18 ms·
AMD Threadripper 3990X 64-Core beats dual Xeon Platinum 8280 in benchmark leak
- mtgx 7y agoIt baffles me that Apple continues to use Xeons (?!) over Ryzen 9/Threadrippers in its Mac Pros, most of all because it could gain a much larger profit margin than with the Intel CPUs, but also because I think they could make the Mac Pros a bit more accessible to professionals. It makes little sense, considering they already use AMD GPUs, so it's not like they can even say "we just wanted the very best for our customers" (which doesn't seem to be Intel for CPUs anymore anyway), because then they would've gone with Nvidia GPUs. This is purely because of its corporate relationship with Intel and the product and the customers suffer for it.
- cbg0 7y agoHats off to AMD for giving Intel a run for their money in recent years, this competition is amazing for the consumers.
- bjoli 7y agoEven in the consumer range, the Ryzen 5-9 parts are crazy value as well when building a reasonably future-proof computer. I am building a 3900x computer now, and with screen and peripherals it will end up sub 3k (this is Swedish prices, so it is quite a bit more expensive than in the US).
- chupasaurus 7y agoAn advice: get a decent cooling for 3900X, stock Wraith Prism can't hold it.
- ChuckNorris89 7y agoI feel it's safe to assume that any enthusiast building his own system with high end parts won't be using the stock cooler which I feel needlessly increases the cost of the product that's passed on to us for something that will end up in the seller. Although you can buy the CPUs in TRAY format without the cooler, the prices are almost identical to the BOXED version and your warranty is lower since they're designed to be sold to businesses not consumers.
- rekoil 7y agoTo the point where I question the legitimacy of including stock coolers with such demanding processors. My own Wraith Prism is just sitting in the basement, and I don't see myself ever using it, unless something happens to my high-end cooling system and I need to install something while getting it fixed, at which point it'll go back to the basement again. It would be interesting to see statistics on how many Wraith Prism coolers sold together with 3900X CPU:s actually end up being used. I expect the number to be quite low.
- JimmyAustin 7y agoThe first gen of Ryzen 7 chips didn't even include a cooler. I suspect they throw in the cools just so reviewers don't put "no cooler included" in the cons section of reviews.
- opencl 7y agoThe 1700 came with a cooler (I know because I have one), it was just the higher TDP 1700X and 1800X that didn't.
- pkroll 7y agoI'd expect it to be pretty high: given reviews, I went with the stock Wraith Prism, and it's been fine. If I did bump up, I'd go to a Noctua, as the water cooling just seems like theater. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=23vjWtUpItk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=23vjWtUpItk
- p1necone 7y agoThe stock coolers on Ryzen processors are really really good compared to Intel stock coolers. Maybe not so great for a 3900x, but they'll even support light overclocking on most of the other Ryzen options.
- sundvor 7y agoThe AMD 7nm TDP might have something to do with that. :)
- dTal 7y agoMore advice: don't get carried away with liquid cooling solutions - they will always leak eventually, and if the pump fails your CPU instantly fries. Just get the biggest honking Noctua fan+heatsink you can fit in your case and call it good. It's silent, simple, reliable, and if the fan does fail the heatsink will save your CPU.
- deadbunny 7y agoIf the pump fails the CPU will thermal shutdown and be fine once you've replace the cooler/pump. Also not sure if you're counting AIO coolers in with water cooling but they are very reliable.
- simias 7y agoI agree with you that a properly designed CPU shouldn't instantly fry for lack of cooling but is water cooling really worth it? As far as I can tell outside of very esoteric special-purpose equipment it seem very uncommon in the professional world and seems mostly popular with g4m3rs looking to impress their peers with their $10k gaming PC builds. In my experience air cooling with a sufficiently large heatsink is simple and very reliable. Water cooling is more expensive, trickier and can fail catastrophically.
- deadbunny 7y agoI use the AIO water cooler on my home system because I can get the system essentially silent (0.5m from my ears) at reasonable temps. They are also a lot less fiddily to deal with (install, ram access, etc...) compared to the huge air cooler you would need for comparable performance IMO.
- idsout 7y agoAll in One (AIO) also known as a closed loop cooler for the uninitiated. They're water coolers that come in a single pre-built piece that you just attach like any fan. Source: Been rocking Corsair AIO coolers for around a decade now. I did have have the pump fail in one of them after around seven years of use.
- philliphaydon 7y agoThe stock cooler can handle it just fine.
- Macha 7y agoIt can handle itself in the sense that CPU won't overheat or spend its entire time throttled. It can't handle it in the sense that it's very loud in doing so, and the CPU will boost more with a better cooler, even with no other changes. I bought a 3900x and planned to use the stock cooler initially, but that lasted about 3 weeks before I replaced it due to noise primarily (I got a be quiet dark rock pro 4).
- philliphaydon 7y agoI think a after market cooler is always going to be better, but I think it's disingenuous to state it can't handle it. In your specific case it handled it fine but was loud.
- duncanawoods 7y agoIMHO it crosses the line from "loud" to something unacceptable enough to call broken. At idle with default fan curves, it was on the knife-edge of max-speed not just loud but continuously revving up and down so incredibly distracting. It would continually grab my attention even with headphones on. I barely lasted a day before ordering a Dark Pro 4 and now it's silent.
- philliphaydon 7y agoDo people just leave the side of their case off or something. At 100% it's definitely not loud unless I remove the side panel off my case. It makes a noise for sure, but everyone makes it sound like it's the end of the world noise.
- duncanawoods 7y agoEh, mine was in a heavy-duty steel tower and it definitely wasn't fit for purpose. Maybe you just got lucky... or perhaps double-check that you aren't accidentally under-volting :)
- gameswithgo 7y ago>stock Wraith Prism can't hold it. It can, just fine. A better cooler keeps it cooler, and you might get an extra 0.1 mhz from it. With the Prism, if you have had/having trouble with it keep in mind two things: 1. there is a switch on it for a higher or lower fan setting 2. you have to crank that little lever HARD all the way over to properly clamp it down. Lot of people miss that.
- vbezhenar 7y agoHow is the stability of the system? I always afraid of AMD because of their low investments into software that AMD systems won't be rock stable. Especially with Linux, where Intel commits a lot of code into kernel. But AMD value is tremendeous, especially comparing with Intel CPU supporting ECC. I'm thinking about buying Xeon W-2265 workstation and it's just 12 cores for $1200, AMD is much cheaper and for that price I can get Threadripper monster.
- simion314 7y ago>I always afraid of AMD because of their low investments into software that AMD systems won't be rock stable. Especially with Linux, where Intel commits a lot of code into kernel AMD CPUs are used on servers so there is no reason they won't make all it's possible to have a stable system, are you referring to AMD GPUs? I read it takes up to 1 year after release until the graphics driver gets stable on Linux.
- numpad0 7y agoRyzen 1st-gen had the segfault issue, RNG issue, voltage/clock related ones and few more. RX480 and 580 were exact same chips, only the latter was mature manufacturing wise and had completely different firmware resulting in a superior performance. It’s true that AMD products has yield(as anyone else) as well as parameter tuning/compatibility issues especially early on. I don’t think their issues are of reliability kinds(like early failure in industrial Intel Atom) though.
- missosoup 7y agoSwitched from intel to amd with the same concerns at the back of my mind. Never had a single issue.
- bennyelv 7y agoI used to work at a global financial services firm that was AMD only back in the late 2000's when they were on top in the CPU wars. We never had any negative consequences from making that decision.
- jhoechtl 7y agoMaybe we will see that Moores law still holds (somewhat) true and it was Intels de-facto monopoly and their inability for progress to declare the end of Moore?
- qubex 7y agoVery perceptive. Moore’s Law has been holding strong in the mobile/embedded market (ARM), on GPUs, and on neural processing units (TPP & cetera). The death di Moore’s Law was premature fratricide courtesy of it’s brother Intel (both being offspring of Moore himself).
- ansible 7y agoMy understanding of conventional wisdom from maybe 15 years ago was that we'd run out of memory bandwidth for high core-count processors. Is this now a factor? I know memory has gotten faster, and multi-channel of course helps, but is that all really enough for typical workloads?
- cma 7y agoIt has a separate dedicated IO die, allowing memory access/latency to all cores. I think threadripper does have less bandwidth than the 64 core Epyc part though.
- greglindahl 7y agoCPUs keep on getting more memory channels per socket. That trend was already visible 15 years ago, when AMD moved the northbridge onto the CPU. Scaling it depends on scaling pin counts, which are now amazing.
- wtallis 7y agoTo put some numbers to this: In 2005, Opterons used a 940-pin socket and had dual-channel DDR, for 6.4GB/s total bandwidth to feed two cores. In 2009, Xeons the LGA1366 socket to provide triple-channel DDR3, 32GB/s for four (later six) cores. Now, we're up to 4094 pin sockets providing 8 channels of DDR4 for a total of 204.8GB/s of memory bandwidth for 64 cores, which is exactly the same per-core bandwidth we had in 2005. (And for comparison, a $200 graphics card will also have around 200GB/s of memory bandwidth.)
- hoistbypetard 7y agoAs a happy first gen Threadripper user (read: someone who wants this) my big question here is what boards will be available. Last time I looked, most of the motherboards available did not inspire confidence when it came to moving away from Xeons.
- jdc 7y agoHow so? Which features are you looking for?
- amarshall 7y agoPresumably they’re referring to how the current crop of TRX40 motherboards are all very “gaming” oriented, rather than workstation or server.
- onli 7y agoBut they are not at all? TRX40 is way too expensive for a gaming system and these processors do not target gamers. The only a little bit gamicky TRX40 boards are the two Asus ROG boards, and even there the gaming marketing is toned down a lot on their product pages. The ASRock TRX40 Taichi looks maybe a little bit as well like that, because of the RGB lightning. But all of those are firmly workstation board, with the huge amount of expansions slots you'd expect from that socket. And literally every other board I saw is either called a Pro, Extreme, or Design/Creator board.
- posix_me_less 7y agoThey do target gamers and enthusiast "must have it" types, check AMD's and mobo manufacturers's marketing - it is their halo product. Of course, it makes no sense if you only game. TRX40 platform can be better used as a workstation but is indeed expensive, I would say too expensive, for what you get. Only 4 DDR channels, only 256GB RAM at max, only expensive unbuffered DDR4. Most TRX40 boards have only one 10Gbit NIC. Only 4 PCIe slots... This is 2010 level tech. The only real selling point of this is TR CPU performance and performance per cpu cost, but otherwise this is a mediocre platform. It does have PCIe 4, yes, but that has little benefits for now. "Pro, Extreme, Creator" tags do not make this on par with the established Xeon workstation platforms. This is how a high-end workstation board looks like: https://www.servethehome.com/supermicro-x11spa-t-motherboard-review-an-intel-xeon-w-3200-platform/ https://www.servethehome.com/supermicro-x11spa-t-motherboard... You can get it for... wait for it... $500. Clearly TRX40 mobo manufacturers are taking advantage of gullible consumers.
- rwmj 7y agoWe have a few of these AMD Daytona X systems (2 socket, 64 cores per socket). They're beasts. It's nice doing -j256 builds.
- fmajid 7y agoHow much effective parallelism do you get out of them?
- rwmj 7y agoI didn't specifically measure that, but most builds are limited by Amdahl's law (./configure kills you) and there will rarely be 256 compiles that can happen in parallel at any one time.
- imtringued 7y agoMay you be blessed with incremental builds. Linking is also a big culprit.
- rwmj 7y agoFor interactive development work sure, but Red Hat builds distros and package builds are done from scratch. I agree about linking. Also Fedora (and therefore RHEL 9) is about to move to LTO which makes everything much worse.
- koheripbal 7y agoI wonder if they'd be good for my RDS servers...
- suedpfalz 7y agoI use OpenEmbedded/Yocto to build embedded firmware and have no problem to run 256 compiles in parallel.
- 2zcon 7y ago
- glandium 7y ago> There has been some speculation that the Threadripper 3990X could arrive at $2,999 Come on, AMD announced it would be $3990 at CES!
- vorticalbox 7y agocould this not be simply down to the fact it was tested against a dual sock system? is the benchmark used NUMA aware?
- amarshall 7y agoI believe some or all of SiSoftware test are NUMA-aware. Regardless, 128/112 threads = 1.143 and 1786/1516 score = 1.178. Really not far off thread-scaling.
- tmaly 7y agoThis is great news. I just started planning to build a video editing machine over the next few months. Are prices likely to come down more? The AMD Ryzen 9 3900X 12-core was what I was looking at. This new 3990X looks amazing, but its probably overkill for what I need.
- puranjay 7y agoI have a 3700X that I use primarily for music production and it runs flawlessly. Prices, at least on NewEgg India, haven't budget even a cent in 4 months though. I would recommend getting a different cooler though. The stock cooler, while adequate, runs noisy and doesn't feel all that sturdy.
- eklavya 7y agoThanks, I didn't even know newegg came to India !
- blattimwind 7y agoDepending on what you use for video editing the CPU really isn't much of a factor.
- BubRoss 7y agoVideo encoding is still very CPU intensive, especially newer codecs like HEVC VP9 and AV1
- blattimwind 7y agoTrue, but that's only for delivery. A good editor like Resolve runs mostly on the GPU, even when rendering for delivery -- whether the encoder also uses the GPU is a separate matter. For what it's worth, h.264 GPU encoders are good enough nowadays that there isn't much point using x264 at a fraction of the performance. In my mind this makes it preferable to opt for a stronger GPU, if you have to decide between a stronger CPU or a stronger GPU (e.g. you have 300 $ left in your budget and want to decide where to put them).
- rubyn00bie 7y agoWhile I am incredibly stoked for AMD pushing the envelope, this should be a gigantic sign to Intel that their entire market is about to be commoditized by physics unless they put every single dollar they have into pushing the envelope (AND get extremely lucky in the breakthrough). Without the advent of Quantum computers, solving P=NP for our computational benefit, and/or some other unworldly mathematics, the PC industry is pretty fucked in ~10-15 years save those who transition into services.
- swarnie_ 7y agoCan anyone vouch for how well consumer CPUs have come along in the last 5-10 years? I'm still running a i7 2700k and haven't even felt the need to upgrade. I guess i didn't want to when Intel only released $600-$800 scam CPUs, now were seeing reasonable competition is it worth another look?
- onli 7y agoI run a meta benchmark[0] that is set up to answer exactly questions this this. The answer: Processors made a big jump since then! There was not that much movement after the 2600K, but only until Ryzen got released. The 2600K is now on rank 86 of my benchmark, way below $120 cpus like the Ryzen 5 2600 [1]. That comparison just shows games, but in in other application workloads the difference is even bigger, because of the better multithreaded performance of Ryzen and Threadripper processors. The 3970X just completely dominates outside of games, but with the Ryzen 9s there are two cheaper and still extremely strong processor for consumer AM4 systems available. And Intel has way stronger processors than the 2600K now as well, the complete 9000 series staring with the i5-9400F ($140). Stronger cores and more of them, i5s have six now, the i7-9700K 8 and the i9-9900K adds hyperthreading. [0]: https://www.pc-kombo.com/us/benchmark https://www.pc-kombo.com/us/benchmark [1]: https://www.pc-kombo.com/us/benchmark/games/cpu/compare?ids%5B%5D=Intel+Core+i7-2600K&ids%5B%5D=AMD+Ryzen+5+2600 https://www.pc-kombo.com/us/benchmark/games/cpu/compare?ids%...
- Brave-Steak 7y agoThis is great, thanks. One of my biggest issues in PC hardware has been comparing older parts with modern ones. Most sites don't retest old hardware with new tests that they use on new hardware, so you end up with wildly different numbers that don't tell you anything.
- onli 7y agoThanks, and exactly! It's an interesting algorithmic problem to get many of those separate benchmarks and put them into a global order. That's what the site does.
- 0xWTF 7y agoIs this uncooled AMD vs Intel comparison still relevant? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HDLjVwxH-Fk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HDLjVwxH-Fk
- oliwarner 7y agoThe 20 years since this video is a long time... But I still remember my P2s and P3s that melted themselves. In the case of the slot-mount P2, it literally melted. So relevant? Probably just as important now as then, but a few P3 designs not melting two decades ago shouldn't give you confidence to do this with a 9900KS.
- rasz 7y ago>P3 designs not melting two decades ago P3s melted, Throttling was a brand new P4 feature, probably a must considering how hot they ran
- oliwarner 7y agoYeah, I had one fail from cooler malfunction, but the video shows one managing to undervolt its way to safety under load. I suspect some were better than others. That's what I meant by "a few P3 designs"; some, not all of them.
- rasz 7y agoP4. You, like most people at the time (until AMD response and subsequent article), missed a trick Toms Hardware employed :(. Undoubtedly following Intel "suggestions" send together with P4 sample press kit, Toms Hardware used specific P3 motherboard with external thermal protection. P3 CPU neither throttled nor shut down on its own, and we dont even see in the video if it survived either. External thermal protection circuit on the motherboard detected high temperature and cut out CPU supply voltage, exactly as described in "Pentium III Processor Active Thermal Management Techniques" http://notes-application.abcelectronique.com/027/27-46150.pdf http://notes-application.abcelectronique.com/027/27-46150.pd... AMD had analogous app note. Motherboard used in Toms Hardware video, Siemens one, was supposedly equipped with very same circuit, it failed. AMD was blamed instead of Siemens. This was at the height of Intel meddling. They directly bribed vendors, ugh Im sorry, I meant offered rebates under MCP (Meet Comp Program) in exchange for strict no AMD commitments. DELL, HP all took Intel $, $6 billion in kick-backs. Another Intel tactic was manufacturing facts and positive press stories, something we now call fake news. Ubisoft loves money, so it will come as no surprise to learn they took a brib^^ promotional marketing funds to plaster huge "Designed for Intel MMX" on game BOX https://www.mobygames.com/images/covers/l/51358-pod-windows-front-cover.jpg https://www.mobygames.com/images/covers/l/51358-pod-windows-... Hint: MMX is Integer math only, unsuitable for accelerating 3D games. Whats worse MMX has no dedicated registers, and instead reuses/shares FPU ones, this means you cant use MMX and FPU (all 3D code pre Direct3D 7 Hardware T&L) at the same time. In POD its used for one specific sound effect (audio filter) and has zero influence on game speed. BTW this wouldnt be the 1st time Ubisoft sold its clients to a highest bidder. Nvidia copied this technique with "the way its meant to be played" campaign https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22090413 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22090413. Intel SSE also got a big push with fake 3D acceleration claims https://www.vogons.org/viewtopic.php?f=46&t=65247&start=20#p734738 https://www.vogons.org/viewtopic.php?f=46&t=65247&start=20#p... Intel version: "At the time, I was working for Intel and was involved in the launch of the Pentium 3, aka Katmai. We _engaged_ a number of games manufacturers to provide demos showcasing not only Screaming Sindy's Extensions, but the arcane and mysterious Katmai New Instructions. One such outfit was Rage Software, now sadly deceased. Rage provided demos of Incoming and an early prototype of a game called Dispatched, which as far as I know never actually saw the light of day. Dispatched featured a strangely-arousing cat riding a jet powered motorcycle. The first version I saw was running on a 400MHz Katmai and was still in wireframe. It was bloody impressive." Reality, according to hardware.fr: "Let's start with Dispatched first. This is actually a Rage Software game that should come out late 99, which Intel showed the demo at Comdex Fall to highlight the benefits of the SSE. Big interest, it is possible to enable or disable the use of SSE instructions at any time. Nothing to say in terms of speed, it goes squarely faster once the SSE activated, + 50% to + 100% depending on the scenes! But looking closely at the demo, we notice - as you can see on the screenshots - that the _SSE version is less detailed_ than the non-SSE version (see the ground). Intel would you try to roll the journalists in the flour?" SSE version is less detailed? How convenient! Rage Software Dispatched never came out. The only outfit, other than Intel, in possession of this software was Anandtech. They used this exclusive press access to pimp out Pentium 3 benchmarks manufacturing fiction like this https://images.anandtech.com/old/cpu/intel-pentium3/Image94.gif https://images.anandtech.com/old/cpu/intel-pentium3/Image94....
- bitxbit 7y agoThis is great but why is it so difficult for AMD to break into the enterprise/server side of the market? Seems Intel is very entrenched in that space despite their clear exercise of market power for over a decade.
- pixl97 7y agoBetween Intel manipulating the server OEMs, and relatively poor lights out management, who could guess?
- wilhil 7y agoI said before - it's more than just this. AMD's ecosystem just sucks... Intel may be doing things that are questionable, but, as a OEM on the much smaller size, Intel have a great partner program. With Intel, I get advanced warranties, presales support, next day parts, details marketing and product information alongside access to privileged information and roadmaps. With AMD, I was waiting the best part of 3 months for a call back, and their "partner" site which is open to the world is severely out of date and doesn't even have all products listed. Intel is frictionless when it comes to doing business, AMD put up roadblocks.
- bitxbit 7y agoThis is my understanding as well. And why I believe AMD needs to either merge or be acquired to really make a run at CPU/GPU market. They’re seriously underperforming (this isn’t to say Lisa Su is a bad CEO).
- posix_me_less 7y agoFor big companies, migration to AMD is a risky move. Old applications work well on Intel and Intel has been reliable for years. Big corps love boring tech. Now that Intel offering sucks, they do notice but they are not jumping all the the same time. Will the old applications work well on the new AMD tech? What if there is an incompatibility/HW bug on AMD platform which makes critical applications fail? It takes years for the big companies to get interested in such a big of a platform switch. For now, they've been sticking with Intel and observing how the situation develops. If Intel keeps screwing up, which they do, eventually the big migration will happen.
- Angostura 7y agoI wonder how long until Apple starts looking at AMD.
- ckastner 7y agoI think it's sensible to assume that Apple is already looking, even if only to renegotiate their deal with Intel. But 8 cores at 15W is really enticing. Apple is already using AMD graphics, so they already have a business relationship.
- eyegor 7y agoDon't forget that Apple already has best in class low power performance/watt on their in house designs. One day they'll probably move all the Mac airs and such to A13 or newer.
- agloeregrets 7y agoWell, it’s kinda assumed that Apple wants to go ARM based for the Mac with their own internal CPUs. Much of AMD’s comeback magic is enabled by them building on TSMC’s 7nm process, this same process is what Apple’s Ax SOCs are built on, so I bet Apple could come close in the consumer market.
- jagger27 7y agoI think that ship sailed when they they shipped the new Mac Pro. That would have been the place to start.
- tachion 7y agoMac Pro was in the making long before AMD released a complete line of products that can compete with Intel on all fronts (not only price, but single core and multi core performance, clock speeds and so on) so quite possibly they'd have to delay Mac Pro even further, if they'd decide to stop and redesign it for AMD platform. Given how willing they been to switch GPU chips between Nvidia and AMD/ATI in past for their laptops, I still have a little hope for something like iMac or iMac Pro with a nice high cpu count AMD CPU in future. I don't hold my breath though.
- tyingq 7y agoI think the server CPU area will be more immediately interesting. What's interesting this time, vs Opteron, is that AMD doesn't need to convince a bunch of conservative data center managers. A few key wins with the three cloud giants, and Intel will feel it. And the cloud giants can start with things like managed messaging, databases, etc, where it's not directly exposed to end users. Similar for the various high end AARCH64 CPUs. Intel is in for a ride.
- jerven 7y agoAlso this time Intel has been pissing of conservative data center managers with all the security issues and performance loss due to them.
- earenndil 7y agoConservative data center managers aren't particularly pissed off. Source: know one.
- ksec 7y agoExcept this hasn't happened. If anything Intel is still selling as many as they could produce as shown in the latest quarterly report [1]. So while AMD managed to grow double digit over a very small number, it still felt they were picking up the scraps from Intel. And Amazon is full steam ahead with their own ARM CPU. I wonder if Google and Microsoft paused and think they will need to act now if they haven't already. [1] https://www.anandtech.com/show/15433/intel-q4-fy-2019-results-record-quarter-record-year https://www.anandtech.com/show/15433/intel-q4-fy-2019-result...
- Shorel 7y agoI agree, Intel sells everything they make, and it has been like that for years. The difference is that AMD is starting to do the same, and it seems the process and architecture lets them make more chips than Intel. And this forces Intel to lower prices on the more powerful chips, something that had not happened in about a decade. Right now the winners are the customers, having such great chips at good prices.
- wilhil 7y agoThe only annoying thing here is the thread count!! Intel do servers at all levels including low core count/high core frequency, where as AMD have a very decent core count, but, performance between the models is largely just an increase in core count (there is very little difference in frequency - e.g. NO high frequency/low core) So many jobs still require Windows licenses unfortunately and since the shift to core count, it's ludicrously expensive to license a lot of the new AMD machines on SPLA licensing. Not that I'm not trying though...
- 3fe9a03ccd14ca5 7y agoThe high-performance, low core count CPU market is not well served by AMD, but I don’t think that’s a large segment of the CPU purchasing share. AMD is aiming for top dog not boutique.
- zrm 7y agoThe trouble is you can't actually scale that way. You might be able to make a 5GHz dual core that can match a 2.5GHz quad core, but nobody can make the 80GHz dual core that would be needed to match a 2.5GHz 64-core. Good luck even making a 5GHz 32-core unless you want to measure power consumption in kilowatts. Meanwhile if all you need is single thread performance for lower core counts, that's Ryzen rather than Epyc, but it's not like they don't make that.
- wilhil 7y agoAgreed, but, not really for servers/enterprise usage which the parent thread was about... For example, I7/I9 is much cheaper and more powerful than entry level Xeons, but, you VERY rarely see them in a rackmount chassis/server. Same goes for Epyc and Ryzen.
- zrm 7y agoThe main enterprise thing you get from Xeon and not Core is ECC memory, but Ryzen does support ECC memory, and anybody can put it in a rackmount chassis. Whether or not it's common, it's available if you want it.
- lisk1 7y agoJust heard that VMware is changing the license for vSphere up to 32 cores and you have to pay more expensive license if your using more than 32 cores per CPU. In my opinion VMware products are overated there are good enough free to use products similar to vShpere without the per CPU/socket licenses with payed support if you need one.
- whalesalad 7y agoOverrated? If I had to pick a level 1 hypervisor for a production environment id probably choose VMware without hesitation.
- tasubotadas 7y agoWhat makes it so good?
- JackRabbitSlim 7y agoIf there is a show stopping bug I can throw VMWare under the bus. If Xen has a show stopping bug I get to patch it myself. Oh you mean technical reasons? None.
- chousuke 7y agoWell, you could buy RHEV and throw Red Hat under the bus. I don't know if there are enterprise-supported Xen distros. Alternative exist, but VMWare has a lot of mindshare and their products are pretty good, so they're hard to beat.
- e12e 7y ago> I don't know if there are enterprise-supported Xen distros. Didn't Citrix buy xen a while back (or some part of it)? They had something called xenapp, now apparently "Citrix Virtual Apps and Desktops (XenApp & XenDesktop)"? Not really the same as "a supported xen distro" I guess.
- 7y ago
- faebi 7y agoHow do you see the future of AMD in the next 1-3 years? Will they get anywhere close to Intel in terms of sales?
- leshenka 7y agoWith news like this (https://wccftech.com/amd-dominates-retail-cpu-sales-outselling-intel-2-to-1/ https://wccftech.com/amd-dominates-retail-cpu-sales-outselli...) yea I believe they can do that.
- bitL 7y ago3990X is limited to 256GB RAM, so not really a competitor to dual Xeons anyway...
- p_l 7y agoOfficial numbers say 1TB, which is probably what was "validated" and the real numbers are "how many JEDEC-compatible ranks can you fit before the signal degrades too much", as was the norm with AMD. They don't put artificial limits on CPUs
- bitL 7y agoThere are no 128GB UDIMM modules and I doubt they will ever be for DDR4.