12 ms·
Sonos is getting rid of its controversial “recycle mode”
- amanzi 7y agoGood decision by Sonos. Customers can use the trade up program to get a discount on new gear, and keep using the old gear (or sell it / give it away / whatever). Obviously a win for customers but this also feels like a win for Sonos - they get to sell more new gear to existing customers, while potentially getting new customers buying into the Sonos ecosystem.
- lallysingh 7y agoYeah but I think one of the hidden issues was that older equipment was getting hard to support. They're still in that pickle.
- mfer 7y agoGood design is long-lasting. It’s one of the Dieter Rams design principles. Short lifespan’s for technology that often gets thrown into dumps in the ground isn’t good for the environment
- Infinitesimus 7y agoTight hardware software integration is tough to support as hardware evolves though
- YawningAngel 7y agoI don't follow this claim. I don't think anyone expects new features to make it to old Sonos devices. What's so hard about running a version of your v1 API indefinitely and occasionally backporting a bugfix or security patch?
- londons_explore 7y agoI think the issue is not the server API, but the app to hardware and p2p comms between different bits of hardware in the same house. Assuming every different version has a few quirks and bugs, maintaining compatibility between every version and every other soon becomes impractical, especially since you probably want to build some kind of integration test that checks this all works as it should, and that probably involves a lab with all the old hardware and a human running hundreds of tests by hand because it's hard to automate tests on embedded stuff that you can no longer compile software for.
- mumblemumble 7y agoThis might be an argument for open standards being better for consumers. I don't want to say that vendors shouldn't implement custom protocols for an enhanced experience. But, as a consumer, I'd be a lot more likely to shell out for a product like this if I knew that there were a wifi speaker equivalent of PostScript, and that the speaker supported it. That gives me confidence that there will be some least-common-denominator level of functionality that I'll be able to get out of it for as long as the hardware itself lasts. As it stands, my impression is that these limited-lifespan IoT products are mostly for people whose disposable income is rather more disposable than mine is.
- tracker1 7y agoProbably the closest to what you are looking for would be a bluetooth audio interface... then using your phone or other device to do the actual playback. Chromecast devices aren't too far off themselves, I wish Google was more open with them though, per another comment learned they don't even make the audio version anymore.
- ajford 7y agoIdeal solution would be to make the control system a separate user serviceable module. For example, a smallish cartridge with perhaps a board-edge connector that can be swapped out from underneath/rear with all "digital" connectors. Then build the high-end audio gear into the chassis, such as a solid quality amp and speaker pair. That way only the the electronics needs to be swapped should the audio quality still be sufficient. I'm not an audiophile by any stretch, but I appreciate a decent speaker. That being said, solid audio equipment can last much longer than digital tech can. A system like above could even bring about a new sub-market around swappable chassis. Allow a customer to purchase a chassis in multiple styles and colors for less than a full module. That might mean people would be more willing to buy a "fashion swap" should they redecorate.
- tracker1 7y agoFor that matter, a usb3 power + standard audio interface to the speaker + amp... then you can use a pi board or any future device with single usb3 connection. It's already relatively ubiquitous.
- mfer 7y agoI can get a basic toilet. I can get fancy toilets (heated seats and more). All of them hook to the same connectors in my home. Different brands. I can hook them into pipes and connectors that are decades old. It works. This is just hardware integration. It's due to standard interfaces and being designed to last. What we build with technology now isn't designed to last. It's an intentional part of what we build even if we don't think about it much. It has an impact on end users (and even the environment... think of all the trash). The rate of interface change is intentional on some levels. And, it's something we can control.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- JohnFen 7y agoAnd yet, it certainly can (and should) be done. Many of the places that I've worked for (including my current employer) manage to do exactly that. What it requires is a well-engineered protocol (which is what Sonos apparently lacks) that allows for feature additions while maintaining backward compatibility for old hardware and software. The old hardware and software often can't use the new features, but it can continue to work as it always had before.
- givinguflac 7y agoI don’t disagree but we’re talking about some products with 2005 cpu and 32mb of ram. Big for 2005, nothing today.
- ivanfon 7y agoSounds like plenty for a speaker.
- wvenable 7y agoOld sonos users don't want new features -- they just want their existing features to keep working. That should not require more resources.
- mixmastamyk 7y agoI got a lot of real work done on a 486, and it already could calculate faster than I could read the results.
- jhallenworld 7y agoI doubt RAM is any issue, but I'm also fairly sure that they went cheap on flash memory and there is no setting higher than -9 for compression :-)
- AdamJacobMuller 7y agoTheir hardware isn't that short-lived, especially not in comparison to others. I've had some of this hardware they are discontinuing for over a decade.
- dangus 7y agoThey’re speakers, they should last longer. My decade-old desktop PC would still work fine with Windows 10, and it’s far more complex than a speaker.
- JohnFen 7y ago> while potentially getting new customers buying into the Sonos ecosystem. Perhaps. While I was unlikely to buy Sonos gear in the first place (because I avoid purchasing IoT stuff like that), if I were in the market for gear like this I would certainly not buy Sonos gear now. This step they took was good, but it doesn't erase the memory of their behavior leading up to this.
- supernovae 7y agoAs a parent, I can only laugh at this concept... I mean, I don't care what you buy, but this one strike and your out culture... There wouldn't be a living human being if we went by that as a society.
- giantrobot 7y agoWhen it comes to a company like Sonos it's not one strike and they're out. Their whole stupid "recycling" program came from a series of stupid decisions inside the company and then someone signed off on it! No one got fired for it so everyone in their decision making tree is still in place, waiting to strike. Sonos has a bunch if opportunities to signal they realized they made a mistake and correct it. Instead they doubled down. The fact the policy is still in place means they think everything is fine. I think their policy is stupid and so they're not going to get any of my dollars.
- pxtail 7y ago> Their whole stupid "recycling" program came from a series of stupid decisions inside the company and then someone signed off on it! Moreover in my perception it signals company's predatory and anti-customer philosophy and I'm convinced that sooner or later they will come up with similar "clever" idea - only difference will be that next time they will try to sell it better or just hide it better.
- fierarul 7y agoI think Sonos did the right thing by creating Recycle Mode and the over-reaction to this was amazing. Telling customers to just send the bricked device to the local recycling centre in exchange for a discount seems fair. Apple also has a trade-in program except they expect you to send them the device. Sonos took the cheaper approach by offloading the actual recycling to a local centre. But people want to have it both/all three ways: feel good about recycling, get a discount on a future new gadget and sell/give the functioning old device to somebody. Amazing.
- speedgoose 7y agoWhy sending to the recycling centre perfectly fine products ?
- yardstick 7y agoExactly this. Answer: they were too lazy to collect the returned units and clean/prep/rebox them for resale. The whole discount for recycling offer was just designed to encourage more sales, they didn’t care about the recycling bit. Maybe they should just... reduce their prices by 30%? Side note: will there now be a market for buying used Sonos devices dirt cheap just for the discount in buying new devices? Or will Sonos only offer this on the first sale.
- givinguflac 7y agoThis is wildly wrong. The whole point was that it’s a massive carbon footprint to ship them all back. Local recycling is much more environmentally friendly. Not to mention this is an optional thing regardless. The discount is offered to any owner provided it hasn’t already been claimed by a previous owner.
- zwily 7y agoThe discount only works once per device.
- fierarul 7y agoBecause a trade-in program where you sent the device to Sonos wasn't operationally / financially possible. There are extra costs with doing this in house (or, I guess, by partnering with a recycling centre) which meant the discount would have been much lower, or perhaps close to 0. But for an existing customer that did want to trade in, 30% was perhaps acceptable.
- ThePowerOfFuet 7y ago> When triggered, Recycle Mode would start an irreversible 21-day countdown, after which the device in question would cease functioning. Sonos said it went this route to ensure that consumer data was being erased on recycled products. What a crock of shit. Credibility? What's that?
- germinalphrase 7y agoMan... any good alternatives for adding Sonos multi zone functionality to a traditional stereo?
- flarg 7y agoChromecast audio while it lasts, bubble upnp also works
- dsr_ 7y agoI don't know what "traditional stereo" means to you. My music is stored on a computer sitting near a TV and a Yamaha receiver, which runs five main speakers and two subwoofers. There's a powered speaker set hooked to a Chromecast audio in another room, and a cheap old laptop running an old Yamaha receiver with 2 mains and a sub in the living room. forked-daapd (you'll want the current version out of github) runs on the main computer and has a web interface. It can talk to the Chromecast and the laptop and the main receiver to send the same audio to all of them. Delays can be adjusted. I hardly ever do that. Instead, I call up music in whatever room I'm in.
- germinalphrase 7y agoI suppose ‘traditional stereo’ means any stereo receiver that was built without smartphone connectivity. For instance, I inherited a nice receiver that was built in the early 90’s. It sounds great, but I do recognize that being able to stream music and control multi-room speakers through my smartphone (a la Sonos) is desirable.
- poooogles 7y agoEcho dot + 3.5mm to phono works fine for me.
- sethhochberg 7y agoYamaha's MusicCast platform is great for this. Pricey, and their all-in-one speakers sound worse than a Sonos One, but the WXC-50 appliance has been the core of my home audio system for years. https://usa.yamaha.com/products/audio_visual/wireless_streaming_amplifiers/wxc-50/index.html https://usa.yamaha.com/products/audio_visual/wireless_stream... They make one with a stereo amplifier built in, and also one that is just a preamp.
- dandare 7y agoSonos speakers have beautiful sound but the constant loss of connectivity is a nightmare. Just few days ago I had to reset the system once again and despite the fact that I am logged in none of my services and settings are remembered. I am very dissatisfied with Sonos and I will not buy any of their future products.
- lallysingh 7y agoI wonder what frequency range they're in. My Sonos systems have never given me that trouble. I'm guessing the difference is the kinds of local interference in their range.
- givinguflac 7y agoI’ve never had those issues it sounds like your network has problems
- mrclark411 7y agoSame here. I wish it was a little faster in changing configurations (I move some speakers around to different rooms and different pairings from time to time), but the last time I did so - it was faster/better than before.
- bestham 7y agoThis might be the issue where Sonos devices uses their own network and your network thereby crafting network loops. Do you run STP? Is one Sonos device attached via Ethernet? A lot of Unifi users are experiencing problems with Sonos due to their mesh.
- jon-wood 7y agoI was once responsible for an office network where on a semi-regular basis the entire network would collapse and become unusable. It took several days to work out that it collapsed when one particular user came into the office, and even longer to find that the Sonos iOS app does some STP magic which didn't cooperate with the cheap wireless router we were using.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- _Understated_ 7y agoEdit: earlier comment was full of shit :) What's with companies dictating what we can do with our stuff when it's EoL? People who buy this shit: Stop buying it and they'll stop forcing it on us! Please... just stop.
- 0xdeadb00f 7y agoMost of their customers probably couldn't care less, or don't know any better. It's likely the majority of their customers will still buy this shit, regardless.
- paulhart 7y agoFor those looking for an alternative solution, I'm currently running Mopidy on a Raspberry Pi connected to a old Logitech iPod speaker dock that also has an aux input, and have a music library on a home NAS (Helios4 from kobol.io). Mopidy acts as a jukebox, streaming files from the server and locally managing playlists and a queue. It enabled me to reuse my old speakers, put a RasPi to good use, and offers a responsive web UI to manipulate the queue from our phones. It was the best low-requirement open source solution I found. https://mopidy.com/ https://mopidy.com/
- givinguflac 7y agoTo each their own, but having heard all the Logitech iPod docks, they sound bad.
- narrowtux 7y agoIt can literally be any other speaker or amp with an aux port.
- givinguflac 7y agoAbsolutely, I was commenting on their choice of speaker. Not sure why that’s such a controversial comment
- fragmede 7y agoIt's not controversial, it's mostly downvoted (as of this writing). I'm guess it was downvoted because it adds ~nothing to the conversation. Might as well have commented "this", or all that was added.
- craftinator 7y agoYeah, and those gold plated HDMI connectors make the picture just so much, sharper!
- 7y ago
- ubermonkey 7y agoIt's a good move, but honestly they're moving in a direction that is less interesting to me. Ten years ago, Sonos was the sine qua non of easy home audio, becuase they were ahead of the game on interface AND gave you a great way to access your music library anywhere in your house. The extra bonus feature was their usage of a proprietary mesh network, so the music didn't stream over your increasingly-overburdened regular wifi network. Well, most of those advantages have kinda gone away. Moving in reverse: - wifi is way better now; I never have dropouts anymore. - The Sonos interface is now way, way, way behind the Apple music interface IMO. My nontechnical wife never warmed to Sonos at all, but she can use iTunes on her phone with aplomb, and playing music in the living room uses the same interface as playing music on her headphones. - Library access was a sticking point, given that Apple formerly relied on a convoluted approach here, but by subscribing to Apple Music the problem is completely sidestepped. I pay for this mostly so I don't ever have to plug my phone into the media box and sync files -- for me or for my wife. That's worth the price right there, to be honest, but in addition to that you get access to nearly anything. It's rare I can't find what I want there. (We DO still buy CDs locally, but only because we live in a place with a real indie record store.) The tl;dr is that we were already kind of Done with Sonos when this whole kerfluffle started -- we have sunk costs here, but as these devices stop functioning we'll move to something else that plugs into the Apple infrastructure better. Even if we have to revert to local music only due to some Apple failure, there are still better/easier options than Sonos at this point.
- ssully 7y agoI just got a Sonos beam a few months since it seemed like a decent soundbar for the price. I also use Apple music and I just airplay music to my Beam. Does that not work as well when you have a multi-speaker setup?
- rconti 7y agoSonos AirPlay devices are pretty new. Supposedly you only need one, and it can stream to all their devices, but the devices form a cluster, and I'm not sure how intelligent they are about making sure the device that can airplay is the device that's always the master.
- Reubachi 7y agoHOLY MOLY NSFW tag, my friend.
- JohnFen 7y agoI'm pleased that Sonos was convinced to stop doing the obviously terrible thing that it was doing.
- dang 7y agoRecent and related: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21895086 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21895086 Also https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&query=comments%3E10%20Sonos&sort=byDate&type=story https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que...
- ornornor 7y agoHow do you unbrick the ones already in “recycling” mode? Or is it too late for these and they’re now landfill fodder?
- throwaway77384 7y agoOh Sonos, you have caused me so much joy and pain. I have multiple wifi access points in my (solid brick) house, because nothing seems to be able to penetrate these walls. When Sonos works it's great. When it doesn't, I end up spending half an hour having to reset everything to get my randomly disappearing speakers back. Some are wired, some are wifi, some are on powerline adapters. It's quite a hodge-podge, but none of my other devices have any issues with the setup, so why does Sonos decide to die randomly from time to time? I've gone through the trouble of switching wifi channels, trialling different ones, just to see if anything improves the situation, but there is no regularity in the failures. It either happens, or it doesn't. I also do not appreciate that Sonos is seemingly all about streaming services. I wish local NAS playback wasn't treated as second-class citizen...it's the only way I use Sonos.