8 ms·
This article contains an almost certainly incorrect assertion: "As I found while writing my 2019 book Superior: The Return of Race Science, geneticists today ri
by dekhn 7y ago
This article contains an almost certainly incorrect assertion:
"As I found while writing my 2019 book Superior: The Return of Race Science, geneticists today rightly treat eugenics as a laughable proposition, and the concept of biological race — the belief that humans can be subdivided into distinct groups with meaningful differences between them — as easily debunked nonsens"
Race (the social construct) is a proxy which only loosely correlates with genetic history. But, generally scientists believe that genetic history does allow for distinct groupings with meaningful differences. A simple example would be northern europeans with genetic differences that allow adults to drink lactose from animal milk without getting sick (an example of mutation natural selection).
It's not even controversial that higher skin melanin (associated with "black" or "dark" skin) is protective against higher solar radiation, again this is somethign that is part of genetic history, and also gets convolved with "race" frequently.
Nothing I said above is eugenics as practiced by Galton (whom we also have to thank for many important scientific contributions which last to today), or the scientists at Cold Spring Harbor Lab. They are cold, hard facts supported by immense data and are generally accepted within the field.
- thaumasiotes 7y ago> Race (the social construct) is a proxy which only loosely correlates with genetic history. The correlation is not loose -- it is extremely tight. For example, take this study: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1535610818303799 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S153561081... > To avoid confusion, in this manuscript, we categorize genetic ancestry as EA, AA, EAA, and NA, and self-identified race from TCGA as White, Black, Asian, and American Indians, and Alaska Natives. For patients with race information in TCGA, we observed that 95.6% of categorizations based on the k-NN algorithm following principal-component analysis (PCA) were consistent with race, suggesting that race and genetic ancestry identified by our approach appear to be highly correlated across TCGA patients. Or this much bigger one: https://sci-hub.tw/https://www.cell.com/ajhg/fulltext/S0002-9297(19)30338-6 https://sci-hub.tw/https://www.cell.com/ajhg/fulltext/S0002-... > Among nearly 202,000 individuals with SIRE [self-identified race/ethnicity], 1,079 (0.53%) had GIA [genetically-inferred ancestry] strongly indicating a different racial/ethnic group. These aren't two loosely correlated concepts; they're one and the same.
- kixiQu 7y agoBut lactose-tolerance is also found non-contiguously in the world, and you'll have a real hard time finding discrete "groups" defined by skin melanin rather than a spectrum. Genetic lactose tolerance exists; genetic contributions to skin color exist; these are facts---but your interpretation of them is interpretation, and that you can't see it as such is sort of the author's point.
- booboolayla 7y agoNot again with anecdotal evidence... Could we all please agree that "I know of a guy" is NOT an argument against statistical findings over a group of people?
- dekhn 7y agolactose tolerance occurs outside of europe, sporadically, but nearly always in populations that subsisted on animal milk, or obtained the gene through european parents. one thing you'll learn in genetics is that it's all statistics; not all europeans are lactose tolerant, and not all africans are lactose intolerant. But the trends are consistent with natural selection via multiple experimental methods.
- kixiQu 7y agoone thing you may yet learn in genetics is that it doesn't take pains to correspond to your social constructs. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1893020/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1893020/
- creddit 7y agoYup. It’s also pretty obvious that eugenics would work since it works just fine across plenty of other species (see dogs, cows, chickens, pigs, etc.). This article is the identity politics monstrosity coming to take more control.
- dekhn 7y agoI wouldn't use the term "eugenics" for that; I'd use the term "breeding". Part of the problem is that the eugenicists got their scientific breeding ideas mixed up with their nonscientific racism ideas. And I think suggesting that people do human breeding for desired traits would probably still be fairly unpopular.
- creddit 7y agoAgreed to both parts. I think my post is still in some sense a refutation of the selected quote in the parent.
- thaumasiotes 7y ago> And I think suggesting that people do human breeding for desired traits would probably still be fairly unpopular. Not necessarily; Yao Ming seemed to be pretty popular.
- dekhn 7y agoThat's... not really breeding in the scientific sense. Yes, having two tall parents means you're likely to be tall (height is highly heritable), but actual breeding would involve statistical populations, because nearly all traits of interest are non-mendelian, and come from effects from a wide range of genes. And also, it seems probably that you would also have to select against negative traits (for example, breeding very tall people -> all sorts of disorders).
- thaumasiotes 7y ago> That's... not really breeding in the scientific sense. ...because? He comes from an intentional breeding program on the part of the Chinese government. What more do you want? There's a big difference between "what are we doing?" and "how much are we doing it?".