7 ms·
Previous discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22107823 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22107823 Does this mean they'll also "backtrack" on the
by userbinator 7y ago
Previous discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22107823 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22107823
Does this mean they'll also "backtrack" on their destruction of the URL? I was extremely disturbed and horrified when I realised that not only did they replace / with >, but also seemed to arbitrarily remove and rewrite pieces of URLs shown in the results (e.g. all articles from HM would show nothing more than "news.ycombinator.com > item", which was intensely confusing.)
- jonny383 7y agoI opened Chrome on a friends phone (first time on Chrome mobile in years) and was shocked to see the url bar is no longer editable. It just gave me a weird context menu with a copy icon. I guess they really want to funnel everyone through search...
- Arainach 7y agoRight next to that copy icon is a pencil - the edit icon.
- jonny383 7y agoOkay I didnt see that. But why is this necessary? What was wrong with the text box that opened what you would expect - the box filled out with the url of the page you are on? In my opinion this is still a gentle push to encourage users to just type in a search query instead.
- dragonwriter 7y ago> Okay I didnt see that. But why is this necessary? Probably because URL copy or share (the two icons besides edit than the new UI provides) are more common interactions than URL editing, and are (without a keyboard and with a traditional text edit control for the URL bar) higher friction; this streamlines the common usecases at the cost of adding an extra tap for URL editing.
- jonny383 7y agoThe old version opened with the text fully selected. You could either type a query and overwrite the text, edit the url, or tap and hold to get... Low and behold, copy and share. The only thing they have added is confusion and behavorial conditioning. I see no benefits of the "new" way.
- wffurr 7y agoSo what you are saying is the most common actions, copy and share, were behind a confusing an easy to mess up long press gesture. A whole lot of people in this thread have never watched a normal person use a smartphone in a UX study.
- jonny383 7y agoI'm saying it operates as mobile users have learnt to use over the past decade (and how the rest of the OS UI works).
- wffurr 7y agoLong press, especially on selected text, has always been a subpar user interaction. None of this UX design is perfect or totally settled, especially since it's only been 10 years since it's been mainstream.
- dragonwriter 7y ago> Long press, especially on selected text, has always been a subpar user interaction. Exactly, and other than web pages (before this UX change), virtually every other well-defined piece of content that is likely to be shared had a prominent, distinct, easy-access share button on mobile (the separate copy to clipboard button added for URLs is not a common affordance; in most cases that functionality is one of many options accessed through the sharing function. OTOH, for URLs and certain other shared content, copying-and-paste is a particularly common sharing method, so promoting it to a first-class option further streamlines a common use case. ) This change actually better aligns the browser with every other way of interacting with shareable content on mobile rather than violating mobile UX expectations.
- dredmorbius 7y agoYes: you cannot DIRECTLY edit the URL in the navbar. Nor, for that matter, can you click, ctrl-A (yes, Virginia, I have and use a Bluetooth keyboard). Instead it's click, then Copy Icon. Utterly blinkered. Oddly: Incognito mode is not (yet) crippled in this manner. Don't get me started on pull-to-nuke-whatever-you'd-been-composing-or-losing-your-place-in-infernal-scroll
- saghm 7y ago> yes, Virginia, I have and use a Bluetooth clipboard I'm assuming from context that your mean keyboard, but the idea sounds kind of cool so I have to ask: any chance this is a term for a a bluetooth device solely designed to facilitate copy-pasting between other devices?
- dredmorbius 7y agoYes, thanks, edited. For cross-device control, there's ... Synergy, I think: https://symless.com/synergy https://symless.com/synergy There's an Android client (I've no experience with it): https://sourceforge.net/projects/synergyandroid/ https://sourceforge.net/projects/synergyandroid/ On the Android, there's Termux which offers a clipboard interface -- termux-clipboard-get and termux-clipboard-set which I've aliased as "xp" and "xc" respectively. (I have similar aliases for Linux and MacOS's respective clipboard manipulators.) You can paste (including to remote SSH sessions) with the ctrl-alt-v keystroke. It's possibly to select and copy screen regions, but tediously, so that piping to / from xc / xp is far more convenient. (I sometimes use this for composing / editing HN comments, more frequently on other sites.)
- Rebelgecko 7y agoLogitech (and probably others) make wireless keyboards that let you copy/paste between different devices edit: I should mention that I think this requires drivers on the computer end, so probably won't on iOS/Android
- efreak 7y agoSuch a keyboard wouldn't need drivers if it's programmed in to send multiple keypresses--ctrl+[axcv] works on standard Android text inputs and selections, as do the shift, arrows, home, end, pgup/dn etc.
- userbinator 7y agoIn other words, an obfuscation of functionality that clearly shows their attempts at behavioural conditioning.
- clSTophEjUdRanu 7y agoMore like- how often do you edit a URL in the bar on mobile? It's a pain in the ass.
- harry8 7y agoEvery single time someone im's me some url with a bunch of tracking garbage after the ?
- rapnie 7y agoI don't use Chrome but you have tracking token stripper plugin: https://github.com/jparise/chrome-utm-stripper https://github.com/jparise/chrome-utm-stripper
- thenewnewguy 7y agoI'll get right to installing that extension on Chrome for Android...
- jimmaswell 7y agoI do often enough.
- ddingus 7y agoNot really. I do it regularly.
- wruza 7y agoAt this point one should question why it is pain in the ass, not how often does one edit it because it is. Browsers could easily show Notes.app-like editing window for a long urls. There is no reason to force it to be a one-liner, except that it is historical.
- guerrilla 7y agoIt's really scary. And it's a shame Firefox is so slow on mobile...
- rapnie 7y agoThis surprises me. It rocks for me on mobile (Android), esp. with Privacy Badger and uBlock Origin installed its really fast
- input_sh 7y agoA complete re-do of Firefox on Android hit Nightly. It'll replace current version of Firefox (stable) in the first half of 2020. Judging by the current state, it'll arrive with no add-on support, which I honestly hope doesn't happen.
- dx034 7y agoIs it? At least on Android it's the same as Chrome for me with no addons enabled. With ublock origin, Firefox is much faster.
- dragonwriter 7y ago> It just gave me a weird context menu with a copy icon. Share, copy, and edit icons. While I'm not a big fan of it, it probably fits the frequency and relative friction of interactions on mobile better than the previous UI.
- userbinator 7y agoThere is no other reason, than their desire to "herd" uesrs, why they could not have the additional options to share/copy and have it behave like any other edit control, i.e. you can tap the other icons to copy or share, and more importantly still start editing it without going an extra step.
- codyb 7y agoThat sounds annoying. This is like Slack forcing their WYSIWYG editor on me. Thankfully Apple hasn’t done this yet and the URL bar still acts very much as it should. But just ask me how I feel about navigating other parts of Apple’s UI! Dunno who they’re user testing with but these changes make me a bit ornery sometimes.
- ibly31 7y agoThankfully Slack backtracked and made that editor optional. I was pretty relieved after a few weeks of frustration
- shadowgovt 7y agoDid their usage numbers show most people wanted to hand-edit the bar or just copy it? If the latter, the default behavior gets in the way of the critical path.
- stevula 7y agoIt’s editable for me on iOS. I would probably stop using it if they removed the ability to manually edit the address bar.
- GuB-42 7y agoIt is editable, you just need to use the pencil button. It is an unerstandable choice because it puts forward the most common uses of the address bar and still allows you to edit. I just hate it because it breaks well established UI conventions. The thing looks like a text field but doesn't act like a text field. For me it is more of a "stop messing with UI" situation than trying to funnel everything through search. If they wanted to do that, they would have kept the dedicated search button. Early Android phones had that.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- dx034 7y agoI'm actually a fan of this. I rarely edit URLs, mostly copy them to share. Before, that always needed several clicks. Now I have the option to directly copy/share/edit it. Editing is at most one click more, sharing and copying is much easier.
- 3xblah 7y agoThis and the other stuff described in these discussions relies on Javascript, CSS or certain HTTP headers. If the results are requested with a simpler HTTP client that does not automatically execute Javascript or CSS, where we can control te HTTP headers, then these manipulations can easily be sidestepped. This is not "blocking". It is using a client that does not process JS or CSS, where we can easily control the headers sent. This can be done, e.g., with openssl s_client, obsd nc, socat, etc. They are probably sending different html+css+js based on user-agent. They have been doing that for many years. The difference this time is people are objecting to the look of what they are sending.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- svnpenn 7y agoBlocking 3rd-party scripts, 1st-party scripts and even inline scripts doesnt do what you say it does. It not as easy as you say it is, theyre using server side scripts to mangle the URLs.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- userbinator 7y agoA filtering proxy can still fix the results by substituting the real URLs, since they are still unmolested in the href= attribute of the anchor tags.
- tempodox 7y agoI'd still rather vote with my feet than putting effort into repairing what Google fucked up. That would seem like a pointless arms race to me.
- 3xblah 7y agoLong live privoxy. However, I wonder how privoxy users handle TLS. I use localhost proxies to decrypt TLS before it reaches destination programs as well as encrypt outgoing plaintext HTTP traffic from non-TLS enabled programs. Using proxies allows me to edit incoming and outgoing traffic where needed. From the privoxy FAQ: 4.15. How can Privoxy filter Secure (HTTPS) URLs? Since secure HTTP connections are encrypted SSL sessions between your browser and the secure site, and are meant to be reliably secure, there is little that Privoxy can do but hand the raw gibberish data though from one end to the other unprocessed. The only exception to this is blocking by host patterns, as the client needs to tell Privoxy the name of the remote server, so that Privoxy can establish the connection. If that name matches a host-only pattern, the connection will be blocked. As far as ad blocking is concerned, this is less of a restriction than it may seem, since ad sources are often identifiable by the host name, and often the banners to be placed in an encrypted page come unencrypted nonetheless for efficiency reasons, which exposes them to the full power of Privoxy's ad blocking. "Content cookies" (those that are embedded in the actual HTML or JS page content, see filter{content-cookies}), in an SSL transaction will be impossible to block under these conditions. Fortunately, this does not seem to be a very common scenario since most cookies come by traditional means.
- ehsankia 7y agoCalling it "backtracking" feels strange. They still want to put favicons in there, but as pointed out, the positioning is misleading since it's in the same spot as the "ad" icon. They will most likely just move it to another more unique position.
- gwittel 7y agoFavicon display seems rife for abuse. I wonder what happens if you put a favicon that looks like googles’ or that says “ad”. All sorts of fun to encourage clicks onto a malicious site because it looks safe.
- janesvilleseo 7y agoCorrect. There could be quite a bit of fun. This more than likely could work for sites not in the top spot. If you borrow the credibility of another brand you could get a boost. This click thru boost could then translate into higher rankings over time as you outperform your spot. I have already seen seen some ascii stars in the URLs of Googles ads. There is always abuse.
- realusername 7y agoI guarantee you will have people putting favicon looking like a check-mark or an arrow to make people click more.
- milofeynman 7y agoI would hope they've put thought into that and might even blacklist sites that try to steal other more popular sites favicons. I guess it would catch a lot of false positives with companies making new sites on new tlds that might share favicons.
- stephanozzz 7y agoAccording to the twitter announcement, they are not "backtracking", they are going to experiment further. As of today, search results are still favicons on mobile...
- AJ007 7y agoThe URL seems way more important to me than the favicon / ad issue. Its an issue, but the users who can't see the difference didn't know they've been clicking on ads for the past 10 years. #1 What does Google want the web to look like? Look at Google News. #2 Google gets to hijack 20%~ of the screen space to get users to install their own apps, and go back to Google, not onward to the publisher's own website. #3 Removing the URL is the final disambiguation, where no one but the most technical users can go where they want.
- jjoonathan 7y agoAOL Keywords are back!
- ddtaylor 7y agoIs it wrong for me to be happy?
- shadowgovt 7y ago> where no one but the most technical users can go where they want In what sense?
- kennyadam 7y agoA lot of people just do not understand how to use URLs and EVERYTHING they visit online is done through Google search. I work in a large school and the majority of the students only use their phones to access the internet and everything is abstracted through apps or Google search bars and they just don't understand URLs.
- shadowgovt 7y agoHow does that restrict them from going where they want online?
- kennyadam 7y ago
- lopmotr 7y agoIf URLs are read by humans, they need to be human readable. If you use a prominently displayed name to contain crap like "?id=22107823" which is meaningless to most users, then get off a search engine. Nobody needs to see that. Give it a human readable name if you want humans to read it or hide it completely if you don't. It's amazing how long unreadable URLs have lingered. I'm all for them being as hidden as HTML code. Even if you have a lot of pages, you can still make a readable URL, like The New York Times "https://www.nytimes.com/2020/01/22/style/modern-love-podcast-jessalyn-gilsig.html" https://www.nytimes.com/2020/01/22/style/modern-love-podcast.... None of that except perhaps "https://" https://" and ".html" are mysterious computer codes.
- userbinator 7y ago"?id=22107823" which is meaningless to most users Absolute rubbish. That is obviously a number identifying the item. I wish a lot of URLs would be shorter, but that's different. I also offer this piece of evidence: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7678729 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7678729 People are intelligent. They can learn and see things if you give them a chance, and you're basically advocating for keeping them stupid and unknowing by hiding things from them... why?
- lopmotr 7y agoPeople figured out how to make phone calls with numbers too, even area codes and special 0's in front. But it was an ugly mess necessitated by the technology. This isn't necessary. Even if you know what it means, it's still not suitable for reading. If you saw that in search results, how will you decide if you prefer ?id=7678729 or ?id=22107823 ? They're not even sequential. You can't remember it from something you've seen before. Yes keep them stupid and hide things from them. That's an important part of how computers became popular. A lot of people were excluded in the days of command line everything.
- userbinator 7y agoNo, no, no! There's another comment here which sums up my thoughts on this perfectly: "Don't make me think" has turned into "Don't let me think", and that is a disturbingly dangerous direction for freedom from corporate/government control. Society would be very different today if, several hundred years ago, the "ruling elite" decided that literacy should be discouraged.