4 ms·
Exactly this! I kind of understand the WHO, the broad public, including media, doesn't care about models and such things. Providing to much details can have the
by hef19898 7y ago
Exactly this! I kind of understand the WHO, the broad public, including media, doesn't care about models and such things. Providing to much details can have the opposite effect, instead of calming things down it could spark more fear.
On the other hand, online stuff like said growth hacker can draw a lot of attention. This will end up in the mainstream. That diseases aren't exponential, who cares when exponential curves fit so nicely early on.
What could, and should, be done by large tech companies is preventing this. Google could make sure that every Corona related search ends up showing the WHO on top, followed by local sources like the CDC, Robert Koch, John Hopkins and so on. They could support these parties in getting them up in the search results. Facebook could do the same, as does Twitter. In Germany, you have to explicitly include Robert Koch or RKI in your search for the link to show. Even by doing so, earlier today it still wasn't the tip link. The rest is reporting crap written every time a new case was found somewhere.
And yet, nothing like that happens.
- Certhas 7y agoBut the early stages of disease spread _are_ exponential. And I find that people really fail to understand the meaning of that, and how scary numbers like "new confirmed cases doubling every two days, 500 new cases in France yesterday" truly are.
- hef19898 7y agoYes, but extrapolating the early exponential phase is, plain and simple, mathematically wrong. No idea why data scientists aren't going the first mile and look up the relevant functions before spitting data out. Total fail on their part, IMHO.
- whatshisface 7y agoIt's not wrong: it has produced extremely good predictive results day after day for total cases outside of China for months now. Using a simpler approximate function in place of a more complicated exact function is far from wrong, it is bread and butter for getting practical results in all areas of science.
- zaroth 7y agoIt’s right until it’s totally wrong, e.g. for any country which has already peaked, of which there are several.
- goatlover 7y agoCountries that implemented extreme measures to slow the spread of the virus. It will be different for countries which haven't. The WHO and other health officials around the world are saying the same thing. This will spread to a large number of people. It's too late for containment, you can only hope to flatten the curve. That's why it's now a pandemic.
- zaroth 7y ago> This will spread to a large number of people. It's too late for containment, you can only hope to flatten the curve. Follow the logic through. South Korea is detecting ~100 cases per day on top of a total of 7,700 and 66 deaths. Total population is 50 million people. How long do you shut down the economy over a disease where you are detecting 100 cases per day with a CFR of 0.8%? Seems like this is a perfect example of the curve being too flat.
- arpa 7y agoUnless you simultaneously ramp up your healthcare resources (what China did), even as "low" as 100 cases/day still has very real potential to go exponential (R0=2.5), overwhelm your healthcare, and kill 10% of our population if not more (especially if your population is aged).
- zaroth 7y agoI hear that, what I'm saying is, follow that logic through... If it's crucial to maintain strict protocols even during a rate of only 100 new cases/day, that means these protocols stay in place roughly... indefinitely. Counting individual cases and deaths in a country of 300 million is nonsensical. You could do the same thing with the flu and you'd hit 20,000 deaths a year and you'd destroy the economy in the process. IMO, the solution is best preparing to treat the number of people who do become severely ill from it, and getting the rest of the country fully back to work as quickly as possible. Although I disagree strongly on the "kill 10% of your population" bit, which is just fear-mongering, it's kind of besides the point.
- Certhas 7y agoMathematically wrong is not a relevant category here. There is no "ground truth" that is approximated by an exponential growth. Every disease model is counterfactual "spread of the disease if no countermeasures were taken", etc... Modelling the beginning of an epidemic as exponential growth is useful, sensible and empirically validated. As, countermeasures are taken during the beginning of the epidemic, for discussions of the effect of countermeasures, exponential is the correct model. In fact, hopefully the countermeasures taken will be sufficient that the intrinsic disease dynamic will never get past the exponential stage...
- hef19898 7y agoI don't find any differentiation between early stage and later stage nor references to exponential functions: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mathematical_modelling_of_infectious_disease https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mathematical_modelling_of_infe... If you find any source, idealy scientific papers on the subject, that shows that contagious diseases can be modelled with simple exponential functions, please share them. I am not an expert on that matter, so I would be really interessted to see some reliable sources confirming the use of exponential functions.
- cvwright 7y agoOk, look at the differential equations on this page about the Kermack-McKendrick model: https://mathworld.wolfram.com/Kermack-McKendrickModel.html https://mathworld.wolfram.com/Kermack-McKendrickModel.html Notice that the rate of change in the infected population (dI/dt) is proportional to the current number of infected (I) and the current number of susceptible (S). In the early stages, when S is large and I is still small, this acts just like an exponential function in I. For example, think about what happens when you double I the first several times. S stays relatively unchanged, and so dI/dt roughly doubles each time you double I. Does that make sense?
- hef19898 7y agoYeah, exactly. In the beginning exponential, later on not anymore. Without changing the equation. So, no, not exponential. Because, you know, very early on an exponential graph can approximated by something non-exponential. Would be utter BS, sure, so nobody does it.
- ericol 7y agoThe problem is, exponential for how long? For instance, all seems to indicate measures in Italy are taken too late: and the exponential growth is still happening there (almost 3 weeks after the problem started) import pandas as pd import numpy as np import matplotlib.pyplot as plt %matplotlib inline it = pd.read_json('https://raw.githubusercontent.com/pcm-dpc/COVID-19/master/dati-json/dpc-covid19-ita-andamento-nazionale.json', convert_dates=True).set_index('data') plt.plot(it[['deceduti', 'totale_casi']]) plt.xticks(it.index.values, rotation=90);
- Certhas 7y agoIt's to early to say. The people who are popping up with symptoms now might have been infected up to two weeks ago. If you look at the Wuhan data, you see that the lockdown worked, but the number of confirmed cases at the time continued to rise dramatically until 12 days after the lockdown went into effect. We are only three days in on the Italy lockdown. https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jama/fullarticle/2762130 https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jama/fullarticle/2762130 Figure 1.
- TeMPOraL 7y ago> That diseases aren't exponential, who cares when exponential curves fit so nicely early on. Shouting this point does more bad than good. Outbreaks are exponential in their initial stage, to an extremely good level of approximation. Sure, they're ultimately s-shaped, but we're far from the bend point. That the growth starts to deviate from the exponent a tiny bit when half of your country is sick isn't a useful observation right now.
- hef19898 7y agoAnd ignoring the long term s-shape is just wrong. It is completely different function. Facts matter.
- cperciva 7y agoYou don't have to wait until half the country is sick, though. If you restrict movement, you see a sharp reduction in transmission when you start getting neighborhoods hitting 50%. Some will get there faster than others.
- TeMPOraL 7y agoYup. But to make that point, you have to show the trend that the disease will follow if you won't restrict movement - and shouting that "it's an S curve, not exponential" isn't particularly helpful here.
- thomasmg 7y agoTo be exact, it's a "logistic curve", which initially is exponential. From this 3Blue1Brown excellent video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Kas0tIxDvrg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Kas0tIxDvrg
- zaroth 7y agoSo how do you explain South Korea? Their cases have decisively peaked. So one of three things happened; 1) Herd immunity has kicked in, meaning a majority of people have already been infected and are recovering/recovered 2) Containment measures were effective against a highly communicative virus which can live in the air for 3 hours and on surfaces for up to 12 hours. 3) They just stopped testing and/or are lying about the results and are hiding the resulting health care burden. IMO the only one here that doesn’t require competency on the part of the government is #1, making it by far the most likely scenario. If #1 is true to any extent, then it means IFR is actually quite low, more like 2009’s H1N1. The other fundamental question I keep going back and forth on is the final total population infection rate. For H1N1 and other flus it’s usually on the order of 10-30% of the population. (There are arguments why this one might be higher, although I think some people confuse exposure numbers with infection numbers...) Containment supposedly will not meaningfully reduce this ultimate number but would just slow down how long it takes for everyone to ultimately be exposed. So while there are very few new cases in China (and they are closing their temporary hospitals) what happens when people go back to work?
- marcus_holmes 7y ago> The rest is reporting crap written every time a new case was found somewhere. This is the problem. Not that our institutions are failing to deal with the problem, but that our media has vastly overblown the whole situation in order to scare everyone witless so they'll keep clicking on news updates and watch those ads. With the secondary effect, of course, that all searches for information end up at a media outlet trying to scare people, and not the appropriate primary source of suitable information. And the tertiary effect that an institution presenting non-sensationalist data based on research is dismissed as an "inadequate response" if it doesn't match the hyperbolic media frenzy. We should be shutting down newspapers, not schools.
- hef19898 7y ago+1! And just to be sure, I would add social media. But in all seriousness, I am absolutely disappointed with the reactions of Google, Facebook, Twitter and YouTube on this. Everybody made a well deserved fuzz about the 2016 US election. So these companies are absolutely aware of this. Now that the stakes are much higher. Still no response, no action.
- whatshisface 7y agoWhat are you suggesting exactly? Do you want them to delete "alarmist" posts? That sounds like a recipe for a total collapse in trust in public institutions.
- hef19898 7y agoNo, just giving the top search spots to updates from WHO, followed by the national, regional and local sources. Play with the search algorythm to push the more alarmist ones further down. Help the above mentioned institutions to write their "content" in a social media optimized way. That would be agreat opportunity for these tech giants to gain trust they lost since 2016. Not doing anything right now moght very well have the opposite effect.
- 7y ago