13 ms·
What kind of data is my new car collecting?
- raesene9 7y agoOne thing that's interesting to me is, modern cars know (relatively accurately) whether you're speeding or not. They have GPS and a database of speed limits. Also depending on what's in the car, they may know who was driving it. How long before a speed safety campaign starts arguing that car manufacturers should be handing over information about people breaking the law in their cars to law enforcement...
- tonyedgecombe 7y agohttps://www.cnbc.com/2019/03/27/cars-in-europe-could-be-fitted-with-technology-to-stop-speeding.html https://www.cnbc.com/2019/03/27/cars-in-europe-could-be-fitt... You won't be allowed to break the law. The petrol heads will complain but they will lose because "think of the children".
- raesene9 7y agoI predict a strong market for "classic" cars that are exempt from these regulations...
- brewdad 7y agoI predict that drivers would then be required to retrofit a monitoring device in order to be road legal. Oregon already experimented with GPS tracking as an alternative to paying the gas tax.
- gambiting 7y agoEven the very proposals for this say that there should be an ovveride in the cabin, just like you can switch the Start/Stop system off. I'm one of those "petrolheads" and it's not a law I worry about in the slightest.
- no_flags 7y agoOur phones, too.
- mhb 7y agoWell what has happened with speeding inferences that can be made from electronic tolls?
- paganel 7y agoI also suspect that in the near future insurance companies will demand higher premiums from drivers who commute on more "dangerous" roads (i.e. roads on which statistically speaking more accidents happen). The companies already have easy-enough access to most of the drivers' GPS data, they certainly do know the GPS locations of most of today's accidents (via Waze-like services), I'm surprised why they haven't already started implementing this.
- PinguTS 7y agoIn fact there are insurers right now, which give a discount of up to 20% if you share your data with them and if you "follow the rules" like not driving so fast, not doing so much acceleration, … The problem is, if more and more people switching to those insurances it becomes very expansive for people who mind their privacy.
- Jamwinner 7y agoThe other issues is that their sensors always report bad driving. There is no upside to putting one on your car.
- dsfyu404ed 7y ago>I'm surprised why they haven't already started implementing this. I would be completely unsurprised if they've run the numbers and determined that penalizing entire zip codes is far more lucrative.
- Spooky23 7y agoThat is already here for motor carriers. New York, Kentucky and Tennessee have been piloting different technologies for a few years for truck and bus inspections. Cars are required to have certain telemetry capabilities starting in 2020 or 2021 as well. We’ll have automatic inspections and taxation by the end of the decade. Law enforcement already has fairly pervasive networks of fixed and mobile LPR. You cannot leave most cities without a record of it, and if you attract federal attention, passage through many interstate corridors is captured with LPR and photos of occupants.
- avip 7y agoIt's already handed over to insurance companies.
- esotericn 7y agoThe information is still not even remotely accurate enough for this to work without ridiculously high levels of false positives. An obvious example would be in Germany. The autobahn for example has sections that are unrestricted, but those same sections are 130kmh (or sometimes lower) if it's between certain times or raining or whatever. Half of the time my car interprets that as just being 130. Outside of that; there are countless instances of my car thinking I'm in an 80kmh zone when it's actually 100, 120, whatever. I can override that because I know what the actual speed limit is. Would the car be constantly reporting back that I'm doing a bad? Ultimately I reckon perfect enforcement of this would just stop me bothering. I'll get someone else to drive me around like an Uber and they can take the endless tickets instead.
- 34679 7y agoThere are a lot of useful data points in modern cars. For instance, the compression rate of your suspension can indicate how aggressively you're cornering. This sort of thing is already being used in opt-in programs by insurers in the US. They interpret as much data as possible in an attempt to calculate for each customer a sort of driver safety rating that is then used to determine insurance rates.
- raesene9 7y agoI guess that depends on country. For example the UK has no public road (that I'm aware of) where a speed of higher than 70mph is allowed, so that would be an easy initial rule. Where there are dynamic speed limits in place, it would be plausible to report back possibles (car location and speed) which could then be checked against a central database which was more accurate. I'm not suggesting that such a system is a good idea, but that I can see car safety campaigners looking on it as the next step in their campaigns...
- gambiting 7y agoThis already exists and it's a massive fucking joke - it's called "black box insurance unit". My sister had one in her car and during one year we've had to ring up the insurance company multiple times to manually correct her driving score, as she was being penalised for "severe speeding". After asking the company to send us the full tracking data it was completely obvious that the system doesn't have enough accuracy - couple times it tagged her as going 50mph(!!!) over the speed limit, because she was driving 70mph on the motorway going over a small 20mph road.....so the system naively queried the speed limit at coordinates XYZ and concluded that she was going nearly 4x the limit. Good thing her insurance wasn't automatically cancelled over it as I've heard it happen to many people in this country(and then you need to go and fight it with the insurance company, like your time is free or something).
- 34679 7y agoIMO, it's more likely that humans will be mostly priced out of driving, via insurance, once the data show that self-driving vehicles are safer. It still isn't settled exactly how insurance will work on a car without a steering wheel. Will the manufacturer insure its entire fleet or will the customer insure their personal vehicle? Or will there be something entirely new, like a government approved industry standard that shifts liability to the public? Whatever happens, insurers will make it more and more expensive for a human to drive a car once it becomes clear that it's safer for a computer to do the driving.
- PinguTS 7y agoTalk to automotive guys and you will learn that the most current map with this kind of information is in minimum 6 month old. But most of the time this information is 2 to 3 years behind. This is true for all current map providers.
- dsfyu404ed 7y ago>How long before a speed safety campaign starts arguing that car manufacturers should be handing over information about people breaking the law in their cars to law enforcement... Probably sometime after we have speed limits reasonable enough that the overwhelming majority people do not routinely exceed them and/or the politicians who write the laws stop driving.
- detritus 7y agoI rented a van last year from a company I don't ordinarily use and had to phone them up about the constant beeping that I couldn't figure the source of. Little did I realise that was a direct admission I'd been speeding on my way back to the studio! - ed (It wasn't even bad speeding (mostly) - I'm in London after all - it kicked in every time I went a mile an hour over whatever limit I was subject to. Very [very] annoying)
- falcolas 7y agoAt least in my 2019 Subaru, that DB is already badly out of date for my area. Amusingly, it's all on the high side - 80 for a 75 zone, and 45 for a 35 zone. It's also usually late in registering the switches, by a good quarter mile in some cases.
- foxyv 7y agoI wouldn't mind an automated governor that picks up speed limits from RFIDs in the road. If it could make residential roads safe for kids again it would be worth it 10x over. Although automated fines for passing the speed limit is kinda stupid when you can just limit the car in the first place.
- st8675309 7y agoSometimes I wish HN had a hard stop on posts that link directly to paywalled content. Feels spammy.
- simion314 7y agoTurn JS off by default and white-list websites that you trust.1
- egdod 7y agoI have JS disabled, and this site says it can’t validate my access to the article.
- simion314 7y agoI don't know how to explain this. Works for me in Vivaldi with JS off
- tpxl 7y agoI have JS disabled and the site renders fine
- celeritascelery 7y agoI have JS on, and it works fine.
- bsenftner 7y agoYeah, my last car purchase was an exercise in locating a vehicle without any "smart" technologies. Car manufacturers are the last corporate group I'd trust with anything they are not heavily regulated to provide, such as basic safety measures such as the seat belts they fought for years not to provide. I plan on this being a car I nurse forever, as it is going to be a generation of extremely intrusive data collection, and extremely poor security on these vehicles. I'm staying away for a complete generation, if possible.
- hprotagonist 7y agoTVs, too.
- merpnderp 7y agoTv's are simple though, just don't connect them to a network and they work fine.
- flyingfences 7y agoI've heard allegations that some of the newer TVs will automatically scan for open networks in the background.
- gruez 7y agoI saw some comments like this last time there a smart TV thread. However, none of the commenters were able to substantiate these allegations.
- 0xcde4c3db 7y agoThey very well might scan even with no networks configured (some Wi-Fi stacks scan in the background by default; it can reduce the the time the user has to wait when selecting an SSID or initiating a connection), but has anyone claimed that they actually connect? I think that would make headlines.
- SamuelAdams 7y ago> “There’s just massive amounts of data being collected, and if you want the service, you have to agree to it. And people do agree to it, and they have relatively little control over things,” Scassa says. I'm curious what this will do to the used car market in 10-15 years. Say the original owner consented to all this data tracking. They go to sell the car to buy a new one, and the 2nd owner does not agree to the tracking. Is there a vendor-provided way to shut this off? Or is the vehicle always stuck in a "data collecting mode" regardless of who it is sold to? Furthermore, if a customer changes the car to stop data upload, that could be seen as tampering with a vehicle. This could lead to legal consequences, but I'm not a lawyer so I can't dwell on the specifics.
- Psyladine 7y ago>I'm curious what this will do to the used car market in 10-15 years. Depends on LEO. If it is easier to deal with trackable cars, then untrackable cars will be hotter than black tinted windows and radar detectors. It already is, to some extent; why can I not gut my catalytic converter & change some programming so my car says the outputs are fine? Because the state wants me to get rid of my old functional car to support the economy of newer more expensive vehicles.
- xg15 7y ago> why can I not gut my catalytic converter & change some programming so my car says the outputs are fine? Because the state wants me to get rid of my old functional car to support the economy of newer more expensive vehicles. ...also probably to protect the environment?
- Psyladine 7y agogarbage argument. A single cargo container pukes more shit into the ocean and atmosphere than all the little commuter cars put together. And we have fleets of them running 24-7 to make this world possible. Humans breathe out CO2, I wonder how long until the go-greens suggest a permanent solution to that booming population issue...
- 7y ago
- hprotagonist 7y agoNot too long ago I owned a motorcycle from the 70s. I realized at one point that it was probably EMP-proof: no fuel injection, no fuel pump, certainly no OBD anything, and a (literal) kickstarter. The most complicated thing in the wiring harness was the key cylinder and the relay for the turn signals and headlights. I miss that bike sometimes.
- Eikon 7y agoWas the engine two-stroke?
- hprotagonist 7y agoTwo cylinder, four stroke. Old Honda UJM with a small engine and fairly low compression ratio, so you could kick it over in one kick without breaking your ankle.
- jpindar 7y agoHeck, you could 'kickstart' some of them by hand.
- i_am_proteus 7y agoI had a diesel car that I once drove with no alternator and no battery: started off a jump and drove to the auto parts store. Radio, windows, and lights were dead, but the car drove fine.
- overcast 7y agoThat's how diesel works, off its own compression.
- deaps 7y agoYeah - I remember when I was a volunteer firefighter - if you parked a fire truck in an atmosphere that was filled with combustible gasses, the engine would not shut off. The trucks were equipped with some type of an emergency throw should that situation ever arise. We never had to use it in my time there.
- imposterr 7y agohttp://archive.is/JdLhu http://archive.is/JdLhu
- kgwxd 7y agoI'd really love to see companies start being proud to be "dumb" and disconnected.
- zaphod12 7y agoand you'll pay a very large premium for it, too, unfortunately, since the company has to close off another revenue stream.
- kgwxd 7y agoFine with me. At this point I'd pay regular price plus the expected discount from data collection, just to be sure. Call it a "privacy fee" and I won't even be mad.
- mywittyname 7y agoAt what point does data become so accessible as to be worthless?
- RickS 7y agoIMO the better question is when data becomes too expensive to be worth it. There are currently no serious financial downsides to scraping, hoarding, selling, or leaking customer data. There is huge financial upside to doing or risking all of those things. Companies' data policies may be user-hostile, but they're economically rational. Data becomes "worthless" when the average joe's phone number is worth $0.003 to marketers, but there's a $500 fine for leaking it, allowing access from an internal team for purposes not specified in a granular opt-in form, or for being found to possess it after its deletion was requested. Routine third party audits are mandatory if you want to interact with other serious players in your industry. For all the ways that banking and healthcare are hellish, they've at least got the semblance of teeth on stuff like this. We'll know it's working right when companies spend the same effort to avoid hosting your data that they spend on collecting it today.
- newscracker 7y agoThat’s take a long time for this to come full circle and for most people to want such a thing (and being willing to pay for it). Meanwhile, what may become available would be the “Apple Car” or something similar that collects data for processing locally in the vehicle and has measures to not send it “to the cloud”. We’d have another one of those “What happens in your car stays in your car” marketing campaigns!
- jhoechtl 7y agoAs long as self-driving a car will be allowed (and I predict this will become quickly impossible the moment self-driven cars will share the space with autonomous vehicles) I will refrain buying any car collecting AND transmitting data without my consent. Yes that means in ten years or so I will be riding a used shabby old car.
- ethanwillis 7y agoA used shabby car can be completely rebuilt, not just the engine, for a tenth of the cost of a new car.
- RickS 7y agoI don't think that's true. You can get a new car for $15k in the US. "completely rebuilding" a used car of any quality, by any definition, is likely to surpass 15k in labor alone, unless you're doing the work entirely by yourself, at which point it's likely to cost 15k in tools.
- blaser-waffle 7y agothat might work... until all of the cars on the road are self driving and non-self-drivers are no longer permitted.
- pmlnr 7y ago> A car camera for Affectiva, a company that is developing technology for measuring driver emotions, in Boston, on Oct. 6, 2018. No. Just no. Why would anyone allow collecting this kind of information? There is no way it can't (so, won't) be used against you. Everyone gets angry from time to time.
- maze-le 7y agoThere is also no way this information is 100% accurate at all times. Emotional recognition is inherently probabilistic -- there will be false positives and false negatives, no matter how good the heuristic is. In the end, it'll be you who has to prove that you were in an emotional stable state, and not the algorithm that gets scrutinized.
- samfriedman 7y agoYou could join the data to billboard locations and sell it to advertisers who want to know what kind of emotional impact their highway campaigns are having.
- falcolas 7y agoIMO, that's still using the data against our (the driver's) best interests.
- cs702 7y agoWill the impersonal multinational corporations that control the software in you car be looking out for your best interests? Will the data collected about you and your behavior be used in ways that never go against your best interests? Can individual software developers and teams working for these corporations do much about this if they disagree with it? The answer to these and many other related questions is probably not. Little by little, we human beings are gradually building a panopticon monitored by machines under the control of corporate organisms whose behavior is beyond the control of most human beings. As an example, think about about all the people at Google who have tried, mostly without success, to prevent it from acting like every other impersonal corporation. There's nothing preventing it.
- avip 7y agoIt's educational to read waze's verbose privacy policy which goes over what is collected and why. Assuming good faith here, this is one of the best privacy statements I've read. https://www.waze.com/legal/privacy https://www.waze.com/legal/privacy
- geocrasher 7y agoI'm proud to say that my vehicle has zero tracking, is user serviceable, and my purchase of it had zero carbon impact. It's also 32 years old, gets 14-15mpg, and drives like a truck. It's a 1988 Chevy Suburban. I bought it a few years ago, for $1450 and really haven't put much into it overall. It runs reasonable well (still some things to figure out) and is comfortable. If I had some money I'd fix some of the things wrong with it and update the interior with seats out of a newer model, but overall, it just works. And that's what I see going UP in value over time. To think I could own a car that could tell some corporate partner where I went for lunch is just unfathomable. I can't afford to own a car that "cool" and I'm glad for it.
- bagacrap 7y agoI'm glad you're happy with your ownership of that thing, but I'm more glad that most of them are off the road by now as we've made great strides in emissions and crash safety since the 80s, not to mention mileage. These are factors with measurable real-world impact on your fellow citizens, and, I would submit, more important than your paranoid secrecy wrt your dietary habits.
- geocrasher 7y agoHeh it's not paranoia, it's just a matter of privacy. Then again, my phone already knows, so it's moot. Crash safety has come a long way, no doubt. But mileage really has not. For all the complexity of a modern Suburban (at over $50K USD!) it gets 14 MPG around town and up to 23 MPG on the highway. Mine gets about 14/17. Since most of my driving is local, it doesn't really matter.
- bagacrap 7y agoFWIW unless you have a diesel your official city mileage was 11 when the car was new. But as someone who has to live near other people and use roadways myself, I'm more concerned about tailpipe emissions. NOx standards are literally 100x more stringent starting in 2025 than 30 years ago (50x now compared to 1988).
- 7y ago
- Seenso 7y agoOne of my major requirements when I was shopping for my last car was that it not have a cell modem to enable connected car features. It's too difficult for them to monetize your data if they can't get it off your car in near-real time. I also reckon it's a bit more secure. The car salesmen have no idea about whether the cars they're selling have modems or not, so I found you have to ask about them indirectly in terms of features. I has success with this line of questioning: 1) Does this car have connected car features? 2) If it does, and I decide to get them later, can you enable them from your computer without me having to bring my car in? If the answer is yes to both questions, the car has a modem. Unfortunately, my wife wanted a car that failed that test. However, my research had indicated that those features seem to be implemented by a module that's separate from the entertainment system. Hopefully I can physically disconnect it without the car nagging about it being missing, but that's a project for another day.
- gambler 7y ago>Hopefully I can physically disconnect it without the car nagging about it being missing Don't count on it. Physically locating it and disconnecting it might be very difficult. Worse, since the module in networked via CAN, you literally have no idea how the rest of your car will react. It could switch to limp mode, for example.
- Seenso 7y ago> Don't count on it. Physically locating it and disconnecting it might be very difficult. I already know where it is: it's in a box underneath the entertainment system ("head unit"), and there are a lot of instructions about accessing it. I also have two options for disconnecting it: 1) total disconnection 2) leave it connected, but cripple its function by removing the antenna connections I'm thinking that if #1 results in an error #2 would be less likely to.
- namibj 7y agoBetter: unscrew the antenna and screw in a matched termination/load instead. This will protect the amplifier inside (HF reflections due to a miss match could fry it with overloading the transistor), and be an even worse antenna compared to an open SMA (or such) connector.
- moretai 7y agoHas there been a similar dive into what Tesla collects?
- mothsonasloth 7y agoI used to work for a British car manufacturer which is currently in the process of monetizing all the telemetry they get out of their vehicles, some examples: * Pothole tracking --> sell to local goverments * Tyre wear --> sell customer data to target adverts for them / promotions * Hybrid battery charge levels --> sell data to EV charge point companies. What was even more concerning was that this data is being collected by another company (who supplied the hardware), who had first dibs on the data.
- djanogo 7y agoToyota is also doing this now, they began collecting data all 2020 models with TSS 2.0. They started insurance offerings to generate $$ off of this data, toyotaims.com.
- 882661830 7y agoAs a benefit for paying for their safety services they will harvest everything by default, it’s not even clear if you can opt out of absolutely everything https://www.toyota.com/privacyvts/images/doc/privacy-portal.pdf https://www.toyota.com/privacyvts/images/doc/privacy-portal....