5 ms·
"I just can't understand any of it." Neither can those of us who live here. I mean, I can kind of understand the series of historical accidents of how we got
by jimbokun 16y ago
"I just can't understand any of it."
Neither can those of us who live here.
I mean, I can kind of understand the series of historical accidents of how we got here. What I can't understand are the politicians promising to fight tooth and nail to roll back the very minor reforms just enacted, and all of the people who enthusiastically just voted them into office last election, based on that platform.
- marshray 16y agoThose "minor reforms" were 10,000 pages long and I doubt that anyone understands them except the lobbyists who wrote them.
- gnaritas 16y ago> Those "minor reforms" were 10,000 pages long So what? We live in a litigious society, laws are verbose because they have to be. Make it too vague and you just force the issues to be resolved in the courts making it even more confusing because the rules become written in case law.
- marshray 16y agoThe "what" is that our so-called "lawmakers" hadn't written it, much less read it, understood it, and debated it in any rational way before they voted on it. Call me an idealist, but I think that's bad. Like a tax code, usually these kinds of things end up working out mostly to the benefit of the larger parties who pay the most lawyers and professional staff to find and execute on the loopholes.
- krschultz 16y agoI don't know, it took about a year for them to pass it. I understand it fairly well because I've read a lot of perspectives on it from both sides. The "IT'S SO DAMN LONG NOBODY CAN UNDERSTAND IT AND THEY SHOVED IT DOWN OUR THROATS SO FAST" is just a tactic to try and sway people who haven't been following in detail to be against it. Anything trying to change this convoluted system is going to be complicated. I do engineering for government contracts. The spec for the system I work on covers thousands of pages. I've read about 6" thick worth of it and that is less than 10%. But they detail down to the most minute thing what you are allowed to do and not allowed to do. The big picture stuff fits on the first 10 pages, and then they drill down into exactly what kind of thread you can have on a fastener and exactly how you are allowed to stress a weld for the next 1,000 pages. But it stems from previous experiences and errors, and it leads to a better product (though a more expensive one). So I don't think "# of pages" should ever be a metric for judging a law.
- marshray 16y agoThe "IT'S SO DAMN LONG NOBODY CAN UNDERSTAND IT AND THEY SHOVED IT DOWN OUR THROATS SO FAST" is just a tactic to try and sway people who haven't been following in detail to be against it. Yeah, well what you said is just a tactic to try and sway people to think what you believe. See where that line of reasoning goes? I do engineering for government contracts. The spec for the system I work on covers thousands of pages. I've read about 6" thick worth of it I've read and implemented big specs too and I know how much work they take to produce. And I know darn well it wasn't some committee of smart and well-intentioned elected representatives that wrote it. then they drill down into exactly what kind of thread you can have on a fastener and exactly how you are allowed to stress a weld for the next 1,000 pages. But it stems from previous experiences and errors, and it leads to a better product (though a more expensive one). Are you seriously claiming the health care bill is so big because it's a precise engineering document which "stems from previous experiences and errors, and it leads to a better product"? If so, how much does 10,000 pages of high-quality engineering documentation cost to produce? Who do you think paid for it? I think you're just imagining that it's what you want it to be.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- protomyth 16y agoWell, the health bill that was passed had a lot of the standard "real rules coming later" in it. So, actually reading the bill didn't give much information either. I was really interested in what would be an acceptable insurance based on deductible.
- leot 16y agoIf this were something the health insurance lobbyists wanted, why have the health insurance companies spent so much in the last election to try and overturn it?
- marshray 16y agoMaybe they didn't like the outcome either. But the bigger reason is probably that ultimately they know the key to maximizing their long-term profitability is to funnel as much money into Washington DC as they possibly can. There will be more laws regulating healthcare in the future. Baby boomers are going to be using a lot of healthcare in the coming decades and retired people vote. The debates will be no less political.
- haploid 16y agoI can give you one perspective. Moral hazard and fairness. The vast majority of costs borne by and in the US healthcare system are the results of overeating, oversmoking, and underexercising. Period. Heart disease, many forms of cancer, diabetes, most forms of pancreatic, gallbladder, and adrenal conditions, are largely the result of personal choice. Setting aside for a moment the fact that congenital defects, hereditary disorders, infections, and accidents are no fault of the victim/patient, it should be important to note that a system that REQUIRES those who take care of their health by eating and exercising properly to subsidize the consequences of the choices of those who do not, is taken by many Americans to be fundamentally unfair. If legislative initiative were taken to find a way to exclude universal coverage of lifestyle diseases, while still permitting universal coverage of non-lifestyle conditions, many people would not have such a viscerally negative reaction to the notion of universal health care.
- rdouble 16y agoThe same lifestyle diseases are at the top of the list for every country that already has some form of universal health care.
- potatolicious 16y agoI'll admit it - I'm a former fatty (BMI 34). In Canada the government paid to send me to a dietician, along with an 8-week course that now makes me more informed about nutrition and dietary choices than most of the population. That played no small part in getting me back in shape. A single-payer/public system has a strong incentive to preventatively fight lifestyle diseases in a way that bickering insurance companies simply do not.
- joe_the_user 16y agoYes, it's not like US-style unhealthy behavior stops at the US border...
- Lewisham 16y agoThe thing to do, is if your health care is paid for by taxes (like the NHS), is for taxes to be levied proportionately on the higher-risk things that will hospitalize you. The UK already has sky-high taxation on tobacco. I rather like the idea of the Fat Tax as well. Placing a tax on fat content would increase the proportion of earnings used for the NHS by those who would use it the most. It would also provide a disincentive to eat unhealthy in the first place. Of course, many many people think this smells a lot like social engineering (what isn't at government level?), so this wouldn't pass in the UK, let alone the US. Lots of good background on Fat Tax in the References at http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fat_tax http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fat_tax
- greendestiny 16y agoI have to be honest as someone else from a country with universal health care I'm not sure I can tell if the reforms are actually an improvement.
- jacoblyles 16y agoThe United States spends more per capita on health care than any other country in the world. Health cost inflation is the number one problem with the US health care market. If care were cheaper, coverage would expand and costs would be less of a burden. In my opinion, the "very minor reforms" you mentioned will probably accelerate health cost inflation by subsidizing more consumption of health care goods and offering no incentive for offsetting conservation. They may ease the symptoms for a time, but they will exacerbate the underlying illness.
- mkramlich 16y ago> What I can't understand are the politicians promising to fight tooth and nail to roll back the very minor reforms just enacted, and all of the people who enthusiastically just voted them into office last election, based on that platform. It's the Republican Party. They serve a certain set of masters. This set of masters is not the everyday Joe. This should be old news. Unfortunately it is not. And yes some folks vote for them that probably should not, but we have a sort of Bell Curve of intelligence and education out there -- though everyone's vote counts exactly the same -- combined with a variety of different levels of empathy for others, combined with a propaganda-rich media environment. This is what happens under those conditions. Ideally, we want to change these underlying conditions.