16 ms·
Washington pressures TSMC to make chips in US
- awinter-py 7y agosecurity risks aside, andy grove of intel publicly regretted offshoring semiconductor manufacturing because of his suspicions about generational shifts in innovation and expertise I've tried to read econ papers on colocation of innovation and manufacturing -- they're mostly long-winded and unconvincing but the concept is compelling
- jmole 7y agointel is one of the few companies with leading-edge fabs in the US. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Intel_manufacturing_sites https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Intel_manufacturing_si...
- Turing_Machine 7y agoDoesn't Samsung have some fabs in Texas?
- bradstewart 7y agoSamsung does have a fab in Austin (maybe elsewhere), but it's mostly flash in the 50-180nm range, not a leading edge process AFAIK.
- bob1029 7y agoThe Samsung LSI/flash lines in ATX are not a leading process node in terms of all foundries (i.e. TSMC), but last I heard they were pretty close to the bleeding edge of what Samsung is capable of in their Korean factories. The ATX lines were always intended to be exact copies of their Korean counterparts, but this may have deviated in recent years (I have been out of the loop for ~7 years now on their internals). Some of the major reasons behind Samsung building that factory in Austin were to satisfy Apple and to also leverage the more "open" innovation attitudes of the average American worker.
- tooltalk 7y agoAccording to Samsung's own account, their first fabrication plant in Austin, Texas opened in 1997, followed by major upgrades/expansion in 2007 and 2017.
- trynumber9 7y agoYes. It was Samsung's first 14nm fabrication facility. They were planning to upgrade it but haven't seen any articles since 2017 on that. https://www.samsung.com/us/sas/company/history https://www.samsung.com/us/sas/company/history
- bschne 7y ago> I've tried to read econ papers on colocation of innovation and manufacturing -- they're mostly long-winded and unconvincing but the concept is compelling Sounds interesting, do you have some references?
- awinter-py 7y agoI think Ketokivi is the paper I read (no idea what website this is hosted on): https://www.econstor.eu/bitstream/10419/63693/1/519737458.pdf https://www.econstor.eu/bitstream/10419/63693/1/519737458.pd... aside from the basic claim that large factories are doing some amount of R&D on-site, this read like nonsense to me. Could be my lack of depth in industrial organization / economics. maybe also search 'industrial clustering' or 'innovation clusters'
- lonelappde 7y ago> regretted But not enough to lift a finger about it > > Andrew "Andy" Grove was a Hungarian-American businessman, engineer, and author who had a net worth of $500 million dollars.
- Cedricgc 7y agoDan Wang explores this idea in 'How Technology Grows' [0]. To summarize, he asserts that the main downside of offshoring is the loss of process knowledge (the tacit knowledge that is learned by doing and transmitted through culture). [0] https://danwang.co/how-technology-grows/ https://danwang.co/how-technology-grows/
- wrkronmiller 7y agoCouldn't this have the opposite effect from what is intended? If all the US military TSMC chips come from a separate facility from those for Huawei, etc... then there's only one, big, target with minimal collateral damage.
- adventured 7y agoNo. If you're already at the point of China bombing fab plants in the US, you're at absolute war and many millions of people will die. The US would respond very badly, quite overly irrationally to an extreme to having its mainland bombed. Having those fabs in eg Taiwan and of mixed use (US & China both deriving supply from them) would be pointless under that conflict scenario anyway; all it would do is keep China from bombing them - maybe - and instead they'd seize them physically and shut off US supply while trying to keep their own supply going (the US can't stop China from taking Taiwan; if they move on Taiwan, they're getting anything left standing, including fabs). There's zero upside to keeping them mixed with US / Huawei if there's a conflict.
- morrbo 7y agohe's probably more hinting at ransomware/espionage on the shop floor
- riversflow 7y ago> the US can't stop China from taking Taiwan; if they move on Taiwan, they're getting anything left standing, including fabs I’ve seen this repeated in this thread, is there any evidence of this apart from conjecture?
- adventured 7y agoSure, I think it's quite technically obvious when you look at any aspect of the matter. Taiwan is five feet from mainland China and they have a massive military that is increasingly quite advanced technologically (clearly the overall #2 military in the world in both capability and technology at this point; Russia is superior to China in a few categories, but not overall; China is rapidly rising, Russia's military is rusting) and they have an increasingly potent navy. They can stand off US carriers effectively and are building multiple carriers of their own. They can rapidly, massively resupply locally, whereas the US would have the British Empire problem of trying to supply a conflict very far away (and facing non-stop Chinese harassment & losses in attempting to resupply into Asia). US bombing capability is far too limited in volume now versus a target as massive as modern China's manufacturing and military (we can't take it down effectively or fast enough; and we couldn't easily consistently penetrate their territory air defenses anyway; Russia would very happily feed them volumes of S missile systems, which would severely restrict US bombing efforts). US military resupply is wildly expensive, Chinese military resupply is not (specifically on such a local/regional basis). My god the resupply capabilities of a full war footing modern China in the local region - just get the fuck out of the way of that. Picture WW2 scale US manufacturing arms output capability and then double it. What is the US going to do, lose a couple hundred thousand soldiers and a large number of naval ships trying to save Taiwan, which is an impossible task long-term. No chance the American public goes for that unless the mainland US is at risk or unless China makes the mistake of killing a large number of US soldiers in eg South Korea or Japan. Taiwan is an ally, it isn't necessary for US national well-being. If China gets Taiwan, and the US keeps its manufacturing-import relationship with China/Taiwan for its domestic economy benefit, the US public will have little appetite for an actual war with China. Where's the US public self-interest otherwise? Do you kill everyone in China, alternatively (not plausible, as that's all out nuclear warfare between the two nations)? Because that's the only way to permanently stop them from taking Taiwan if they want it. They have an authoritarian system, truly epic scale manufacturing capabilities of all sorts, a rapidly advancing military, and 1.4 billion people to throw at problems (with only minimum regard for killing large numbers of them if it's regarded as absolutely necessary for national goals; China will tolerate losses far better than the US, authoritarian systems have demonstrated that repeatedly in the prior century).
- Nokinside 7y agoI think there is a geopolitical reason why most TSMC's 300mm GIGAFAB's and advanced backend fab are located in Taiwan (1 fab in China). https://www.tsmc.com/english/contact_us.htm#TSMC_fabs https://www.tsmc.com/english/contact_us.htm#TSMC_fabs Concentrating geopolitical risk of TSMC operations makes Taiwan more important to the rest of the world. The US would naturally want to reduce this risk. In Taiwan-China conflict world chip production would take a huge hit or be in the danger of falling under Chinese rule. If TSMC's leadership is patriotic, they should refuse this pressure as much as they can and ask more weapons for Taiwan instead.
- joe_the_user 7y agoArguably, the situation is something of an incentive for peace since it makes the cost of war huge for all concerned.
- SiempreViernes 7y agoThe cost of war is always huge for all concerned, and is very rarely the outcome of any sort of cost-benefit analysis. Most wars between nations are fought for something like honour: https://blogs.lse.ac.uk/europpblog/2013/07/16/most-wars-are-not-fought-for-reasons-of-security-or-material-interests-but-instead-reflect-a-nations-spirit/ https://blogs.lse.ac.uk/europpblog/2013/07/16/most-wars-are-...
- lonelappde 7y agoCost is huge for the lower classes and maybe half the upper classes. They are sold on honor, but they fought for the profit of the ruling class, via conquest or be diverting fund to the military industrial complex.
- jvanderbot 7y agoWhat you describe is the effect of war, not its origin. Ironmongers get rich from war, but they probably don't make the conflict happen. How could Northrup Grumman force the invasion of Kuwait to improve F117 sales?
- phkahler 7y agoI'm curious about the politics here. I get making the chips in the US, but if security is the concern they should no be made by a company based in Taiwan regardless of where the fab is.
- amerine 7y agoWhy?
- Roboprog 7y agoSo that there is a “chain of custody “ from plan to production completely within the US. Presumably the people working in such would be reachable by US law, if not closely aligned with their own country’s interests.
- kevingadd 7y agoWhy is Taiwan specifically a threat? They're a long-term ally and their voters recently gave a new mandate to anti-China leaders in an election. If the US is worried about threats from Chinese electronics companies like Huawei it doesn't make any sense to alienate Taiwan.
- Apocryphon 7y agoChinese espionage in Taiwan, perhaps.
- microcolonel 7y agoThen again, maybe that's a good thing; certainly would encourage greater counterintelligence cooperation in Taiwan.
- nwallin 7y agoTaiwan isn't the threat. China annexing (or otherwise disrupting) Taiwan is.
- bgorman 7y agoTSMC already makes chips in the US through Wafertech in Washington (state)
- wyxuan 7y agothe article mentioned that, but you aren't having stuff like n7 or n10 nodes being done in US, which is what Washington presumably wants
- Nokinside 7y agoWafertech has 0.16-micron and above processes. The US wants TSMC's latest GIGAFAB's.
- metaphor 7y agoFrom the article: > The U.S. accounts for 60% of TSMC's sales, but the company operates only its subsidiary WaferTech there, producing chips for mature technologies. In this case[1], "mature technologies" appears to mean downto 160nm tech node...essentially irrelevant with respect to FPGAs. [1] https://www.wafertech.com/en/foundry/technology.html https://www.wafertech.com/en/foundry/technology.html
- zweep 7y agoWhat Washington should be doing is investing in creating a US-based top-notch semiconductor foundry business. And that's something that takes 20+ years.
- andromeduck 7y agoOr Intel can just spin off their foundary business.
- foota 7y agoHe said top notch though :-)
- creddit 7y agoThere's Intel today but, also, presumably this could be done with GloFo? They were in the midst of research into 7nm processes but stopped due to competition. Feels like investment there could work faster than 20+ yrs.
- ghaff 7y agoAnd ON Semiconductor bought Global Foundries' Fab 10 (formerly IBM) in East Fishkill. Sematech was the last US government effort to improve US competitiveness in semiconductors. It's still around but isn't a US government initiative any longer.
- agoodthrowaway 7y agoIntel does not support a fabless semiconductor business model. Lots of other chips are necessary besides CPUs.
- ausjke 7y agoTSMC is beating Intel for making chips. Still Intel is the last hope for US to secure IC manufacturing should a war, or a huge earthquake brought down Taiwan someday. I suddenly think it's time to buy INTC stocks.
- jngreenlee 7y agoTexas Instruments, Micron, OnSemi, Amkor, Microchip...there's lots of options US based for ICs!
- ausjke 7y agoNone of them are advanced these days comparing to TSMC, other than Intel.
- Taniwha 7y agoMost chips don't need the latest silicon technology, mostly that's just for high end CPUs and memory - "fast enough" allows one to start to optimize for cheaper
- NonEUCitizen 7y agoNot even Intel.
- ausjke 7y agoThat's true, Intel is the only one that is closest, though a little too far behind.
- jtdev 7y agoGood
- kds3 7y agoSo, at first we encouraged military companies mergers to save our money (back from 1980s?) and left only with a few monopolies, then suddenly there is only one company that can make our military chips? What a surprise! And now we have to pay premium to have them made on our soil? Same situation with non-military monopolies and near-monopolies.
- vonmoltke 7y agoIt was the 90s, and the only major defense contractor that had large fabs for digital chips was TI. The consolidation had little effect on where the chips are made.
- RantyDave 7y agoIt's not a bad idea. It would (presumably) insulate them against future border tariffs.
- lota-putty 7y agoHow is it different from colonialism? Leeching in the name of democracy? There are several democracies between Taiwan & USA.
- nimbius 7y agoIve always considered Chinas status as both a valued trading partner and supply chain asset, as well as a security threat and trade-sanctioned nation to be a rare example of the sort of capitalist schizophrenia that seems unique to the United States in the 21st century. On one hand you have capitalists drive for more capital, and on the other hand their increasing paranoia and distrust of any nation that seems to be enjoying the fruits of capitalism to advance the living wage and progress their society that hasnt avowed question-less allegiance to Washingtons foreign and domestic policy. Perhaps its because the nations, at heart, arent really so different? the US maintains the largest prison population in the world, followed closely by China. Both China and the US employ dragnet spy tactics against their own citizens. Neither country seems particularly keen to protect whistleblowers, and both have their own tongue-in-cheek definition of freedom of speech as somewhat of a moving target that suits the administration as its seen fit. Both countries are willing to openly steal technology to advance their respective causes, with the US perpetrating theft from the Germans after world war 2 and rocket technology theft from the USSR. china conversely steals from corporations that partner with it for cheap manufacturing and lax labor laws. Both countries use forced prison labor, although the US tends to toss a few coins to their laborers as a token gesture of "pay." If you insist on outsourcing your manufacturing technology to undermine your domestic labor in pursuit of profit, there will come a time when your pay to the piper no longer calls tunes you like.
- unlinked_dll 7y agoYikes with the whataboutism. I don't see concentration camps with millions of Uyghars in them in America. I don't see any state owned companies whose R&D is amplified by state actors engaging in corporate espionage. I don't see people being executed for minor drug offenses. I don't see tanks rolling through Washington DC used to crush the bodies of protestors. I don't see artists or reporters being locked up for being critical of the government. I don't see a one party state with a dictator ruling it for life. And I don't see a population that is fine with any of the above because they nominally increased the standard of living over the last 30 years. By the by, there's way better examples of "theft" than Operation Paperclip.
- 7y ago
- incompatible 7y agoWould the location of the factory really make much difference? If TSMC was to buckle under China pressure, it could probably find a way to interfere with or distribute secrets from the US military chips regardless of the physical location.
- klodolph 7y agoTSMC is "in China" it's just that ROC fabs are a few process nodes ahead of anything in the PRC. Various US military and government orgs prefer to buy chips entirely sourced within the US, this isn't as much about pointing fingers at China, but it is presumably harder to suborn domestic workers than foreign workers. Personally, my take on things is that the major world powers should use silicon entirely manufactured and assembled within their borders for critical and military/government hardware. It is too damn hard to verify chips after they are manufactured, because potential backdoors and vulnerabilities are too small to see these days. It is always an arms race between attackers and security, and whichever side is "winning" in a particular domain will shift back and forth, and the cost-effective tradeoffs will shift in position. Same thing happens in physical warfare over the course of history. The argument that PRC "could probably find a way to interfere" is not germane, because perfect security was never on the table in the first place. We are just comparing different relative levels of security on a probabilistic basis comparing cost of attack and cost of defense.
- bluGill 7y agoMilitary prefers locally sources parts because if war breaks out you need absolute certainly you can get the critical parts you need to build whatever weapons you don't have. For short war this isn't a big deal because you are stuck with whatever you have one hand. For a longer war you need to buy more weapons - and that means you need a source you can buy them from. Friends and enemies change all the time, so the only way to be 100% sure is to produce your own parts in your country.
- knolax 7y agoSounds like forced IP transfer to me.
- bumblebritches5 7y agoGood, fuck outsourcing.
- xvilka 7y agoPolitics aside that is the huge problem of having a monopoly in that industry. I really hope we will have more contract chip manufacturers at some point in the future.
- filereaper 7y agoDoD's having a crisis with its trusted Foundry Program [1][2]. Originally, IBM's East-Fishkill plant was the largest trusted-foundry of near latest generations (14nm, 22nm) but that was sold off to Global-Foundries, which then sold it off to ON Semiconductor. Now it needs someone to fab the latest generation with a full chain-of-trust. [1] https://semiengineering.com/a-crisis-in-dods-trusted-foundry-program/ https://semiengineering.com/a-crisis-in-dods-trusted-foundry... [2]https://www.dau.edu/cop/dmsms/DAU%20Sponsored%20Documents/OutreachHandoutJanuary2016.pdf https://www.dau.edu/cop/dmsms/DAU%20Sponsored%20Documents/Ou...
- BostonEnginerd 7y agoON is at least a US owned company. Should make it easier to maintain the trusted foundry there, as they have several other sites which are accredited. According to their marketing material, they are licensing the GF/IBM 45nm/65nm nodes. https://www.onsemi.com/pub/Collateral/BRD8079-D.PDF https://www.onsemi.com/pub/Collateral/BRD8079-D.PDF
- chvid 7y agoI thought the deal about the F35 and other fighter planes was that when the various countries bought this hardware they got to build a part of it. Really as a way to soften or justify the absurd cost of these things, For example here in Denmark, the Danish company Terma which is specialised in radar technology produces a number of components for the F35: https://www.terma.com/media/444108/f-35_and_terma_171012_screen.pdf https://www.terma.com/media/444108/f-35_and_terma_171012_scr...
- throwGuardian 7y agoFrom a purely economic viewpoint, fabs these days have such high levels of automation that locating them in Asia doesn't carry the cost benefits it used to
- NicoJuicy 7y agoI'm wondering which foreign company would trust today's president. The current president receives worse approval ratings than Poetin or Xi ( was a Washington company based petition in Europe, Asia,...) Which is a very hard achievement to reach.
- ptah 7y agoI fail to see how this removes chinese interference purely by moving manufacturing to US