13 ms·
Parachuting for Charity: A 5-year audit (1999)
- Zenst 7y agoThis is 1999 and popping "parachute jump for NHS" into Google yields many results and let's not forget the ADsense promoted ones as well. So a known issue and one perpetuated still today for profit. But this is a pattern we see play out over and over again and alas without some media drama incident of say a charity parachutist landing on a child in a playground with fatalities - nothing will change. Heck - look at bigger issues like climate change and how long that's been known about and how long it drags out. Which makes you wonder why governments who have departments for everything, lack one for common sense education as many sound messages get lost in the void of nothingness.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- im3w1l 7y ago> The injury rate in charity-parachutists was 11% That's how-are-they-even-allowed-to-operate high. Can this really be right?
- krilly 7y agoBear in mind that you wouldn't do a jump for charity if you wanted to it anyway. Their usual clientele would probably be very fit and young, whereas charity jumpers would be more likely to be old or unfit. So I'm sure their overall injury rates are lower
- VBprogrammer 7y agoThat doesn't ring true to me at all. Almost all of the people I've seen do some kind of charity extreme sport event would definitely have done it without the charity part if that was an option.
- krilly 7y agoI was actually chatting to some friends about this the other day. I personally would love to go skydiving but I wouldn't get sponsored for it because it isn't actually hard. Unlike running a marathon for instance, it doesn't require any preparation on my part or any superhuman effort, just a lot of cash. I think most people who do feats of endurance for charity (marathons, cycling, mountaineering, etc) would probably like to do it anyway but it's fair to ask for sponsorship money because of the effort involved.
- usrusr 7y agoWhy would doing a marathon and pretending to do it for other reasons than doing a marathon be any different? The only reason separating endurance sports efforts "for charity" from a hypothetical "candy crush for charity" or "Netflix binge for charity" is that the athletic efforts apparently impress some potential donors. If the same is true for courage dares like fixed line parachuting then so be it. An entirely orthogonal question is how event costs are funded: do participants pay out of their own pocket or is it taken from the donations pool? If it's the latter I'd call it borderline charity fraud, no matter if the activity is running, flaggelation, parachuting or smoking weed. The usual compromise, I think, is clear separation between sponsors (who fund the event) and donors (whose money is given to charity with zero cut or expenses deduction). It's hard to find something to criticize in that model, if someone wants to sponsor entertainment, fine. If tens of thousands of sponsorship dollars yield tens of donation dollars, still fine: the assumption that the tens of thousands would have been donated otherwise cannot be made. (it still might get muddy if that sponsorship somehow gets different tax treatment than other business expenses or if the main beneficiary of those costs, either as participant or as organizer, is the CEO or something like that but that's totally besides the question of parachuting vs endurance)
- perl4ever 7y agoSkydiving does not require "a lot of cash". You don't have to buy a parachute! Or an airplane, for that matter.
- sosborn 7y agoAt first I was thinking no big deal, it probably includes things like minor scrapes and bruises from the landing, but then I saw this: >Sixty-three percent of casualties who were charity-parachutists required hospital admission, representing a serious injury rate of 7% Can any skydivers give insight on this?
- cromulent 7y agoThat sounds extremely high to me, but I couldn't find which 5 year period was studied. Back in round parachute days, injuries were much more common. Most people who have jumped in the last 30 years have never seen someone use a roundy. These days most people do tandems, and if you follow instructions and raise your legs upon landing, you won't get hurt.
- digikazi 7y agoPfffff, I used a roundy for my first jump here in the UK only yesterday! I mean 1998. Which suddenly seems like yesterday. Jeez...
- perl4ever 7y agoBack in 1996 (I think), I had the impression they were obsolete, and during the instructional session before jumping, we were told to pay attention because once a guy who had experience in the military thought he knew everything from jumping with the round ones, and didn't listen and died as a consequence. I think it was something about the reserve being automatic on a military rig and not on a civilian one.
- viacoffee 7y agoSkydiver here. I'm not familiar with this particular event, but that does seem rather high even for those years. In the USA we average ~1 incident per 250,000 sport skydives. Tandems are around 1 in 500,000. You can find the USPA incidents here: https://uspa.org/Find/FAQs/Safety https://uspa.org/Find/FAQs/Safety
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- digikazi 7y agoYes, that figure is probably right. I did my first parachute jump in the summer of '98, a year before this study. It was a static line jump, using a round canopy; ancient stuff even then! I had wanted to skydive for a long time, so it wasn't a "charity jump." However, almost everyone else on my course was - they were really young as well, a bit naive and maybe a little dazed by the idea of jumping out of a plane. Some of them were Chinese/Korean students, with a very, very rudimentary grasp of the English language; I genuinely have no idea how they all passed the course, but they did. When they went on to jump, I think just under half of them ended up with broken legs/sprained ankles and so on. If my memory serves me right during the same drop the jumpmaster managed to kill himself too. To sum up, 11% sounds about right.
- htfu 7y agoWait, you're not exactly sure whether your instructor died or not? Just how drunk were you? Mushrooms are way more rewarding anyways.
- digikazi 7y agoNot very drunk at all :) The instructor's name was Andrew Kelly, and the time was May 1998 [1] - quite a long time ago, so forgive my foggy memory. I wasn't on that particular load; I had already done my first jump a few days before...and my second jump 3 days after he passed. [1] - http://www.skydivingfatalities.info/search.asp?MinDate=5%2F8%2F1995&MaxDate=1%2F2%2F2009&Place=Headcorn&State=&Country=&Category=&MinAge=16&MaxAge=78&UnknownAge=on&MinJumps=0&MaxJumps=15000&UnknownJumps=on&AAD=&RSL=&Description=&DescriptionOperator=OR&Lessons=&LessonsOperator=OR&Personal=on http://www.skydivingfatalities.info/search.asp?MinDate=5%2F8...
- htfu 7y agoAh fair play, makes sense.
- jcampbell1 7y agoThis is round parachute static line. You hit the ground at about the same speed as jumping from 10 feet. Completely manageable on a windless day or over a freshly plowed field. Outside of those conditions, it’s a shitshow.
- jbob2000 7y agoWhat better way to show someone the value of a hospital system than to have them admitted and treated by it!
- perl4ever 7y agoNew doctors have to practice on someone...
- blowski 7y agoPublished in 1999.
- boyadjian 7y agoAn example of charity business
- chiefalchemist 7y ago> "...and places a significant burden on health resources." How can 174 people place significant burden on NHS? I understand their concern but certainly there are bigger fish to fry. Also, more importantly, the analysis is completely flawed. Their ROI is based on the injuried, not all who donated and dived.
- refurb 7y agoParachute jumping for charity is not cost-effective in raising money, as the cost of treatment of the 11% who are injured is far in excess of any money raised by the rest. There analysis is correct. They looked across all charity parachutists, the medical costs for those injured versus total amount raised. How can it put a burden on the NHS? Of 105 patients admitted to hospital, 66 (63%) required operative intervention. Can you imagine the 1 or 2 hospitals dealing with this? The system overall can deal with it, but not the local providers.
- Apfel 7y agoTheir analysis actually only focused on two centres in the east of Scotland. There were ~1500 jumpers in 5 years across the two centres, of which 174 (11%) were injured at a cost of £3751 per injury.
- chiefalchemist 7y agoWhere does it mention the total universe of donors/jumpers? It says the average donation was 30 quid. That said, 30 to jump is not the same as 30 per donated. Too many loose ends here, or a sloppy job at communication.
- refurb 7y agoIt’s in the open access article. They calculated the “net” donation after costs.
- skue 7y agoThis study was published in 1999 and while it is a wonderful example of incentives gone awry, it’s also dated. Per the article, “All charity parachuting in our study was apparently done by static line methods from 2500± 3000 feet.” [1] Static line parachuting means the participant jumps solo and a cord automatically opens the parachute for them when they exit the plane. It’s very different than skydiving tandem, which is far more common these days and much safer. That still doesn’t mean that skydiving for charity makes any sense financially. It strikes me as absurd that people who want to skydive collect money from friends under the expectation that a small percentage of the donated funds make their way to a charity —- £30 per jump for the NHS, though apparently more for other organizations. [2] But then this comes from a country that is trying to convince the rest of the world that wearing a clown nose for a day is a charitable act. [3] Y’all can’t just give for the sake of giving? ;-) [1] https://www.gwern.net/docs/sociology/1999-lee.pdf https://www.gwern.net/docs/sociology/1999-lee.pdf [2] https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-3224643/Why-tell-charity-skydivers-running-JUMP-Good-causes-fraction-cash-NHS-pay-injuries.html https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-3224643/Why-tell-ch... [3] https://rednoseday.org/ https://rednoseday.org/
- smcl 7y agoI have never understood this either. It might seem a bit cynical but it often feels a bit like someone trying to: 1. Do something cool they always wanted to 2. Get someone else to pay for it 3. Get some feel-good story to tell their friends in the process Perhaps it’s not the case, and that most people are well intentioned, don’t think about it this way and aren’t trying to do anything nefarious. But it’s hard to shake the idea once it’s in your head :-/
- fooblat 7y agoMy uncle once asked me to sponsor him to do a charity marathon. I contacted the charity and found out that at most 50% of my donation would go to the charity and the rest would pay for him training and event fees. I did sponsor him but I kept thinking it would have been better to send 100% of my donation directly to the charity in my uncle's name. Of course that would have been a lot less fun for my uncle.
- mytailorisrich 7y agoTo be honest, many charity events cost more to organise and run than they collect in money. A bit of a (related) tangent... As a parent this is really obvious for almost all events that schools run. Of course, an argument in those cases is that they have educational value, but I think that teaching to do the maths and to be effective beyond the immediate desire to "help and do something" also has educational value. Sometimes we, parents, have to spend £20 to get the child ready for the event where they are asked to donate £1 for the chosen charity...
- projektfu 7y agoIn other news, programs like Product (RED) cost much more in marketing and advertising than they raise. https://web.archive.org/web/20070624105650/http://www.africomnet.org/news/mustreads/read03081.php https://web.archive.org/web/20070624105650/http://www.africo... The question, I suppose, is whether it's better for charity that it collects a few dollars that it might have not received anyway. The example in the OP is particularly egregious because it suggests that society is paying a high cost for a few dollars donated to charity.
- braythwayt 7y agoSome years ago I organized some bridge* events for charity. It was as simple as selecting a worthy cause (a children’s hospital), signing an agreement that we were going to turn over the funds, collecting the funds, and handing them over. These were a minuscule success, and I later thought that a “fun run” would be a good way to raise some money. I asked around about how to organize such things, and I was connected to a firm that organized these things as a service. They took me to a nice lunch, which I thought was a bad sign. “Never buy anything in a room with a chandelier,” is the old saying, and while there was no chandelier in the restaurant, the metaphor was nevertheless on point. When I finally got the actual details of how the run would operate, I realized that the firm’s fees would greatly exceed the amount of money that would end up going to the charity. I speculate that the “market” for these services are people who want to buy some respectability. Had I gone though with the deal and the run was a success, everyone would think I was a nice person doing nice things for people in need, even if the actual numbers would show that I was a nice person doing nice things for a service company’s revenues. N=1, of course, but I have had an extremely cynical view of charity events ever since. There appears to be an entire industry built around siphoning away 90%-99% of every dollar adjacent to charity. ——— * Bridge the card game, not the BASE-jumping location.
- tareqak 7y agoReputation-laundering. I would not be surprised if such an adjacent industry also exists for foreign aid.
- nradov 7y agoI've participated in many such charity fun runs and see no problem with this type of arrangement. It takes a lot of work and experience to host successful running events: registration, insurance, web site development, course marking, permits, aid stations, timing, t-shirts, clean up, etc. It's worth paying an event management company to ensure everything runs smoothly. Shop around and you might find a smaller local company willing to do it for a lower price. In the end the charity still gets more money than they had before and the runners get some exercise: win / win. Plus you've raised awareness of the cause and some participants will go on the become regular donors.
- angrymouse 7y agoThis brings back memories. Used to work for an NHS hospital trust. The chief executive made a rather rash, very public announcement (under peer pressure) that he was going to do a skydive for the hospital charity. Lots of jokes etc. But he was going to do it. Until our chief medical director took him aside and told him about the injury rate and how they actually cost the NHS more. Though a few people from the charity brought it up, it was politely forgotten about. And he did a walk around the peak district instead
- jxramos 7y ago3 questions * at what cost * compared to what * with what hard evidence At least they figured out the first eventually.
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 7y agoI have always found the premise of “run for charity” or “jump for charity” weird. If I thought a cause was worthwhile, I would donate to it. Why does someone running or jumping have anything to do with me donating?
- reaperducer 7y agoDitto for all the dozens or maybe even hundreds of new charities that are formed each week (at least in the United States). It seems like instead of having a hundred thousand micro-charities, it would be better if the money were just sent directly to a large charity that already operates at scale and can use the money more efficiently. Sending $100 to Doctors Without Borders is far more effective than giving $100 to The Dr. Steffy McStethoscope Memorial Fund For People Who Want To Make Themselves Feel Good. It's like "raising awareness." It doesn't help anyone but the people trying to make themselves feel better about themselves.
- raldi 7y ago> It seems like instead of having a hundred thousand micro-charities, it would be better if the money were just sent directly to a large charity that already operates at scale and can use the money more efficiently. We could call it "taxes".
- OscarCunningham 7y agoPeople's charity preferences are very different from their tax preferences. In particular people prefer their tax money to be spent on their own country, while often giving money to foreigners.
- reaperducer 7y agoExcept that (again in the United States which I point out because the article is UK-focused), governments at all levels have been offloading their responsibilities for the common welfare onto private entities, often for-profit entities. And in many places simultaneously making it harder for charities to do their work.
- Balanceinfinity 7y agoif you start from the assumption that each of us has a finite amount of money we will give to charity and that - one way or another - we will give that amount, then giving to things like fun runs and fancy balls (https://leukemiaball.org/ https://leukemiaball.org/) makes no sense at all (the donation pie is fixed). If, however, these activities increase the pie of actual donations, then holding them makes sense, so long as the increase in the size of the giving pie is not exceeded by the expense of holding these activities.
- htfu 7y agoMakes me think of this one time. It was me, and a first timer who'd been convinced by his gf it might cure his fear of heights. Yada yada yada, he broke both his legs. Something tells me it didn't help much.
- emmelaich 7y agoAfter a local epidemic of chuggers ("charity muggers") here there was a good newspaper article on some disreputable charities. A bit of web searching took me here: https://thedevilcorp.wordpress.com/ https://thedevilcorp.wordpress.com/ It's very enlightening and alarming!
- travisoneill1 7y ago11% injury rate with 60% of those admitted to the hospital! Cost is not the main issue with this!
- gojomo 7y agoI've not heard of parachute jumps for charity in the USA. Is it more popular in the UK? And if so, is it possible the existence of the NHS – making participants & charities somewhat more indifferent to the medical costs – is what's helping the popularity (& resource waste) here, in a classic 'moral hazard' situation? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moral_hazard https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moral_hazard Have UK charities just figured out a way, via a slight nudge to wannabe parachuters, to siphon off some of the value of NHS coverage into their own program funds?