17 ms·
There is no evidence that automated driving systems are any safer than human drivers, or that they ever will be.
by heavyset_go 7y ago
There is no evidence that automated driving systems are any safer than human drivers, or that they ever will be.
- tensor 7y agoAutopilot is evidence that automated systems are already better than humans today. The edge cases scare people but on aggregate the stats show is superior to people. This sort of tech is only going to keep getting better.
- pjkundert 7y agoLook up "Ergodicity". Autopilot doesn't need to be 2x or 10x better than a human driver -- it needs to be 100x or 1,000x better, or nobody (sane) should touch it. The problem is not that autopilot is superior than your own driving in the vast majority of the cases! The problem is the 1 in a million times when it makes a trivial mistake that virtually no human would, and kills you instantly. Like driving under an obvious semi-trailer, and shearing your torso off. An understandable example: You have two games of chance, both with identical 5/6 chance of winning. One game, you'll play immediately (and as often as possible). The other, you would never play, not even once. How is that possible? Both have identical 5/6 chances of winning? But, one is "ergotic", meaning that the odds hold over the long term as often as you play, and one is "non-ergotic", meaning that as soon as you lose, you're finished. One is a single dice roll. The other is Russian Roulette. Self-driving cars are Russian Roulette. One "mistake" on the part of the system, and you're dead. The fact that the "stats" prove that it is safer, overall, don't change the fact: you and your family are dead.
- kens 7y agoPeople die all the time from driving under a semi-trailer. Look up "Underride". Over 200 people die every year from underride crashes in the US, so this isn't a mistake made only by autopilots. In other words, if we switched to self-driving cars and three people died every week when the autopilot drove into a semi-trailer, that would be a big improvement.
- pjkundert 7y agoSo, your family would be ok that your car sheared you off in a quirk unnecessary accident, so long as the overall stats were better than average? Non-ergotic stats are not comparable to ergotic (group) stats.
- michaelmrose 7y agoGiven 100 individuals who would have died in everyday accidents all would prefer a 99% chance of survival. Given a population of a million all would prefer a 1 in a million chance of death under a semi to a 1 in 10k chance of being smeared in a more average fashion. Your argument is the same one used against seat belts with people advocating a strictly inferior survival strategy to prevent a rare misadventure.
- iso947 7y agoThat’s not how it works for humans though. “Other drivers are terrible. I am above average. Other drivers underride. I don’t”
- DrScump 7y agoLet's say your autodrive system replaces 100,000 driver-hours. Let's say those driver-hours would have resulted in 3 deaths of others (in vehicles or pedestrians) but your autodrive results in 1 different death (which wouldn't have occurred with the human drivers). Your stats are no comfort at all to the loved ones of your victim. It's like the Trolley Problem but the humans are unidentifiable.
- michaelmrose 7y agoThe trolley problem challenges people who don't consider choosing not to act equally an active choice or intuitively feel that action is different than inaction. I would always pick the most valuable to me side and pull the switch or leave it be to bring about the better end result. Given the availability of self driving vehicles that reduce mortality choosing to drive oneself and kill more people is an unethical choice that will be as little comfort to the 3 victims as the one.
- pjkundert 7y agoDon’t be a drone. What are you downvoting for? Are you going to remain ignorant, or start to think? I’m totally in support of, and believe in the value of self-driving vehicles. But, the SV soy-boys need to bring their A-game. Not the “My machine learning system that underperforms a nematode worm’s neural performance is going to totes solve self-driving cars” toy they’re delivering now. Come on! I expect better, especially from Elon Musk, who should know better - he’s a Saskatchewan boy! You can’t see the highway 6 months of the year, and there’s no static friction; only dozens of variants of dynamic friction, which can only be distinguished by a sensor suite that includes vision, sound, vibration and predictive estimation from historical models, recent historical temperature profiles, and precipitation, insolation energy and angle, wind and recent traffic over the same road. So man up. Increase your model learning and real-time solving power by between 10 and 100 times. Increase your sensor suite. Include historical memory and group learning. Sheesh.
- dang 7y agoPlease don't let downvotes get to you like this. I know it's not always easy, but the site guidelines ask it explicitly of everyone. That's because it quickly causes comments to sink below the acceptable levels, which is what happened here. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- pjkundert 7y agoThanks for all you do, dang! However, unless HN implements K-Means clustering, a single-axis downvote mechanism will inevitably lead to echo-chamber bullying, I believe. Especially if no-one fights back, encouraging the people who vote “sensible” vs “nonsense”, and discouraging the “like” vs “don’t like” voters who ruin debate.
- dang 7y agoIn my experience, everyone is a like vs. don't-like voter.
- michaelmrose 7y agoYou are overcomplicating things. Every minute of drive time is Russian roulette with on average very low chances of losing. The only thing that matters is the overall odds there is no inherent mathematical difference between the 2 scenarios. There is no difference to prefer more likely death in common scenario to less likely death in a stupider scenario. If you believe otherwise you ought to explicate with numbers.
- Nasrudith 7y agoThat doesn't sound like a proper set of assumptions - that human accidents will be fender benders while self driving will be chunk-salsa worthy. The cumulative fatality risk applies to both parties. Humans will die in fatal accidents that no Self Driving car would do. The 1000x better demand is more a stupid human illusion of control thing like fearing flying more than a road trip of equal distance.
- blub 7y agoAutopilot is at most evidence that human-machine systems are better than just human drivers. Throughout its history "autopilot" had many cases where the human saved its ass and quite a few where it managed to kill the human anyway.
- nrp 7y agoFrom Tesla's latest Vehicle Safety Report: > In the 4th quarter, we registered one accident for every 3.07 million miles driven in which drivers had Autopilot engaged. For those driving without Autopilot but with our active safety features, we registered one accident for every 2.10 million miles driven. For those driving without Autopilot and without our active safety features, we registered one accident for every 1.64 million miles driven. By comparison, NHTSA’s most recent data shows that in the United States there is an automobile crash every 479,000 miles. It's pretty unsurprising that at least augmenting human attention and input with machine attention and input reduces accidents. I agree that the cross-over point in time for full automation being safer than human drivers is a total unknown though.
- zdragnar 7y agoAm I correct in thinking that most people use autopilot in the most boring parts of or most boring drives? It seems to me that knowing the autopilot isn't 100% perfect is a good reason to not rely on it in more dangerous or complicated scenarios (construction, roads with poor markings, school areas). I haven't followed too closely here though, just curious if that is a reasonable hypothesis.
- tim333 7y agoAutopilot tends to be engaged on freeways / motorways where accidents are much lower than driving through town. If you do the stats properly Tesla's autopilot is probably more crash prone than just having a human drive. There were some stats that if you compare model S deaths to other luxury cars in the same price range they are about 3x higher for the S. Death rates in luxury cars are much lower than the average vehicle. I think self driving tech will cut roads deaths eventually but it needs more work.
- Groxx 7y agoThe vast majority of the data I'm able to find on road types covers only fatalities, not accidents... but New York has accident rates per road type (and junctions!) for several years[1], and their rates are very roughly 1 accident per 300k-500k for rural roads, and 1 per 500k-1m for "[fully] controlled access" (which I read as highways, with divided being by far the lowest rate). So even if it's just on highways, Autopilot is still out-performing humans by 2-3x, if not more. On average, ignoring better luxury car rates mentioned elsewhere, and that I have no clue if this is representative. I would be surprised if broader data was so much worse that it would reverse the relationship though. [1] https://www.dot.ny.gov/divisions/operating/osss/highway/accident-rates https://www.dot.ny.gov/divisions/operating/osss/highway/acci...
- dodobirdlord 7y ago> or that they ever will be Eventually being better than humans seems like it's obviously going to happen. Not driving drunk, not getting distracted, and not sleeping at the wheel alone are advantages enough that I would be amazed if the balance doesn't eventually fall in favor of the self-driving car. Self-driving cars don't even have to be particularly good drivers to be better than the average human, given how much the human average is dragged down by recklessness.
- raducu 7y agoWhile I would love for self-driving cars to be a thing, the AI to detect tired, distracted, drunk or sleeping drivers could be in every car way, way before self-driving cars will be a thing.
- spookthesunset 7y ago> Self-driving cars don't even have to be particularly good drivers to be better than the average human, given how much the human average is dragged down by recklessnes Tell that to the jury when your self driving car runs into the side of school bus full of kids (which will happen given any reasonable adoption). Self driving cars would have to be held to an almost insanely high standard to be “winnable lawsuit” proof.
- WalterBright 7y agoSuch lawsuits are a net detriment to society. It's why light airplane design remains stuck in the 1960s, and why vaccine companies are protected from lawsuits.
- AgentOrange1234 7y agoIf we (society) took an air traffic safety approach, e.g., analyzing each crash, root causing it, and working to address it, one can imagine a day where self-driving cars are very safe. (I’m sure that day is a long way off still.)
- stale2002 7y agoThese lawsuits alright happen. Right now. A car manufacturer can already be sued for things that go wrong, in a car, but the world keeps spinning.
- Groxx 7y agoHumans have been failing to drive safely for longer than we've had computers, and neither has been around for very long. It's far too soon to claim we've hit peak performance.
- robbrown451 7y agoThere is a lot of evidence that technology tends to improve over time.
- paulryanrogers 7y agoBacteria in a sealed container will reproduce until all resources are consumed. Then they drop to anemic levels or die out entirely. Humans live in a relatively closed system. And modern technology sits atop a very fragile foundation. All that to say past evidence does indicate technology generally gets better, but not necessarily forever.
- XorNot 7y agoNo we don't. We live on a planet around a midlife star. The amount of resources available to us over the next 10,000 years is staggering.
- paulryanrogers 7y agoHumans haven't proven the ability to live sustainably on one planet. Sustainably utilizing resources beyond the planet is far from certain.
- ta999999171 7y agoFor the record, I don't really like this thread, but GP's point does not hinge on using up other planets sustainably...
- joejerryronnie 7y agoHardware eventual fails, software eventually works.