11 ms·
That's a nicely built valve. Looks like something from 1890. If the Romans had discovered the Bessemer process for making steel in quantity, the industrial rev
by Animats 7y ago
That's a nicely built valve. Looks like something from 1890.
If the Romans had discovered the Bessemer process for making steel in quantity, the industrial revolution might have happened two thousand years sooner. They had a "steel industry", but could only make enough for swords and such. A Bessemer converter is much simpler than that valve. Would have changed history. The railroad era might have started around 150AD.
- rayhendricks 7y agoIMO that [Bessemer process] is really the sticking point that prevented the Ancient Romans from harnessing steam engines, and we had to wait until the early 18th century (1712ish) for the piston steam engine. The ancient romans did know of a rudimentary steam engine though. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aeolipile https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aeolipile
- smacktoward 7y agoThe explanation I've always heard for why the Romans didn't industrialize had less to do with technology and more to do with economics. The Romans made extensive use of slave labor, so while they might have had the capacity to build engines and machines, there was simply no demand for anyone to do so -- why bother tinkering with machines when you can always just throw more slaves at your problems? Whereas in Britain slavery had mostly been confined to its colonies only, and the institution was abolished entirely between 1807 and 1833 -- the same period when industrialization really took off. A similar effect could be seen in the different ways the American North and South evolved after independence -- the North, which didn't have slaves, industrialized, while the slaveholding South remained stubbornly agricultural right up to the Civil War. The more expensive human muscle power becomes, the more attractive it becomes to replace muscles with machines. And a slave society is a society where muscle power will always be cheap.
- rayhendricks 7y agoThat does sound like a plausible explanation, however the United states industrialized and also had slavery until 1865 alright the south was less so.
- smacktoward 7y agoApologies, I edited my comment to address the US comparison before I saw your comment. Sorry to have ninja'ed you!
- rsynnott 7y agoWhile I’m sceptical of the slavery explanation for Rome, the pre civil war US south wasn’t meaningfully industrialised.
- LessDmesg 7y agoThat's a valid point, of course. However, abolition of slavery is only a necessary condition, not a sufficient one. Remember e.g. the Black Plague in Europe which led to a sharp increase in the value of human resources and caused some positive effects like the rise of free cities, powerful guilds of professionals, and the Renaissance of arts and sciences. However, things stopped short of an industrial revolution: it took some 3 or 4 centuries more to come around.
- buzzkillington 7y agoYes, because by the third generation population had recovered.
- NikolaeVarius 7y agoWho is making the claim that the Romans didn't industrialize? They may not have gone through the industrial revolution, but I find the claim that they didn't have industrial output to be nonsensical/doubly when trying to connect the lack of a "full scale industrial revolution" to slavery, which is some weird myth that refuses to die. Romans heavily implemented new processes for things such as mining, milling, and shipping. The slavery angle doesn't pass any form of smell test. If the claim is true, why would any society that ever had slavery ever do anything? Romans had waterwheels that drove machinery and used generated power to automate many aspects of their society.
- marbu 7y agoAgreed, it's especially worth looking at particular examples of Roman industry, such as Las Medulas gold mines. That said, while we could assume that slavery angle wasn't ruling out industrialization entirely, it wasn't pushing towards it either.
- Spooky23 7y agoI've read that too, and always were skeptical. The Romans obviously made extensive use of technology, and their peers didn't advance much more quickly than they did, with the massive capitalization of slave and other labors. Nor did the vassal states within the "boundaries" that we find in history books.
- patentatt 7y agoI’ve heard it explained that every ‘great’ civilization has a ‘great’ energy source, and that slavery was Rome’s energy source. Much of especially the late Roman empires expansion and conquest can be seen through a lens of needing to capture more slaves. Not a historian, but I’ve heard that argument at least.
- usrusr 7y agoThe main source for the large-scale applications of mechanical energy that were later powered by steam engines was animals, in ancient Rome just as in pre-industrial England. I've heard that argument before, no technological progress because of slavery, but it's widely oversold. Romans had water-powered grain mills, saw mills, and trip hammers, despite slavery. They did have some famous mine-dewatering systems that were human-powered (slaves), keywords: reverse overshot water wheel. Mind-dewatering has been the original use case for the steam engine, so it's quite likely that those installations are the inspiration for the "no technology because of slavery" argument.
- muro 7y agoAs Christianity became popular, Rome started to free slaves. Later Rome was no longer a society based on slavery, rather early feudalism. Rome was also short on population after multiple plagues and needed to focus more on food production, rather than having enough manpower to industrialize. After all, they couldn't even put up armies in the size they needed. So at the time they could afford it, they were expanding or fighting civil wars, later they were scrambling to hold it together.
- Gibbon1 7y agoFar as I understand there are two issues. One is before coking was developed you couldn't use coal to produce iron. You needed to use charcoal from trees. Which Italy had a limited supply of. Iron production also competes with using wood as fuel and building supplies. There is also a transportation problem. The inputs for steel manufacture are large. To be economic you needed fuel and ore in close proximity. Sweden was a power house based on high quality iron ore deposits and vast pine forests. Which they cut down pretty much completely. I think India with fast growing tropical forests was also a large exporter of iron. Britain initially had large forests and iron ore. But also huge reserves of coal almost on top of their ore deposits. That allowed them to keep going once the forests were gone.
- aksss 7y agoIt's an underappreciated irony that coal save the trees and the whales (coal gas supplanted whale oil at a time when whales were being hunted to extinction, deforestation in America was dramatically retarded after coal reduced the need for wood for charcoal). Oil and gas are reducing our reliance on coal. Barring some new discovery about energy sources, nuclear is probably the only thing that can appreciably reduce our reliance on fossil fuels.
- didericis 7y agoI think there are way too many technical problems related to transporting energy through the atmosphere, launch expense, and materials science to make any satellite based energy systems viable, but I’ve heard of some really cool concepts, like one that relies on dragging a tether and somehow harvesting huge amounts of energy to beam back to earth. Does anyone know if those are as far off/unrealistic as they sound?
- AngryData 7y agoLarge space-based solar installations are feasible, the only big problem is transmission of the power, usually proposed via laser or directed energy beam to the ground. That is technically feasible, but nobody has ever attempted to wirelessly transmit such high levels of sustained energy over long distances. Depending on the transmitter and receiver efficiencies and what wavelengths are used a lot of power could be lost and there are potential disasters like missing your target receiver with your energy beam, or interactions of the air with such a high powered beam, or EM 'pollution' from an imperfect transmitter. As for something like tethering orbiting objects or the like, it is all still theoretical. A space elevator requires similar material technologies and nobody has found a way to feasibly build such a large, strong, and light tether or chain. But that isn't something I would expect to see any time soon.
- LessDmesg 7y agoThe industrial revolution's main prerequisite is not a converter or any other clever device. It's about power sources. When you've got e.g. a bunch of coal that gives off lots of thermal energy, finding ways to transform that energy (with engines, factory machining etc) becomes a hot open engineering contest with good solutions being a matter of years, and optimal ones, of decades or centuries (i.e. much longer than Roman history). But if you ain't got the energy, then making any devices, however clever, isn't going to change the tide. Antique and medieval civilizations had some rather elaborate mechanisms like the antikythera, the trebuchet, rapid-fire crossbows in China etc. But without a major source of low-cost energy, none of them succeeded with an industrial revolution: large-scale coal-mining was what did it in the end.
- Merrill 7y agoThe first steam engines were motivated by the need to pump water out of coal mines. https://www.egr.msu.edu/~lira/supp/steam/ https://www.egr.msu.edu/~lira/supp/steam/ This was long before Bessemer and less expensive steel.
- hbbio 7y agoExactly. There is a Newcomen on display (it's not small...) at the National Museum of Scotland in Edinburgh. Edit: cf. https://www.nms.ac.uk/explore-our-collections/stories/science-and-technology/newcomen-engine/ https://www.nms.ac.uk/explore-our-collections/stories/scienc...
- dredmorbius 7y agoAnd all of that generated about 5 hp (3.7 kW), at about 1-3% efficiency of thermal energy to motive power. Watt's engines were about 10-20 hp, and about 10% efficient. Peak efficiency of a triple-expansion steam engine approached 25%. The best thermal engines today (combined-cycle steam turbines) approach 50%, and have a far better power-to-weight ratio.
- thaumasiotes 7y ago> When you've got e.g. a bunch of coal that gives off lots of thermal energy, finding ways to transform that energy (with engines, factory machining etc) becomes a hot open engineering contest with good solutions being a matter of years Not really; people had bunches of coal giving off lots of thermal energy forever. They used it in the obvious way, burning it for heat in winter. This didn't lead to much in the way of technological advance. > and optimal ones, of decades or centuries (i.e. much longer than Roman history). How is "centuries" "much longer than Roman history"? Roman history goes on for more than 700 years, and that's just the history of Rome as a major international power centered on the city in Italy. The Byzantine Empire, or -- as it called itself -- the Roman Kingdom, with extensive cultural and institutional continuity, went on for another 1000 years after that.
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoThe Romans were not good at adopting technology when they found it (conquered it). Seems they continued using oxen to pull loads when they had knowledge of horse collars. Would have doubled their 'speed of commerce'. Probably the inertia stemmed from being one of the worlds largest bureaucracies.
- marcosdumay 7y agoOxen are stronger, heavier, and have other uses besides pulling loads. Horses are faster, but oxen are way more efficient. But were widely used right until transport mechanization, neither replaced the other.
- ip26 7y agoSupposedly horse traces were also much more expensive to make & maintain compared to an ox yoke.
- Turbots 7y agoand horses are much harder to maintain... they die of basically anything :D I also think horses were more used in personnel transport and armed forces
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoOxen pull carts at 2mph, horses 3 or 4? So using horses could have had roughly the effect on commerce that steam trains had, or what FedEx did to business, you pick the analogy. Packages delivered in half the time; half the time spent on the road; cheaper (because the drover could deliver twice in a day) and on and on.
- marcosdumay 7y agoFaster, yes, but not cheaper. What gain is there in being able to do the trip twice if you carry less than half the amount? (Yeah, it's rhetoric, there is some gain, for some cargo, and loss for other cargo.)
- dredmorbius 7y agoThere's little to no coal in Italy. Nearest reserves are in (present-day) northern Spain, a very long sea voyage, possible only May - November. Coal throughout Europe is mostly in the northern band, from Scotland, especially in Cornwall, France, Germany, and present-day Czech Republic and Poland. Where industrialisation happened, for the most part. England's coal mines were near the sea, and river/canal transport, and could be moved readily by ship elsewhere in the country. Coal in the US didn't come into wide use until after substantial rail infrastructure was built out (the 1880s), with high-grade Bessemer steel, capable of bearing heavy coal cars. Until then, wood, usually locally-sourced, was the preferred fuel.
- Merrill 7y agoEngland had an advantage in that coal mines, iron mines and limestone quarries were reasonably close together, facilitating the smelting of iron.
- agumonkey 7y agofunny how geology factors our reality even at the technological layer
- blaser-waffle 7y agoThe logistics of space -- not outer space, just, like distance -- are pretty damn tricky. Most of the time there is no way to deal with it other than "brute force" aka haul stuff long distances. Maybe you get a tunnel or pass through a mountain, maybe you get easy access to iron or oil, but otherwise you're a prisoner of logistics.
- agumonkey 7y agoany articles about the link between logistics and entropy ?
- dredmorbius 7y agoWhat's fairly freaky is that current transport cost ratios between modes of transportation are little changed from those of pre-industrial times. Land transport costs about 20x that of sea. The principle differences are: - Rail. Which is roughly the equivalent of a canal or waterway, though with higher speeds. About 1/2 as efficient as large-scale cargo ships. - Air. Extraordinarly expensive, but fast. Also very effective at spreading disease.
- allemagne 7y agoIt's interesting to speculate about an industrial Rome, but I'm more convinced that the industrial revolution was just as much facilitated by the political and economic institutions of 18th century England, things that Rome never had. The story about "flexible glass" during the reign of Tiberius Caesar is probably false, but illustrates how technological innovation is expected to be received when there are powerful gatekeepers to broad technological change: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flexible_glass https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flexible_glass You see similar actions by technophobic rulers in Ming China following the voyages of Zheng He or even in 16th century England: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/William_Lee_(inventor) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/William_Lee_(inventor) Entrenched interests usually would much rather maintain the status quo than enable anything potentially disruptive. The industrial revolution started because it was infeasible for any one powerful group in England to oppose innovation.
- ratacat 7y agoNot to mention the discovery of vulcanized rubber. You can't have an industrial revolution without hoses, gaskets, and tires.
- jacobush 7y agoYou'd go a long way with coal and steel. Heck, even large scale plain iron works would make something else entirely out of the ancient world.
- fsloth 7y agoI totally agree. The financial and societal aspects are as much important as the technological development in kick-starting industrial revolution. As an engineer, I've come to believe the main reason industrial revolution happened when it did was not the sudden advancement of science, but the emergence of stable and inclusive economy based on commerce and private property and the inclusive political system that did not allow incumbent to stifle innovation through force.
- alanbernstein 7y agoThat's a great little story, I assume untrue, where the "flexible glass" was just chosen as a mythical invention, to make the point. Similar to the "acid that dissolves any material" story. Reading it, I thought how fantastic it would be if that material had actually been around for centuries. Then of course, the end of the article links to gorilla glass, a material we all use daily and barely even think about. Do we live in mythical times?