11 ms·
Interview with Paul Graham
- PouyaL 7y agoQuite like the phrase on inequality "Perhaps the reason the pie fallacy is so prevalent is that it’s in our DNA."
- goto11 7y agoIts a fallacy to call it a fallacy though. Sure, many forms of wealth is not zero sum, but some are. For example political influence correlate with wealth and is basically zero-sum. So larger economic inequality concentrate power among fewer people. This is pretty significant whether you consider it a good or a bad thing.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- PouyaL 7y agoThe things though here is that comes rather neutral. Neither bad nor a good, but false or positive symptoms. That could a better starting point to take actions to strengthen the positive ones and get rid of false.
- Dirlewanger 7y agoThere's no doubt it's in our DNA. Forming groups with likeminded people is what kept our species alive for hundreds of thousands of years. And it's only been in the past ~150 years that we as a civilization have started to seriously care about the wellbeing of others unlike themselves. We've undoubtedly come a far way, but that's not to say we don't have much further to go. Fighting with our innate tribalistic tendencies is hard.
- piker 7y agoInteresting to see PG worrying about coronavirus. Otherwise somewhat of a bizarre series of interview questions, including asking him to opine on seemingly random quotes. Perhaps there is some non-obvious context.
- celticninja 7y agoPerhaps to push the post YC depression post off the top spot? https://www.bmaho.com/articles/post-yc-depression https://www.bmaho.com/articles/post-yc-depression
- efxz 7y agoYou don't? You should. Everyone should.
- flexie 7y ago"The exit “tax” seems the most alarming to me. Though it’s called a tax, it’s really just confiscation. And if you look at the other countries in history that have confiscated the property of people who tried to leave, it’s not company you’d want to be in" - Denmark currently has what is in effect an exit tax on rich people. It's a complicated tax and changed all the time in order to dodge EU requirements on the freedom of movement between EU countries. PG probably wouldn't want to be in Denmark since after all he exchanged chilly and grey England with warm and sunny California, but Denmark is hardly among the worst places in the world in which to live or do business.
- aliceryhl 7y agoWhat is this tax called? As someone who lives in Denmark, it would be nice to know.
- mjul 7y agoIt is called “fraflytteraktieavanceskat”. It is a capital gains tax for equities that can be paid at once as if you had sold the shares, or you can delay it by filling out a form every year to the Danish tax authorities after moving abroad.
- radres 7y agoCapital gains tax is not the same as exit tax though?
- anovikov 7y agoWell capital gains tax is pretty much normal, it exists in most places. As for exit tax in the U.S., i really wonder how one could enforce it. So if you left the country and have another passport (otherwise you couldn't drop U.S. citizenship), what can they possibly do to you? I don't think this absurd leftist idea even deserves much attention or comments, someone just said bs without thinking of it much.
- andyjpb 7y ago
- yodsanklai 7y ago> Soon I’m going to have to say enough is enough, and push the coronavirus into a corner of my mind so I can have room to think about other things again. I'm in the same boat. I'm not particularly worried about the coronavirus, but I spent too many hours discussing and looking for information.
- DrNuke 7y agoI think the point here is as soon as any “guru” is brought out of his / her superior and acknowledged niche expertise, the universal, human frailty prevails and coronavirus is the plague of today. Keep well, folks (and every man for himself).
- thundergolfer 7y agoDidn’t Charlie Munger say something apt like: “I’m smart in spots, and I stay around those spots.”
- quantumwoke 7y agoQuite a diverse range of topics for pg from politics to epidemiology. Interesting to see that juxtaposition between his ultra-capitalist viewpoints with his isolationist stance on coronavirus. The latter comes across to me as a little out of touch with both the disease and his risk factors compared to the general population. To me the wealthy retired have a responsibility to be educated yet critical on current events such as coronavirus.
- dntbnmpls 7y agoIt felt less like a real interview and more like a pre-arranged/pre-planned "message". > Why do so many even well-educated people think in zero-sum terms if all they need to do is separate the idea of money from material wealth? Because many well-educated honest people know that wealth = power and power is a zero sum game. It's the well-educated dishonest people who keep insisting everyone focus on the superficial non-zero sum nature of wealth and ignore the zero-sum consequences of wealth in relation to power. If that interview room was the world and PG and the interviewer were the only people in the world and they produced 1 handgun and 1 nerf gun, they increased wealth. But that increased wealth is meaningless isn't it? What's important is who gets the handgun and who gets the nerf gun because it affects the power relation in the room and power is zero sum. If PG gained power, then the interviewer necessarily loses power. And vice versa. Historically, it's always those with wealth/power who insists everyone look at the non-zero sum nature of wealth. A king or a slave owner says to a serf or a slave that increased wealth is good for everyone. Of course the king and slave owner would take greater portion of the wealth which increases their relative power over the serf or the slave. It's the same dynamic in north korea or with a pimp and a prostitute. Even if the greater wealth in north korea slightly benefits the poor, it still leaves them worse off vis-a-vis "dear leader" who takes a greater share of the wealth. Nevermind that if the percentages were reversed ( people get the lions share and "dear leader" gets a smaller slice ), the wealth would still have increased. But PG would probably say that's unfair or confiscation. > Though it’s called a tax, it’s really just confiscation. All taxes are confiscations then. > Interestingly, though, this policy shows how quickly socialism turns into authoritarianism. And there you have it. The agenda. Also, it's not like capitalism hasn't confiscated either? Entire continents of land was confiscated by capitalism. Entire races of people's labor was confiscated by capitalism. Wars have been started, governments overthrown and resources stolen in the name of capitalism. > But on the other hand, I’m one of the few people who can say heterodox things without worrying about getting fired. Or banned. > So if I don’t say these things, who will? Nothing in the interview was "heterodox". What heterodox statements has PG made? > The top idea in my mind right now, to be honest, is Covid-19. Was wondering why there has been a sudden surge of covid-19 posts lately. Frankly, this is why podcast interviews are so popular and tv/mag/etc interviews are not. There is no genuine free-flow exchange of ideas or honesty. It's just pre-arranged robotic soul-less talking points. It's the interview equivalent of the potemkin village. It has the fake facade of an interview, but there is no real interview.
- liqla 7y agoTo some extent, the pie fallacy exists. But if your major life work is Viaweb (which was really worthless and sold during the bubble to Yahoo contacts), perhaps you should not talk about pies. There are a huge number of Open Source contributors here who have produced way more wealth than Graham.
- nickpp 7y agoPaul Graham's major life work (so far) looks to be YC, not Viaweb.
- akp10 7y agoThe pivotal work (with rtm and trevorj!) was Viaweb. Without that he would not have been able to start YC. Also I presume he had substantial help in starting YC. Many successful people like Bechtolsheim and Khosla go into the VC business. Still these two would probably list Sun as their major work. The OSS contributor comment still applies: In the technology business one would need to go into the league of companies like Intel to even start comparing the wealth generated by companies vs. the wealth generated by OSS.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- jannotti 7y agoI mean, he had to learn to read too. If not for that, he'd never have founded viaweb! True, but not very interesting. I happen to think both were fairly innovative. Both viaweb and YC were at the forefront of a newish idea that seems pretty obvious in retrospect: Server based applications, and startup incubators. Both existed before to some extent, but pg recognized their value pretty quickly, and did them both well enough to make an impact. (I'd learn toward more credit incubators and less for server-based apps, but whatever.)
- alqwlsq 7y agoI think you are rewriting history. Viaweb was selling shovels (enable small businesses to generate websites) Ycombinator is selling shovels (enable people to launch startups, initially for an outrageously low investment). Selling shovels was one of the fundamental concepts during the first bubble, nothing new. Webshops were nothing new either. His innovation was turning startups into movement, largely using this website and blog about it so tirelessly (always using the term "startup") that he is credited with the concept.
- dangus 7y agoIt seems like Paul Graham is being asked a bunch of questions not at all related to his field of expertise. I point out once again that the only reason he’s on the front page here is his association with YC. He often has nothing revelatory to say and yet he’s on here due to the cult of personality. Every time I mention this it stirs up controversy which in itself kind of proves my point. People want to hear what this dude says because they fantasize about the pure-luck impossibility selling a company to Yahoo! years ago and getting to spend the rest of your life as a semi-retired wealthy man with ample time to write essays.
- skrebbel 7y agoThis is like complaining when an interviewer asks Brad Pitt for life hacks. I.e. it's like complaining about every celebrity biopic ever. Your point is valid, just like my argument that the sky is blue.
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoExcept tech folks are supposed to be more evidence-driven, and not prone to praising pointless fluff as wisdom. Worth mentioning at least, to warn the careless to not get sucked in?
- hackinthebochs 7y agoThe fact that PG was a founder, then went on to build a company/investment vehicle that is relevant to founders is "evidence" of relevant celebrity in this space.
- dangus 7y agoDo you think this is the sort of forum that should turn to posting celebrity biopics? If you like, I could post some stories about the kind of clothes Mark Zuckerberg is wearing today. Personally, I’d prefer to see interesting technical or related content and I’m disappointed that other people interested in technology upvoted an article about what a wealthy person thinks of Elizabeth Warren.
- 7y ago
- ones_and_zeros 7y agoSince I follow paulg on twitter I don't have to read the article to know where this is going. On twitter paulg is a "capitalist idealogue" (a term someone else used to describe him which I thought fit very well). and that comes with all sorts of controversial points of view. The most entertaining/snarky way I can describe it is he is a try hard auditioning for the role of Peter Thiel's best friend. It's a little disappointing considering the regard I held for him for so long. I try to separate the essays from the twitter account.
- baron_harkonnen 7y agoDoes PG earnestly believe that the critique of income inequality and capitalistic exploitation in general is really "everyone should get a fair piece of pie!"? I have a hard time believing a Harvard PhD and rapid support of capitalism has never encountered a critique of the topic outside of a third grader's worldview.
- hef19898 7y agoThe one poit I dont quite get is the connection between economic inequality and "noone should support founders". The one has nothing to do with the other, you can support founders and support initiatives to decrease economic inequality at the same time. Generally, i don't like the view that there is nothing between radical capitalism on the one side and stalinist communism on the other. And that everything that is not 100% "true capitalism" is automatically socialism hich is, by the above logic, stalinism style communism. Every European country prooves otherwise.
- andyjpb 7y agoThe article draws heavily from his essays and both the questions and answers assume a good familiarity with them. In at least one of his essays he argues that founding a company creates wealth and wealth creation does two things. 1) Makes society as a whole better off. i.e. "A rising tide lifts all boats", so the poorest in society benefit as well as the richest. The mean value of all individual's wealth increases. 2) Increases inequality because the distance between richest and poorest increases. The variance in individual's wealth across the population increases. Of course, these are just arguments he puts forth. Others may disagree with them. ...but I think it's worth trying to understand the distinction he makes between "inequality", "wealth creation" and "improving society as a whole".
- hef19898 7y agoActually I came accross PG's essays before I discovered YC. Historically I think he's right. Even the poorest ones in today's western world are still better of in most aspects than most of the richest ones back in, say, the 16th and 17th and even 18th century. Easily. He even once wrote, no idea in which essays, that he would prefer to be poor in an advanced society to be rich in an non-advanced one (something along these lines). Now, as we know that automation and software are enabling companies, and their investors / founders (with VCs investors more than founders IMHO), to create a lot of whealth that is not very well distributed across society. Which we see every day. So, working from his earlier statement on which society he would rather life in had he the choice, I assume PG has some level of understanding about the social realities. He is now also in a position to actually do something about it, him being arguably very rich and influential in his own way. And what is he doing? Arguing against taxes for the rich to make life easier for the poor, against reducing the economic and social distribution and faisness in society. Because, according to him as far as I understood his later essays, as long as everybody can be enabled to found a company that problem will go away. Which it will not, not everyone can start one, regardless of access to capital. And even then most of the return will end up in the hands of the rich investor class with founders being more often than not cogs in the system. Call the opposite approch socialism if you want, but if we as a socuiety don't think about these issues, hard, we will end up in deep trouble. Not just in the US where these problems are way more extreme than in Europe. I'm just way beyond believing that rich people will voluntarily do something about the poor if it would cost them a single dime.
- patrec 7y ago> But on the other hand, I’m one of the few people who can say heterodox things without worrying about getting fired. So if I don’t say these things, who will? Has Paul Graham ever made use of this freedom?
- PedroBatista 7y agoHe has been talking bs for more than a decade, but I don't know if that's just him being in his bubble taking himself too seriously or saying heterodox things because it's all relative.
- patrec 7y agoWell, I'll settle for BS if it's heterodox BS -- any examples?
- krapp 7y agoI haven't read every essay he's written, but to me it seems like his "heterodoxy" is relatively weak. He won't be fired for his opinions but he's not going to risk his reputation by doing something actually controversial, like denouncing capitalism or calling out the racism and misogyny in his own industry.
- patrec 7y agoThis is was my impression as well, hence asking. I dimly recall him getting zinged by some fringe enforcer group once or twice, but not because what he was saying was genuinely heterodox, simply to tighten the overtone window a bit on that side. I agree with him that financial independence and a bully pulpit give one freedom and, as a public spirited person at least, responsibility to make use of that freedom to voice otherwise supressed opinions that merit some airing (whether correct or not). If he's actually doing it, it would certainly enhance my opinion of him.
- jiveturkey 7y agoYeah I mean we don't have to go far to find someone that actually is taking a risk. Peter Thiel comes to mind.
- the_watcher 7y ago> a new Lisp dialect written in itself called Bel (2019). Is this accurate? I thought it was a spec for a new Lisp?
- drcode 7y agoHe wrote an implementation too, but he hasn't released it yet because he says it's too alpha for now. BTW, I'm like the world's biggest fan of PG's Lisp work, but given that the bel spec doesn't have an efficient association data type in 2020, I find it completely impossible to take it seriously. (This is speaking as someone who wrote a production app in arc that is still in use)
- the_watcher 7y agoGot it, thanks!
- tabtab 7y agoRe: Interestingly, though, this policy shows how quickly socialism turns into authoritarianism. That's a slippery-slope fallacy. Anything can "slip" further. If you claim X is more slippery than Y, you need to provide solid evidence. I'd rather hear his opinion on start-ups and technology rather than politics.