6 ms·
I honestly cannot blame someone in that business for hating linux. The number of variables to test for if you only care about windows gamers is staggering. Linu
by bob1029 7y ago
I honestly cannot blame someone in that business for hating linux. The number of variables to test for if you only care about windows gamers is staggering. Linux is 10x harder than windows if you care about supporting any arbitrary distribution and driver stack. I think if users were willing to load a linux VM for each game they'd like to play, this would be more manageable from a game developer's perspective.
I understand SDL2 exists. I understand that Valve has "mostly" pulled off linux/macos support. But, is it really worth it from a business perspective for all game developers to support linux? How big and wide do your margins need to be before it makes financial sense to fully support both operating systems? How many features (or even titles) will stay in the backlog because your developers are busy chasing down the 5000th weird linux network/GPU/sound bug that only occurs on this one kinda-old version of Ubuntu?
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 7y ago> I think if users were willing to load a linux VM for each game they'd like to play, this would be more manageable from a game developer's perspective. As I understand it, this is the direction Steam is heading by running games in containers.
- throwaway2048 7y agosteam does not run games in containers.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 7y agoNot yet, but: https://www.phoronix.com/scan.php?page=news_item&px=Steam-Linux-Exp-Containers https://www.phoronix.com/scan.php?page=news_item&px=Steam-Li...
- bob1029 7y agoIf it turns out that this path is acceptable to the masses, I am 100% on board with all game developers following a similar pattern. Personally, I don't have a problem with this, especially considering most games I install these days are upwards of 100 gigabytes anyways. If 2 gigabytes of each game was a Linux OS image and supporting tools, I probably wouldn't notice. Having a standardized Linux image with containerization support shared across the entire industry could be a really powerful tool for game developers who want to target Linux but don't have EA's budget. Over time, this could put Linux on equal footing with Windows in terms of platform support cost.
- gambiting 7y agoThat's not going to happen. The main benefit of developing natively for windows is that the game should pretty much compile for Xbox straight away, with some minimal changes to the code. The PC build is almost a byproduct here. I don't personally see devs making a linux-but-not-really version for Windows if that cuts them off having a "free" xbox version. And from financial point of view having a Linux vs Xbox version is almost a non-starter, unless you're targeting some hyper-nieche.
- kgwxd 7y agoSupporting only a single distro of Linux would be fine. If it's not my prefered distro, I'd be happy to dual boot into another to play a game. But I don't want Windows on any of my machines, even as a secondary OS.
- Jasper_ 7y agoPeople always say this, but then post support comments saying stuff like "nobody uses Ubuntu, everybody uses insert distro here". It's a big mess to support.
- FreeFull 7y agoOfficially Steam only supports Ubuntu, and other distros do the work to make it run on them. The same could probably be done for games.
- grawprog 7y agoI'm still not sure.why game developers are aiming to support distros rather than library versions. That tends to be the biggest problem with linux is the huge number of versions of libraries each distro could have or not have and the location of said libraries on the system. That's the issue crossplatform developers should be aiming to tackle rather than trying to cater.to every single linux distro. That's like trying to shoot at minnows in the ocean with a BB gun.
- wink 7y agoAlso last I checked, if it works on Ubuntu, someone usually will make it work on other distros of roughly the same generation, often within a week. If the core is available, the linux gaming community is quite amazing.
- BubRoss 7y agoI don't even understand why anyone bothers with targeting dynamic libraries. Why not statically compile everything? The system calls aren't changing are they?
- Rebelgecko 7y ago>I understand that Valve has "mostly" pulled off linux/macos support Although I think the vast majority of their games don't work on the most recent OSX release. Depending on your perspective, either Apple pulled the rug out from under them, or Valve is letting their code atrophy. Maybe a bit of both, but my opinion is more of the former.
- baldfat 7y agoThat is 100% Apple's fault and makes me thankful for backwards compatibility. Music Production has been hit hard by this same move. Plugins and virtual instruments that people have been using for years are all gone from support. All the open source plugins are out right now. Everyone is holding off and I am glad I use Linux and Windows 10 for music.
- jamesgeck0 7y ago> or Valve is letting their code atrophy There haven't been many good reasons to release a 32-bit only macOS app for some time. If Valve is at fault, it's that they didn't require publishers to submit 64-bit builds for macOS years ago.
- egypturnash 7y agoValve didn't even have a 64-bit build of Steam for the Mac until after Catalina was out.
- jamesgeck0 7y agoI forgot about this. Valve released a 64-bit build of Steam two months before Catalina came out [1], but they did not migrate users of the 32-bit version to the 64-bit version automatically. https://9to5mac.com/2018/07/27/steam-for-mac-64-bit/ https://9to5mac.com/2018/07/27/steam-for-mac-64-bit/
- Dylan16807 7y agoThere hasn't been much reason to release a new one, but there also hasn't been much reason to port old ones.
- traverseda 7y agoOf course linux is pretty flexible. Wouldn't it be nice if you could just target linux, and get it to automatically support windows/macos? Like a reverse proton? That should be a lot easier than proton ever was. That's the direction I'd like to see steam's containerization go.
- ActorNightly 7y ago>Linux is 10x harder than windows if you care about supporting any arbitrary distribution and driver stack. Not really. Most hardware is very standard these days, which is why you can install Ubuntu on most any laptop or desktop and have it work with less than or equal issues than a Windows install. Amd and Nvidia both have Linux drivers that work on all the popular distros. The reason devs don't even bother with Linux is because there isn't enough people that are playing on Linux.
- BubRoss 7y agoAmd and Nvidia drivers for what? Big games aren't being made with openGL. What is the state of vulcan across drivers and engines?
- BlackLotus89 7y ago> Amd and Nvidia drivers for what? Big games aren't being made with openGL. Doom 2016? > What is the state of vulcan across drivers and engines? Quite good actually. Intel has older generations supported than on windows. There are 2 mature AMD vulkan implementations. Also through investments of valve there is a new shader compiler in the works that got merged in mesa which helps quite a lot. The performance is about equal, but sometimes faster under windows (I didn't look at benchmarks of 2020). Oh and vulkan 1.2 is implemented in mesa 20. Oh and it's vulkan not vulcan
- proncton 7y ago>which is why you can install Ubuntu This is actually one of the root causes. It would be SO MUCH EASIER, for me, an app developer, if every linux user used centos, or ubuntu, or mint, or whatever the hell. Don't care, pick one. But, customizing is part of the fun... anyways. Also yeah, desktop Linux is about 10% of users, depending on who you ask. Worse for gamers, although that's just feedback loops. There's one more thing though, which most people aren't aware of... driver versions. Drivers often ship game-specific hacks for performance fixes. It's an insane, unspoken practice that occurs because some developers will only test heavily on one mfg GPU. Right now, nvidia is taking the brunt of the work because consoles are AMD based.
- jandrese 7y agoNobody is going to support 5 year old Slackware for their game distribution platform. They'll support current Ubuntu and maybe Fedora--anybody else can work out the problems on their own. And by support I mean a one-off build for the platform and a public forum where users can ask and answer questions of other users. Maybe if you're lucky they'll do a new build when a patch is released. Linux users aren't asking for much, and Epic has been more than just dismissive to them. They've been outright hostile, doing things like adding checks to make sure the game isn't running under Wine.
- gamblor956 7y agoLinux users are asking for quite a lot; not just support for Ubuntu and Fedora but for all the random custom builds and drivers out there. It's simply not worth it when 0.3% of your customers represents more hardware and software configurations than the remaining 99.7%.
- thethrowboat 7y agoI thought steam only supports ubuntu and therefore games only support ubuntu. That being said, I use arch and most games just work.
- gamblor956 7y agoRocket League isn't available on Steam (anymore). Epic does not technically support Linux outside of Android.
- Polycryptus 7y agoRocket League is not (yet) available on the Epic Games Store, and has not been removed from Steam.
- noicebrewery 7y agoYou're making things up; who are these Linux users demanding anything? Generally speaking once a game developer gets it working on Ubuntu the Arch wiki guys will happily figure out the rest on their own.