7 ms·
>It also seeks to give workers new protections, including paid emergency leave, with both 14 days of paid sick leave and up to three months of paid family and m
by whatshisface 7y ago
>It also seeks to give workers new protections, including paid emergency leave, with both 14 days of paid sick leave and up to three months of paid family and medical leave, as well as enhanced unemployment insurance, which will extend protections to furloughed workers.
>In addition to supporting workers, the "Families First" bill would also seek to strengthen food security initiatives, including SNAP, food bank services, student meals and senior nutrition programs, while also increasing federal funds for Medicaid, as states across the country face increased costs.
By packing so much social assistance into the bill, the House is going to create serious problems with getting it through the Senate. The goal of mass testing would be better served if the controversial issues were separated from the immediate one.
- revel 7y agoSNAP is set to be cut in April. It's essential that the program coverage not be cut during what is almost certainly a massively global recession. The most vulnerable will die without this assistance.
- wonderwonder 7y agoThe administration confirmed a couple days ago it is still intending to push forward with their budget request to cut CDC funding by 15%. They don't care about poor people.
- Shank 7y agoI mean, this is how politics generally works. Almost every big bill has included in it things that don't relate to the bill and are just on someone's wishlist to get passed. It'll likely be rejected by the senate and amended, but this is pretty normal politics to me.
- dionian 7y agoYup plus it gives them the opportunity to grandstand about why their rivals didn't approve
- easytiger 7y ago> I mean, this is how politics generally works In the USA
- airstrike 7y agoI think the point the parent is making is that "normal politics" need not apply here given the abnormal situation we find ourselves in
- amhokies 7y agoThe reason this stuff is acceptable is we just shrug it off as "normal politics". Politicians should not take advantage of emergencies by tacking wish list items on to bills that address the emergency.
- Seenso 7y ago> Politicians should not take advantage of emergencies by tacking wish list items on to bills that address the emergency. What exactly are the unrelated wish list items here? Everything I'm seeing here looks on point and directly relevant to this crisis. Workers need rights to sick time right now, or the virus will spread even more quickly and this will be worse. People are going to be losing jobs or hours because of this, and if they don't have extra cash they're going to need food assistance. Medicaid is about to get hit hard, just like every health insurance program. The elderly and disabled people are vulnerable groups, and are going to need greater levels of assistance during the coming disruptions.
- Goronmon 7y agoProviding food and healthcare is a "wish list item" during a pandemic?
- root_axis 7y ago> The reason this stuff is acceptable is we just shrug it off as "normal politics" Not really. They understand what they're doing, this happens because it is a contemporary political strategy in the U.S, it doesn't matter what individual constituents feel about the practice.
- thawaway1837 7y agoExcept none of those things are unrelated. They are directly related. The only difference is that in most other developed countries they are available as part of daily life without an emergency. The US needs to add stuff like paid sick leave because it is not available normally, and without it you’re very likely to find people consciously or even sub consciously avoiding testing, or going in to work even if they are sick because they will face a severe financial impact other wise.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- nostromo 7y ago"Hey, it's an emergency, pull out your wish list for the past four decades."
- Seenso 7y ago> "Hey, it's an emergency, pull out your wish list for the past four decades." All the proposals listed in the article makes total sense in the context of this crisis. Sick time for people to quarantine, food assistance for the people whose incomes will drop due to the fast approaching recession and isolation measures, all totally on-topic. The US has long-understood systematic problems that will contribute to making this crisis worse. If you want to mitigate the crisis, you'll want to fix those issues that you can.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- bosswipe 7y agoRepublicans are mostly just proposing their solution for everything, tax cuts. So it's the same debate we always have, tax cuts vs direct assistance.
- thawaway1837 7y agoYou could also rephrase it as stuff that will not do anything to stop the spread of the virus (tax cuts) vs stuff that is recommended by health experts to mitigate the spread of the virus by idneitifying the afflicted and incentivising them to not make decisions that will impact society negatively.
- pmiller2 7y agoIs it even a debate anymore? The last 40 years of history have shown that tax cuts only benefit the wealthy.
- MereInterest 7y ago"Hey, it's an emergency of exactly the kind we've been trying to prevent. Let's suggest the things we've been suggesting to prevent exactly this kind of emergency."
- ColanR 7y agoAgreed. It sounds like this is a very non-partisan bill, with only a small part publicised to make it sound partisan. It's almost disingenuous to add everything else in there.
- trophycase 7y agoIf I know anything about American politics it's that EVERYTHING is partisan
- ceejayoz 7y agoWell, everything is treated as partisan. Michelle Obama's "kids should eat healthier school lunches" wasn't partisan, but it was treated as such.
- nokcha 7y agoI have a feeling that many of the working poor with mild symptoms would resist getting tested even if the test is free, due to the economic costs of quarantine if they test positive. Strengthening the public social safety net (and using govt funds to pay for sick leave of those who test positive) seems like a prudent public-health measure, to help ensure that people are more willing to get tested and to self-quarantine if they are infected.
- gopalv 7y ago> even if the test is free, due to the economic costs of quarantine if they test positive. Worse than that, they could even face a Tom Hanks Philadelphia like situation, after they test positive.
- wyldfire 7y agoThat's unlikely, covid19 is not infectious for very long after symptoms disappear [relative to HIV's infectiousness].
- magduf 7y agoYep, and for good reason: they absolutely should keep working (and spreading the disease around) if they have it, because they cannot afford not to. This is the consequence of having a society where there's no real social safety net to handle crises like this. Personally, I'm a well-paid tech worker, but even for me, if I'm quarantined, my company policy is that I cannot come to work (nor can I work from home), and I must take either PTO or (if that's exhausted) medical leave of absence (without pay). Luckily, I'm single and frugal, live well below my means, and have lots of savings because I'm somewhat paranoid, so I can easily live for a few months without pay, but this just isn't true for most people, especially people without families who aren't overpaid tech workers like me. So I certainly cannot criticize people at the low end of the scale who avoid getting quarantined: they have to do this to survive. If we don't like this, then maybe we should have done a better job voting for leaders who would handle health crises better and set up social safety nets for things like this.
- 7y ago
- unhashable 7y agoI'm sure that was by-design. It's a common game for the House to throw up packages they know the Senate will bat down. They are trying to make the Senate look bad in the eyes of the nation. "Senate vetos critical Coronavirus support package."
- crooked-v 7y agoIf the Senate votes against expanded worker sick leave protections and expanded food aid in the middle of a crisis massively influenced by lack of sick leave protections and lack of food aid, then they should look bad.
- anigbrowl 7y agoWhat is to prevent the Senate taking it up, amending it, and then negotiating the differences over a day or two? This persistent refusal to even consider or debate legislation that isn't already tailored to the (implicit) wishes of the Senate is just a procedural veto. The Senate's behavior is like one person hitting another and then saying 'now look what you made me do.' Why do you hold the House responsible for the political choices of the Senate?
- chadlavi 7y agoControversial issues like not killing people during a crisis?
- tomp 7y agoIf that was the point of the bill, all measures would have well-defined time limits (e.g. 3 months, after which they need to be renewed). That's how Switzerland does it (even the constitution has time limit!) Edit: I mean limiting the amount of time these bills remain valid, not just limiting the amount of paid leave.
- Goronmon 7y ago14 days of paid sick leave and up to three months of paid family and medical leave Those seem like pretty specific limits. What other limits do you feel are missing from the bill?
- vonmoltke 7y agoI think tomp is talking about a time limit on the validity of the legislation itself, not the provisions in it.
- ApolloFortyNine 7y agoObviously the OP here means on how long 14 days of paid sick leave and three months of paid family and medical leave will remain the case. If it's indefinitely, then this is clearly Democrats trying to attach what they've campaigned for to a Coronavirus bill, in an attempt to make it seem like Republicans are the ones holding up Coronavirus support. If it's the rest of this year, then it likely should be passed.
- crooked-v 7y agoIf those provisions go away, then they just become a problem again within a few years when the next novel coronavirus strain appears, and in the meantime all the money spent on setting up the necessary bureaucracy has been wasted by just chucking all it out the window.
- josephorjoe 7y agoBy controversial issues we apparently mean "providing food and a safety net for people who lose their jobs" (most of whom will lose their jobs due to the crisis brought about by the pandemic). I feel there is something very wrong with us that this is immediately seen as "OMG Super partisan crazy talk!!!"
- JMTQp8lwXL 7y agoIt's not that your parent poster necessarily believes a basic social safety net is super partisan, but seems to be speaking from a point of reality. McConnell has been called the grim reaper and is proud of how many House bills he has stopped.
- majos 7y agoOther coverage of this bill suggests McConnell is OK with passing something he sees as imperfect, given cover from Trump. > Should the White House and House Democrats come to terms, Mr. McConnell has indicated privately that he would quickly bring up the measure and pass it to allow Mr. Trump to sign it into law. https://www.nytimes.com/2020/03/12/us/politics/trump-house-coronavirus-relief-bill.html https://www.nytimes.com/2020/03/12/us/politics/trump-house-c... It’s hard to imagine he would incentivize Pelosi to pass an aid bill just so he can block it, what is the political upside for him if he does that? Similarly, the fact that Pelosi is even trying to work with Trump, Mnuchin, etc suggests she believes passage is possible. If she’s just doing this to make the senate republicans look bad when they reject it, then it’d be much easier to pass something with little to no input from Republicans.
- dole 7y ago> It's hard to imagine he would incentivize Pelosi to pass an aid bill just so he can block it, what is the political upside for him if he does that? If it looks like it doesn't have a chance of passing anyway, it provides an opportunity to publicly rebuke the other party. He pushed through AoC's Green New Deal with a smirk [1]. [1] https://www.cnbc.com/2019/03/26/aocs-green-new-deal-dies-in-mcconnell-led-senate-vote.html https://www.cnbc.com/2019/03/26/aocs-green-new-deal-dies-in-...
- jhpriestley 7y agoThe goal is not mass testing, what good is mass testing if it just tells us that the virus is spreading rapidly because people can't afford to stay home?
- tayo42 7y agoIt'll shut up the "its just a cold/flu" people if you have proof you're contagious. People are still going to work and doing errands.
- Goronmon 7y agoThe goal of mass testing would be better served if the controversial issues were separated from the immediate one. Dealing with only the surface level issues and ignoring everything else seems like a great way to pretend like you are accomplishing something without actually doing anything useful. What parts of the bill do you consider too much "social assistance"?
- whateveracct 7y ago> What parts of the bill do you consider too much "social assistance"? There is a sect in the USA that considers the social assistance already in place as too much no matter what. That's the mindset of the opposition here. This isn't even a political hot take from me. It's an often-stated purpose.
- pmiller2 7y agoThat sect is frequently referred to as "the Republicans."
- cassalian 7y agoNot the parent, nor am I saying I agree with the parent. But I'm pretty sure the answer to your question is: "It also seeks to give workers new protections, including paid emergency leave, with both 14 days of paid sick leave and up to three months of paid family and medical leave, as well as enhanced unemployment insurance, which will extend protections to furloughed workers."
- crooked-v 7y agoTesting means nothing if people then just go to work anyway because they can't stay home, whether to self quarantine or to care for family members and then self quarantine, without being fired.
- cassalian 7y agoNo disagreement from me! Just trying to clarify what I believe the parent would have interpreted as "too much 'social assistance'" in case it wasn't obvious for some reason
- thawaway1837 7y agoI mean this is basic. Without paid leave sick peopke will come into work. 2 weeks is a fraction of the standard European sick leave so it isn’t even that onerous.
- kolbe 7y agoThank god Europe had the extended sick leave in place or else they might have a COVID outbreak right now.
- throwaway2048 7y agoI got some bad news if you think the USA's response and cultural attitudes are going to result in a better weathering of this crisis.
- kolbe 7y agoAs of March 12th, you are wrong. But I appreciate your optimism that you will be right! We need more people with very strong unfounded opinions that they treat as fact if we want democracy to succeed.
- fzeroracer 7y agoCan you explain exactly what is controversial about those additions? Generally speaking, strengthening social assistance during a period where social assistance is going to be strained seems like a good idea.
- whateveracct 7y ago> Generally speaking, strengthening social assistance during a period where social assistance is going to be strained seems like a good idea. Not when your stated purpose is to dismantle said social assistance, which explains why this bill is going to die in the Senate.
- kick 7y agoIt...kind of makes sense, though? SNAP: People are going to be out of work because of this, not everyone has a job they can work from home with, and emergency savings in America are sparse enough to where it's a real concern. Food bank services: People are going to be out of work because of it, so on, and encouraging people to keep in one region delays the spread of the virus. Student Meals: ? Senior nutrition programs: Reducing spread among the most vulnerable, plus most of those programs are about increasing the quality of nutrition, which might help boost immune systems. Medicaid increase: (explained in that blurb) If anything, it seems like this would be agreeable among both sides overall, especially when taking into account 45's television address, which focused heavily on the elderly. It makes sense, because there's a strong incentive for the Republican side of the aisle to keep them alive: too much of them gone at once and more than a few of them would be at risk of losing their seats.
- majos 7y agoRe: students, a nontrivial fraction of students get meals from the schools they attend, so if schools close this would help cover that demographic.
- kick 7y agoOh yeah, of course! Thanks for pointing that out!
- mmcnl 7y agoNobody is saying it doesn't make sense, but does it really need to be on the same bill?
- kick 7y agoThings will get worse without those things, so it seems like it does.
- PeterisP 7y agoIf you want mass testing, you need to create circumstances that allow people to go and get tested. If a positive test would result in a quarantine without a financial "safety net", then people won't agree to be tested or will ignore test results and the goal of the bill will fail. Actually doing the tests and "here's what will happen if you get tested positive, and it's not horrible and won't bankrupt you" are two sides of the same coin. I mean, the end goal is not tests as such but to restrict spread of the disease. If "tests are available" but if the vulnerable parts of the population (e.g. the dude putting stuff on the shelf of your local store or the girl at the counter) don't have that safety net, then the testing was useless because they'll still go to work and infect you and others. So this safety net is a key part of the bill.
- gdubs 7y agoI guess the financial crisis was a whole decade ago now, but the consensus back then was that if we wanted to avert a full blown depression, we needed to move fast, and be bold. None of those programs listed sound frivolous to me, given what’s probably coming financially. It’s better to get this on the table now, than have to keep coming back piecemeal over the next year.
- kube-system 7y agoThose are all directly related to the issue at hand. People are going to need to stay home, eat food there, and get medical assistance.
- dv_dt 7y agoThese are basic measures to effectively fight coronavirus... The goal of not overwhelming our healthcare system and minimizing deaths is best served by getting a full set of measures out fast.
- joe5150 7y agogiven that COVID-19 is untreatable and people who are at-risk or symptomatic should go ahead and hunker down as if they have it whether it's lab-confirmed or not, I don't think testing millions is more critical than ensuring affected people remain housed and fed while they are out of work. testing is important for public health data and understanding how the virus is spreading and how to respond, but economic security is absolutely an "immediate issue" for anybody laid off or unemployed because of the pandemic.
- chvid 7y agoIt is a bit freigthening to follow US politics on this. Everything seems to be politicized. I compare it to Denmark where the opposition fully supported the government's decision to shut down schools and send home public sector employees. I am pretty sure no politician here would dare to politicize a situation like this because of the fear of being punished by their voters.
- Mountain_Skies 7y agoIf large numbers of people start dying you'll likely see the tolerance for political grandstanding drop to near zero. In the meantime, politics are the dominate sport of the United States and people will vigorously cheer for their chosen team.
- mattnewton 7y agoIf you believe the social assistance is necessary, this kind of brinksmanship is the only way to get it through the senate at all.
- mikestew 7y agoBy packing so much social assistance into the bill, the House is going to create serious problems with getting it through the Senate. It could be seen as a political gamble that even Mitch McConnell doesn't want to be seen as that much of a monster, as one who turns away furloughed and quarantined workers from assistance. Or it could be seen simply as "being a human being with some compassion". Or it could be seen as, "doesn't make much sense for free testing if people are going to lose their homes if they test positive". I'm going with the last one. Free tests to see if I'm still employable or not? Yeah, that's a hard pass from me, I've got kids to feed.
- 2bitencryption 7y agoThis seems like a really smart move to me. It's a win-win for Democrats -- either the bill passes, along with all this reform that was stuck into it, which dems can brag about to voters in the campaign. Or it doesn't pass, because of all the stuffing, and dems get yet another example of republicans moving slowly on the issue and blocking much-needed reform.
- whatshisface 7y agoIt's only a win-win from the political perspective of the house majority. From the perspective of the public good, legislation needs to pass. The people will not really benefit from another political missile being added to one side's arsenal, they need working legislation.
- 2bitencryption 7y ago> It's only a win-win from the political perspective of the house majority sounds like American politics in a nutshell to me, aside from a few rare exceptions!
- crooked-v 7y agoSo tell your Senator to pass the bill, then. Any negative aspect here is entirely on the heads of the Republican senate majority for being worse than useless about any kind of public relief. They could easily get ahead of this thing by passing a lesser bill that provides some or temporary benefits, but that would mean helping people instead of corporations.
- pmiller2 7y ago> Or it doesn't pass, because of all the stuffing, and dems get yet another example of republicans moving slowly on the issue and blocking much-needed reform. Yep, and that's exactly why we've elected 8 Republican administrations (not counting Ford because he wasn't elected), and 5 Democratic administrations since 1968. Oh, wait....
- wonderwonder 7y agoHourly people (including those working food services) would not get tested as they would then be forced to quarantine. They cant afford to lose 2 weeks of pay and potentially their jobs so they would avoid the test all together. Given a choice of going to work and potentially infecting others or losing their jobs and their kids going without food most are going to skip the test and go to work. Additional safety nets are required to incentive those people to get tested. The only way to do that is to ensure they receive their pay, their jobs are secure and the test and treatment is free.
- StaticRedux 7y agoThe Democrats could pack universal single payer healthcare into this bill and it would still pass. It would be political suicide for Republicans and Trump to block it. They would of course scream about the Democrats playing politics, but they do that about everything already, so what's new. The Democrats would be able to say they tried to help the country in a time of crisis and were blocked. It would be a win-win for Democrats. Disclaimer: I am an independent and don't think Medicare for all is a good idea. Still though.
- unlinked_dll 7y agoI strongly disagree. Testing is much less important than the social net. We will not be able to test everyone even if it's free, and we don't need to test everyone to flatten the curve. We need to keep people insulated which can only happen if people are able to survive while insulated.
- kryogen1c 7y agoAh, partisanship - the true amnesiac. 9/11 got used to push through horrific legislation, but most people only cared because of partisan results and cared nothing for the mechanism of action. here we see the same mechanism of action in effect again, and again only people who disagree along partisan lines care. i thought we were engineers, coders, and scientists? hackers, for god's sakes. what happened to systems-level thinking? what happened to working the problem (the ROOT problem) with rationality? we've had dangerous global pandemics very, very recently (SARS, swine flu) but none saw fit to take the alarmist stance so many commenters emotionally grandstand with today ("this is not.the.fucking.flu", et. al.). where will your righteous anger and verve be two years from now? the HN comments themselves and subsequent upvotes/downvotes have been truly disappointing. divine comedy indeed. just weather the storm, friends. you know where the coronavirus looks safest? where there is the most testing - south korea. dont worry, everyone. earth's orbit weaves through cosmic missiles with sufficient energy to immediately and permanently extinguish all life on earth, and we have neither the detection capacity for warning nor the prevention capacity to stop it even if we had warning.
- anthm1988 7y agoMaybe the fucking monsters in the senate shouldn't treat relief for workers as controversial.