16 ms·
Why we've never fallen in love with virtual reality
- FractalParadigm 7y ago> A major issue is that the price of headsets has remained very expensive. They mention it in passing in a later paragraph, but the cost of the headset is peanuts compared to the cost of a system that can provide a consistent, high-framerate, high-quality image. While cheaper options exist (Daydream/Gear VR, Oculus Quest, PSVR) they just don't have the quality or framerate to really send home the "future of gaming" VR has been sold as. I'd argue we're still minimum three years away from seeing mass adoption of VR in the household/consumer market. With raytracing still being in its infancy and software optimizations for many-core CPUs just beginning, it'll still be some time before mid-level <$800 systems are capable of providing a good VR experience.
- donkeyd 7y ago> they just don't have the quality or framerate to really send home the "future of gaming" VR has been sold as Have you actually played with the Quest? I've had many people use mine, also people who used Vive or Rift before and nobody was disappointed with the quality of it. If realism and frame rate were the most important part of gaming, then Pokemon Go and Candy Crush wouldn't be as profitable as they are. The majority of people want simple, arcade style entertainment, not hyper realistic sagas that take hours to finish.
- AndrewDucker 7y agoAgreed. I've seen numerous people put on a Quest, play 5 minutes of Beat Sabre, and come out _very_ excited.
- roenxi 7y ago> The majority of people want [X current product] not [Y under active development]. I've lost count of the number of times people have used that template and turned out to be humerously wrong. My favourite is probably when people tried to use it for Japanese phones > iPhones then the next generation iPhone wiped the competition in Japan. People want good entertainment more than they want their senses stimulated, but it seems very likely that good entertainment which stimulates the senses more effectively will have a massive market. We're dealing with something where the output can be strictly better than video in a fairly meaningful way. It'll turn out people want that when someone makes a compelling and high quality game/app. Sure, nobody is going to move over just because the visuals are good; but there is artistic space in VR that hasn't been touched before and some of it is going to be amazing. I suppose the short version is you are right but we've seen people say that before and it presaged massive changes.
- donkeyd 7y agoI'm not predicting though, I'm just observing. The most popular free games on mobile are consistently low quality arcade games. Also, I'm not saying it's the only thing people play, GTA and RDR are super high grossing franchises and they are high quality sagas. I'm mostly rebutting against the notion that lack of quality is holding back consumer grade VR.
- kipchak 7y agoI think performance in terms of keeping things consistent and smooth is really important, but visual realism or duplicating reality is overrated. Not only do you get into uncanny valley territory but more stylized art is often more compelling than imitation of reality. Beat Saber, Superhot, Sprint Vector, or I Expect You To Die for example have varying levels of unrealistic stabilization but are still immersive. Call of Duty on consoles has long been described as feeling better than other shooters, partially because of it's 60fps target since Call of Duty 2. At the time few people would care if "60fps!" was a feature printed on the box, it was more behind the curtain magic.
- megla_ 7y agoThose are mobile games and your phone isn't strapped 3 cm away from your eyes, covering your complete sight.
- gmueckl 7y agoGood VR isn't just about graphics quality. Mobile phone GPUs can deliver a high enough frame rate to deliver an immersive experience. The Oculus Quest is proof of that. The only downside is that the graphical content has to be stylized. But in games, stylized looks can be a boon instead of a hindrance. A typical good gaming experience is extremely stylized and over the top, anyway (especially in these "realistic" militaristic FPS games).
- PetitPrince 7y ago> "Mass adoption remains impeded by the hardware required to run it, in my opinion. Take videogames - you need a very powerful PC, a good amount of space, sensors set up around it, and of course the VR helmet itself. > "The cost runs to thousands and for most it is completely impractical not to mention too expensive. The Oculus Quest is about 50$ more than a PS4 Pro / Xbox X at launch. Still expensive but not in the thousands.
- donkeyd 7y agoI think it's the same issue that's happening with electric cars. People remember only the disadvantages of old technology and aren't aware of new tech being much better and more user friendly. With VR, people think it's cables, bulky PC's and complex setup, because that's their first and only experience with it. With electric cars, it's range anxiety, slow charging and degrading batteries. Meanwhile, the media tends to strengthen this bias with articles like this one and reporting every single incident with a Tesla. The only way to change people's minds is to let them experience the alternative, I see this both with my Quest and my Tesla. We recently had a game night at work, where multiple people brought VR headsets, but mine was the only tetherless one. I let people play Tea for God, which is a procedurally generated game that lets people walk a long distance in a restricted play area. Many of them had played VR games before, but nobody experienced anything like this and many people asked me more about it, even days later, because they weren't aware that the technology existed.
- CM30 7y agoI suspect the software has an effect too. There's certainly some neat stuff you can experience with VR headsets now, and apps have been made for it, but none of the things released so far have been a big enough hit to make people want go out and buy the systems to experiece them. They just don't have their Super Mario Bros/Tetris/Wii Sports/Minecraft/whatever equivalent yet, the thing that'll set the world on fire enough that people will be all like "I'll have to buy a VR headset now, to experience this product everyone else is talking about"
- Outpox 7y agoThe Valve Index (by Steam) has been sold out in December after they announced Half-Life Alyx which is included with every Index. This is won't be the time everyone goes VR yet but the market is expanding.
- CM30 7y agoYeah, the market certainly is. And Valve making a Half-Life game for their system was probably the best move they could make as far as increasing demand goes too.
- dTal 7y ago>They just don't have their Super Mario Bros/Tetris/Wii Sports/Minecraft/whatever equivalent yet, the thing that'll set the world on fire enough that people will be all like "I'll have to buy a VR headset now, to experience this product everyone else is talking about" That'd be Beat Saber, in my opinion.
- timwaagh 7y agovr is just expensive and requires fairly high end hardware still. There are also are all kinds of software issues with it. like when i was playing a well known racing game, very often the camera would be somewhere other than the driver's seat. And those are the kind of games that really are quite heavy on vr adoption and are the natural fit for this type of control. many games do not naturally lend themself to vr, and by those i mean the most popular genres, like fps, rpg, action-adventure. Basically every game that requires your feet to move about in a virtual world. I don't think it is suitable for strategy or management games either. So that leaves simulation, racing and some very old genres like on-rails-shooters. which is a sizeable market, but not the mainstream gaming market.
- jplayer01 7y ago> the most popular genres, like fps, rpg, action-adventure I'm not sure why you think so. I can't think of a genre where VR wouldn't work in some form, but especially anything first-person should work just fine. edit: Downvoting, classy. Yeah, let's ignore first-person games like Sairento, Budget Cuts, Boneworks, etc. which are fantastic because they're first person and how immersive it is to be inside a game as the player. It couldn't ever work. The proof is right there (not really).
- rusk 7y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html Please don't comment about the voting on comments. It never does any good, and it makes boring reading.
- jplayer01 7y agoBeing downvoted for an uncontroversial opinion is also boring and quite shitty, and becoming quite typical of this site. Wish the site would finally get rid of the fucking downvote system. If people disagree, they should actually comment and talk about it, instead of blindly downvoting whatever opinion they happen to disagree with.
- Kiro 7y agoI'm a firm believer that Oculus Quest is the new beginning of VR. I used to be a real skeptic but now I've turned. I think it's futile to analyse the market pre-Quest and I'm excited of what's to come.
- zmmmmm 7y agoI agree. I bought the Gear VR and actually only got the quest because Samsung stopped supporting Gear VR on new phones. I didn't expect to be much better but it solves every single high order problem with the low end headsets. It's a completely different thing.
- nottorp 7y agoIt sends everything you do to Facebook right? Occulus products are the one thing I'll never consider buying.
- draugadrotten 7y agoit evens transmits telemetry to facebook 24x7 when you are not using the headset itself. I have no idea what it is saying, but since I got an oculus, I can see traffic to graph.oculus.com more or less constantly.
- whywhywhywhy 7y agoSo do WhatsApp and Instagram and it hasn't hurt them. Not that I agree with it, but the general public doesn't care.
- baby 7y agoSame here, the Quest is a game changer. It seems like most comments here have tried some limited or light VR gears, when everybody I demo the Quest to is amazed at the thing.
- lasagnaphil 7y agoWhat I think virtual reality would be immediately useful right now: for anyone working on 3D modeling/animating/CAD. It is very finicky to view and manipulate 3d data on a flat 2d monitor, VR headsets and manipulation devices should be a godsend to those professions. (Also, they have a lot more money to throw than ordinary consumers, they would be willing to pay thousands on a superior workflow.) If VR software developers would focus on those programs first, I would see VR being a must-buy for certain niche groups of people (which would be a solid foundation for the VR industry.) Too bad that many of the VR developers are tunnel-visioned and only care about flashy games/entertainment, where the real gold might be somewhere else.
- fyfy18 7y agoI will admit that I am not a professional, but in my spare time I have designed some parts in CAD software (Fusion 360) which I've then 3D printed. My experience was once I understood the key bindings to manipulate the view, it was very easy to spacially understand what was going on, even with parts that had layers hidden below other layers (you just turn off the layers you don't care about). I'm not really sure how a VR headset would have helped in my case, but as I said, maybe this is just because the work I was doing was simple.
- samatman 7y agoBack in the ol' cyberpunk 90s, the vision of VR always included gloves for fine-grained manipulation of the virtual space. I still believe that the combination of VR goggles and gloves (can't forget the wrist keyboard!) with the right software would lead to a quantum leap in 3D modeling. Guess we'll see what happens.
- gmueckl 7y agoI currently hack together a mini mesh modelling tool in VR for very specific reasons. I find that creating a UI for something moderately complex isn't all that easy. The common idiom is to treat your controllers as laser pointers, but precision is limited. So you need big UI elements to have easy to hit targets. With the number of simultaneous UI elements thus limited, you need to create hierarchies and menus fast, making interaction cumbersome. Also, using VR controllers in thin air for a prolonged time becomes a workout. The human body isn't quite made for keeping arms in these poses for extended periods of time. However, being able to view and manipulate a virtual object directly in 3d space is pretty darn sweet. Just bending your head or moving your hand beats manipulating virtual canera perspectives and gizmos for precision 3d interaction on a screen. I nearly forgot: the Unreal Engine editor has a VR mode that brings in the nornal 2D GUI as floating windows. I didn't like that very much, but people seem to be OK with it. I don't know any other DCC software that has VR support.
- aurbano 7y agoI used to be a casual PC gamer, with a fairly good spec build. Then one day I played some VR games at a friend’s house on PSVR, which blew my mind - not only how much fun I had, but how much fun our non gamer friends had! After that my wife and me got a second hand Vive for 350, and it’s been amazing. I never play regular games any more, and even she (who never played any games) now enjoys it a lot and plays with me from time to time. All this is to say that I do think VR is here to stay, it just blows regular gaming out of the water... but it definitely is at its infancy - games look and feel the way PC games did 10 years ago..
- mrfusion 7y agoThe vive is so non casual though. I always felt like it was a big production to clear the space, launch steamvr, often wait for updates. Plus I’m moving around when I’d prefer to be relaxed on the couch. On the other hand VR is amazing. I’ve since switched to the quest which helps with most of those issues I mentioned.
- jpindar 7y ago>I’m moving around when I’d prefer to be relaxed on the couch. For some people, this is a good thing.
- majewsky 7y agoThe most accurate description that I've heard is that we're at the point where GUIs were in the 80s. The tech was just good enough for it and there were already several products on the market, but designers were still exploring the space and had not agreed on common metaphors yet. Which is exciting to witness, but shows that we're still squarely in the "early-adopter" phase of the curve. (As for myself, I tried a friend's Oculus Quest extensively two weeks ago. Now I'm sitting at home, drawing up plans in Inkscape for how to rearrange my furniture to accommodate a room-scale VR area.)
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- 7y ago
- newzombie 7y agoThe very main reason VR isn't taking off is because it has no killer app, that is, an app that other platforms can't have, and that people love. End-of-story. What's to understand here is that it's not said that this killer app "exists". If VR is only a cooler screen, then it will sell like cooler screens. Now maybe it's a killer screen, that is a screen that everybody wants. I guess there is a competitive advantage of thinking like that, but right now, vendors think they are making a software/hardware platform when they have no killer app.
- golergka 7y agoLike the next Half-life? https://www.half-life.com/en/alyx https://www.half-life.com/en/alyx
- cyphax 7y agoI'm gonna argue that VR does have a killer-app: Beat Saber. It was a top seller on Steam in 2019 and it's only just been overtaken by Asgarth's Wrath in terms of popularity, after about a year and a half. It has also sold more than a million copies and is multi platform. I've seen kids play it, adults, even seniors: everybody can do this. If you wouldn't consider that a killer app, what would be in your eyes? :)
- xallace 7y agothe killer VR-app for me was racing simulation but it is a very niche market. and way too expensive for most people VR-Goggles, high-end PC, good steering wheel (G27 at minimum) racing seat, ... and ideally dedicated room for the setup it was great fun (did it for 2 years) but got rid of it because it consumed too many hours
- zmmmmm 7y agoI don't know if it will happen, but a killer app that ought to exist is exercise. I've never found anything that gamified exercise the way the Occulus Quest does. The kind of full body workout I get from ducking, weaving, dodging and swinging at fast moving opponents, all at 6:30am in the morning without leaving my home, is simply amazing.
- unnouinceput 7y agoFor me personally VR it feels still weird, too cartoonish, not an immersive experience as expected. What I'd argue people would want is AR instead. That one is way more fun when done right
- altacc 7y agoI think this depends upon the system you use and what you're viewing. I was underwhelmed by a couple of VR headsets (Samsung Gear plus something I forget) but changed my mind after using a Rift, as that was so much better. The media/game matters too. Anything trying to look real does indeed still look cartoonish, but it's a different story for games where looking like the real world isn't the goal. Then you can enjoy the immersion without comparing to reality.
- krapp 7y agoOne big problem is what people expect, and what VR advocates describe, is basically the Holodeck from Star Trek. The immersivity of the experience is basically like being there. That's what people want, to jack in to the Matrix or some kind of old-school cyberpunk experience. Except your brain knows it's looking at a display and not an actual 3D space, and the cognitive dissonance between what it sees and proprioception are always going to limit how immersive VR can be. And that's not even getting into the other senses that VR can't simulate. Sight and sound are actually less important in terms of immersion than taste, touch and smell.
- armitron 7y agoSensationalist article that is completely out of touch with reality on both social and technical levels. Oculus quest is a game changer - obvious to anyone that puts it on - and the fact that it’s not even mentioned says a lot. I doubt she has even tried it. On a social level, it is comical how myopic her vision for VR is and how far off the mark the focus on VR arcades lies. The big selling point of VR in the near and not so near future is not expensive social experiences on somebody else’s commercial infrastructure but escapism and social experiences including work in the comfort of your own home. Global warming, rising populations, terrorist attacks, widespread decoherence, pollution and decay in our urban centers are all powerful accelerators and extremely synergistic for the future of VR.
- ergl 7y agoAre those use cases supposed to make VR sound good?
- rkho 7y agoTruly immersive VR experiences are great. The park I went to in Tokyo recently had some fun licensed ones: + A Shin Godzilla themed helicopter raid which required a customized "cockpit" to ride in with rumble capabilities, + A Dragon Quest free-roaming VR adventure which required a LOT of space to enable + A Mario Kart race which, again, required a customized "kart" to ride in which simulated the physics of every sharp turn I took. The first and third attractions were about five minutes long each. I don't doubt that there was a lot of engineering effort required to even get to that much content nor the fact that I would likely grow very tired of having to play an extended version of each for, say, an hour or two. I think for at least the time being, this is how VR is going to be adopted: As a theme park experience where short novelty experiences people want to have is made available with the space and props already provided to enjoy it.
- Nursie 7y agoWhile the graphics and sensor capabilities have undoubtedly come a very long way ... I'm pretty sure I played a VR racing game in a similar sort of setup in the 80s! There were only ever a handful of games, and they were only found in a very few places, but foir my birthday one year when I was a kid I was taken to the Trocadero centre in London where they had a few of these machines. They weren't massively responsive but they were good fun and for the time they were amazing. But given just how long VR tech has been around, I do wonder if it will ever be mainstream in any way.
- aedron 7y agoYes, this seems obvious to me. Stuff like The Void[1], where a complete arena is built to supplement the visuals, with physical features that match the VR ones (like physical buttons on walls that match the VR projected ones, moving platforms), smells, wind, sounds, etc. The future of this is going to be incredibly cool, I think. Just subtle stuff like blowing cold air on your face when you're standing on top of a VR mountain, will do wonders for the immersion. [1] https://www.thevoid.com/ https://www.thevoid.com/
- kstenerud 7y agoAnother issue is motion sickness. For a significant portion of us this is a huge problem.
- sundvor 7y agoI tried the Dirt Rally game with my Lenovo VR kit. Super, super fun ... until my stomach revolted. As opposed to Elite Dangerous where I could go on for hours, I merely lasted 10 minutes before I had to stop.
- aepiepaey 7y agoMost people can reportedly get used to the discrepancy between the vision and balance senses and be rid of the motion sickness (with some training: keep playing until you start feeling uncomfortable, wait until the next day, go again). Ginger can also help delay onset. It can also be noted that motion sickness really only is a problem where the game character moves while you stand still physically (e.g. using a joystick to move around). Other forms of locomotion (like teleportation) are usually fine.
- kstenerud 7y agoThese are, unfortunately, falsehoods that keep getting perpetuated despite efforts to the contrary. While you can become slightly more tolerant with repeated exposure (as you can with anything noxious), the the discomfort never goes away. And it's not just game character motion. Any camera movement can trigger it, at different levels for different people. If you don't get triggered, count yourself lucky, and don't tell the rest of us to "just practice" or attempt to explain away that it's only X and not ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWYZ. Listen to what we're actually SAYING. I still remember Valve responding to complaints of motion sickness in Half Life 2 with the lame excuse "It's because our technology is so amazingly lifelike." I wanted to punch the guy in the face and ask him if that was lifelike enough for him.
- dreen 7y agoI think there isn't any recent scientific research on how many people are affected and how many of those see improvement after they get their 'vr legs'. I would like to see some rather than anecdotal evidence.
- bartread 7y agoI have the PSVR and in many ways it's great. For example, it's tough to beat Wipeout VR as a future racing experience. The fact that you can look around/through the corners the way you do in the real world when you're driving a vehicle really changes the way the game plays and makes it much more immersive. OTOH some games do seem to cause quite severe motion sickness (I forget the name of the one I'm particularly thinking of because I haven't played it in ages, for obvious reasons). The other problem is that ergonomically it's an absolute arse-ache. I have the first gen PSVR which is just an festooning nightmare of cables. The lenses are also way too prone to fogging. I believe the second gen headsets are better but there are still cable management issues. It's also, frankly, not that comfortable to wear. It's not painful or anything like that, but I'm no fan of wearing hats because they tend to make me feel too hot, so you can imagine what having a bulky conglomeration of plastic and electronics strapped to my face for long periods feels like. Really these things need to be wireless and rechargeable but then, of course, you open the system up to more latency issues. One area I haven't had so many issues, which is touched on in the article, is the drop in quality, and in particular graphical fidelity. Wipeout VR, I think, runs at 4K on a PS4 Pro but only 1080P with PSVR. I haven't found this to be something that bothers me at all, or at least not with this game. On the other hand I have found the drop in quality with Driveclub VR to be noticeable to the point where it does detract from the experience. It really does very much depend on the game though. Still, overall impressions of the experiences on offer are fairly positive.
- meesterdude 7y ago> but then, of course, you open the system up to more latency issues. Nope. Maybe "of course", if they just lazily hack something together. But the tech is there, today, for low latency.
- cybwraith 7y agoThe PSVR is basically the worst "high end" VR headset out there, and is on the underpowered PS4 hardware, with poor controller tracking and lots of motion blur and downsampling to make the games even run. You really ought to try an Oculus Quest or Rift S/Vive Pro. PSVR has 1080 vertical pixels, Quest has 1600 vertical pixels, much better lenses, and much better controllers. Not to mention the games run much more smoothly
- adam0c 7y agoClearly she's never played Firewall: Zero Hour on PS4 but more importantly this is a BBC news article so lets all face it, its a load od bull
- sundvor 7y agoElite Dangerous. There, now that's been said. Brilliant experience.
- tomclive 7y agoI had a GearVR and it was pretty fun for a while but the battery life, overheating and lack of great apps made me lose interest. I then got a mixed reality headset and Beat Saber was a game-changer for me. The controls are so simple and are perfectly suited to VR. No motion sickness etc. It's a great game. I've picked up loads of the best selling VR games on Steam and although some have been fun, none quite match up to Beat Saber. Google Earth with room-scale VR is stunning. Being able to walk around your hometown as if you were a couple of hundred feet tall is an incredible experience. I'm looking forward to MS Flight Simulator 2020 and it looks like the devs are making VR a priority. This could be a winner for me.
- mlang23 7y agoI am concered about the upcoming accessibility disaster. Granted, most games are likely not really essential for say, blind people, to play. But the future will bring UIs to VR. And I doubt that companies will think about accessibility from the start. It is already hard to maintain screen readers for typical GUIs. But it will be almost impossible to have meaningful assistive technologies in VR as long as they are designed as add-ons.
- SirHound 7y agoIt’s a simple matter of price performance ratio. Price meaning comfort and money. At some point that ratio will tip.
- cal97g 7y agoIt's not that cool, it's too expensive, it makes you dizzy, the games aren't good, you smash your tv / yourself.
- skizm 7y agoVR won’t ever be more than niche because there is no way to fake tactile feedback or motion. Games need to design around this. Beat Sanger is the best selling VR game because your character doesn’t move and there is nothing to touch. God games, like black and white or the sims, and 4x games might work well too. Also if graphics get better people can set up virtual desk spaces and get rid of screens. Ultimately though the reason most games don’t work is the tactile feedback and motion issues, which I can’t imagine ways of solving at the moment.
- falcor84 7y ago>there is no way to fake tactile feedback or motion Why not? There are quite a few companies working on these with some success. Virtuix for example (disclosure: I'm an investor) are seeing some steady commercial success in regards to addressing motion[0]. And in terms of feedback, there's a lot of interesting work done Fl around gloves in particular, including by Apple [1]. [0] https://www.virtuix.com/ https://www.virtuix.com/ [1] https://www.patentlyapple.com/patently-apple/2020/01/apple-adds-an-optical-sensor-to-its-optical-imaging-system-and-more-to-its-haptic-feedback-vr-gaming-gloves.html https://www.patentlyapple.com/patently-apple/2020/01/apple-a...
- Fabricio20 7y agoOn this note I also feel inclined to mention Teslasuit [0]. I recently learned about this company and their product, they are developing (I think some of it is even already available) a full-body tracking suit with feedback zones. Pairing this with a VR headset and immersion would go way up compared to most (if not all) things we have nowadays. [0] https://teslasuit.io/ https://teslasuit.io/
- skizm 7y agoI meant more like swinging a sword will never meet another sword. Punching someone in the face will never hurt your hand, etc. and then when you swing through air as your in-game hand stops, it feels kinda lame.
- 7y ago
- mrfusion 7y agoSomething about vr systems makes it not feel real to me. I’m thinking it’s that I can’t change the focus of my eyes. Everything is in the same focus. I forget what that’s called but it makes it feel fake to me.
- mulletbum 7y agoIt also could be that you are looking through odd glasses that have black cones around them instead of fully encompassed video space.
- throwawayhhakdl 7y agoInfinite depth of field. Magic Leap said they had solved this for their device (maybe they did, not that it makes up for the rest). Probably not solveable unless we do eye tracking and adapt the screen content to that or change the model from being small screens in front of your eyes altogether. I agree though. I cannot relate at all to people who say VR is immersive.
- cybwraith 7y agoVarifocal VR headsets are in the R&D stage. A year or two ago Oculus showed off a headset called Half-dome that had varifocal displays. It'll get there.
- Digit-Al 7y agoWe need these[0], but better. [0] https://www.slashgear.com/panasonic-vr-glasses-are-a-steampunk-dream-for-5g-09606466/ https://www.slashgear.com/panasonic-vr-glasses-are-a-steampu...
- bykhun 7y agoReally, what a bad time to publish such article. Oculus Quest hit records with its' sales for Christmas, and out of stock for two months ahead.
- degenerate 7y agoAlso, Valve will release Half-Life: Alyx [1] in March 2020. It's the first game in the much-loved HL series released since Portal 2 in 2011. I don't own a VR headset and I don't intend to any time soon - it's too expensive and nothing looks enjoyable enough to justify the cost. But once enough big-name games like Alyx get released, gamers previously on the fence (like me) will start to purchase VR headsets, and VR will eventually become the new gaming platform that publishers wants to release on. [1] https://store.steampowered.com/app/546560/HalfLife_Alyx/ https://store.steampowered.com/app/546560/HalfLife_Alyx/
- ekianjo 7y ago> and VR will eventually become the new gaming platform that publishers wants to release on. I predict the opposite. It will sell a few headsets maybe (a peak), but that alone will not change the course of the technology at all in 2020. Plus, Half Life's popularity in 2020 has nothing to do with its popularity 20 years ago.
- baby 7y agoThe Oculus quest is 400$, that's a pretty fair price imo (and it is amazing).
- mdorazio 7y agoReally surprised that neither the article nor the comments here mention the #1 barrier to entry. Your average person doesn’t want to strap a big, heavy, sweaty contraption on their face that blocks their vision entirely. Analysts and enthusiasts seem to miss this point constantly.
- hobs 7y agoGot my neither analyst or enthusiast sister the quest this christmas, she and the kids were constantly playing beat saber and pistol whip without stopping. The quest 100% is less bulky and sweaty, and it includes cameras if people are in your field of control or need to do setup. It really is much better than the last generation in terms of UX and I have the vive and the entire setup.
- chrischen 7y agoPeople will do things that they aren't used to if the benefits outweigh the costs. And of the list of things preventing people from doing VR right now, I doubt strapping the headset on is anywhere near the top (things like cost, PC, space, etc are).
- untog 7y ago> I doubt strapping the headset on is anywhere near the top For me personally, a side effect of that is the reason I'm not excited about VR: it's anti-social. I'm shutting myself off from anyone else in my apartment in a way a normal video game doesn't do. It makes me way, way less excited about the potential of VR.
- baby 7y agoInterestingly, I've had the most impressive social experience in VR. I got the Oculus Go when it came out and bought Catan (the board game, but in VR). I then launched a game online, and ended up playing for an hour with a finish kid and a canadian dude. We talked like we were all together, and at the end I couldn't just leave without saying goodbye (usually I just quit a game, but here I felt some social pressure to do the right thing). We even shook hand.
- Gunax 7y agoI am long on VR. It really does look good. I think everyone's experience has been ruined by crappy. The 90s had a VR far but they sucked. Of you're putting a phone across your face, it sucks. The market was spoiled by crappy imitators and gimicks. Anytime someone tries a real VR headset for the first time, they are usually amazed. I have personally sold 3 headsets just by having friends of mine try mine for a few minutes.
- scottlocklin 7y ago"Why we've never fallen in love with 3-d glasses" -fixed the title. Science fiction predictions of the future are almost universally comically bad. People should know this by now; we completely lack positronic brains, warp drives, moon bases and tricorders. VR is a science fiction prediction of the future, just like positronic brains. The fact that people won't pay lots of money for a cheesy 3-d glasses experience as a proxy for science fiction VR shouldn't surprise anyone.
- augusto-moura 7y agoWell, at least a moon base is on the way. Just not like how we thinked of. More like a ISS on moon ground than a grand hotel
- gwd 7y agoBut we do have personal communicators, which are way better than sci fi ever depicted.
- scottlocklin 7y agoI never saw captain Kirk recharging his, nor fiddling with it when he was bored. Space1999 commlocks were also way better than an ipotato. http://catacombs.space1999.net/main/cguide/umcomlock.html http://catacombs.space1999.net/main/cguide/umcomlock.html
- oblio 7y ago> I never saw captain Kirk recharging his Well, if the current trend of battery improvements holds, and considering the unfathomable amounts of money and time thrown at the problem, we're hopefully about 10 years away from devices that can last 1 week on a single charge. Not quite Captain Kirk material, but we have about 240 years to get there. > nor fiddling with it when he was bored Do you consider this a minus? Most people consider it a huge plus :-)
- ggreer 7y ago
- zaphod420 7y agoI really enjoy VR games. The problem I have is motion sickness. I can only play for very short periods of time, and I feel sick after playing. I've had the Rift for about a year, and despite people telling me I would get used to it, I still get motion sickness. Because I've had the experience so many times, now just thinking about playing the game will trigger the sensation of nausea, which prevents me from even wanting to play.
- arminiusreturns 7y agoI hope to build a system primarily for a Valve Index this year. I think VR is here to stay, and it reminds of the early days of PC's and pc gaming, when a PC could be 4k (I mean they still can be, but you get what I am saying), and games required the top level hardware and didn't always try to run on yesterdays potato, an artificial limitation put on way to many things today.
- utf985 7y ago"We've never fallen in love"? Really? This is he first time for me where an emergent new technology in the gaming world feels like a proper thing with actual potential, and not a just a novelty gimmick like motion controls, 3D and previous attempts at "VR" were. I had the chance to try the new Oculus Rift S and the HTC Vive over the holidays with some Beat Saber and Superhot and it was a really amazing experience. I have honestly never felt such awe for a game since my childhood days where I'd witness a brand new graphics engine like Source for the first time. There is definitely a bright future for VR as the technology will only get better, cheaper and more accessible with time.
- ekianjo 7y ago> "We've never fallen in love"? Really? Yes, really, You are the exception. By now there is quite a few people who have tried VR in some place or another and the market has clearly shown sales are not skyrocketing at all. It's a very slow growth, we are talking about a few millions headsets per year, which is just pocket money market wise compared to smartphones or even PCs at large. Also, most of the software is utter crap (with a few exceptions like Beat Saber, Tetris Effect) and not convincing enough for anyone who cares about their spending.
- marliechiller 7y agothere is no space for gaming to evolve at the moment without VR. The only thing that next generation consoles are bringing to the table is more advanced graphics. VR offers a truly innovative space for gaming to move into and whilst its not there yet in terms of hardware and software, I can see it being 'the future' as it were.
- 3fe9a03ccd14ca5 7y agoThat same argument could have been made for 3D tech in TVs a few years ago, and we all know how well that technology took off. It seems most people seem to want an incrementally “better” experience, not a fundamentally different one.
- 7y ago
- gwbas1c 7y agoI find that playing a game in VR is like listing to music in 5.1: It requires a lot of physical space and setup, which then limits the audience to a dedicated niche. The limitation, in this case, is being affluent enough to have a large empty indoor space to dedicate to VR so you don't bump into things as you walk around; and the desire to calibrate the thing correctly. It's like setting up a really good sound system to listen to music in 5.1; really fun if you like that kind of thing, but "meh" to most people who are happy with a smart speaker. In my case, when I played a friend's VR setup, he had to have his entire living room completely empty and the system calibrated correctly. Even though his living room was rather large for a Boston-area apartment, it just wasn't large enough, and I kept bumping into a specific wall where his system was miscalibrated. Such a system will never work in a typical tiny Tokyo, NYC, or Hong Kong apartment; but I could see it selling being a good niche in suburban areas where it's common to have large basements.
- lordCarbonFiber 7y agoAs someone that lives in a "small nyc apartment" I'd say the blanket statement around vr and small spaces doesn't hold. There's potential for extremely immersive experiences even in the Vive's smallest play area. Right now, as I see it, the bigger barriers to VR adpoption are cost of equipment and social norms. Right now VR tends to be an isolating experience, and there aren't a lot of experiences that allow for VR and non VR people to interact, let alone have multiple participants in the same space.
- codingmess 7y agoThat'S not an issue with the Occulus Quest anymore. You need a little space, but setup is very easy and requires no extra arrangements.
- specialp 7y agoFor me personally I have tried it, and it gives me a headache and makes me feel bad. Now this could be like anything else that causes motion sickness where one would get accustomed to it, but I am not prepared to spend a lot of money on a headset not knowing if it ever would not give me a headache. Also the experience isn't really mind-blowing either. We are still in a physical space where I'll walk into a wall. Virtual reality is far from reality and constrained by reality at the same time. I'd rather game with a large HD screen and use input devices so I still have my senses if I have to respond to the real world.
- bitwize 7y agoRez Infinite was, alone, enough to sell me on having a VR headset. But Rez Infinite and maybe Tetris Effect were the only applications so far to really hold my interest in VR also.
- jdlyga 7y agoI own an Oculus Quest, and it's not bad. But it does take up too much room to play, it's isolating, there's not enough content yet besides glorified tech demos, and both the hardware and the games are too expensive.
- rafaelvasco 7y agoThe price. That's the only reason for me. Other than that it's wonderful; Once the prices reach affordable for the masses level, it will surely blow up, given the right apps come with it. People yearn to fantasize, break away from reality, new sensorial experiences etc. If VR offers that at good prices it'll be an explosion. That's my view on it.
- y-c-o-m-b 7y ago100% this for me. Every 6 months or so I go and price out a VR capable desktop machine along with a headset. It's hard not to spend close to $2000 and still have confidence the rig will hold up in 2-3 years. I've seen builds out there around the $1000 price point with people marketing it as "VR-ready", but honestly I'm skeptical of what exactly that means and whether or not it's durable towards upcoming content. The price to (good) content ratio is awful as well. EDIT: wording
- lostmsu 7y agoNot sure what the two of you are talking about. You should be able to comfortably play with a <$1000 machine, including a headset (but not monitor).
- mhh__ 7y agoVR is fine (with lots of upscaling) on my 1070 which isn't cheap but equally is years old. Keep in mind you'll probably be playing beat saber for the most part so graphics don't mean fuck all (some people on Reddit claim to play on integrated graphics) for the game to be as addictive as crack cocaine.
- mrguyorama 7y ago$2000 is enough for me to get a brand new Index, an RX 5700xt, and a ryzen 3600. For reference, my previous VR capable machine was an i5 4440 and an RX 580 8gb with an original Vive. You are misrepresenting what is required to play VR. All you need is a mid range processor newer than 6 years, and a $180 RX 580 or nividia comparable GPU. Vives are selling used for around $300 as people upgrade
- 7y ago
- grawprog 7y agoAbout the only VR game that's ever seemed appealing to me is that table top simulator game. https://store.steampowered.com/app/286160/Tabletop_Simulator/ https://store.steampowered.com/app/286160/Tabletop_Simulator... Personally, I'd love to get a group of people together and play a DND campaign or something with it, but other than that, I don't have any interest in VR games. If anything, these days, I prefer quicker, less immersive games I can pick up and play and put down again. VR's the opposite of that in just about every way.
- clSTophEjUdRanu 7y agoI liked Virtual Virtual Reality https://youtu.be/Sb1efNYhkGI https://youtu.be/Sb1efNYhkGI
- wayoutthere 7y agoPersonally, I find Elite: Dangerous to be the best, most immersive VR game I've played. It's a 6DOF space sim set in a 1:1 scale version of the Milky Way that puts you in the pilot's seat, with a few dozen ships to choose from. The insides of the cockpit (or bridge on the larger ships) are fully modeled. Paired with a decent HOTAS or dual-stick setup, it's about as close as you're going to get to flying a futuristic spaceship. The game offers combat, trading, exploration, mining, rescue missions, surface exploration and you can have friends join you on your ship as either a gunner or ship-launched fighter pilot. Development has stalled somewhat over the last 6 months -- the developer is actively releasing updates, but mostly catching up on bugfixes in anticipation of a new expansion later this year. But if you're new to the game, there are easily 100+ hours of gameplay available as long as you're ok that it's not a narrative-driven game. The community is very active, with player factions driving many of the activities in the game from public Discord servers, so the lack of content updates isn't necessarily as bad as it would be in other games. Only like 0.5% of the systems in the galaxy have been explored, so plenty left to discover!
- grawprog 7y agoI have to admit, a vr space sim could be pretty awesome. I've played a lot of oolite and I used to play another space Sim pretty heavily the name which escapes me right now. >surface exploration and you can have friends join you on your ship as either a gunner or ship-launched fighter pilot. This seems like it would be pretty fun. I find space Sims get boring though, they tend to get really repetitive. How does elite dangerous do with mission and system variety? I find in the end, with most games like that, different systems tend to boil down to different numbers on the trade screen, maybe a random event or two and a lot of flying around empty space to get to a planet or stations, load up on some trade goods or get a mission, head to the next system, repeat. Maybe mine an asteroid or two for minerals in between. These things would definitely be prettier and more immersive in VR, but are they any more fun?
- vrporntaway42 7y agoSince I haven't seen any other comments on it, I'll be that guy. So many people are talking about games and graphics quality, etc. But completely ignoring: virtual reality porn. Porn is definitely not a niche interest. There is definitely a lot of crap, but some of the higher quality recordings are quite compelling.
- Kaiyou 7y agoIf I could pay $200 to get the full experience, I'd already have paid. I can't, so I haven't. Unless they can get the price for the whole package including a game to below $500, it won't reach the masses and unless they get below $200 they won't reach me, because I'm a cheapskate that is satisfied with playing 30 year old games.
- tentboy 7y agoSim racing, or for those unaware of it: basically racing games with realistic physics and usually a competitive online racing field, is incredible in VR. The sense of speed and immersion with a good wheel and pedal setup in VR is unmatched by a monitor based setup. I tried it at a VR arcade and kept adding time to my session to keep playing. I have a fairly nice and expensive sim racing setup at home right now, but my PC cant run any of the current sims in VR well enough for me to justify getting a headset. Between PC upgrades and headset im looking at $500+ in upgrades that I just haven't gotten around to doing, but you can bet its on my list
- capableweb 7y agoSame for flight simulations (I'm using X-Plane and DCS World [DCS World has much better VR, better overall X-Plane is more fun]) with VR headset. With VR headset, it crushes any other simulators I've used, as the immersion increases and it becomes much more natural.
- cybwraith 7y agoAnd we're "weeks/days" from the much-anticipated Xplane Vulkan update!
- mhh__ 7y agoVR simracing can be hit and miss i.e. rf2 looks amazing but is rough around the edges (Hungaroring in the wet in a GT3 car is amazing in VR) but assetto Corsa looks awful. Don't bother with anything worse than an Index these days, the Vive is amazing in beat Sabre but awful if you want to read the dials.
- WhompingWindows 7y agoI've gotten nauseous every time I put on a VR headset...no wonder I haven't fallen in love with it.
- flyGuyOnTheSly 7y agoI put a PS4 VR set on my head at my relatives over the holidays and I could not have been more disappointed. They had just been gifted it for Christmas and were trying out all of the demos. I put it on and while I could rotate my head in any direction like I was living inside some google maps experiment almost... The picture was extremely blurry and the entire experience gave me a headache... after probably only 10 minutes of use. I am not surprised that experience hasn't "taken off" yet. It was terrible. I can't believe somebody paid good money for that. As soon as I put it on all I could think was "damnit, we're still 20 years out from this actually working like we expect it to".
- berdon 7y agoDid you try fixing the focus?
- flyGuyOnTheSly 7y agoI was pulling the goggles away from and closer to my face if that's what you mean, I believe that was the only focus mechanism.
- berdon 7y agohttps://support.playstation.com/s/article/PS-VR-Blurry-Picture-Issues?language=en_US https://support.playstation.com/s/article/PS-VR-Blurry-Pictu...
- cybwraith 7y agoThe PSVR is the lowest-resolution "high end" VR headset out there, and is on the underpowered PS4 hardware, with poor controller tracking and lots of motion blur and downsampling to make the games even run. You really ought to try an Oculus Quest or Rift S/Vive Pro. PSVR has 1080 vertical pixels, Quest has 1600 vertical pixels, much better lenses, and much better controllers. Not to mention the games run much more smoothly
- flyGuyOnTheSly 7y ago
- jjtheblunt 7y agoI saw the title, and thought "because real reality is more engaging".
- berdon 7y agoI have the Quest and an empty basement set up for it. The games are all still too indie feeling but with the focus dialed in the experience is truly remarkable. Oculus is pushing in the right places too - standalone device with PC support, hands free capability (for older/elderly), and hopefully guardian-less mode (outside play). I've had a number of friends and family members of different ages try it. The older ones struggled with the controls but once they got into Beat Saber they enjoyed it. With better content and games I see it finally taking off. I dream of the day we have parking lots/warehouses where people play MMOs on VR and stay fit.
- kevinmgranger 7y agoThese comments (and inevitably, anywhere else there's discussions of VR) always find themselves with a 50/50 split on: "Most people I know (love it / hate it / don't get motion sick / get motion sick), those who (hate it / love it / get motion sick / don't get motion sick) are the minority." Does anyone have real data on this, or just anecdata?
- overcast 7y agoVR is only going to become an obsession when we're jacked into it like the Matrix or The Beam. Otherwise it's just you wearing a screen on your face.
- taloft 7y agoSaying it’s just a screen on your face is an oversimplification. While that may be a somewhat accurate physical description, it doesn’t capture the actual experience, anymore than saying a smart phone is just a phone in your pocket. I’ve had vr sets since the oculus dk2, and admit that I probably haven’t used it in over a year, because it’s a bit cumbersome, locks you into a single experience, removes you from your environment, and the relatively lower quality of applications that are available. There are some really great immersive applications though such as subnautica, google earth, and elite dangerous.
- iguanayou 7y agoAs a pilot, I use VR with the XPlane flight simulator and it seriously feels like I'm in a real Cessna. True, the flight controls are a little off (for example, stalls and landings don't feel like a real plane), but other than that, everything is absolutely spot on. It's a great way to scratch my aviation itch and is also great for practicing procedures, especially when paired with a live air traffic control network like PilotEdge. My brain seriously forgets that it's a simulation when I'm in it. This could be a way to revolutionize flight training, and make it more accessible. The entire cost of my PC build including VR gear and software is a fraction of what real-life flight training costs.
- freediver 7y agocan you describe your setup in more detail?
- iguanayou 7y agoSure, it's a scratch-built PC (i7 / 2070 Super) with an HP Reverb, which is a lightweight VR headset. I use a physical yoke (Honeycomb), rudder pedals (Thrustmaster), and throttle quandrant (Saitek), but everything else in the cockpit can be manipulated with the VR controllers that come with the headset. You just interact with the cockpit as you normally would, pressing buttons, pulling levers, and twisting knobs. In the virtual cockpit, there is a tablet app that displays all of your maps/charts/checklists/reference materials. Works pretty slick.
- mrguyorama 7y agoHow is the resolution/screen door effect of that headset? I use an original Vive with VTOL VR and other games and while they are still very fun and serviceable, I just built a new PC so I could purchase an Index when they go back on sale. I'm hoping the bump in resolution is as significant as I've heard
- iguanayou 7y agoThe resolution is good enough to read all of the gauges easily. It won't look as nice as a good monitor, but the immersion more than makes up for it. I do notice a screen door with the Reverb. Not bad, but it's there.
- d--b 7y agoFIELD OF VISION. Why can’t VR people understand that humans are used to ultra wide vision angle? Peeping into a VR headset removes all peripheral vision, meaning you have to rotate your head all over to see things. It’s like playing quake with your neck. Make a 180 angle headset and maybe people will feel transported to another place. Right now it’s more like looking into a doll’s house. No wonder immersive rooms are better
- wayoutthere 7y agoThe Valve Index is actually pretty good at this. It's not quite 180, but somewhere around 130 which is good enough to give you decent peripheral vision. I feel like the next generation of VR will be a lot closer. Also, the main thing holding back VR right now is the amount of graphics horsepower required to run complex games at high resolutions and refresh rates of 90-120fps. I don't think there are any cards on the market that can run the Index at native resolution in most games (the software will scale the resolution to your hardware).
- chinesempire 7y agoActually for Formula 1 racing games VR is just perfect In fact it's the tool used to simulate field of view on F1 cars and how they tested the halo https://hips.hearstapps.com/hmg-prod.s3.amazonaws.com/images/screen-shot-2018-03-20-at-3-26-52-pm-1521574045.png https://hips.hearstapps.com/hmg-prod.s3.amazonaws.com/images... My girlfriend's mother has a genetic disorder of the eyes called retinitis pigmentosa which causes tunnel vision. VR is the tool she uses to explain to medical students how it feels to suffer from it.
- zlsa 7y agoVR is still new, and with a 180 degree field of view, either the pixel-per-degrees would be painfully low (very low-resolution) or it would be high-resolution, but no computer would be able to push all the pixels.
- throwawaaaayvr 7y agoi have an oculus go that I got for christmas. the one that got me: vr porn. it is very immersive. next level when your partner gets involved. having only been with my one partner, it is like experiencing other people and that is very exciting.
- ilikehurdles 7y agoIt seems like a bulky novelty. Like something we would very much enjoy but because of the cost and involved setup I'd rather go to an arcade to experience VR than throw it into a room and turn gaming into an even more socially isolated thing than it already is. I also don't know how often I'd use it past. Seems fun for racing and flight games, but I also can't justify keeping a ton of simulation racing/flight gear around in my house. A simple handheld controller seems "good enough" for achieving 90% of the fun. I do wish there'd be more VR availability in arcade-style places.
- dade_ 7y agoIt isn't ready yet. We have come a very long way, but the hype always sets expectations - too soon for the quality and price consumers demand. Compare what was an amazing experience in 1995 with MechWarrior 2 VR ($3000 headset + $3000 PC in 1995 dollars) to the experience that Sony offers with the PS4 for less than 1/6th the cost today. I am still excited to see what comes next.
- shostack 7y agoIMHO nothing matches the truly immersive experience of Battletech that they had at North Pier in Chicago when I was growing up. It was a fully themed space and you'd walk into a room full of pods (cockpits) and they'd slide the hatch closed on you. Then lights and multiple monitors would come on and you had a joystick, throttle, foot pedals for rotating your turret, and a massive array of switches, buttons, and their associated little red digital displays for weapon assignments, etc. It was unbelievable and at the end you all went into a room to watch a spectator view of the match and got a printout with every blow of the match described in log format. I think I still have my membership card somewhere.
- HellDunkel 7y agoUncomfortable to the point of sickening. Space and price are valid point but for me its the sickening impression of fake motion, staring at screen so close to your eyes, burrliness, wheight of the headset and silly looks.
- war321 7y agoLooking silly is the one critique of VR I just don't get. Your in the safety of your own home and either A) live alone or B) live with a significant other/parents/roommates. In which case, who cares what they think you might look like while enjoying yourself?
- HellDunkel 7y agoYears ago i remember working at a company where a vr presentation was cancelled because some high level automotive management folks refused to wear a headset because it might mess with their hair. Thats just one example. I personally dont like to put on these headsets too.
- epaga 7y agoI agree with everyone here who is praising the Quest. How they’d write an article like this and not mention the Oculus Quest even once is beyond me. It is a game changer and two of my friends have bought one after trying it out once. No cables, no PC, minimal setup, and incredibly immersive.
- zmmmmm 7y agoYep. I have a friend who simply mocked my Gear VR who was looking up the price on Amazon minutes after trying out the Quest. Anybody trashing VR needs to try the Quest. Trash it afterwards if you like, but don't trash it based on the previous gen (either high end or low end) because they are not comparable.
- hutzlibu 7y ago"This could be a way to revolutionize flight training, and make it more accessible. " I rather think this could revolutionize any expensive training. Everything with heavy machines would benefit. And every other sector where a beginner misstake can literaly blow something up.
- lowdose 7y agoAnyone coming up with a Ted like teddy bear conversational experience in AR. Cracking jokes at consumed content at hand will make a killing and will silence all critics. This is an article from a conservative that could have written an article like why the Electronic vehicle will never be a car 5 years ago. We know nay sayers do not have the power of imagination they just consume the fruit when it's ripe.
- eddhead 7y agoThere are so many problems in this article.I don't know where to begin. Obviously she doesn't mention the Oculus Quest and Obviously she doesn't even mention popular VR games that everybody is actually buying. There are VR devices for everyone and she seems to be basing her entire article on the shoddy VR mall experience she once got to try out. The Quest is the best VR experience today for casual and semi-hardcore users and it changes the game entirely.