8 ms·
Housing as investment is a mindtrick, and a dangerous one at that. With it often comes property taxes. There's the time and cost of maintenance. There's the fr
by chiefalchemist 7y ago
Housing as investment is a mindtrick, and a dangerous one at that.
With it often comes property taxes. There's the time and cost of maintenance. There's the friction of being able to easily relocate for a better paying job.
Worst of all, past performance is no indication of future returns. That is, it's possible your property won't appreciate, at least not sufficiently. For example, think Detroit. Or beachfront property in say 25 yrs. Or McMansions. Will smaller less consumption-minded families in the future want them?
Housing works as an investment because everyone is in on the scheme. The gov. The banks. Everyone. And it's still a roll of the dice.
- UncleOxidant 7y agoI don't look at my house as an investment as much as it is an inflation hedge. We bought our current house in 2010 when prices were low due to the great recession. Our mortgage is $835/mo (15yr mortgage). If we were renting now our rent would be ~$1500/mo for a comparable house in the same area. And our mortgage will be paid off in about 3.5 years as we've paid some extra on the principal over the years. Yes, there's still property tax and repairs but those are built into rental prices anyway. I also don't have to worry about having to move if the landlord sells the place I'm renting. I like the area and don't plan to move for a different job anyway.
- _bxg1 7y agoSounds like that panned out, but it's pretty circumstantial. Not all of us have the opportunity to buy a house at the bottom of the largest real-estate recession in generations.
- sunnytimes 7y agoi got extremely lucky buying my first house right in the middle of that recession. paid 101k , got it appraised last year at 190k and the area has gone up since. my second house where i'm at now was right when the prices started going up so a bit more but less wife. i owe alot to that recession.
- snowwrestler 7y ago> I don't look at my house as an investment as much as it is an inflation hedge. It's worth pointing out that hedging inflation is a valid goal for investing, whether or not the investment involves real estate.
- treyfitty 7y agoIdk why you’re being downvoted. I can confirm- bought in the Upper East Side of NYC 5 years ago. Appreciation wouldn’t offset closing costs and fees when I wanted to sell last year.
- jhauris 7y agoCommon wisdom is that 5 years is the bare minimum time to own before selling. Buying a house is a long-term strategy to lock in a current mortgage when you know you aren't going to move and rents are likely to go up. After 10 or 15 years your payments will be slightly larger (with increased tax evaluations), and rent is likely to have increased more. There are additional benefits, but these vary drastically based on what you buy and what your goals are. This is all very general, and doesn't apply to every area equally, but it is a very rare situation where selling after less than five years makes sense on its own. Renting is a great option for people planning to move again in that time frame.
- toast0 7y ago> With it often comes property taxes. There's the time and cost of maintenance. There's the friction of being able to easily relocate for a better paying job. As a renter, you may not pay directly for property tax and repairs, but they do come out of your rent, unless your landlord's business is unsound. Maintenance costs the renter time and hassle too, although depending on the work done, perhaps less. Certainly, relocation friction is higher, although some turn that into an opportunity to be an absentee landlord in a way that's more satisfying than subletting.
- usaar333 7y agoThey come out of your rent, yes, but at least in markets with low supply (think the Bay Area), your rent is not being set by the presence of property taxes and repairs. That is, if we raised everyone's property taxes by 0.2% or so, approximately speaking, no one's rent would go up.
- refurb 7y agoAs a renter, you may not pay directly for property tax and repairs, but they do come out of your rent Yes, but what the landlord is paying may be very different from what you'd be paying if you bought. For example, I know a landlord charging $3,000 per month for a place that would rent for $5,000 (rent control) or have carrying costs of $6,000 if purchased today. He does just fine since he bought 15 years ago, so his mortgage is $1,500 and his property taxes don't go up more than 1% per year. So yes, rent must cover the cost of ownership, but not the cost of ownership today.
- tagami 7y agoI am pleased with the 6.5% compounded annual return on our principal residence we purchased in 1994. Tax deductions are helpful, but the big benefit is our mortgage is less than half the cost of rent.
- citrablue 7y agoFor comparison, the stock market has done 9.1% during that time. $40k in an index fund back then would be worth around $390k today. Leverage is the biggest benefit, I would imagine. Although paying half as much in rent sounds really nice these days :). Glad it worked out for you.
- ssalazar 7y agoIf you could take the money you were going to pay in rent (or at least the difference of mortgage-minus-rent) and instead put it in an index fund, this would be a meaningful comparison.
- citrablue 7y agoSure, but you aren't getting 5x leverage in an index fund.
- wahern 7y ago> Leverage is the biggest benefit, I would imagine. Yes, absolutely. A 20% downpayment of $40k suggests a $200,000 purchase price. A 6.5% annual return over 25 years suggests the house is presently ~$950,000, because that's usually how people frame things (appreciation on the value of the asset, not their equity), unless they say otherwise. (Correct me if I'm wrong.) So the house appreciated $750k, which is theirs to pocket. And based on the $40k downpayment, that's a ~13% annual return. But even if you base it on the purchase price, nobody cares about a lower annual return if you have a higher absolute figure you would't have been able to achieve otherwise. (If you're not paying a mortgage, you're paying rent, and rents are typically approximately the current price of houses plus maintenance. There's a ton of variance, of course.) We live in an intensively capitalist society, for better or worse. If you're not in debt, using money to make money, you're losing. Houses can be a risky investment, and for most people a mortgage is just what you have to do to maintain an average standard of living, especially in your later years when you can draw down equity and any appreciation. But if you don't have a mortgage you're at a serious disadvantage. Rich people, or people who have the time and energy to trade derivatives, don't need home mortgages because they have other ways to make leveraged investments. For the vast majority of people, the first and only opportunity is a home mortgage. This is why I think it's insane that we're building low-income housing with exactions and public expenditures. It's like buying Cadillacs for everyone too poor to buy a car on their own. You either buy older buildings (used cars) and refurbish, or better you get banks to finance construction of new properties in which they and the low income residents can have a property interest, similar to Singapore and (I think) some places in Honk Kong. The property interest may have constraints (can't sell for 5-10 years, some appreciation has to be rolled back into the program, etc), so it would take some public expenditures to cover the gap. But you're still playing the capitalist game, leveraging assets, and digging into the pockets of global wealth (not just the local tax base). Of course, the potential for abuse and bad planning is immense, but there'd have to be a ridiculous amount of abuse to burn money faster than buying Cadillacs for everybody. And when you consider the wealth building potential for residents (no longer just a handout, but the opportunity to build assets, like the middle classes), it makes even more sense. A couple of years ago there was some press about some non-profits doing this in Oakland and elsewhere in the U.S. But the programs are just too small to matter, and the constraints far more onerous. If you don't permit such properties to eventually enter the free market and "gentrify", you risk creating ghettos. Do it right in a place like the Bay Area you need billions on the line.
- the_gastropod 7y agoNo idea why you're being downvoted here. You're absolutely right. As an investment, housing has some incredibly awful attributes: - Incredibly low liquidity—takes months of effort to buy or sell - Very complex to buy/sell (usually requires lawyers, lots of inspections, documentation, etc) - High fees to both buy AND sell it - It's taxed every year, regardless of whether you actually earn any money on it (aka: sell it) - It's constantly falling apart, and requiring upkeep maintenance - It's completely undiversified: subject to not only one country, one state, one city, one neighborhood, but a single tiny plot of land at one specific location that could be hit by any sort of natural disaster, get bad neighbors, have the local economy collapse, etc. Its pool of potential buyers is also limited to this very tiny location. - Returns are relatively low, roughly in-line with inflation - It's almost always leveraged (often good, but that cuts both ways, and you have to pay the interest on it regardless of what happens) Sounds like a wonderful deal, eh?
- usaar333 7y agoAgreed in general, but there are some advantages. > It's taxed every year, regardless of whether you actually earn any money on it (aka: sell it) Property tax is generally lower than your imputed rent. In the US at least, there is a huge advantage of being shielded from capital gains taxes (up to $500k if married) > Returns are relatively low, roughly in-line with inflation This is market dependent. SF Bay is something like 5.4% nominally over the past 30 years, which crushes inflation. Housing prices in the Bay Area in fact imply heavy future price appreciation. [1] Also, the high leverage position (which you point out cuts both ways) does drive expected returns above inflation. Especially with, in the US, interest being somewhat tax deductible. Also strongest advantage of owning a house over renting is the stability you get. My rent can always go up, potentially above my ability to pay; my ownership costs (esp. in CA with prop 13 limiting property tax rise) only barely goes up. (and far less than inflation) [1] https://medium.com/@usaar33/why-you-shouldnt-buy-a-home-in-the-bay-area-right-now-9eff37da8d6 https://medium.com/@usaar33/why-you-shouldnt-buy-a-home-in-t...
- the_gastropod 7y ago> This is market dependent. SF Bay is something like 5.4% nominally over the past 30 years, which crushes inflation. Housing prices in the Bay Area in fact imply heavy future price appreciation. [1] Yes, but this is cherry-picking. In the US as a whole, RE typically matches the inflation rate. Some physical and temporal locations over- (or under-) perform. But in aggregate, that's the reality. There's no way of knowing ahead of time which market will out-perform. Investing in Bay Area real-estate today very well could continue to out-pace inflation. But that seems as big a risk as dumping $1M into Tesla stock today.
- JakeTheAndroid 7y agoWell if you aren't investing in property as a principle residence, then relocating is moot. You can still get a huge amount of value investing into the housing market looking to cash flow, not buy your potential forever home. And, so long as you don't any old house on the market, but instead take your time, do your research, and expect to hold it for longer than 10 years, your risks are substantially lower. Which is true for a lot of investing. Time in market is king. And it doesn't matter how long you spend in the market if you buy ignorantly for well over market value.
- untog 7y ago> Housing works as an investment because everyone is in on the scheme. Does that not apply to most investments? The stock market, aftre all, only works as an investment because everyone is in on an elaborate confidence game.
- rifung 7y ago> Does that not apply to most investments? The stock market, aftre all, only works as an investment because everyone is in on an elaborate confidence game. I don't think this is true? As far as I can tell, there is no reason for housing prices to increase on their own. I suppose you can make the argument for increased population growth but we haven't reached the point where this is a problem, at least in the US. On the other hand, businesses exist for the sole purpose of making money. Literally everyone in the company is (supposed to be) working towards the goal of increasing profits.
- refurb 7y agoThis is very true. I've talked to people who bought a house at $200K, then sold at $300K 5 years later. Crazy return right? Then you account for maintenance, opportunity cost of the down payment, transaction fees, etc. Then you realize the actual return was 8% when the market has returned 12% since then. Suddenly it doesn't seem like such a great return.
- SketchySeaBeast 7y agoIf you want to get technical you'd also have to give credit for how much you're saving a month by not renting. That'll be a grand or two a month you're not having to spend while you live in your investment.
- refurb 7y agoAbsolutely. The baseline would be renting and doing something else with the down payment. In a lot of cases, principle, interest, insurance and taxes are a wash with rent (obviously there are exceptions).
- goobynight 7y agoMy family definitely got the short end of most of these factors in the midwest. * Very few high paying companies in the area and they were less likely to move due to owning. * They made about 3.3k/year in appreciation for 20 years. That's on the order of a 13 hour per month side gig. * Any gains definitely erased by the amount of labor they put into things such as mowing the lawn, shoveling snow, having the washing machine hose disconnect and leak water down into the basement. All of these little things added up to many man hours across.