42 ms·
Everything is a system. The economy, society, relationships, nature, traffic. You don't need math to reverse engineer a system. You just need to pay attention
by muzani 7y ago
Everything is a system. The economy, society, relationships, nature, traffic.
You don't need math to reverse engineer a system. You just need to pay attention to it. You can say the right words to make a date happy. You can figure out which lane is the fastest route, better than Google Maps can. You don't need an app or data - your brain is a wonderful data processing machine.
Don't be angry at the people who are benefiting from a system, or at the system itself. Most just end up that way, the same way a river meanders towards the sea, or an electrical current tries to find ground.
Fixing/improving a system often requires deep understanding of it. An action here will cause a response there. People often document it, but few will do a proper design.
If you don't fix a system, few will. Most people are reactive to it and try to live with it as background noise.
If you don't control a system, it will control you. You don't have to change its fundamentals, just move out of the way of harm.
Neatness/order is a way to understand a system. All systems tend to fall to disorder. Disorder is not always a bad thing. Order is very expensive, and only serves as better documentation to those who do not understand it. Very often, excessive order is a symptom of someone who does not understand or control it.
- subhashp 7y agoWonderful. Thank you for putting it so nicely.
- jerome-jh 7y ago"Order is very expensive, and only serves as better documentation to those who do not understand it. Very often, excessive order is a symptom of someone who does not understand or control it." Pretty good description of my current management. Could also apply to a codebase that has grown organically but would be just prohibitively expensive to rewrite.
- neilkakkar 7y ago> "You can figure out which lane is the fastest route, better than Google Maps can." Why do you think so? Given Google Maps has real time information about cars on both routes, I'd think it does a better job of aggregating this data than my intuition.
- sokoloff 7y agoOriginal post is unclear. I can figure out which lane of traffic on a given route is faster (which is something that Google Maps doesn't even attempt to do as far as I can tell). I agree that Maps/Waze can figure a better real-time route than I can, especially in unusual situations.
- hugey010 7y agoIf you know an area well, you almost always can find at least slight improvements to the Google Maps route. When I know there's a closure or accident, I often look at Google Maps to figure out which way it's recommending and intentionally avoid that route.
- neilkakkar 7y agoHow do you measure that your route was indeed faster?
- lotsofpulp 7y agoBoth Google and Apple Maps are terrible at knowing when not to use local routes to theoretically save less than a minute or two of time. In reality, you’re wasting brake pads and fuel in stop and go traffic that has far higher variance in travel time than a highway.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 7y agoGoogle Maps has tried to route me through closed off bridges in the relatively recent past. I don't have a huge amount of confidence in the validity of its data.
- jbay808 7y agoIt once asked me to drive my car along a bicycle path!
- adriantam 7y agoGive you an example: A highway in my neighborhood is congested often but if you can put 3 people in your car, you are eligible to use the HOV lane and usually you can watch the cars next to you moving slowly while you can go in 50mph. Google won't know you are eligible for HOV lane and assume you are not.
- tamebadger 7y agoReminds me of parts of 12 Rules for Life by Jordan Peterson, but still authentic! well said
- anotheryou 7y agohow do you think about politics and capitalism than? can the system still be simplified enough to grasp it well enough to change it? where would an individual who has grasped it find the power to change anything? capitalism seems super stable for now one of the most sad thoughts I heard: if you try to change the system to the better you might keep it from hitting the wall and actually stabilize it
- hans1729 7y agoNo one claimed that every system can be changed; traffic will be traffic. The same applies for the rules of politics [0]. Not sure how you get the idea that "capitalism" is a bad thing, the majority of educated people (and not just Americans) would strongly disagree; there is a reason why all credible attempts at non-market-driven growth failed, see China and Russia. You may look at the struggle in the world and link it to the perceived epxloitation of the poor, but if you'd ask the people who e.g. work in the textile-industry in "3rd world countries" wether they'd prefer not to have any job (because that's the sole alternative within our system) or keep on working under current conditions, they would prefer to keep feeding their family. The riches we enjoy through what you call capitalism aren't merely the number in your bank account: wealth includes the services we provide for another: being able to get a haircut at any time, etc. -- see what "being rich" without a functioning economy did to Venezuela, which was flowing in oil-money, distributed it among its people, and, in consequence, failed to keep up with the rest of the world. The system isn't what it is because of money and greed, but because it's the best we came up with, the implications of political workings notwithstanding. [0]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rStL7niR7gs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rStL7niR7gs
- geggam 7y agoIt's a cycle. We have to go through the socialism so people see how bad it gets. People forget people aren't inherently nice when it comes to survival.
- dnautics 7y agoVenezuela did not distribute it's oil wealth among it's people, or if it did so, it did so highly unequally, which, arguably is a natural consequence of state socialism, as predicted by Tucker and Bastiat.
- pryelluw 7y agoTo a poet everything rhymes.
- jstummbillig 7y agoI don't know. Seems sound enough. Unless you put forward more specific criticism – and I'd be happy to hear your thoughts – I'll be a poet today.
- atmosx 7y ago> You can say the right words to make a date happy. If the partner doesn't like you, you can say all the right, do all the right things, etc and still be passed-over. Then another partner comes in and does all the wrong things. Still he gets not passed-over. There's chemistry involved in relationships as well. From smell to much more subtle things. It's a function with infinite variables. We can create models that help us understand society, economy, etc. But these are social sciences, the outcome is affected by the observer ;-)
- darkerside 7y agoWhy doesn't the partner like you? Likely in large part because you didn't say the right things.
- yipbub 7y agoIn the answer-space -of things you could say or do, there are many right things, many wrong ones too. Only some are true.
- jmiskovic 7y agoMy criticism can be summarized as "map is not the teritory". The reality is messy. Sure, we can think in terms of feedback loops and interactive modules and it can be helpful sometimes. We just have to be aware we are imposing our puny models onto the infinitely complex beast. The model will break down at some point. Recognizing the correct model and extrapolating from it is not useful unless we know the limit at which it breaks down. It is also hard to be objective about our mental models, we tend to apply all kinds of favoritisms and observation biases when evaluating them. In machine learning (google maps) those biases are still present, but at least they are not our personal biases so they are easier to spot and correct for.
- CrackpotGonzo 7y agoThis is a great point. I read Thinking in Systems a few years ago and it changed how I observe and try to influence (or not) existing systems. Highly recommend. https://www.amazon.com/Thinking-Systems-Donella-H-Meadows/dp/1603580557/ref=nodl_ https://www.amazon.com/Thinking-Systems-Donella-H-Meadows/dp...
- tudorpavel 7y agoI recently read "An Introduction to General Systems Thinking" by Gerald M. Weinberg [0], which may or may not be in the same vain. These concepts are hard to wrap my mind around but they are appealing. I'll try your recommendation too, thanks! [0] https://www.amazon.com/Introduction-General-Systems-Thinking-Anniversary/dp/0932633498 https://www.amazon.com/Introduction-General-Systems-Thinking...
- aelhage 7y agoI highly recommend this as well. Coming at this with a background in mechanical engineering, ie, familiar with formal definitions of control systems, feedback loops, delays, etc, this book did a fantastic job showing how all those same concepts apply to nontraditional systems without requiring any deep technical knowledge of control systems.
- Buttons840 7y agoReminds of the book Systemantics by John Gall.
- tatar 7y agoVery well put. What I noticed is that every discipline invents their own lingo to describe the systems in play at the ethos of their discipline and they often manifest as some sort of law, principle or concept. What I'm really curious about learning is to see if there's some sort of overarching discipline that focuses on these sort of systems as a meta and finds improvement points or market opportunities based on a given principle. Take Moore's law for instance. It essentially describes a relationship between the most atomic component of {system} and the price of the commodity that is offered by that {system}. (system=hardware) Now apply that to any other field. How about energy production? Is there a correlation between amount of cells in a solar panel and the price of energy at large available to consumers? This is still in the field of engineering so I'm guessing there will be some sort of relationship, but I wonder what taking it further into business and design for instance would look like. I don't know how that would look like but to clarify I don't expect any of these laws to illustrate a similar pattern, but I do expect them to define how further along or behind any given "system" is, assuming that they are somehow comparable.
- hans1729 7y agoI've thought about this a lot, it's my goto "one day I'll write a book about this". I frame the problem slightly different (heh): Different disciplines, branching out, will (or so says my hypothesis) discover the same topologies, but express them differently due to different scopes (perspective, dimensionality, DSLs [...]). What I'm thinking about is: how can we parametrize the manifestations of these scopes, and, ubiquitously, reverse-engineer them, thus linking all the systems? Then: which systems are topologically identical? If there are classes, how many? How do they differ? Are they (the systems OR the classes of systems) related? If so, is there a hierarchy (or are there multiple hierarchies)? My urge for this came from the intricate geometric representations for arithmetic problems; different scientific disciplines and industries just appear to fall into the same pattern. If someone knows a book that touches on this topic, please let me know about it, this thought is haunting me for years now :-)
- Chris2048 7y agoSystems thinking? Category theory?
- exabyte 7y agoI would highly recommend reading the book "Finite and Infinite Games" by James Carse
- davidwitt415 7y agoI highly agree. I read this book 30 years ago and it sticks with me to this day!
- davnicwil 7y ago> Don't be angry at the people who are benefiting from a system, or at the system itself. Most just end up that way, the same way a river meanders towards the sea This is absolutely brilliant, going to favourite it and steal your quote! The only thing I'd contribute is to also think about the system from your perspective, wherever you've ended up. Zoom out. Think about how you got here. How much of it is truly deliberate and chosen, how much is the default path of least resistance? How much did you create, how much did you accept and learn from others? How much is earned, how much is luck? What do you want to change, what can you change? Are you able to help others change? Are you able to help others by changing the system itself? Things how they happen to be now aren't necessarily how they ought to be. Indeed probably as a rule they aren't. It's not the natural order of things just because it's been that way all your life, or you've been a part of it all your life. At any moment, you have the ability to put your head up, think critically about things, act deliberately and independently, and change yourself and the system around you for the better.
- notduncansmith 7y ago> Think about how you got here. I would add that, when asking yourself questions, make sure it’s your intellect and not your ego answering. They’re part of the same machine, but sometimes they give very different responses to the same question. Be suspicious of any answer that’s easy to accept.
- tehjoker 7y agoThe reason you get angry at those people is because when you try to change the system they try to stop you. ;) Just my 2c
- kazagistar 7y agoI mean if a system is bad and anger helps to change it for the better, then it seems like that's fine. Anger, outrage, etc are all systems as well, that you shouldn't be "angry" at, right? The rejection of the utility of emotion is itself irrational.
- sevilo 7y ago
- Psyladine 7y ago>If you don't fix a system, few will. Most people are reactive to it and try to live with it as background noise. I'd add: If you want to know why a system remains broken, look to who profits by its brokenness.
- ameister14 7y agoIt's not always who profits - often it's who will it cost to fix it and generally what will the effects of fixing it be. Inertia is powerful, so perceived cost will result in people who are actively harmed by a broken system deciding they don't want it fixed.
- muzani 7y agoIf it profits them, it isn't entirely broken now, is it? ;) It's a matter of perception. We profit from the cattle industry. Most of the world doesn't - the climate, the cows themselves, ecology. But we wouldn't 'fix' it, nor would the cows. The cattle industry could be done so much better. But as it is, it works. Nobody will change it as long as it accomplishes everyone's goals.
- rohinibarla 7y agoVery well said. All these points resonate well with my experience.
- celticmusic 7y ago> Everything is a system. The economy, society, relationships, nature, traffic. This very much screams "when all you have is a hammer, everything looks like a nail" to me.
- thisisbrians 7y agoA hammer and a nail is also a system. In all seriousness, though — what alternative do you propose? When nothing seems to violate the laws of physics, we can make sense of things using our understanding of those laws.
- a-saleh 7y agoAlternative could be, sometimes things don't form a system, because 'system' could imply more order and predictability than there really is. Sometimes stuff just happen, and if you try to look for the system behind, you would see patterns that are not really there. I would say this is what leads to magical thinking, right? And I even like magical thinking, all those little nudges where I take a wrong turn, but then meet an interesting person and thing to myself "turns out I was supposed to be here", despite the my second thoughts being buzzkill about "that is not how world works!"
- TallGuyShort 7y agoIt's a bit like saying everything can be modeled. What do economists, biologists, and traffic engineers increasingly use to do their work? Models. An awful lot of things are actually nail-like for this particular hammer. Applying it to relationships and society feels like a slippery slope. People are still people. But there's definitely cases where the analogy is useful, and maybe even spot-on.
- mpol 7y agoI am almost through the book "Attached" by Amire Levine, on 'advise' from HN last week. It talks about the spectrum "fear/insecure - safe - avoiding" in relationships. It is very systematic in its approach and it opened my eyes to this way of looking. It is about the interactions between people on that spectrum inside a relationship. I look at my past 2 relationships now quite differently. I am mostly safe attached, and tend a bit to avoiding as well. My first relationship was with a fear/insecure someone, which ended with a lot of drama. My second relationship, I wanted to avoid drama, and ended up with someone who was avoiding. That pushed me more in the direction of fear/insecure, but since I am more on the side of avoiding than fear/insecure, there wasn't enough glue to make it last. Now I am with someone who is mostly safe, but has some fear/insecure tendencies. We do manage quite well I think :) I tend to look at it like this; people are individual and always unique. When you bring together 2 unique persons, you end up with a unique relationship. But there are still systems that you can discover there.
- jpg_converter 7y agoI agree w you mostly but you extended this form of systemic analysis to "making a date happy" which I think is a fundamental misunderstanding of relationships. To everyone reading this: please don't go around treating other people as systems to be optimized! If you wish to think about relationships as systems, you really need to understand that you are a partial component in social systems and therefore a flawed observer. It is impossible to objectively "diagnose" social systems without communication, empathy, and collaboration. It is far more than "saying the right words"
- solveit 7y ago> I agree w you mostly but you extended this form of systemic analysis to "making a date happy" which I think is a fundamental misunderstanding of relationships. To everyone reading this: please don't go around treating other people as systems to be optimized! I think people who say this kind of thing have a fundamental misunderstanding of how a certain type of people think. Of course people are systems to be optimized! What else could they possibly be? It's like people who object to love being a chemical reaction. What else could it be possibly be? And why in the world would love being a chemical reaction and people being systems to be optimized rule out treating people with respect, empathy, and kindness? What kind of straw Vulcans do you think we are?
- pkalinowski 7y agoPeople will straight reject reality if it doesn't fit their worldview. Go tell your wife love is just chemistry. Your words will haunt you for years :)
- nestorherre 7y agoIf that's what you think you should be able to say it. Otherwise one or both of the next things are true: -You married the wrong girl -You need to regain your manhood On the other hand, you do need to look for a good time and a good way to say it, and that just goes to being empathetic and caring about your partner.
- 7y ago
- trevyn 7y ago>Don't be angry at the people who are benefiting from a system, or at the system itself. But understand the impulse to be angry, and hear what it’s trying to tell you.
- kazagistar 7y ago> If you don't control a system, it will control you I'll go one further, and say the people controlling the system will control you, often to your detriment. You are also part of many systems, and your actions affect others in those systems. And finally, the complexity of all those systems is such that your understanding is always an incomplete model. It's fine t try to change the bad systems with an incomplete model, as long as you seek out better ones as well. Any given system will have many different models that are all relatively accurate, and you will get the best results not by picking the one that seems most accurate in some instance, but by using the one that is the most applicable to the situation. Models are not truth, they are lenses, and having more options means you can more easily find the one that provides the clearest picture. Any system of axioms complex enough is incomplete, and starting from axioms is unneccesarily complex. Find the model or foundation that is closest, and make it easier.
- marcosdumay 7y ago> I'll go one further, and say the people controlling the system will control you Some times, yes. But as a generalization, you are granting too much agency to people. Most systems simply have nobody controlling them (even powerful people), people are satisfied to just live within them and not do the labrorious task of gaining control.
- bg4 7y agoI could not agree more strongly. Also recommend this book for anyone who hasn't read it: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Systemantics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Systemantics
- downerending 7y agoSeconded. It's now titled "The Systems Bible". As humor, the book is a bit dry, but as (perhaps cynical) insight, it's gold. Read this and the entire collection of Dilbert strips, and you'll know 90% of how the world works. (Amazingly, it wasn't written by a computer guy or other engineer. IIRC, the author is/was a medical doctor or something like that.)
- mnemonicsloth 7y ago> Everything is a system... The problem is that this sometimes isn't good enough. A cell is certainly a system, but cells are far too complex to model with current techniques. The usual next step, breaking the cell down into a group of smaller systems, doesn't work either. No such decomposition exists. In cells, everything interacts promiscuously with everything else. And it should go without saying that cells are important. If we could debug cells like we debug software we'd all be immortal right now.
- ratacat 7y agoHave you ever gotten to read The Systems Bible by John Gall? Take a look, I think you'd really dig it
- alexashka 7y agoI'd rephrase it as 'most people are not systems thinkers'. A more cynical view is that they are systems thinkers on a tiny scale of only solving for personal gain. Because they are only solving for personal gain, they don't stop and think 'who put these thoughts of personal gain into my head, why do I want to own a house and think Mercedes is better than Toyota?'. Because most people don't ask these questions, advertising works extremely well and society is constantly in a state of broken-ness - a system can't function well by the virtue of self interested jerks acting in their self interest - sorry Adam Smith. The only way to make the system less broken that smart people have figured out is either making humans act like robots so as to limit their natural desires (personal gain) or literally create technology to do the jobs we want done. The way forward for humanity, is to eliminate humanity as we know it. Most people don't know it because it doesn't compute when all you're concerned with is personal gain.
- ploxolo 7y agoThis is key! I think one thing that is missed is that the systems that exist at a given point in time tend to be successful (at least in a Darwinian sense of the word) and stable. >The same way a river meanders towards the sea This is something to keep in mind when trying to change it. What if the aspect you are trying to change is key to its continued existence as a successful system? It probably will resist this as it probably gravitates towards its own stability. Of course, some people understand this and yet would like to see it be destroyed. To them the only question I would ask is: Will the system you build in its place be as stable/successful? Then again, many of them in their overconfidence will think so. But let's just say that I would bet a system that developed more or less organically and succeeded will be possibly more adaptable and resistant than one that is centrally imposed.
- muzani 7y agoThe river metaphor is appropriate here. Many people adjust systems to fit their needs, not necessarily the needs of others within it. Often you can just add a 'plugin' or 'extension' to it without modifying the system, to extract more out of it but not change it. Ironically, when too many attempt to simply patch it, that's what causes real changes.
- starpilot 7y agoHave you seen the Black Mirror episode with the Uber-esque tech company? The CEO is trying to placate a man in crisis over the phone. The CEO's support team starts feeding him via Slack de-escalation bullet points from their psychological experts. The man, bewildered and frustrated at the mechanical responses, stammers at him, "Why don't you talk like a normal fucking human being?!" The CEO then drops the "systematic" approach and talks to him like a person, from instinct, the heart, or whatever. Now you'll say that's a system too, but at some point the system is so riddled with exceptions that it becomes indistinguishable from chaos or intuition, and no longer is a useful system that can be described in any explicit way.
- einpoklum 7y agoThe river meandering towards the sea may flood my home if we don't maintain dams and levies. So, disagree; I'll get very angry at the system and those heading it if they do this, or let it happen.