8 ms·
No chance. This isn't the 1950s. We don't just throw people atop rockets anymore. These are vehicles, aircraft. There is absolutely no way any of the curren
by sandworm101 7y ago
No chance.
This isn't the 1950s. We don't just throw people atop rockets anymore. These are vehicles, aircraft. There is absolutely no way any of the current crop of space vehicles could be made ready for a trip to the moon anytime before 2024.
Going beyond low orbit, away from the sub-45min return time, is something we haven't done in generations. The craft need to be tested, repeatedly. Each test flight then has to be analyzed before the next test flight. The turnaround for a single test will be many months, even a year. Getting all the bits and pieces together would then take many more years of integration work.
Look at the JWST. Look at the F-35. Look at the 737-max. These are complicated systems with layers of dependencies. Our society today simply does not accept the cowboy approach to safety that was the original moon race. The next moon landing will only happen after a decade-long deliberative, iterative, campaign requiring the support of many subsequent governments.
- Someone 7y agoAlso, combine ”NASA says contracts to build a lunar lander could be awarded in late February or March.” with https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apollo_Lunar_Module#History https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apollo_Lunar_Module#History. For the LM, the contract was awarded in September 1962, and first flight (unmanned) was in January, 1968. So, even Apollo’s aggressive schedule needed more time to first flight than what NASA would have now between awarding the contract and landing humans on the moon.
- onionisafruit 7y agoDid we throw away everything we learned in the apollo program? They won’t be starting from scratch on the design.
- NikolaeVarius 7y agoA good chunk of Apollo knowledge isn't very useful for various reasons. 1) The tribal knowledge to even implement Apollo era technology is pretty much gone 2) Apollo flight hardware doesn't exist, probably couldn't even be manufactured without extremely expensive tooling and build up to recreate outdated hardware. 3) Lots of Apollo era designs don't exist on paper. The F1 engine doesn't really even have a standard design, since every iteration was changed to be "better" by throwing shit against the wall and seeing what sticked.
- mandelbrotwurst 7y agoWould you mind elaborating on that first point?
- Aloha 7y agoThe people who did it are dead or dying, the tribal knowledge wasn't written down.
- azernik 7y agoFrom my Jewish perspective, I think of it as oral tradition vs written tradition (like the pre-Mishnaic distinction between the Written Law and the Oral Law).
- geogra4 7y agoThey need a space flight talmud
- azernik 7y agoIn general, I see good commit messages as a Talmudic codification of a company's oral knowledge - complete with back-and-forth conversations, contradictory points of view and distinct characters. Still better than having to go talk to the people involved, some of whom may no longer be in the organization. (Specifically with commit messages as Gemara and wikis as the much more organized and impersonal Mishnah.)
- IIAOPSW 7y agoOr, hear me out, let's add the space flight knowledge to the existing talmud.
- ngcc_hk 7y agoIt is still surprise to me the switch to woman based Jewish identity and the importance of oral tradition in your culture. Also shocked when Dead Sea Scroll come out, I only knew then the Jewish bible oldest is only 1000 years old.
- azernik 7y agoIn addition to technology loss mentioned in other replies, reproducing Apollo designs without major redesigns is not a viable option for simple cost reasons: no NASA program in the foreseeable future will have anything near Apollo's budget, and so any new moon lander will have to be much cheaper. Given the advances in control systems, simulation, and materials I think this is very doable, but it's work.
- harryh 7y agoNASA's budget during the Apollo era peacked in 1966 around 4.5 billion. That's about 35 billion in today's dollars. That's a fair bit more than the actual NASA budget of 23.5 billion but it's not all that far off. The money is there. The challenges are mostly, as other's have noted, large changes in safety requirements and general execution challenges for large scale projects in today's America.
- NikolaeVarius 7y agoDuring Apollo a majority of that budget was dedicated to Apollo. Modern NASA maintains the ISS, multiple observatories, satellites, the DSN, and dozens of similar projects, budget alone does not paint a clear picture
- harryh 7y agoYa that's true. Apollo was 60-70% of NASA's budget for close to a decade. There's a lot more going on now. If anyone is curios about the details, there's a good summary here: https://www.nasa.gov/sites/default/files/atoms/files/fy2020_summary_budget_brief.pdf https://www.nasa.gov/sites/default/files/atoms/files/fy2020_...
- WalterBright 7y agoI have a friend who ordered the mechanical drawings for a P-51, intending to make P-51 assemblies. In investigating this, he talked to some P-51 experts who told him that the drawings were nearly useless. The real specification of the airplane was the tools and jigs created to make and assemble the parts. Those are long gone. The mechanical drawings were made after the fact to satisfy some DoD requirement.
- netman21 7y agoThis. I used to work in automotive engineering. I marveled at the lack of security around drawings for mechanical components. Ford, GM, and Chrysler all used the same design shops to create blueprints. When I went to get the latest drawings they would be sitting out on a big table in the lobby. The rolled up blueprint on top of the 9"mag tape that contained the CAD files. They were clearly marked with the car's model year and the part name and number. Anyone could grab it off the table. Only later in my career did I understand that the drawing for a component, while necessary, was more of a record, not an actual representation of the final component. The final part was a product of a tool that had been crafted to produce it. Die barbers had polished a stamping tool to get a wrinkle out. Someone in manufacturing had changed the melt time for a casting. The slump temperature for a windshield glass had been adjusted. A spray pattern for body paint was manually plugged into a robot arm and adjusted until the desired results were obtained.
- jsymolon 7y agochuckle, Classic case of the documentation doesn't match the "code".
- pjc50 7y agoYes. The UK encountered a variant of this with its project to extend the life of the Nimrod recon aircraft, which were built on airframes that had essentially been designed in the 1950s. The aircraft all being individual meant that a conventional waterfall project to build new parts and retrofit them encountered huge cost overruns. Someone described it as more of an "aircraft reenactment society" than a viable aircraft for the 21st century. One caught fire in the air and the project was eventually abandoned.
- ngcc_hk 7y agoOrganisation memory perhaps is a better word though not tribal / cultural memory. You can’t write everything done and for an ongoing concern you always have people around. In fact one of the problem is these Organization memory is sometimes in the way and you do not know why or even that exist. But here is about the absence, as it is not an on-going concern.
- cs02rm0 7y agoOrganisation would imply to me that the knowledge was held by the organisation as a whole though. Tribal implies small groups of individuals, which is probably closer to the truth.
- Cthulhu_ 7y agoSome things will have to be rebuilt though. I read a story the other day (probably from HN as well) about rebuilding an older model rocket engine, because they still had the plans. Turns out a lot of that depended on the skill of the engineers, welders, machinists etc at the time, which could compensate for small changes on the fly. It didn't work the same with modern manufacturing technologies and materials. Mind you I do believe the modern stuff is better, they can do the same or better performance with less material and waste.
- mattrp 7y agoNot to mention SLS which is just nonsense at this point. As well as the numerous delays on the demo missions to the ISS. This feels to me like an ultimatum to NASA... move the ball forward or get out of the game. I get the sense there is real fear we could lose the idea of ‘space’ if we don’t start showing some progress. As it stands now there isn’t a platform for the moon and there’s not going to be a platform by 2024 unless some really remarkable things start to happen.. I wouldn’t be surprised if Spacex does it but if it does I can’t imagine NASA will have anything other than token participation. Perhaps that is really for the best...
- JulianMorrison 7y agoNASA is going to end up being the label on the shipping crate. They don't have a funding model sufficiently detached from political actors trying to sell the sizzle and uninterested in somebody else's steak.
- jvanderbot 7y agoNASA builds, deploys, and operates the largest and most successful space exploration network in history and will hold that distinction for the forseeable future. The lunar campaign seems designed to force commercial partners to step up and become the UPS and Uber service for future NASA instruments and missions. You seem to be focused soley on SLS as a failure case and forget that when it comes to huge campaigns with fast turn arounds and zero room for error they dont have the funding model period.
- mattrp 7y agoI’m reading the reddit thread below and I’m inclined to say maybe as a permitting organization, there’s not just a place but a critical need for an org like NASA: https://www.reddit.com/r/spacex/comments/f2a1yx/eric_berger_nasa_confirms_crew_dragon_almost/ https://www.reddit.com/r/spacex/comments/f2a1yx/eric_berger_... But at the same time, how can it accomplish its mission without going on boondoggles like SLS? I just saw an article yesterday about a project they funded for Lockheed Martin for them to explore an SST that doesn’t create loud shockwaves... I guess you could say this falls under the Aeronautics mandate but really? Is this an area of research that needs government funding? Or can they say anything that furthers the understanding of safe flight and NASA’s regulatory mission of private space flight, then its justifiable?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- kiba 7y agoJWST is considered a highly mismanaged project with all the groundbreaking technology crammed into it.
- StillBored 7y agoYawn, space is dangerous. We would all still be living in trees with this attitude. I don't believe that we can actually design a system that is safe like this, so yes it needs a lot of testing and iterative improvement. In the meantime, we need to use it to launch equipment and a few brave souls that understand the risks. Actually to add to that, I think putting timescales in front of something like this as a tendency to clarify the goals and therefor simplify the engineering. If we sit around for decades trying to shave a couple ounces off every single part and build in triplicate redundancy so its perfect it will fail. If you look at apollo, what you see is that they had a review committee that followed up the work and tested/built their understanding from the ground up. Part of that was ripping out systems that were to complex to be easily understood when possible, and considering how everything worked together. In many ways this appears to be what spaceX is doing, initial design, prove it out with a bunch of launches, fix problems as they appear, etc. So one of most important design goals is designing something that will be launched thousands of times (not necessarily the same rocket, just the scale) rather than something that is designed to be the perfectly safe vehicle for another half dozen launches before we scrap it for another 40 years.
- throwawayhhakdl 7y agoThe problem with this approach is that you don’t get anything for the added risk. We could decide to keep trying. That is, build a rocket, put people on it, send it up, and repeat until one reaches the moon without exploding. That might get us to the moon faster, but it doesn’t improve our knowledge base much faster than carefully managed testing with carefully managed risks. If we get to the moon while taking a big chance, that doesn’t mean we get to cross off the things that could have gone wrong, but didn’t, as solved.
- CydeWeys 7y agoThe public has no appetite for dead astronauts. It's simply not workable to be so cavalier with astronaut lives, even if the astronauts themselves are willing.
- matt-attack 7y ago
- jacobwilliamroy 7y agoWe're gonna kill some astronauts, and blame it on Iran.
- wnevets 7y agoThat is because its a purely politically statement. NASA's budget and mission is largely kabuki theater. Remember when Bush Jr [0] said we were going to have a moon base and land a human on mars during his reelection year? [0] https://www.cnn.com/2004/TECH/space/01/14/bush.space/index.html https://www.cnn.com/2004/TECH/space/01/14/bush.space/index.h...
- ehnto 7y agoWe launch people on rockets every year to the ISS.
- 101404 7y agoThe Russians do it for the US. The US hasn't launched any astronaut in almost a decade. SpaceX and ULA have been certified recently to launch astronauts too. But launching to the orbit of the ISS (about 500 km) is very different from launching to lunar orbit (about 400000 km iirc). My money is on SpaceX to land on the moon before 2025, not any government. Not even China.
- varjag 7y ago"Even"? China has never been a space exploration powerhouse.
- dirktheman 7y agoLaunching people into space is one thing, but to land them on the moon and get them back safely is infinately harder. 2024? Not going to happen, it's impossible.
- ehnto 7y agoUnlikely just from the weight of bureaucracy, but I'm not sure about it being impossible. It took 8 years the first time, and that was in the 1960s. Surely with such technological advances, previous learned knowledge and some gumption it could be done.
- baq 7y agoone case in point is that you're citing cost-plus contract works. the current environment is conductive to different payout strategies.
- fredgrott 7y agoeven the Russian rocket thrusting nozzle tech that NASA dusted off to use was several years of integrated testing before a full booster test.
- nickik 7y agoWhile true in general, we already have Falcon Heavy, SpaceX Dragon and if it is just 'make the simplest possible moon mission' and you had the budget, you could make it happen. However that is not how Congress would do it anyway (NASA can not choice).