, with peak torque of 443lb at 3000rpm which is pretty good! I would expect NA torque to be somewhere in the mid 200lb region, which is comparable to the 2020 Nissan Pathfinder in both V6 and I4 petrol variants. The I4 Turbo diesel obviously putting out far more torque at lower RPM making it more usable. But there is no doubt that Koenigsegg has made a huge leap here. The only missing datapoint is reliability. How aggresive is the tuning on the engine to get these numbers and does that effect it's long term robustness?
- kingkongjaffa 7y agoJust look at the cars they currently make. Highly tuned supercars not economical commuter vehicles. skeptical tech from one will transfer to the other. I used to work for a supercar company, our unit price made certain tech possible, not even thinkable for mass-auto.
- ehnto 7y agoYou're right, I wouldn't expect this level of performance from a commuter car with similar displacement. That said, Hyundai recently developed their Continuously Variable Valve Duration system, which looks to solve changing valve duration more affordably in an all mechanical system.
- ska 7y agoThere are a few of these valve systems around (if i recall correctly they've been around for decades, really). BMW started putting them in motorcycles recently.
- ehnto 7y agoYou might be thinking of VVT or variable valve timing, which changes when the valve opens. Variable valve duration changes for how long it opens for and I think is a recent innovation. The latter allows for more efficiency as the engine at different speeds and loads requires more or less lift duration. It's also continuously variable across the RPM/load table, wheras most VVT systems just swap between two different activation timings and as such are always a compromise somewhere in the range. I have also seen a system that swaps between two different cam lobes entirely, offering two different cam profiles which can also vary valve duration and not just timing, but you're limited to two settings again, where these newer systems offer complete variability.
- ska 7y agoNo, these are not VVT. I might be misremembering, but I thought the new bmw system was dual cam - so exactly what you are suggesting, a trade off in the middle, but not vvt. At any rate, variable cam systems in bikes have certainly been around since the early 80s with one of the 400c cbrs. They never really caught on but there are a bunch of variations.
- kingkongjaffa 7y agoIs the cost of the old parts being replaced more than the new ones in terms of the technologies being used? Mechanical cams are going to be more reliable than a pnuematic system. maintenance is going to be much different than the other 99.9% of cars that use a timing belt/chain. Skeptical that the incumbents like Bosch wouldn't have already tried this in some form they have the OEM EMS / fuel rail industry major market share. As with all things mass-auto it's down to unit price economics vs how desperately do we need to put this in the cars to meet emissions regs.
- busterarm 7y agoRenault was racing camless engines with pneumatic actuators in Formula 1 in the 80s. This tech has a long history and research behind it.
- eanzenberg 7y agoRacing engines last ~1000mi
- vvillena 7y agoNot anymore. F1 cars use just 3 engines for the whole season. Lots of other categories use one single engine per seasone. The "one engine per event" era is long gone.
- DagAgren 7y agoInternal combustion is over. There's no future to be improved in it, it's going away. We simply can't afford to use it any more, and it is being phased out.
- vardump 7y agoYou're right, but for wrong reasons. Internal combustion engines will go away, because electric vehicles' cost curve will destroy them. IIRC, batteries get 13% cheaper per year, and that means price halves every 5 years or so. Right now 1 kWh of batteries (including BMS) costs about $100. So in 2025 one kWh of batteries will probably cost only $50. Electric vehicles purchase price will simply be cheaper unless ICE vehicles get subsidies. At that point, for economical consideration you'll need to have pretty compelling reasons to buy an ICE vehicle. Ultimately even gas station network will be decimated and gradually fade away.
- busterarm 7y agoThere are still areas where ICE will dominate simply because batteries aren't practical or economical, despite being a cheaper fuel. Extreme environments, heavy machinery, etc. ICE are never going away.
- DagAgren 7y agoAnd?
- busterarm 7y agoAnd I directly refuted your argument and this is all you have to say. I didn't even get into the laughable aspect of how 1/7th of the planet's population still lives _without electricity_. There's countries that do have electricity where their energy infrastructure and access is unstable (e.g., Moldova). Most of those places can get some burnable fuel, but I'm sure they'd just love your argument that batteries will soon be the only game in town. The idea of ICE being a technological dead end is a spoiled person's fantasy.
- forkexec 7y agoFreevalve is awesome. https://www.freevalve.com https://www.freevalve.com
- jotm 7y agoLooks amazing, I guess it simply wasn't possible (or extremely difficult and expensive) to create something like this before the advent of miniature+powerful computing. I wonder how else can ICE's be improved with more onboard processing power
- calvinmorrison 7y agoProbably totally possible with late 80s tech in ECUs. They already had dynamic spark retardation and fuel maps that changed based on rpm/speed/other factors. Freevalve to me is another natural step after that. We already see dynamic valve timing with VVT and the like. Now it's just infinitly variable. Another benefit is that you are able to tune at all RPMs and produce more horse with less power. I love it
- tibbon 7y agoI just got a Boxster, and while the engine in it is amazing, this would be a hell of a swap (not at all easy, perhaps next to impossible, but the idea of a 600hp engine that actually fits in the Boxster... whoa). Edit: I knew their cars were expensive, but it seems Koenigsegg cars start around 2mm and up to to 10mm? I'm gonna guess that there's zero chance of just buying an engine for $10k and throwing it in another car like an LS swap
- darksaints 7y agoYou could always do something like this, which definitely could fit in a boxster. https://emrax.com/e-motors/emrax-348/ https://emrax.com/e-motors/emrax-348/
- jacquesm 7y agoPancake axial flux is a really compact and powerful combination. If they ever get them weighing so little that they could be unsprung weight there will be a revolution in drive trains.
- sudosysgen 7y agoI think given the focus on ethanol and their request for partners they want this to be a mass market product
- leetcrew 7y agoyou would have to upgrade a lot of other parts in a boxster for it to be able to handle 600hp.
- djrogers 7y agoNot really - the Boxster Spyder and Cayman GT4 variants are already in the 400s, and use transmissions capable of much much more than that (as seen in other Porsche vehicles).
- trhway 7y ago>AI engine management software for Freevalve engines like the TFG. "The system will learn over time the best ways to operate the valves, what's most frugal, what's cleanest… It will eventually start doing things we’ve never thought of," Koenigsegg says. "It'll float in and out of different ways of combusting by itself, eventually in ways not completely understandable to us." sounds like the blue-collar jobs of the future like car engine mechanic would need a Stanford AI degree. Camshafts definitely got to go. Like carburetors it has been a solution from pre-electronic age. The variable timing has been a workaround for the last 3 decades, it is kind of a complication on top of the camshaft approach. These days though i don't understand while mainstream car manufacturers wouldn't just go for the fully independent valve approach like that "Freevalve", i.e. each valve is driven by its own solenoid/pneumo/hydro actuator controlled by the computer - such approach looks simpler and cheaper to me (may be because i'm in software :)
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- analognoise 7y agoThis is just dumb marketing speak for a simple hill climber with a handful of dimensions and a few heuristics. Ecu's have been doing this for like 25 years. Basically, AI=bullshit in any marketing copy at this point.
- dukoid 7y agoDoes anybody have a pointer to a schema / animation how this works? Is this a radial motor?
- brink 7y agoThere's a video in the article. Did you look?
- dukoid 7y agoYes. There are 4 photos and an unrelated "rube goldberg" video at the end?
- brink 7y agoI'm not sure why you're not seeing it. This is the video in the middle of the article. https://vimeo.com/395222190 https://vimeo.com/395222190
- dukoid 7y agoThanks for the direct link! I can't find any vimeo reference in the page source, perhaps it depends on country or adblocker or whatever. I guess part of my confusion stemmed from mixing up the camshaft and the crankshaft (the former seems relatively straightforward to replace in a conventional motor, the latter not so much...) O:)
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- Theodores 7y agoHow come it has taken many decades for Freevalve to come along? Genuinely curious as it doesn't seem impossible that someone else had thought of it.
- noughtme 7y agoPneumatic valves are expensive. They have been used in F1. Similarly, despite overhead 𝚟̶𝚊̶𝚕̶𝚟̶𝚎̶𝚜̶ cams being invented in 1902, they weren’t popularized until the 1983 Toyota Corolla, and you can still find pushrods in the 2020 Corvette.
- rootusrootus 7y agoSeems you misspoke. We've been using overhead valves far longer than 1983. Overhead cam is probably what you meant. Though depending on how mainstream it needs to be in order to be considered 'popular', the first dual overhead cam engine was in production in the 20s, IIRC.
- tonyedgecombe 7y agoFIAT/Lancia were using OHC engines in the seventies, well before 1983.
- jacquesm 7y agoThey were used in a little 0.7 liter Daihatsu Copen engine as well if I remember correctly.
- irjustin 7y agoEngineeringExpalined has a great video[0] on the overall mechanics of the system. Sadly, I don't expect to see this in regular Ford or Toyotas any time soon. The cost benefit combined design upgrade and tooling change is just not practical. [0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FJXgKY2O4po https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FJXgKY2O4po
- csours 7y agoI wonder if this engine is only 3 cylinders because of the cost of the valves? Fewer cylinders, fewer valves...
- mysterydip 7y agoThey said in the article basically "why make it bigger than it has to be? It does the job and leaves more room for passenger space."
- xgbi 7y agoJust like for motorcycles, 3 cyl is the ideal for both torque and revs. Bi is all torque, 4 is all revs, and the 3 is just in between.
- speedgoose 7y ago> "We don't make pure electric cars because for the time being, we think they're too heavy, and they don't make a cool sound. And as long as we can be CO2 neutral and frugal and clean comparatively, we will push the combustion engine." I read that as "we don't give a fuck about emissions because we like vroom vroom and we plant a few trees to not feel bad about it". I agree about the weight problem of large lithium batteries, and light hydrogen fuel cells may not deliver enough pick power, so I don't have a good solution for hyper cars. I just think that ICE engines shouldn't be in cars ASAP.
- Justin_K 7y agoThey make high performance cars, what do you expect? With your logic, any improvement to IC engines is evil...
- speedgoose 7y agoIt's ok to improve ICE engines. I'm sure some people continue to improve horse drawn carriages. Thankfully we don't have our cities full of horse poop anymore.
- rad_gruchalski 7y agoJesus. Not everybody lives or wants to live in a city. Get over it.
- speedgoose 7y agoYou never drive to a city ?
- rad_gruchalski 7y agoNot as often as driving over a horse poop when out and about in the countryside. And I’m not complaining about it. But when I’m there, I never really feel comfrtable walking around. It’s full of people on bicycles who don’t give a damn about pedestrians.
- m_a_g 7y agoCurrently, there is a 160% sales tax for vehicles that has an engine larger than 2.0 liters in where I live. This engine could be a game-changer in countries that have the same taxation. I wish this engine can become mainstream.
- louwrentius 7y agoThey will change the law to 1.99 Litre or less, it probably won't work.
- sk5t 7y agoThere are already plenty of good 2.0 liter engines that represent little compromise. If the tax regime hasn't adjusted to punish Audi S3 buyers, well, there would be even less to be gained by making special accommodations to tax a small handful of supercars based on displacement.
- sgt 7y agoOr maybe buy a Tesla.
- Summershard 7y agoYou may be living in a US bubble. Tesla in many countries is still expensive, not that popular, and electric cars infrastructure is just bad.
- lgleason 7y agoI wonder if this is an interference or non interference design. If it is the former, one glitch in the valve timing and the engine would need a rebuild. Hopefully it is the later.
- ufmace 7y agoThis is really cool tech, amazing that somebody's managed to get dynamic valve action working reliably. What I'm wondering, though, it what the benefit is of using it on a hybrid car. It sounds like they did connect the engine mechanically to the drivetrain, with the electric motors mostly assisting. But why not have it just directly drive a generator, with some decent sized batteries? An engine that only runs at full power at a single RPM to charge batteries doesn't benefit much from elaborate valve technology.
- andrepd 7y ago>"We don't make pure electric cars because for the time being, we think they're too heavy, and they don't make a cool sound. And as long as we can be CO2 neutral and frugal and clean comparatively, we will push the combustion engine." Impressive tech, but I'd by lying if I said this doesn't rub me the wrong way. How do you mean combustion being CO2 neutral? And cool sound, this is one of my pet peeves. Why does a rich guy's wish for a "cool sound" in his sports car justify being a nuisance to other people? Motorbikes are the worst offender here. Sound limitations should be a lot stricter than they are.
- dfee 7y agoSure dude. And as a driver on a motorbike, how about you stay off your cell phone while driving. And, as I frequently see here in California, how about you all also stop smoking blunts while driving? I should mention that a lot of motorcyclists feel that loud exhausts are a way of protecting themselves from distracted drivers.
- andrepd 7y agoWhataboutism at its finest. How to drivers using cell phones diminish the validity of complaints about excessive noise? They're two unrelated problems.
- dfee 7y agoI’m confused. Did you not read my comment? I specifically addressed how they’re not two separate problems.
- Klinky 7y agoYou need to accept some responsibility when deciding to ride a motorcycle. You're essentially saying you're okay with your body acting as the crumple zone in a crash. If it's so dangerous out there that you need to rumble around at 100dB then maybe it's time to reconsider. Many cars have impressive sound dampening and those that don't have wind noise drowning out almost anything else on the road.
- agoodthrowaway 7y agoI race motorcycless and so have some experience with high horsepower small engines. My first thought is I wonder how high the compression is to get this HP with only 3 cylinders? With high compression, everything wears much faster and components like pistons, connecting rods, and bearings need to be replaced at regular intervals for the engine to remain reliable. Additionally frequent oil changes become necessary as the oil breaks down more quickly under these conditions and metal shavings from wear build up in the oil. Things like connecting rods become stressed and need to be replaced at regular intervals for the engine to remain reliable. I’d imagine that the Konigsegg buyer probably doesn’t care about maintenance costs but they might be irritated at the service intervals. I wonder how much maintenance that will be?
- jjjensen90 7y agoCars in the class of Koenigseggs are actually rarely driven, things like wear and tear are often not a concern at all, what's more important is exclusivity and exotic-ness. Maintenance is something a buyer in this class doesn't even consider in my experience.
- zeusk 7y agoThey're actually marketing this freevalve tech for consumer cars. They already have a tech demonstration partner (a Chinese car maker).
- MegaButts 7y agoI'm curious if it will be adopted. I assume cost is a big issue. Hyundai considered it, but decided to roll their own (of course they were already pretty invested in their own technology, but Hyundai is known for reliability and Koenigsegg is not). https://www.roadandtrack.com/new-cars/car-technology/a31224648/hyundai-cvvd-system-explained/ https://www.roadandtrack.com/new-cars/car-technology/a312246...
- hi5eyes 7y agoKonigsegg is part of the echelon with bugatti owners that have warehouses of cars
- Wistar 7y agoJalopnik does a deep dive into the engineering of the entire Gemera drivetrain but plenty about the 3-cyl engine. https://jalopnik.com/a-detailed-look-at-the-koenigsegg-gemeras-mind-blowing-1842073757 https://jalopnik.com/a-detailed-look-at-the-koenigsegg-gemer...
- hinkley 7y agoI take it the complexity of the system favors fewer cylinders and a larger bore. This could be interesting when it comes down market a bit. Especially given the flex fuel ability.
- olivermarks 7y agoThese engines remind me of the wankel rotary era. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wankel_engine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wankel_engine Great idea that really worked but let down by reliability issues. I hope the Koenigsegg gets into some sort of mass production so we can see how reliable and durable it is though!
- Hamuko 7y ago>I hope the Koenigsegg gets into some sort of mass production Don't hold your breath.
- detaro 7y agoKoenigsegg makes <100 cars a year afaik, and I doubt that'll change.
- olivermarks 7y agoI meant the innovative new engine in a mass production car, not a luxury vehicle
- sorenjan 7y agoKoenigsegg will work together with NEVS to make cheaper cars. Still close to $1 million, but their aim is to make more. And I think Christian said they were making 1 car per week at the moment. https://www.autoblog.com/2019/03/04/koenigsegg-affordable-supercar-nevs/ https://www.autoblog.com/2019/03/04/koenigsegg-affordable-su...
- Animats 7y agoComputer controlled valves are an old idea. It's been a "can be done, but not worth the trouble and added complexity" thing for years. This is more like the last gasp of fuel-powered supercars, as the IC engine people try to stay relevant.
- wcarron 7y agoHur dur, gas baaaaad. If you don't understand car culture, and why this is cool, why are you commenting on this thread? There are other forums to jerk off about pathetic road-legal electric go-karts.
- peter_d_sherman 7y agoHow many watts of electricity could this make, if it were removed from the car, and made to power an electric generator? Would there be any efficiencies compared to say, an ordinary gasoline piston engine with a camshaft, driving that generator? I'm guessing yes... which leads to the next question: Would a diesel motor (again, to drive a generator) be more effective than this one which uses gasoline? Why or why not?
- csours 7y agoOT, but kind of related: Would it be possible build an air-cooled engine that runs on alcohol, and uses water/methanol spray in the intake air such that the temperature of the engine is controlled by the amount of water/meth?
- fock 7y agoSo, this is all fascinating and nice advertisement for this racing company which might want to compete in Formula 1... But: what problem is actually solved by this thing?
- krak12 7y agoIts not a racing company, it’s a boutique automaker, the beauty resides that they are not solving any problem. They are using their talents to push the automotive technology to the limits for the fun and glory. Your yoga-dog walking app solves a lot of problems I guess.
- eyegor 7y agoThis is really cool, but estimating 280HP at 2L when naturally aspirated has already been beaten. The party trick here is definitely the pneumatic valve control being able to switch combustion cycles on the fly. If you just want max power per liter, Nissan's 3 cyl from 2014 claims 400HP at 1.5L [0]. I'm guessing this high-output small engine tech will never come down to the consumer level since they all rev at 7-8k rpm. If there was a way to build a 3cyl SUV, I'm sure someone would have done it by now. [0] https://www.autoblog.com/2014/01/28/nissan-three-cylinder-race-engine/ https://www.autoblog.com/2014/01/28/nissan-three-cylinder-ra...
- perl4ever 7y ago"If there was a way to build a 3cyl SUV, I'm sure someone would have done it by now." Ford's new Escape has a 1.5L turbo I-3 on the base model. And Ford also used to have a 1.0L turbo I-3 in some models of Fiesta and/or Focus, although it was kind of obscure and may have only come with a manual transmission (in the US).
- VoxPelli 7y agoHere’s a 3-cylinder SUV from that other Swedish car manufacturer: https://www.autocar.co.uk/car-news/new-cars/volvo-adds-t3-three-cylinder-petrol-engine-xc40-range https://www.autocar.co.uk/car-news/new-cars/volvo-adds-t3-th... Also, the first Freevalve engine to be put presented in a car was in a normal sedan from a Chinese manufacturer: https://www.motorauthority.com/news/1107384_1-6-liter-camless-engine-delivers-230-hp-in-qoros-3 https://www.motorauthority.com/news/1107384_1-6-liter-camles...
- ska 7y agoThat Nissan is also turbocharged, so 280 isn't the right comparsion. you should compare 400hp/1.5L to 600hp/2l. Or perhaps 500hp/2l on regular gas - either way they are similar.
- rasz 7y ago20 year old Honda K20A does ~260-270whp after tune
- msla 7y agoSo a gigantic engine can make horsepower. Is 600 horsepower a lot?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- rcv 7y agoI really love the idea of a camless engine. Is there some fundamental reason it hasn't been more widely adopted other than tooling change costs? I can't imagine the solenoids are that much more expensive than a ground camshaft and all of the supporting hardware at volume. This very much feels like the transition from brushed to brushless motors to me - super cheap compute power and sensors unlocking a much more efficient way to drive electric motors. As far as I know there's no _real_ advantage to brushed motors except in dirt cheap applications where a potentiometer is the most expensive speed controller you can afford.
- zw123456 7y agoI love these way out of the box thinking approached for super cars because that type of innovation can lead to break throughs "down the road" pun intended. Having said that, a configuration I have thought about is the idea of a hybrid that uses a turbine with magnetic bearings turning a high efficiency generator. Probably been thought of but I have not seen it. HN will point me to something I bet :)
- GatorD42 7y agoKoenigsegg claims that because of modern catalytic converters and improved cold starting process for their engine, there are virtually no particulate emissions: https://www.koenigsegg.com/gemera/tiny-friendly-giant-engine/ https://www.koenigsegg.com/gemera/tiny-friendly-giant-engine... I wonder how well these claims will hold up. Seems like a very big deal if true.
- rasz 7y agoTLDR: turbo charged Build turbocharged Honda K20A (20 year old engine) does 500whp. >Koenigsegg says, in theory, a naturally aspirated TFG could make 280 horsepower.) again just like build K20A NA :)
- batsy71 7y agoThe video says 1000 km of hybrid range. Is that then only 4 refuels from NYC to LA?
- dreamcompiler 7y agoSoftware-controlled valves have been a holy grail for ICE for a long time, and now they're here. This is an amazing accomplishment. Unfortunately ICE are rapidly becoming obsolete.
- mleonhard 7y agoThis is a marketing piece.