12 ms·
It is disappointing that the US got all of the authoritarian surveillance that China did but few/none of the safety/planning upsides it could be used to bring.
by sneak 7y ago
It is disappointing that the US got all of the authoritarian surveillance that China did but few/none of the safety/planning upsides it could be used to bring. It’s the worst of all possible configurations.
I wish that extremely large government would use its vast resources to plan for large risks other than “people with guns/bombs/tanks/missiles/planes want to kill us”, and focus at least some of that on emergency preparedness. Why isn’t there a strategic nationwide domestic reserve of supplies for emergencies? I know this is what FEMA is supposed to be doing, but they are utterly terrible at it.
If we’re paying most of a trillion dollars each year for defense, why not defend us at least a little bit against stuff that might well happen sooner or later: giant fires, flooding, pandemics, big/long power outages, fuel shortages, water or food shortages, ice storms, et c? It’s really disappointing to see almost 100% of that money going to a system that is focused more on war (which is, to varying degrees, mostly preventable) and almost none to natural catastrophes (which are absolutely inevitable).
- pfdietz 7y agoUnless there's rapid production of a vaccine or an effective antiviral drug, I think China's system probably won't help them that much. There will be too much opportunity for reinfection from the rest of the world, and inside China as they have to relax restrictions to keep production going.
- arminiusreturns 7y agoThat wouldn't line the pockets of the oligarchs and the good ol boy network, because it would require the money to actually go to resources and not just overblown accounting entries to cover the pocketbook lining in the first place. The DC elite say fluffy words in public but in private are almost to a person "fuck you I got mine" people. They take oaths but don't mean them. It's the sad truth that greed is the largest part of it, which enables the oligarchs to buy the politicians in the first place. Then if some rare person does resist, there are a whole slew of tools to use against them to force compliance, usually in the realm of blackmail (this is what Epstein was). These tools grow even more powerful as the surveillance engine is expanded (and the truism to remember is that surveillance is about control, not security). lookup Thomas Drake and William Binney to find out what happens to people on the inside who actually care about security and not control. Top down compromise of a centralized system makes the system increasingly trivial to control as the compromise progresses.
- easytiger 7y ago> That wouldn't line the pockets of the oligarchs and the good ol boy network Step back for a minute and think about what you are writing and how you came to such a childish view of the world
- bitcharmer 7y agoI'd say his viewpoint is quite realistic and based on common knowledge. It's comments like yours that are childish. If you really believe the structure of US expenses isn't heavily impacted by interests of a few rich, powerful men then I'd call your view of the world very naive.
- duxup 7y agoPeople don't vote for flood protection. They do like military spending. I think sometimes folks wrap up the political will of the people in "oligarchy" simply because they don't like what those folks want or value.
- Hokusai 7y agoThe public if largely mislead on the risk of epidemics, flooding, etc. Democracy needs education to run smoothly. There is many studies that show that the government aligns strongly with big money. Just look at the state of health care as an example.
- duxup 7y agoWhat are the risks of epidemics that people don't understand? I don't doubt money influences things, but also I don't buy into what seems like an all or nothing theory here that the only driver is money or some vague "money". In an capitalist society money will be... everywhere in most every market. It's awfully easy to point that out.
- 7y ago
- joe_the_user 7y agoIndeed, It seems like the state spent vast time and effort to "find weaknesses" but didn't, say, correct the frickin' weaknesses. Bureaucrats with so much latitude they can spend their entire budget on entertaining war games rather, say, emergency medical supplies.
- duxup 7y agoI suspect many of the changes have to be legislative. I don't think most of those organizations can simply restructure themselves at will to deal with a potential small pox attack. That doesn't occur in some sort of "oligarchy" as you describe it.
- bamboozled 7y ago...climate change.
- duxup 7y agoThe leadership that people vote for are interested in "people with guns ...". I know of no political will to restructure government to better handle a small pox attack. People vote on other topics. I'm also a bit skeptical about the theory that China's "upside" isn't simply bypassing the media, ethical and other concerns noted in the article by simply controlling the media, information, and not dealing with ethical concerns. I'm also a bit skeptical about what if any "upside" they have considering their controls on information. I'm not sure you want that....
- Nasrudith 7y agoYeah it has always been Propaganda that their unchecked power "helps the trains run on time". Even naively it is clear that there is a subset of power needed to actually make the trains run on time is vastly smaller than absolute power - it just wouldn't be exploitable which is what they actually want. They will complain about all limitations and scheme to seize it. The actual solution is to evaluate their claims in and refute them in detail and summary and fire the power hungry bastards out. Sadly this option is seldom taken or else we would have an Intelligence Aparatus which understands why trying to limit encryption when your international economy depends upon it both directly and indirectly is a moronic idea.
- quakegen 7y agoSurveillance and Big Data weren't a big thing in 2001. Shit happened after 9/11.
- lmilcin 7y agoThat would require, you know... honest effort. It is well known bias to under or overestimate rare events. It requires discipline and honest effort to properly estimate probabilities and attach them to possible effects and then follow through with proper response. A special category is events that might end civilization/nation/locality etc. as we know it. Compared to more mundane problems, you want a special kind of insurance against them. In the infinite game the objective is not to beat everybody else but to avoid those special events that might end your ability to play altogether.
- TeMPOraL 7y agoThe problem is, like always, other people. The market is built on lots of small actors doing local, short-term optimizations. So let's say you're a supplier, and you come up with a disciplined, honest estimate of a buffer you need in your supply chain to cope with the next epidemic. This raises your costs, and as a buyer who cares primarily about next quarter's report sheets, I'll go with your competitor who doesn't include any safety margin, because they'll be cheaper. Will this land me into trouble in a few years? Probably, but that's out of scope of quarterly reporting, and thus not my problem. Ultimately, the society is enslaved to the aggregate market pressures. We won't fix things until we can figure out how to build safety margins into the market and make them stick.
- marcosdumay 7y agoThat's why people created that government thing, that isn't subject to market pressures.
- protomyth 7y agoWhy isn’t there a strategic nationwide domestic reserve of supplies for emergencies? I know this is what FEMA is supposed to be doing, but they are utterly terrible at it. Read the original enabling documents for FEMA and you'll be surprised at what they actually had the power and funding to do.
- zeveb 7y ago> If we’re paying most of a trillion dollars each year for defense, why not defend us at least a little bit against stuff that might well happen sooner or later: giant fires, flooding, pandemics, big/long power outages, fuel shortages, water or food shortages, ice storms, et c? The best answer is that the federal constitution gives the Congress the authority to fund a navy and an army, but is silent on the matter of 'giant fires, flooding, pandemics, big/long power outages, fuel shortages, water or food shortages, ice storms &c.' — and due to the Tenth Amendment, that means that the states are individually responsible for that. I think that it'd make sense to pass an amendment to give the federal government some power in this area.
- isaacgreyed 7y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Necessary_and_Proper_Clause https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Necessary_and_Proper_Clause
- zeveb 7y agoThat merely states 'The Congress shall have Power … To make all Laws which shall be necessary and proper for carrying into Execution the foregoing Powers, and all other Powers vested by this Constitution in the Government of the United States, or in any Department or Officer thereof.' Congress has the power to pass laws which are necessary and proper to carrying out the powers the states granted it in the Constitution. That doesn't mean that it has the power to pass any laws whatsoever, and even if it did the Tenth Amendment would supersede it. The Constitution simply doesn't grant the United States general power to deal with natural disasters, so there is nothing necessary and proper for the federal government to do.
- sneak 7y ago...and yet we have the Deparment of Education, FEMA, and the Department of Health/CDC.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 7y agoI think there is far less surveillance than everyone thinks.
- bregma 7y agoOf course you say that here. What do you say when they're not watching you?
- sneak 7y agoI think that you thinking that is not an accident. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Utah_Data_Center https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Utah_Data_Center The lower bound on Forbes' estimate of its capacity is 3 million TB, and it consumes 65MW. What precisely do you think they are storing there? > Binney has said that the facility was built to store recordings and other content of communications, not only for metadata. > The project had been designed for foreign signals intelligence (SIGINT) collection but, Binney alleged, after the September 11, 2001, terrorist attacks, controls that limited unintentional collection of data pertaining to U.S. citizens were removed, prompting concerns by him and others that the actions were illegal and unconstitutional.
- Accujack 7y agoFYI, 3 million TB is enough to store 1 copy of the data that transfers over the Internet in the US for about a 15 month time span. It's not enough really, because in addition to the Internet data, they'd have to be storing cell phone data and potentially other sources of information plus all the metadata needed to organize it into something useful. More importantly, sorting through that amount of data to find anything is nearly impossible, even if you have 65MW of servers running. Even the entire Amazon cloud would have difficulty, simply because of the scale of the problem. So yeah, they're storing a lot of data compared to the average corporation, but not compared to the amount that exists nor are they storing all data that gets transferred. It's just too much. From a certain point of view, there's less surveillance going on than you might think, simply because collecting everyone's information all the time is impractical to do and pretty useless.
- 7y ago
- freen 7y agoGentle reminder that just because you don’t know it exists, doesn’t mean it’s nonexistent. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Strategic_National_Stockpile https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Strategic_National_Stockpile
- carlosdp 7y agoThere was literally an article about it on the HN front page earlier this week, this comment should be higher.
- sneak 7y agoI saw the responses they've recently made to hurricanes and fires and now the coronavirus, and they were all woefully inadequate. Just because they have a big building somewhere prepping for a smallpox attack doesn't mean they're in any way whatsoever prepared for the actual issues that people are having, today and in the recent past. https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1235695757652459520.html https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1235695757652459520.html > The U.S. Congress appropriated funds for the CDC to create a pharmaceutical and vaccine stockpile to handle biological and chemical threats from disease that could affect large numbers of the U.S. civilian population. The original name was the National Pharmaceutical Stockpile (NPS) program, but since the original authorization additional materials have been added to the stockpile. Again, I think this is way too threat-actor focused. I'm reminded so much of George C Scott's character in Dr. Strangelove. We're much more likely to end up underwater or on fire or without crops or with a water shortage or with a novel virus that simply evolved than someone seeding bioweapons for which we already have medicines/vaccines. This simply isn't about responding to an attack. It's about helping people stay alive when the normal order of society goes tits up. We've seen this again and again, most recently in Puerto Rico and California. If the federal government has prepared for this in any meaningful way, we've yet to see it out in the field during previous disasters. We have, however, seen them manage to continue to wage the longest war in US history, whilst people in Oakland were making zip-tie homemade not-quite-HEPA filters and wearing "face masks" made out of bandanas because available civilian supplies everywhere had run out when half of California caught fire, to say nothing of the death toll resulting from the long-running power outages in Puerto Rico after Maria. I really don't think a warehouse full of vaccines and antibiotics sitting in DC is any help to the people in diabetic comas in San Juan because their insulin fridge's generator ran out of fuel after weeks of no power, nor will it be if due to the coronavirus spreading too much, ICUs across the country are swamped with cases of viral pneumonia. I hope I'm wrong and that the federal government is going to magically pull something actually helpful out of their ass if this thing goes big, but I would put my money on them being about as helpful as they were during any other recent large natural disaster affecting US citizens: approximately zero. Also, TFA refutes some of the claims at the Strategic National Stockpile Wikipedia page: > There is no surge capability in the U.S. healthcare and public health systems,[5] or in the pharmaceutical and vaccine industries.[4]
- sky_rw 7y ago> Why isn’t there a strategic nationwide domestic reserve of supplies for emergencies? There is: https://www.phe.gov/about/sns/Pages/default.aspx https://www.phe.gov/about/sns/Pages/default.aspx
- Shivetya 7y agowell not to excuse FEMA for issues it has had but you are guilty of the same issue many other are, you grossly underestimate the true scope of the problem you are suggesting we gear up for. I remember all the bellyaching over the response to Katrina and FEMA if not other Federal agencies which paid lip service to the area affected but not the realization of that meant. Hint, the affected area was the size of Great Britain. Comparing how China does it ignores that we don't truly know how China does it. We get what comes out of China and then end up having to rely on sources that may not be reputable for more truth. They simply can make history what they want it to be, even WHO didn't stand up to them as others have completely collapsed when it comes to pursuing cornavirus and previous flu related strains that just magically appear in China. Back to FEMA. Understand that each state and locality all also contribute to disaster preparedness but it all comes down to what will likely happen and how to get resources to the affected groups. Many of these groups are loathe towards any relinquishment of authority to the Federal government; heck some cities don't even care for state intervention. Worse some of the combativeness occurs just because of political party differences! So coordinate your national response with fifty states and how many cities? We are setup so that a Federal government cannot just curb stomp a state's rights. By the way, not only do we spend nearly a trillion on defense but that is less than twenty percent of the Federal expenditure. There is a lot of money that can be better used but the default of just blaming the defense budget grows less and less useful when as a percentage of the budget it is falling behind; not fast enough but both parties seem quite willing to prop it up