10 ms·
"This concern — that Google might just give up on Stadia at some point and kill the service, as it has done with so many other services over the years — was rep
by Animats 7y ago
"This concern — that Google might just give up on Stadia at some point and kill the service, as it has done with so many other services over the years — was repeatedly brought up, unprompted, by every person we spoke with for this piece."
That's a terrible reputation for any company to have.
In addition to Stadia, it seems to be killing off Improbable's Spatial OS, which is a back-end system for very large world MMOs. Originally, that had to run on Google Cloud. Three of the first games shut down, partly because the costs for that service are high. Nobody big is using it.
- Polylactic_acid 7y agoIts so much worse in this case than other google services. Normally when google kills a service you just move to an alternative, no big deal. But now google is holding on to hundreds to thousands of your dollars in game purchases. They obviously wont keep running a server for you for free forever so eventually if you use stadia you will lose your games. Its just a matter of when.
- Fr0styMatt88 7y agoThis is the thing that baffles me the most. You pay the full price for games you don't even own? At least with Steam there's the possibility of downloading your library in case Steam ever goes away for whatever reason. The other thing is - they must, must be playing the multi-year long game here. Infrastructure around the world just isn't ready for game streaming. Having said that, from what I hear GeForce Now is giving people a FAR better experience than Stadia. Now that I think about it, why did they even rush Stadia out? I never got the impression anyone was dying to get their hands on it. They could have given it another year of polish at least and nobody would have complained, surely? I'd love to hear Google's internal rationale for why they thought this pricing model was a good idea.
- ansq 7y agoA few possible reasons: 1. You can't foresee competition, why give up early. 2. It's a big market, worth a shot even if it fails. 3. Someone thought the project would be good for their promotion. This happens more frequently than you might think :)
- simonh 7y agoYou’re probably right, but worth a shot even if it fails is a terrible reason. Not only will they screw over their customers, but they’ll get even more of a reputation for doing so than they have already. If you keep on moving fast and breaking things, people who don’t like it when you break their stuff are going to think twice about trusting you.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- htrp 7y agoItem 3.... Google's promotion process is heavily biased towards launching of new products
- eru 7y agoI agree with most of what you say. One thing: some pockets of the world do have good enough internet already, and they are only going to multiply.
- BiteCode_dev 7y agoEven with the most amazing internet, there is nothing less reliable than a network. I've traveled in so many countries, and the ones with the best fiber in the world can't guaranty a stable ping for the entire day. This is what makes so many online games frustrating. I played MOBAs for a long time, and there is nothing more irritating than losing because you didn't get an information at the right time. Now a non multiplayer game is not real time, so you can put mitigation measures in place, but it can't fix everything, especially for games where the rhythm is important: plateformers, FPS, racing games, etc. We put up with it in multi-players game because there is no alternative. But are you going to tolerate than sometimes, randomly, you are going to die because the network had a spike in ping when playing Mario or Cod when you could play comfortably on your TV locally ? Remember the joke: videos games don't make kids violent. The lag does.
- eru 7y agoOh, I was mostly interested in Stadia (but never played it), when I was looking to play some single player games that my local machine couldn't handle. I wouldn't mind the occasional bad lag nearly as much as in a competitive multiplayer fast-reactions game.
- BiteCode_dev 7y agoI guess you don't intend to play dark soul :)
- eru 7y agoI can play that on the Nintendo Switch in my hand. No need for the extra graphics power. I was thinking of eg XCOM 2.
- skocznymroczny 7y ago"At least with Steam there's the possibility of downloading your library in case Steam ever goes away for whatever reason." Most games on Steam require activation through Steam servers, so unlikely. Also in case Steam went under, there would most likely be legal issues at play, preventing Steam from issuing any sort of no DRM fix.
- RealStickman 7y agoThe Steam DRM doesn't appear to be too terribly difficult to crack, considering there are so many cracks of steam games out there.
- jsjddbbwj 7y agoCracking the steam DRM seems like a case of dropping a dll
- Polylactic_acid 7y agoYep, Pretty much everything on steam has a crack. You can't do this with streamed games.
- pingyong 7y ago>Now that I think about it, why did they even rush Stadia out? The reason for that is as you say, they're playing the long game here. They know it won't make money, not today, not next year, not in 3 years. But in 10 years it could make billions. And getting actual user data and feedback early while you're building the architecture is probably worth a lot.
- dwild 7y ago>At least with Steam there's the possibility of downloading your library in case Steam ever goes away for whatever reason. It's also much cheaper in most case. In average I paid less than 5$ per game on Steam (and that include many full price games).
- tjpnz 7y agoIt doesn't have to be that way either. Nvidia is offering a service which streams games you've already purchased off Steam et el. If their service shuts down you still get to keep your games.
- hnick 7y agoNvidia is already having issues with major publishers pulling games saying they don't have a license to install and use them that way. It'll be interesting to see how it plays out.
- Polylactic_acid 7y agoI fail to see how it should be any different legally. If I pick up my pc and put it in a datacenter and stream the video output that would be perfectly fine.
- hnick 7y agoIn this case the game is already installed on the image/server belonging to Nvidia. Perhaps hundreds or thousands of times. And I suppose they did pay for those copies and the argument is that it's like you are just borrowing their PC to play a game. But I think the counter-argument is that this is more in the realms of "performance" similar to how you can't just buy a music CD and play it in a bar for an audience. I have no idea what the legal ramifications really are, but I don't think there's anything morally wrong with the service they are providing. If companies really believed in the whole "selling a license" thing more of them would be willing to provide cross-platform copies for free once you own one instead of grabbing another sale.
- disillusioned 7y agoI would _have_ to imagine that if this were the case, they would issue full refunds. It'd be inviting some class action cases and it's almost certainly a drop in the bucket for them anyway.
- dx034 7y agoWhy full refunds? People have used the games. At most they'd offer partial refunds, and those could be much lower than what people hope for.
- AnssiH 7y agoThere is precedent: Microsoft issued full refunds for everyone that had bought digital books from them when they shut the store down last year.
- ComodoHacker 7y agoIt's even worse than that. Even if they add a download option, you can't be sure if any of your games will run on your hardware. As a developer, you have an additional burden of testing on and optimizing for Google's hardware, which are apparently different from consumer hardware.
- Abishek_Muthian 7y agoGoogle should come forward with a 'Guaranteed to not shutdown for X years' or like LTS plan to save its reputation. Perhaps being open-source e.g. Flutter, gives them a excuse.
- onion2k 7y agoGoogle can't save their reputation with a marketing message. The only thing that would rebuild it is to not shut down any services for the couple of decades. They're not going to do that though, so Google is now effectively a 'short-term' products company as far as anything new goes. For consumers that's fine. They understand the situation and approach Google products with that knowledge. Stadia is a good example. The people who should be most wary of this policy are Googlers who are looking for a team to join.
- praptak 7y ago"The people who should be most wary of this policy are Googlers who are looking for a team to join." Only building new shiny things from scratch and never having to support them? Doesn't sound like a bad deal.
- onion2k 7y agoAt the start of my career I was all about the tech, and I would probably have agreed with you. But now, with around 23 years of building web things behind me, I've realised that what keeps me interested is the fact that tens of millions of people have found what I've contributed to useful and interesting. Without that I would have given up and got bored. Most people (certainly everyone I've ever worked with) need to have positive external input and feedback on the work they do to drive them forward, and if you're not getting that and the feedback is repeatedly "Meh, it'll just be killed in a few years" it would eventually start to impact your confidence and ability to do good work.
- daemin 7y agoI read this in an opinion piece that promotions and bonuses at Google are issued for launching things - products, face lifts, new features - not necessarily maintaining applications (maybe with the exception of search and advertising). So taking that lens it's easy to see why so many new products are launched but then fall away and are killed, because the people involved can get their money and then move on to do other things. Also explains the constant user hostile redesigns of existing products. To fix the reputation in this regard the internal reward structures would need to be changed so that building new things is the only way to get ahead.
- newbie578 7y agoYou are absolutely right, that is a horrible reputation to have, especially if you are a TECH company. Oh how the mighty have fallen. Google which was an industry gold standard for innovation and job satisfaction has become anything but. What I found most interesting is how Microsoft and Google have seemingly changed roles. Microsoft was the old boring behemoth while Google was riding the front wave. I guess complacency really is a silent killer. I would really love to hear Brin's or Page's thoughts regarding the current Google
- Animats 7y agoYou are absolutely right, that is a horrible reputation to have, especially if you are a TECH company. It's been worse. Google bought all those robotics companies a few years ago. Some, such as Bot and Dolly, had real customers, and the customers were cut off. All the companies they bought were silenced - no papers, no demos, nothing. People in robotics outside Google land thought Google must be doing something spectacular. No. Just a total botch with no plan. Google ended up dumping all those companies. Some just folded. Google basically trashed the advanced robotics industry. At least Google isn't buying game companies and trashing them.
- daemin 7y agoDidn't Google buy a game company recently to work entirely in-house? So not sure how long until they get shut down. Though I think the game industry is kind of used to that by now. Big giants like EA, Activision, Microsoft, etc keep buying smaller studios and shutting them down after a few years and a few projects. I kind of hope that isn't the case with the studios that Microsoft has purchased recently.
- Mindwipe 7y agoMore assembled a game studio themselves. Although one suspects talent will start to flee very shortly.
- ulfw 7y agoMost of them where bought so Andy Rubin has something other than Android to play with.
- bartread 7y agoWhen Microsoft launched Xbox they suffered pretty terrible losses for a number of years but they always knew that was going to happen[1], and they were willing to accept it because they were playing the long game. This worked out not only because Microsoft had the money but, critically, because they had the will to make Xbox a success. They resolved to slog through the years of losses, failures (anyone remember the Japan launch?), and missteps in order to build a successful business. Whilst Google have the money, more than enough money, to do the same, I don't think they have the will. From my own perspective, as a gaming enthusiast, Stadia simply isn't solving any problem that I have, and I don't believe it's going to be around long enough that I want to invest in it. [1] I'm sure they would have preferred if it wasn't.
- bakuninsbart 7y agoI have an incredibly good internet connection since I'm working from home, but because I only play like 2-4 hours a week I can't really justify investing in a very expensive gaming computer. I need a laptop for work, and investing in an extra platform just for those 4 hours? Stadia might be a very good compromise for me, and I think there are quite a few others like me out there, especially in the youngest generation who mostly use mobile in the first place.
- jfkebwjsbx 7y ago"A very expensive gaming computer" You already have a laptop/PC. A lot of gaming can be done with iGPUs so the cost for you would be zero. If you really want to play big titles, then you are looking at a delta of 300$ (the price of a good GPU) for 5 years, which amounts to 5$ a month. I don’t see why anybody who has already a computer would pay more money to vendor lock-in themselves into an online-only service, one-store-only, no-mods-allowed, Internet-quality-dependent service. I can see the appeal for people that wasn’t into computers before that, though. But still, if I were in that case, I would choose a non-locked-in platform at all costs.
- Shakahs 7y agoWhere would that GPU go? My laptop doesn’t have a place for it, and doesn’t have the connections for an eGPU. A $300 delta would only be true if I had a desktop. I use Paperspace + Parsec for a regular Windows cloud desktop so I’m not locked into anything and pay just a few dollars per month for my gaming.
- banachtarski 7y agoLet’s not kid ourselves. Stadia aside, Improbable is obviously a vaporware company woefully out of their league with an absurd valuation from equally uninformed investors from softbank’s utter failure of a fund.
- meheleventyone 7y agoI don't think they're quite that bad. The software itself exists and has shipped games and prototypes. I just don't see much market for it.
- dijit 7y ago>That's a terrible reputation for any company to have. Part of me wonders if this is due to the fact that google doesn't hire traditional sysadmins. It might sound weird, because convention has become that you can "dev" your way out of "ops" and that SRE is the new hotness- but consider the fact that (as a gross generalisation) developers don't like maintaining stuff, it's much more beneficial for your own sanity and to present to management: new things! especially shiny things. Sysadmins however think the opposite; how can we take $legacyThing and make it better, always the eye on maintenance and longevity. SRE's solve for reliability but not maintainability or longevity. EDIT: guess I hit some peoples nerves, could someone elaborate on why?
- seanhunter 7y agoI think it's likely to be a product of internal incentives and how these create a culture. I would be prepared to wager than it's much easier to get a promotion by working on a new hot thing than on maintaining or improving an existing thing. Scroll forward a couple of years and you have a reputation for just abandoning existing things rather than improving them, because people individually maximise their own career advancement by migrating off difficult maintenance and improvement projects on to "new hotness" projects only to abandon them again later for an "even newer hotness". Small organizations have an immune system that rejects bullshit like that but as orgs grow they institutionalize and it becomes harder and harder for them not to succumb.
- hedora 7y agoI think your analysis of DevOps and SRE is spot on. Most developers make terrible operators. Devops shops also sometimes shift release management and QA tasks onto developers. Most developers are terrible at those roles too (and most are uninterested in learning them). I’m good (for a developer; mediocre-to-poor vs specialists) at some of the non-developer roles I mentioned, but I hate doing them, and am better at developing software anyway. Continuous deployment “saves” the system by just throwing something over the wall at customers. This means you always meet the development metrics that get passed up to upper management. SRE’s optimize for minimizing the number of pages generated by the monitoring system. All of the positions that acted as customer advocates or considered long term development roadmap (beyond a few sprints) are eliminated in such shops, so even successful products end up being a flash in the pan. At best, they get too popular to shut down, and immediately stagnate. I’ve seen this play out in multiple organizations from multiple different angles over the years.
- griddleoctopus 7y agoI work at Improbable. Not an official comment, but we're an independent company and Google has no investment in us, though we do have a partnership with them, like we do with other companies like Tencent Cloud. We do support large MMOs, but our networking can handle lots of game types so we have a range of hosting methods - public cloud, bare metal, hybrid. AFAIK, the pricing for SpatialOS is comparable with other managed services for multiplayer - there are examples on our site. And we don't just do networking, we do co-dev, managed hosting, server orchestration, consulting, etc, etc. I guess go read our website if you want to know more?
- dirtydroog 7y agoAs so that's what Improbable do. They're tried to hit me up on LinkedIn several times.
- Doubleslash 7y agoI feel the same. Google simply has no patience. Though they need that because they simply have no track-record in that industry. It's the same with Google Cloud. They have that huge global infrastructure essentially running their own internet, just with 4 times the bandwidth. They have piles of cash and it looks like they are running out of ideas of what to do with it. In 2018 they announced their 5 year plan to overtake Microsoft and possibly AWS in marketshare for public cloud computing. If they don't achieve that they said they'd simply stop putting money in this business and leave "partners" to fill the gap. To me that reads they'll effectively stop expanding GCP capabilities which would mean the end to that service. It's two years later and while GCP is certainly growing, so is the rest and their marketshare is still miniscule.
- d4rti 7y agoIs is patience, or just the difficulty in being an appreciable portion of revenue vs the ads driven businesses (search/ads/gmail)?
- ulfw 7y agoNot surprising. I don't feel Google is setup to be a platform business (even though that's a lot of what they do!). Employee mindset isn't on keeping a platform running or improving but instead chasing the next-best-thing. That's how you end up with x programming languages, y services and 1000 messaging/chat apps.
- oh_sigh 7y agoIt's really just a meme I hear on hn and the likes. I've never heard a "normal person" despair that Google cancels projects all the time.