2 ms·
A). I want to hold a trial before any punishment can be meted out. Yes, I think that concept has a long history in common law. Warrant for evidence are a differ
by joe_the_user 16y ago
A). I want to hold a trial before any punishment can be meted out. Yes, I think that concept has a long history in common law. Warrant for evidence are a different story.
B) Read my statement again. Your example doesn't contradict it at all. The fact that some people sometimes get some relief after the fact doesn't prove that doing things this is fair or that it involves anything like the spirit of due-process. You can fight bureaucracy and win occasionally in even extremely authoritarian countries.
Edit: OK, reading my original post, I should have said "when you lose everything before, the claim that you can sue to get it back becomes a mostly empty claim". I hope the direction I'm going is clear in any case.
- anigbrowl 16y agoA) forgive my pedantry, but I'm not sure that having illegal property seized in a civil proceeding counts as punishment. Distributing child porn is very illegal, and I don't see any benefit in allowing the domain to stay up while the trial proceeds. B) I am not a fan of ever-expanding civil asset forfeiture policies either. But some things are illegal to possess and thus subject to forfeit in the first place. The contraband nature of such items are established before the seizure warrant issues, which is what happened here. I agree with your aim, but not your analysis.
- rhizome 16y agoSo you're saying that it's OK as long as the charges are serious enough?
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- anigbrowl 16y agoThe (apparently) accidental inclusion of mooo.com, and all its subdomains, is not OK. I think that was negligent, and that the domain owners can, should, and will sue. IANAL, so I may be mistaken - if anyone knows better, I'd appreciate an explanation in order to understand the issue better. (The existing sub-thread mentioning the Federal Tort Claims Act seems like the correct interpretation to me, and in several cases a class action against the government has led to a settlement or judgment in favor of the plaintiffs.) If the writer or my understanding of the story was wrong, and mooo.com was incorrectly included on the domain seizure warrant instead of affected by technical incompetence, then I would have to rethink the question, and know more about what happened to form a better opinion. I think we all agree that the mistaken seizure of mooo.com and the subdomains, whatever the exact nature of the mistake, was unjustifiable, and that the domain owners deserve compensation for any injuries to their personal or business reputations. But I think what you're really asking is whether it's ever OK for the government to seize a website first and hold the trial later, yes? If so, my answer is yes, and that due process is satisfied if a warrant was correctly issued, based on a demonstration to the court that the website's content consists of illegal child porn. If the owner/operator can't be found, the warrant is issued against the domain used as a distribution point, because it is also a crime to distribute such material. If property rights took precedence over criminal statute, then the legal system would be expending resources to protect illegal activity. If a cop finds a kilo of cocaine but no dealer steps up to claim ownership, should it be left where it is? If a machine gun were set up on a tripod and rebuilt to fire automatically at random passers-by, should it be left alone out of respect for the absent owner's property rights? If a domain is being employed to serve an illegal purpose, why should its owner expect the legal system to uphold his property rights at the same time?
- pbhjpbhj 16y agoI think he's saying that sometimes it is necessary to take action before a conviction in a court of law. If I see you about to stab someone I'm not going to get a police office to review the case, pass it on to a legal team to assess and bring before a judge, wait for a subpoena, wait for legal representatives to make submissions and then have you arrested. Instead I'd do my best to stop you stabbing them. Sometimes one has to take action when a crime appears to have been committed or some wrongdoing appears likely to be occurring. Seriousness is IMO a large factor in appropriate response.
- rhizome 16y agoLook at his example A, he's describing an accusation of distributing child pornography to justify removing domains from the internet.
- anigbrowl 16y agoI was not. I was describing evidence of distribution being offered to justify seizing control of the domain from whence child porn was being distributed. If I were a defense attorney, it's possible I could find myself having to represent someone on trial for that kind of crime. In fact, I have spent quite a bit of time thinking over that very issue in the last year, and the complex ethical responsibilities involved. Although I expect it would be a very unpleasant task, I would have to be prepared to do it as best I could, because that's what 'the right to an attorney' boils down to. But I really don't think there needs to be any legal protection for the continued operation of a child porn website. The people abused during the creation of such material have rights too, which I think are a lot more important than the porn distributor's property right in a domain name.
- rhizome 16y agoYes, but someone has to determine whether the evidence is real Typically this is a judge's job, isn't it? Of course there isn't and shouldn't be protection for the continued operation of a child porn website, but shouldn't it be found to be one first? You seem to be saying "yes," but that the evidence should be given to I don't know...a dude at Comcast or wherever? I'm fuzzy on this last part.
- joe_the_user 16y agoforgive my pedantry, but I'm not sure that having illegal property seized in a civil proceeding counts as punishment. Well, when talking of doubtful distinction in argument, some may pedantry, others might say sophistry. If I say "I never touched him!" (but rubber hose did a fine job on his kidney), which am I engaging in? More seriously, how the frickin heck can taking someone's stuff not be punishment? Moreover, given that this is a broad power, the existence of some instance where one can argue isn't punishment doesn't mean that there aren't many, many other instances where it is. But some things are illegal to possess and thus subject to forfeit in the first place. Note that civil forfeiture was not historically created or used for taking drugs themselves or other "illegal property". If someone has drugs, you can arrest them for possession and take the drugs as evidence. If you drop the charges, they could come to collect, except they won't since they'll be arrested for possession so you can dispose of the stuff (not that I'm particular in favor of drug laws but that's a different story). Civil forfeiture is for taking money and "instrumentalities". http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Asset_forfeiture http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Asset_forfeiture "Asset forfeiture is confiscation, by the State, of assets which are either (a) the alleged proceeds of crime or (b) the alleged instrumentalities of crime..." IE, it's not used for "illegal property" as such. And the addresses in this discussion certainly aren't "illegal property".
- brg 16y agoI don't see any benefit in allowing the domain to stay up while the trial proceeds. So you believe in guilty until proven guilty? The content of 83990 sites was taken down, none of which had any disturbing or illegal content. There is great benefit in allowing this to stay up while the trail proceeds.
- anigbrowl 16y agoQuite, but none of them from mooo.com on down should have been included in the first place - the error appears to have taken place during the change to the DNS records, not inside a courtroom. As I said before, if that domain had erroneously been included on the warrant itself, there would have had to be another hearing held before that could be cleared up. There is no mention of such in the story; instead work began to restore the DNS records almost immediately (but propogation time means that's not an instant fix). A technical error like that could have occurred just as easily following a trial as following a warrant. It was negligence which was to blame, not a lack of due process.
- rhizome 16y agoI want to hold a trial before any punishment can be meted out. You may be in luck. It just so happens that at least one member of the US Supreme Court doesn't believe punishment can be inflicted before conviction because the entire concept of punishment requires a conviction. That's right, there is no such thing as pre-trial punishment by definition. As for B, you can't always sue to get it back. In fact, under my understanding I'd say you rarely can. http://reason.com/archives/2010/11/29/covering-their-assets http://reason.com/archives/2010/11/29/covering-their-assets