7 ms·
> Obviously, some students thought that fee was ridiculous – just like paying for parking at a university where you’re already paying a hefty tuition fee I ha
by cortesoft 7y ago
> Obviously, some students thought that fee was ridiculous – just like paying for parking at a university where you’re already paying a hefty tuition fee
I hate parking fees as much as the next person, and totally appreciate the creativity of the people who defeated this device.
However, how should we handle distributing a limited number of parking spaces when there are more people who want to park than available spaces?
If we just say "free to park anywhere!", then there is a good chance you come to school and can't park anywhere (especially if you are not there super early)
You could do a lottery, I guess, but then people who don't need parking might enter the lottery and then sell their spot... making parking even more expensive.
Parking fees seem like a fair way to distribute the limited resource.
- appleiigs 7y agoIsn’t “first come first serve” fair?
- klodolph 7y agoIt doesn’t seem fair to me, it seems like it favors people who have early classes or live on early schedules.
- appleiigs 7y agoIf the parking fees are too low, it’ll just turn into first-come-first-serve. If you have high fees, you’d be just transferring the scare resource to the rich. And the people who can’t afford it are forced to figure something less convenient out.
- g82918 7y agoImagine a doctor working at two hospitals who has to move his car from one location to the other mid-day between surgeries. Is it more fair for him to have a worse parking spot and take longer to get to the operating room because he didn't park there earlier? Or should spots be given based on need?
- lostlogin 7y agoRepeat that but with a cleaner who is struggling to get by with 2 jobs while studying and is providing for kids. It seems much more likely given the location in this story too.
- Scoundreller 7y agoNo, it leads to people with 10AM classes arriving before 9AM for the free parking, which just worsens the problem.
- onei 7y agoNot really. Let's imagine students live off campus and commute in each day. If they have lectures at the start of the day, then you'll get a space. But if you have one lecture at 3pm on a given day and don't elect to spend the entire day on campus then you're likely unable to get a parking space. First come, first served works fine if you all start at the same time but I found you're often at the mercy of timetabling.
- superturkey650 7y agoWouldnt that unfairly weight parking spots to those with early classes? Not all classes have a variety of times available
- cortesoft 7y agoIt is 'fair' in some senses and not others... it means if you are a student with later classes, you are less likely to get parking. It also means you can't plan effectively. If half the time, you show up to class and can't park anywhere, how can you make it to class on time consistently? If your answer is "well, maybe you should take public transportation instead of driving", how is that any better for students than charging for parking? If you charge for parking, you are at least giving students a choice and the ability to make an informed decision: "is it better to drive and pay $x to park, or save money and take public transportation?" If you have free parking that is often full, your choice is "take public transportation or have a x% chance of not being able to park and missing class"
- imgabe 7y agoMaybe instead of hiring more administrators or building a luxury dorm, the university could build a parking garage. It's not like the number of students who need to park is unknown. If you know there's 1000 students who need to park and only 500 parking spots for them, randomly charging half of them exorbitant fines does not seem like a good solution.
- cortesoft 7y ago"Number if students who need to park" is not a fixed number. Some of the students parking might have alternative ways to get to school, but will choose to drive if parking is free. Others might have no good alternatives and need to drive. How do we encourage the people who can walk or ride a bike to school to do that instead of drive? By charging for parking. Also, not sure where you get the "charge half of them at random a large fine" bit from... they are fining people who park without buying a permit, not randomly.
- Thriptic 7y agoIncrease supply. Most schools use flat parking lots instead of multistory car parks which would be far more efficient. Alternatively, run public transportation that doesn't suck.
- cortesoft 7y agoBuilding a bigger parking lot requires money... who should pay for that, all students or just students who drive? Why should non-driving students subsidize driving students? Also, the school is not in charge of public transportation.
- greedo 7y agoIt's a slippery slope when discussing subsidizing. Should students who are Lit majors subsidize expensive research labs? Or sports teams? College costs really can't be a la carte.
- apcragg 7y agoNo, it isn't. The literature department is a fundamental component of the university. Providing land and infrastructure for students to store their property in the middle of campus is not - especially when campus is accessible through a variety of modes of transit. Sure, if the university is in a cornfield in Iowa then parking costs are less of an issue given the low cost of land but the majority of campuses I have been to are limited in land. The university has to make a choice between using that land to educate people or for letting people store their cars.
- cortesoft 7y agoWell, you have to draw the line somewhere. Do we pay for all food students eat? The clothes they wear? The houses they live in? The cars they drive? Obviously not... some schools might provide some of those things, but all schools will draw the line somewhere (I don't know of any schools that provide clothing) Why is it anymore of a slippery slope to say "the college won't subsidize student parking" than "the college won't subsidize student clothing"?
- xyst 7y agoMass transportation options coupled with high density buildings should be the way to go. Parking just doesn’t scale. The uni I went to had a decent bus system that had routes along the major apt complexes (private and uni owner). Buses were usually on time, and likely faster than trying to find a parking spot.
- sdenton4 7y agoYah, UC Davis runs its own bus service (entirely run by students, actually), and has run a decades long psy-ops campaign to get people to ride bikes. It seems to have worked quite well!
- ravar 7y agoDavis also has the rare advantage of rarely raining, and being incredibly flat. Both of these make biking far more attractive to the average student.
- ryanlol 7y ago> being incredibly flat Europe is full of two-wheeled vehicles that manage to solve this problem.
- ravar 7y agoBut we are talking about what it takes to get lazy Americans to bike. I am well aware of how popular biking is in Copenhagen even though they have comparatively terrible weather. Davis truly has an unusual confluence of factors that make biking more appealing to Americans.
- lonelappde 7y agoWere talking about motorcycles
- sdenton4 7y agoOn the other hand, lots of other cities in California and elsewhere have similar circumstances. Meanwhile, Copenhagen has very different circumstances but huge bike uptake. It's fundamentally about policy. Take the steps, and you'll get the results.
- HeavenFox 7y agoI think it's about the demographics. College students are cash-poor but time-rich, so they are more than willing to come in early and circle around to find a spot if it means they don't have to pay. College students are generally more liberal, so the capitalistic way of selling resource to the highest bidder naturally attracts resentment. If the community collectively believe paying-with-time is the best way to allocate resources, charging parking fee is nothing more than money-grabbing.
- fossuser 7y agoIf if I was trying to solve this problem and actually cared about the students I would do some capacity based pricing. Almost always free, as you approach parking capacity price increases. You could probably also set up a system to text people who have been there more than X hours that they will start to be charged due to high capacity.
- thaumasiotes 7y ago> You could probably also set up a system to text people who have been there more than X hours that they will start to be charged due to high capacity. Your plan is to have pricing that is not knowable in advance, and assess it against the students retroactively? I'm not sure it's possible to come up with a worse plan.
- cortesoft 7y agoI mean, the plan could be to destroy random cars if the parking lot is full, to make space for more. That might be slightly worse than this person's plan.
- fossuser 7y agoYou can still know a range in advance and you can alert people on their phone before charging them - I'd much prefer this to having to pay all the time even when capacity is low.
- acdha 7y agoThe problem is that people need to know in advance to change their behavior: tell them that today will cost $20 and people will take the campus shuttle, bike, or walk. Tell them that you’re charging more after they got there just makes it stressful and won’t change behavior unless it happens often enough to be highly predictable - just like many people drive hoping traffic won’t be bad today because they’re prone to dismissing bad events as outliers.
- rtempaccount1 7y agoWouldn't it make sense that the university, that is charging the students all this money, ensure they have enough parking spaces to satisfy likely demand? Doesn't seem unreasonable for universities with very high tuitions, to provide amenities like reliably available parking.
- Wowfunhappy 7y ago> Wouldn't it make sense that the university, that is charging the students all this money, ensure they have enough parking spaces to satisfy likely demand? Does the school offer paid parking permits? If so, why should students who don't need a parking spot (for whatever reason) need to subsidize those who do? The high overall cost of tuition is a separate issue, and not one that can be solved by including even more services in the price.
- RHSeeger 7y agoFor the same reason that lots of other things are subsidized, paid for even if you don't use them - school buses and the like - sporting equipment and facilities - library There's lots of services that schools provide, and charge everyone for, because they think it's good for the student body as a while. Maybe a more controversial one... a school that supplies free transit to/from the local night scene, so that people don't drive to/from bars while intoxicated. It's better for everyone, including locals, for this to exist. However, the non-drinkers, the ones who are nowhere near the night scene, get no benefit from it; they pay for it anyways. And a lot of people would say that's good, and a lot would say it's bad.
- pbhjpbhj 7y agoYour examples all seem like things that are beneficial to all, and that all should use.
- RHSeeger 7y ago> school buses and the like Not useful to people that live on campus and don't need to travel off-site much. > sporting equipment and facilities Completely useless to a lot of people. I used the swimming pool in college exactly once, during the swimming class/test. I certainly didn't use the sports fields. I used the bowling alleys, but those were paid-to-use and not covered by the sports fee we had to pay. > library I certainly got a lot of benefit out of this. However, with the internet nowadays, I'm not sure I would if I was in school. The point being, for many school services, everyone pays for them while only some people get a benefit. The scale of "some people" that benefit varies, but the concept doesn't.
- cgriswald 7y agoMy community college had more parking spaces than students on campus at any given time. They then did construction, resulting in one of the largest lots and some of the smaller lots being closed. There was still would have been enough parking for everyone, except they then rented out another parking lot to a pair of local companies. So, we ended up paying for parking when no parking was actually available. This was, of course, after raising the parking fees. The schools initial response to the problem was to get on campus earlier; which is an absolutely absurd statement for a community college since the demographics include a lot of single mothers and otherwise working adults. Not to mention everyone had to travel to campus because there was no housing. (To top it off, the nearby residents petitioned the city to make their streets permit only. I hope they and their visitors get ticketed regularly.) So the school expected us to pay more than ever for parking because they wanted to monetize their lot and they didn't even price it high enough to make parking possible for those who could afford to pay. They also did and do charge students to park at night, despite the fact that night classes don't come close to filling the lots. I'm not much of a stick-it-to-the-man type, but you can bet I found all kinds of creative ways to park and get out of tickets.
- Wowfunhappy 7y ago> The schools initial response to the problem was to get on campus earlier; which is an absolutely absurd statement for a community college since the demographics include a lot of single mothers and otherwise working adults. Also, if everyone came earlier in order to get a parking spot, there would still be no spots, because everyone came earlier.
- beerandt 7y ago>get on campus earlier Parking spots (and their demand) are a time constrained resource, so arriving earlier than you need to, even if practical, increases overall demand. Think about it, if you arrive for a 10am class at 9am, you're now taking up a spot that someone who has class at 9am could be using. You've essentially wasted an hour's use of a limited resource, before you even factor in your personal opportunity cost. I'm sick of universities not being subject to market forces. Student-aid reform did so much more harm than good, even before you consider student debt. This is just one of the many unintended consequences.
- edejong 7y agoSolutions: 1. Place dorm rooms nearby 2. Subsidize local public transport companies 3. Build more parking spots 4. Offer more content for students to watch at home 5. Take in less students if you don’t have the capacity 6. Organized ride sharing programs. 7. Off-campus parking with bus services
- cortesoft 7y agoAt my school, they did many of these things. In fact, it was generally accepted that you shouldn't drive to school, and they made many alternatives. For the small amount of parking they did provide, they charged a fee for. I think that is a reasonable way of dealing with the limited resource. Make it so you dont need it as much as possible, charge some to the people who decide to use it anyway.
- u801e 7y ago> how should we handle distributing a limited number of parking spaces when there are more people who want to park than available spaces? Presumably most students are living on or not too far from campus. What should be done to get more of them to use transportation options that don't involve driving to and parking on campus?
- Doctor_Fegg 7y agoCambridge University has it right: undergraduates basically aren’t allowed cars. https://www.proctors.cam.ac.uk/motor-control https://www.proctors.cam.ac.uk/motor-control
- anoncake 7y ago> Members of the University in statu pupillari who are in residence in term or in the Long Vacation period of residence are required to have a University Motor Licence if they wish to keep motor vehicles (other than mopeds) within 10 miles of Great St Mary's Church. Unless the university owns all land within 10 miles of Great St Mary's Church Cambridge University has it horribly wrong.
- cortesoft 7y agoIsn't that exactly why they charge for parking? To encourage students who have other modes of getting to school to use those? If you have free parking, students will drive 5 blocks to go to school, is because why not? It is free and faster and easier. If you charge for parking, many will walk or ride a bike or take a bus.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- chiefalchemist 7y ago> I hate parking fees as much as the next person, and totally appreciate the creativity of the people who defeated this device. However, how should we handle distributing a limited number of parking spaces when there are more people who want to park than available spaces? This isn't a parking problem. At its root, this is a personal transportation,public transportation and/or cultural issue. Demand for numerous things are increasingly, but supply is effectively static. That is, for example, parking decks are expensive. It's probably not possible to solve this as a parking problem But zoom back, dig for the roots and perhaps sone behaviors can be changed, and some cultural progress made?
- cortesoft 7y agoWell part of making that progress is making the status quo (driving your car to school) slightly more inconvenient by charging to park. That will encourage other modes of transportation.
- chiefalchemist 7y agoI agree. But slightly isn't working. So perhaps it's time to revisit the possible solutions? fwiw, last year I read Alchemy: The Dark Art and Curious Science of Creating Magic in Brands, Business, and Life He makes the case, numerous time for rethinking the approach to problem like this. https://www.amazon.com/Alchemy-Curious-Science-Creating-Business/dp/006238841X https://www.amazon.com/Alchemy-Curious-Science-Creating-Busi...
- LatteLazy 7y agoI get where you're coming from and I agree that people should pay what they owe, but just to split hairs... Paying for parking isn't a "fair" way to distribute it. What is meant to happen is that paying for it funds the creation of more parking (ground level parks are converted to multistories etc). So paying is a necessary evil to create and maintain enough of something to go around. With a monopoly supplier, like here, that doesn't happen as they can just pocket the cash. They may actually cut the supply as charging 20% fewer people twice the price is more money for them.
- wasdfff 7y agoMy old uni sold the rights to operate their garages for the next 50 years to campus park to build a couple dorms. Prices basically doubled across all tiers when the garages were privatized
- zucker42 7y agoParking fees at my university are only in small part due to rationing. You can see this because they recently added fees for the weekend, when they is no need to ration parking spots. For some reason, some university parking authorities are setup not serve the students and staff, but to make money/be cost neutral. That makes no sense to me.
- threatofrain 7y agoIsn’t the parking situation almost like overbooking a venue and hoping the musical chairs works out?
- phkahler 7y agoHow about just building a parking structure? That seems the only way to actually solve the problem.
- dx87 7y agoIt could be like the school my wife graduated from. You had to pay for a parking pass, but the pass didn't guarantee a spot. You were basically paying for the privilege of showing up an hour early to try and get a parking spot. It was a couple hundred dollars a year as well.
- ajross 7y ago> However, how should we handle distributing a limited number of parking spaces when there are more people who want to park than available spaces? By regulating the correct resource: the issue isn't too few parking places, it's too many cars. London basically fixed this: put the fee on the car.
- mikequinlan 7y agoWhy is the University allowed to accept tuition from more students than it has parking spaces? How would a student unable to park be able to attend classes? I can see using parking fees to allocate more desirable parking spaces, but effectively preventing tuition paying students from being able to attend classes is not acceptable (my opinion).
- XMPPwocky 7y ago> How would a student unable to park be able to attend classes? Except in the (very significant, and needs to be considered) case of disability... By walking between close-together classes, and bicycling or taking buses whenever longer distances need to be covered? This just sounds so alien to me... If I can't bring my gigantic metal box and engine with me, how am I supposed to get places?
- Sharlin 7y agoThese are the sort of topics where the US-ness of HN really shines through. Though it’s true that if the alternatives to driving require infrastructure that does not exist in many places then they’re not really short-term solutions.
- anoncake 7y agoHell, at least in warm areas motorcycles are pretty much a drop-in replacement for cars and still require less infrastructure.
- beatgammit 7y agoThe vast majority of universities are accessible by more than just cars, such as buses/shuttles, biking, and walking. If all else fails, you can organise your own shuttle service through carpooling. I don't see why students who don't use parking should subsidise those that do. Driving is a preference and is absolutely not mandatory, so it should be paid for separately.
- cortesoft 7y ago
- thsowers 7y agoI went to a large university located in the middle of nowhere. On any given day, only half of the avaliable spots were filled. A parking pass was $300 a semester IIRC. When parking isnt a limited resource and students are already paying large amounts of money to attend a rural campus that has poor public transit options what then? For me at the time it really just enforced the idea that college is more of a bussiness then it is actually concerned with education
- themagician 7y agoFree-for-all is the best solution. This way everyone is disappointed evenly and randomly.
- dreamcompiler 7y agoUniversities are incentivized to build buildings and destroy parking areas, because buildings make money and parking lots don't. Thus most universities are parking-constrained. The solution is to change that incentive structure, not to ration ever-dwindling parking spaces.
- anoncake 7y agoA university incentivized to educate students and do research will do the same because buildings are more suitable for these purposes than parking lots.
- SubiculumCode 7y agoI work at a hospital. I have to pay for a parking permit to park at my work. On its face, this is ridiculous.
- analog31 7y agoInstead of a lottery, have an auction. I live near a Big Ten university that's on an urban campus, so there's a lot of demand for parking in the area. It's a residential college, but with a lot of employees and grad students. So parking is at a premium. Faculty / staff parking is priced by convenience. The best spots cost the most. There's a relatively cheap lot at the edge of campus that's served by a shuttle bus. The city bus service is free for employees and students. And the town is relatively bike friendly. I ride my bike to work. One friend of mine keeps a bike on the back of his car and uses it for "last mile" to avoid paying for the expensive parking. The places where I went to college and graduate school, parking and housing were both cheaper, but land was also cheaper.