5 ms·
As someone not very familiar with either: Why is TikTok succeeding while Vine failed? And why did Vine shutdown? How do you fail at user-generated content that
by Scoundreller 7y ago
As someone not very familiar with either: Why is TikTok succeeding while Vine failed?
And why did Vine shutdown? How do you fail at user-generated content that you can sell ads and more on?
I ask because I still run blogs that are < 5% of the size they used to be, but still make me $50/month with zero effort in static mode. So why would I stop?
- aty268 7y agoFrom what I understand, Snapchat killed it. They sold to Twitter pretty early for like $30M and Twitter just didn't move quick enough. Also, a lot of the popular viners wanted to be paid in some way, and they didn't really have a clear way for that to happen, so the creators pulled out and it died. TikTok just did it better. Creators can easily get paid, videos are not forced to be 6 second max, and they executed better.
- arzel 7y agoFun fact that I’ll shorten: (vine creators) all met at 1600 Vine in Los Angeles with Twitter execs. Creators asked Twitter for money because _we_ we’re getting offers by competitors to become exclusive to their platform, Twitter denied paying up, and all creators moved to other platforms. It only took a few months for the user base to die out.
- aty268 7y agoHuh that is a fun fact. Crazy how one bad decision can just destroy your company.
- paysonderulo 7y agoCrazy how refusing to compensate the people responsible for generating the value of your company can be considered to be just "one bad decision."
- Craighead 7y agoSounds like one decision
- aty268 7y agoIt is a bad decision, I don't see your point.
- dimgl 7y agoIt isn't just one bad decision. It's many decisions. Those decisions don't just come out of "thin air" and destroy the company. They're always a series of decisions which eventually topple over the company. Vine not paying their content creators wasn't just the one time; they were likely consciously not paying their content creators over a long period of time.
- aty268 7y agoThat is a good point, and I agree.
- samstave 7y agoI think the technical term is “dumb fucks”
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- Alex3917 7y ago> Why is TikTok succeeding while Vine failed? https://rickyyean.com/2020/01/20/from-socialcam-to-tiktok-how-we-figured-out-video-social-in-a-decade/ https://rickyyean.com/2020/01/20/from-socialcam-to-tiktok-ho...
- kangaroozach 7y agoNice post. Ricky da man too!
- sagran 7y agoInsta released video support; overnight 90% of video creation disappeared and growth stalled out as people went back to the platform Vine was borrowing them from. (Facebook’s earlier shenanigans of cutting off graph access didn’t help.) Further attempts to restart growth didn’t pan out. It didn’t help that most people consumed Vine via YouTube (and not the web or app). Other platforms were willing to pay creators much earlier (and had bigger budgets I expect)... but it was probably already too late.
- ehsankia 7y agoI know byte just released, but as someone who has used TikTok for a few months now, the difference is honestly night and day. - byte sticks to the very strict 7s limit while TikTok is a bit loser - TikTok's use of music and re-used sounds help bring popular "trends" - As per the above, you can quickly browse other tiktok's made from the same sound / in the given trend - TikTok has other interesting features too such as duos, letting you reply to someone else's video, side-by-side - TikTok's are very easy to share, and most importantly have a Web UI - TikTok doesn't require an account, as soon as you open the app, you're dropped right into a feed of interesting videos, easy to scroll These platforms are all about content, and TikTok having penetrated the US means it'll be very hard for byte to get users, and without users there's no content. I personally don't think Vine really failed per-se. Twitter just didn't think it was a place worth investing, so they stagnated. TikTok as mentioned above has brought many new interesting evolutions to the format. Most importantly, their learning based feed is pretty top notch and learns your taste very quickly.
- tangue 7y ago+1 and generally TikTok UX is underrated. In a way it feels like Facebook of the old days.
- busymom0 7y agoMind expanding on how "it feels like Facebook of the old days"? I don't have TikTok but from what I have seen, their UI is just a swipe one?
- tangue 7y agoIf you're young it means connecting with people you care (or are interested in) without a confuse UI or scammy ads. I meant the keyword here is friction
- holler 7y agoWait a sec, as you already mentioned, Byte just released! Cut them some slack. TikTok wasn't full-featured when it launched like most other apps. Seems pretty good so far.
- koonsolo 7y agoMy son of 10 and almost all of his classmates use tiktok. The real killer is the dances on the music. They don't have to invent a new topic every time. They just see a music video they like, and imitate it. Together with all the effects it's very easy to create a crazy video with basically nothing.
- bredren 7y agoI have been tracking tiktok for about 11 months now. If you watched it over this time, it is really quite amazing what has blown through the platform. One example of an early "dance" was the Boss Walk. This one is almost completely gone now but it was essentially an inside joke to people who followed the content of the platform. Another thing special to TT is that it was successful at sucking content in from other platforms, including Instagram, and then having that be remixed via the audio under unclear licensing terms. A good example of this is the "oh shit it's a rat" meme. Once the meme makes it into the blood of the userbase, it doesn't even need the audio and it can take on a life of its own leaving behind most content origination though the audio stays. The most impactful example was definitely Old Town Road, and the jump / costume changes. This song was huge on the platform and already waning before it made it onto billboard and exploaded mainstream
- unlinked_dll 7y agoTo be fair there have been videos like that on basically every video platform since the dawn of the internet
- bdcravens 7y agoTikTok does a very good job of removing friction in creating and publishing that content however.
- koonsolo 7y agoIf you copy a video like that on YouTube, you are called all kinds of names. On tiktok, if 3 of your friends make the same video, the cool thing is to also do the same one.
- 7y ago
- m3kw9 7y agoTiktok had good content, more than vine, good suggestions using AI which vine probably has but was really crappy, they had great marketing where they probably paid people to do some really crazy viral stuff, they had good timing, they had China. A lot of you are asking why tiktok is better, it’s probably 10-15 things they needed to hit out of the park to get here.
- james_niro 7y agoI believe the 6 seconds wasn’t enough for people to be creative. TikTok started with 15 second and one minute plus they implemented soundtrack system and great machine learning algo