10 ms·
Here's the main offender: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/User:Christopher_Monsanto http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/User:Christopher_Monsanto One of his arguments i
by jacques_chester 16y ago
Here's the main offender:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/User:Christopher_Monsanto http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/User:Christopher_Monsanto
One of his arguments is that these languages are often only mentioned in conference proceedings.
How you get to be a PhD student in computer science without realising that conference proceedings are the leading distribution mechanism for knowledge in the CS research world is a mystery.
I may only be a humble honours student, but the central importance of conferences over journals has been drummed into me over and over by my professors.
- j_baker 16y ago> We need better criteria for establishing notability of programming languages: for some reason, a number of people seem to think languages are notable if they are mentioned in a book/third-tier academic paper or have a few people who contribute to/use them. My favorite part is how he admits the rules he's enforcing are inadequate, and yet continues to enforce them.
- katovatzschyn 16y agoMy favorite part is how he admits the rules he's enforcing are inadequate, and yet continues to enforce them. Sounds like furthering a cause. By the specificness of that cause, I would have to bet: - Had an article he wrote on a small programming language, possibly his own, deleted for not being notable enough. - Feels that less notable languages than the one in question were not treated similarly. - Perceives injustice. - Takes action. Hopefully nothing other than some quality encyclopedia writing and anti-deletionist attitude (space is very cheap) comes from this. I don't like how ugly this is already becoming.
- j_baker 16y agoI doubt it. Chances are, he's just taking an "I don't make the rules, I just enforce them" attitude. I'm always annoyed by people who don't evaluate rules critically, but I suppose that's just something you have to deal with in life.
- jbooth 16y agoSo this guy's basically the "small town douchey cop" of wikipedia editors? Is he gonna try to organize sting operations on high school parties next?
- rst 16y agoA Ph.D. student in the field of programming languages, no less. Their grad student directory points to this rather thin homepage: http://monsan.to/ http://monsan.to/ I can't find anything in citeseer, though.
- chrismonsanto 16y agoNo, of course I know that :( The problem was that the papers mentioned were either 1) not about the subject in question or 2) not cited enough to count. Hopefully your professors also drummed into you that anyone can write a paper and send it to a conference -- the kicker is if it actually makes an impact. Isn't that more-or-less the definition of notability? None of the articles I nominated for deletion had any reliable sources to back them up. I didn't nominate them for deletion because of hard drive space. I nominated them because there was nothing to say about them barring a superficial overview of syntax. I honestly didn't think that putting in a few AfDs would cause such a shitstorm, to the point where people are calling me a Nazi/asshole/whatnot on my user page. I also never thought my 15 minutes of fame would be for nominating Nemerle for deletion :) Maybe I should have a Wikipedia article...? But seriously. Anyone could have commented on the AfD. Anyone could have provided reliable sources. The only thing anyone did was bitch and moan. I didn't delete the articles -- the Wikipedia administrators did. Thumbs down, internet.
- jedsmith 16y ago> 2) not cited enough to count I look forward to your explanation, to other academics, of why their work doesn't "count" because it isn't "cited enough". I also look forward to you explaining to us why you're qualified to determine whether a paper that you didn't write "counts". > I honestly didn't think that putting in a few AfDs would cause such a shitstorm, to the point where people are calling me a Nazi/asshole/whatnot on my user page. I also never thought my 15 minutes of fame would be for nominating Nemerle for deletion :) Maybe I should have a Wikipedia article...? Infamy is not the kind of fame that you want.
- tptacek 16y agoThis comment is totally uncalled for. You're participating in a discussion about someone's effort to remove "non-notable" articles from Wikipedia. That someone actually took the time to comment on HN, for the first time, for this one story. Attempting to chase that person off HN by saying "get over yourself" decreases the quality of HN for everyone. Please don't do that.
- pvg 16y ago'Only mentioned in conference proceedings' is actually a fairly decent criterion for exclusion from a general encyclopedia - which is the sort of thing all the deletionist/notability teacup storms revolve around. The importance of conference proceedings in distributing CS research doesn't seem particularly relevant.
- jacques_chester 16y ago> The importance of conference proceedings in distributing CS research doesn't seem particularly relevant. So, because computer science does things differently from other fields, it is at fault?
- pvg 16y agoWhat? You seem to be very focused on being upset about something and I can't quite follow what it is. Have you read any of the endless verbiage on notability? There is a (hotly debated, etc, etc) wikipedia policy that article topics have to be 'notable'. If a topic is only covered in academic literature, one can make a perfectly sensible argument that it's obscure and not 'notable' enough for a general encyclopedia. You don't have to agree with the policy (I, personally, am totally indifferent to the whole topic) but you write as if the very idea that something that's only mentioned in conference proceedings is obscure (CS or not, doesn't seem all that relevant either) is somehow irrational and worthy of great indignation.
- jacques_chester 16y agoIt's relevant to CS because in CS, unlike in other fields, conference papers and proceedings are the main way to report on findings. In other fields conferences take a backseat to journals; CS is unusual in this respect. As for the broader issue of whether academic entries are notable, surely the massive body of mathematics entries on wikipedia indicates that material which is never mentioned in the newspaper is notable.
- wisty 16y agoLook at the deletion threads. He knows what he's talking about, but I think he has some agenda. Maybe he failed a functional language course, and wants to kill off his professor's favourite languages? There's no way that he couldn't just do a google scholar search for "Alice ML functional programming".
- chrismonsanto 16y agoOf course I've done a Google Scholar search for Alice ML. There is roughly one admissible source -- "Through the looking glass" in Trends in Functional Programming. Small workshop paper, 12 citations according to CiteSeer. Doesn't show up in the ACM Digital Library. There are a number of other papers on Saarland University's website, but they are either 1) not peer reviewed (tech reports) 2) not cited or 3) not actually about Alice ML. To illustrate #3, consider "A concurrent lambda-calculus with Futures". This is a relatively well-cited paper, and it mentions Alice ML (a sentence or two?), but it isn't actually about Alice ML! It describes a new language construct and models the semantics in the lambda-calculus. In this case, wouldn't it be the construct, not the language that is notable? I gave the following example in my Wikipedia talk page: the first paper on functional reactive programming is very famous. It describes a DSL called Fran. However, Fran could have not been given a name and the paper still would have been influential, because it wasn't the language itself that had the impact, it was the idea of functional reactive programming that had an impact. (For the record, I got an A in PL! We used Coq. And proved a lot of theorems, mechanically.)
- Devilboy 16y agoSo after all this outrage, do you agree that maybe you took it just a little bit too far?
- lparry 16y agodid you ever stop to think what positive impact the deletion of these articles actually makes? I cant come up with any positive contribution you're making, but I can see that if I saw one of these languages mentioned somewhere (hacker news for instance), you've now ensured I have one less place that I can go to to find out about them. you're a drain on wikipedia, a source of negative knowledge.
- getsat 16y agoHaha, I love the edit war on his profile regarding his "non-notable" website: http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=User:Christopher_Monsanto&action=history http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=User:Christopher_M... Which is making him a little handful of money daily: http://w3spy.net/site/smogon.com http://w3spy.net/site/smogon.com Chris, I suggest you pay GoDaddy the extra $10/year and hide your address.
- carussell 16y agoRegardless of whether you agree with Monsanto's actions that are the focus of the reddit submission, that stuff is a dick move.
- getsat 16y agoWhat is Wikipedia's policy on personal offsite URLs on user pages? I think it's just people editing his profile out of spite due to this issue. I agree that it's not done with good intentions.
- carussell 16y agoYou are also welcome to include a simple link to your personal home page Although, that's not a policy page; it's a guideline, but I realize you weren't using a strict definition of the term wrt to Wikipedia. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:USERPAGES#What_may_I_have_in_my_user_pages.3F http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:USERPAGES#What_may_I_...
- getsat 16y agoThanks for the info.
- bpodgursky 16y agoChristopher is a PhD student at Princeton under advisor Dave Walker. If anyone here has connections to Princeton or Dave Walker, I really encourage you to bring this to his attention, as he is hopefully someone Christopher respects enough to listen to advice from. Given that Dave's CV includes designing several esoteric programming languages, I suspect he would have a personal stake in this issue.
- bluesnowmonkey 16y agoOh no, please, let's not sic the internet mob on these people.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- jacques_chester 16y agoHe's already turned up on this comment thread. I think would be inadvisable to ask somebody to talk to him IRL. At worst it can look like intimidation, which is not cool.
- prodigal_erik 16y agoA personal stake? I don't see any reason to believe Prof. Walker is so lacking in perspective that he would automatically regard every esoteric language he works on as notable enough to deserve a place in Wikipedia.
- bpodgursky 16y agoHm, that was probably the wrong phrase to use. I was just thinking that as a researcher on programming languages, he would have more insight into the issue, and have an idea which languages were influential.
- _sebkom 16y agoI am a humble cs undergraduate student too but I can already tell that PhD != Bright.