6 ms·
> The data so far suggests that the virus has a case fatality risk around 1%; this rate would make it several times more severe than typical seasonal influenza
by JKCalhoun 7y ago
> The data so far suggests that the virus has a case fatality risk around 1%; this rate would make it several times more severe than typical seasonal influenza and would put it somewhere between the 1957 influenza pandemic (0.6%) and the 1918 influenza pandemic (2%).
That was a little shocking to read. I had no idea the 1918 influenza pandemic was only 2%. I lost relatives to it, assumed it was a larger percentage than 2%.
- kevinthew 7y agoYeah. The part that should freak people out is this looks multiples more infectious to boot.
- javajosh 7y agoAnd I think its important to note that 2% is the mortality rate in a hospital where they have respirators, etc. The mortality rate outside of a hospital (e.g. in a quarantine wharehouse) is something like 20%. (I wish I could remember the source for this, will look and edit but it may have been The Atlantic). It also seems like some survivors come out of this with pretty severe damage to their organs, especially lungs, because the persons immune system goes overboard and attacks healthy tissue. So, some fraction of people will live, but be disabled.
- greatpatton 7y agoA 20% death rate is highly unlikely.The Italian researchers who sequenced the Italian strain believe that the virus has been circulating widely in Italy since January, even before Italy banned direct air flight to China. This seems to be confirmed by the fact that almost all the new cases in Europe are originating from big Italian cities. If the death rate was 20% we should start to see a lot of death in Italy and it doesn't seem to be the case. Iran and Egypt also seems to be largely hit, as many tourist back from Egypt have been infected. Now getting the real death rate is going to be a very complicated game, especially if many infected patient remain without symptom. I tend to believe the virus is already highly circulating in a high number of place of the planet where the health system is bad, and lacking testing capabilities. We are even starting to see untraceable cases in the USA.
- tessierashpool 7y agoCaveat: some of the "untraceable" cases are kind of "semi-traceable" in practice. The American government (against the advice of its own CDC) flew back American patients who had been on the Japanese cruise ship, infected and uninfected alike, and sent in HHS employees to interact with them, with inadequate training and hazard protections (i.e., no bunny suits). This heightened infection risk for the uninfected cruise ship patients and the HHS employees, as well as anybody who knew them. This plane landed at Travis Air Force Base in Solano County, California. Which is where the first "untraceable" case in the United States occurred.
- animalnewbie 7y agoI keep hearing about this- is there a source for this? Or drumf is inolved so must be true?
- makomk 7y agoYou're mixing up two different evacuations. The whistleblower complaint about HHS employees with inadequate training processing evacuees was about the Wuhan evacuation, not the Diamond Princess one. Only about three of the Wuhan evacuees ever ended up testing positive for the virus, there's no reason to believe they were even infectious when flown back and none of the staff involved have shown signs of COVID-19. It's certainly possible that one of the people involved in the quarantine didn't follow precautions and was infected, even with full training, but I don't think there's any evidence tying the California case to it.
- tessierashpool 7y agoOK — I did conflate Wuhan and Diamond Princess, so thanks for correcting me there, but according to both Time and the Washington Post, HHS employees were sent (without proper training or protection) to meet with evacuees in each case: https://www.washingtonpost.com/health/2020/02/27/us-workers-without-protective-gear-assisted-coronavirus-evacuees-hhs-whistleblower-says/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/health/2020/02/27/us-workers-... https://time.com/5792135/coronavirus-whistleblower-hhs-employees/ https://time.com/5792135/coronavirus-whistleblower-hhs-emplo...
- ekianjo 7y ago20 percent? Where? Most people are not even tested and in China where they have the largest hospital facilities for treating patients the number is far lower than 20 percents.
- amf12 7y agoThat comment was about the 1918 influenza pandemic.
- mytherin 7y agoThe 2% mortality rate of the coronavirus is likely greatly overestimated [1]. Early mortality rates of diseases are generally estimated to be too high because only severe cases are tested. The exact same happened with H1N1 (Swine Flu): initial studies showed a 2-3% case fatality rate, but afterwards it was found to have an actual mortality rate of around 0.15% [2], close to that of the flu at 0.1%. [1] https://www.vox.com/2020/2/12/21134718/coronavirus-china-deaths-mortality-rate https://www.vox.com/2020/2/12/21134718/coronavirus-china-dea... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2009_flu_pandemic https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2009_flu_pandemic
- TomK32 7y agoSo, should we even care if the actual rate is merely 50% above your regular flu? Is this 0.15% one winter/year or across several seasons?
- mytherin 7y agoIt is still speculated to be more contagious than the flu, and the flu itself is no joke. Many people will die if the coronavirus gets out of control. However, it is certainly not the end of the world others are claiming either. Being aware of it and taking certain precautions (e.g. washing your hands more often and staying home if you feel sick) is a good idea.
- mytailorisrich 7y agoIt should also be noted that they did not have antibiotics back then. The Spanish flu today would have most likely a lower fatality rate than it had then. Obviously those diseases are viral. But it seems that they can be helped by bacteria and certainly bacterial pneumonia is a common serious complication, and I believe that patients hospitalised for COVID-19 are given antibiotics for these reasons.
- hyperman1 7y agoThe spanish flu would probably have been much less severe if it didn't happen right after WWI. Basic supplies for food and soap were not yet at their pre WWI levels and the population was still weaker and physically recovering from the war.
- mytailorisrich 7y agoThat's an additional aspect, yes.
- TomK32 7y agoWWI started 10 months after the Spanish flu. Press censorship did also contribute to its spread.
- hyperman1 7y agoHuh, what? WWI started on 28-07-1914 and ended 11-11-1918 while the spanish flu started around january 1918.
- brianpan 7y agoThe death rate was "small" but the reach was large. 1/4 of the world's population got it so the total death toll was large.
- NanoWar 7y ago2% is very huge, it is every 50th person!
- takeda 7y ago2% would be over 6 million Americans. I don't understand why that percentage is often reported as insignificant.
- tessierashpool 7y agothat's legit -- the percentage is not insignificant -- but it does look like you're calculating 2% of all Americans (approx 327M). the 2% number is _case_ fatality rate, i.e., how many cases are fatal. so to get from there to actual deaths, you have to apply it to _cases_. so you need to combine that with the attack rate, or attack ratio. the only number I've heard for the attack rate is 30%, from the virologist Ian Mackay, who caveated it as a guess: https://twitter.com/MackayIM/status/1233511899083530240 https://twitter.com/MackayIM/status/1233511899083530240 it could probably never be anything but a guess, until after the fact. anyway, it would not be 2% of the US population. it would be 2% of 30% of the US population, which is approximately two million people. with the caveat that all of these numbers are early estimates based on limited data. 2M people is still a lot of deaths. but it's not just how many people are killed. the rate of hospitalization is 15-25%. approx 10% of patients in Italy right now are in intensive care. the disease expresses as severe pneumonia, so severe that survivors have experienced _organ failure_. you could be hooked to a ventilator for a month. in the United States, if you survive a medical problem that serious, it still ruins your life. probably this country will see not just a significant number of deaths, but also a spike in medical bankruptcies -- which are already a huge problem here.
- gdubs 7y agoSo the question according to those numbers is, are we prepared to hospitalize 10% of the 30% of people who may get infected in the United States? In particular, do we have enough ventilation beds, the isolation infrastructure, the staffing? During a crisis you’d want daily briefings where questions like these could be asked. I’ve said in other threads: it feels like the US is sleepwalking through this. If the CDC believes, as they said last week, that this will spread inevitably — what exactly are we waiting for? We have two cases of unknown origin in Santa Clara county, yet schools are still open as of now. Wouldn’t it make sense to close them for two weeks now to hopefully slow the spread and give us additional time to ramp up our medical response?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- askvictor 7y agoOn numbers from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22432358 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22432358 (and those numbers are not necessarily accurate for lots of reasons) the death rate is below 0.4% for all age groups below 49. Then it increases exponentially. I'm curious what the comparative age breakdown of the 1918 flu was, particularly given that a lot of people would have been malnourished due to the war, and health care was not as advanced as now.
- exdsq 7y agoThe Spanish influenza affected young adults more than the elderly/weak because it caused the immune system to attack the body. The stronger the immune system, the more damaging the individuals illness.
- E14n 7y agoThere are some graphs broken down by age for the Spanish flu https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3734171/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3734171/
- ekianjo 7y agoContext matters. We had almost no medicine back in 1918. That changes everything.
- saberdancer 7y agoI am not getting it either. "It infected 500 million people around the world,[2] or about 27% of the then world population of between 1.8 and 1.9 billion, including people on isolated Pacific islands and in the Arctic. The death toll is estimated to have been 40 million to 50 million, and possibly as high as 100 million, making it one of the deadliest epidemics in human history" 500 million infected, 40-50 million deaths. Isn't that 10% death rate? Perhaps it was 2% for people who were treated in hospitals.
- tspiteri 7y ago2% of 2 billion is 40 million. So perhaps it was 2% of the whole population.
- phyzome 7y ago2% means 1 in 50 people. How many people do you know? How about people who are a friend of a friend? What is that number divided by 50? In all likelihood, within a year, several people you know will die of covid-19. (Also note that the effects will be different around the world and in different social strata; in poorer areas, the death rate will be much higher, and in rich areas much lower.)
- qznc 7y agoWikipedia is inconsistent for 1918 flu pandemic: https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Spanish_flu&oldid=943187983 https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Spanish_flu&oldid... "The World Health Organization estimates that 2–3% of those who were infected died (case-fatality ratio).[51]" "The unusually severe disease killed up to 20% of those infected, as opposed to the usual flu epidemic mortality rate of 0.1%.[2][54]"