8 ms·
Whoops, so long with the "no bullshit" policy. I stopped using them a while ago but for a different reason. I used to use their website to check availability/w
by moralestapia 7y ago
Whoops, so long with the "no bullshit" policy.
I stopped using them a while ago but for a different reason. I used to use their website to check availability/whois for domains that I was interested in buying. If it was available I didn't buy it at the time but until I finished the website/app whatever I was going to put there, this took me a few months obviously. It happened to me that when I was finally ready the domain had already been sold to someone else. This repeated five times during six or so years. Now, I know, "someone else could have thought the same thing" but I find it very hard to believe that it happens so often. These domains were a bit of niche words that were not hot topics at the time, some of them using fairly uncommon TLDs (like .one). Another weird thing is that they were always registered to someone living/or doing business at India, and it was a fairly simple landing page with a "contact me" link. I'm a bit superstitious so I don't think it was a coincidence.
Now, I don't think this is a GANDI problem per se, but my theory is that they share this information (who is looking for which domains) with marketers or something like that, or maybe it was a rogue employee trying to make some money squatting domains. I would have expected this from BigDaddy or similar sharks, but from a company whose motto is "no bullshit" I had much better hope. Anyway, I decided to move (to namecheap if you're wondering) and surprisingly the problem went away.
- Jasper_ 7y agoI've heard that this isn't actually the registrar's fault, it's the registry's fault. So your TLD is sharing the "is registered" query with other parties. That said, everything about the domain registration industry seems designed to appear sketchy as all hell, so who knows.
- craze3 7y agoThis happened to me with GoDaddy and Namecheap before, which is why I switched to using Gandi for all my domain searches... Now I'm regretting it! But as @Jasper_ said, this could be a problem with the domain name registry selling/leaking that info (AKA all their 'is_available' queries), and not the registrar.
- Hoasi 7y agoYou shouldn't regret it. GoDaddy was and still is way worse than this, there is no comparison.
- snapetom 7y agoAt one point, I believe a GoDaddy VP was doing this as a personal side business. For many reasons, GoDaddy is the shadiest of them all.
- albedoa 7y agoI was always told that Namecheap does not engage in this practice. It's a single data point, but I instructed a client to search for domains on Namecheap last year since they were undecided. I just didn't want them to use GoDaddy, and I warned them why. They settled on a domain but registered it months afterwards. It was still available.
- benhurmarcel 7y agoI have the same story with Gandi. Searching for a domain (several times even, on a .com) and was still available months later.
- j45 7y agoI have had a similar experience with other registrars. Edit: Sad to hear of the data loss and for anyone affected. Trusting cloud providers doesn't always work out either.
- moralestapia 7y agoNice to know I'm not the only one! :D
- jandrese 7y agoDomain registrars giving away domains to squatters when people search for them is a time honored practice. The advice I've seen is to not search for the domain first, just register it outright from the start. The domain registration business is run with all of the integrity and customer focus of TicketMaster.
- Verdex 7y agoReally? I may have just found myself a new hobby. Search for incredibly unique (and worthless to me) domains to see if I can get people to squat on them. Heck, it could be a game ... I could get all my friends to make bingo boards ... or maybe see if I can think of some scrabble like rules.
- brianwawok 7y agoI suspect a human gets a dump of them and decides which to pay the $10 for. For example, asdasdahbdajsdbajdbhsbdahsdd.com... not worth the $10 ireallylikechicken.com... maybe worth the $10? (ireallylikechicken.com is available, go squat it and get rich)
- capableweb 7y agoSomeone did buy it it! > Creation Date: 2020-01-09T19:37:01Z Registered with Gandi, ironically enough... And the domain is meta! Response from HTTP GET > Location: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22001822 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22001822
- masukomi 7y agoer.... was it you?
- capableweb 7y agoIt was not
- 7y ago
- contingencies 7y agoIt could be your local DNS resolution that is leaking to bad actors. It would be kind of stupid and self defeating for registrars to undercut their own customers. I would expect that some have done this in the past, but would be very surprised if it is done at Gandi with their knowledge... and undoubtedly French law would not smile kindly on such behavior.
- Operyl 7y agoThey never had a real "no bullshit" policy. When I had my domains with them, I had been asked to verify my identity 34 times in 12 months. 34 separate fucking times. Because "ICANN says so" or some stupid shit (their words, not mine). It stopped the moment I moved to Google Domains, where they asked once and never again. EDIT: And, to make things worse, each time I was threatened with the "confiscation" of my domain, and the round trip on the tickets was so high that each instance took 2-3 days to resolve. Frustrating as hell.
- capableweb 7y agoSince you're giving a anecdote, let me do the same. I have about 30-40 domains with Gandi, and have been using it for about ten years. I don't remember ever verifying my identity, but guess I most have done it at least once. I have not been asked to verify anything for at least the last five years of using it. Disclaimer: I don't work there or have any relationship, except I'm a happy customer
- Operyl 7y agoIt was a matter of them refusing to keep my identity on file, and the threatening tone of each ticket. It grew tiresome quickly.
- capableweb 7y agoSounds more like a bug than anything. Why would they want to not make it easier for you if they can? Seems you missed my point though. Both of our anecdotes doesn't really say anything, in terms of if Gandi is good or bad.
- smnrchrds 7y agoHis anecdote does say something though. It suggests that Gandi has a "if we have a bug, it's your problem not ours, sucks to be you" policy, which is exactly what has happened with this data loss issue as well. Actions speak louder than words. Google famously has a "we don't have bugs, you just don't know how to use it, talk to the hand" policy for example. It is better to learn about the policies due to minor issues rather than major. OP learned of it early on and moved away with little trouble. Others did not learn until now and stayed, and now they are SOL.
- todd3834 7y agoIf you want an alternative to searching with a registrar you can always type: whois mysupergreatcoolappidea.com into a terminal window and see if you get back a result
- Ayesh 7y agoWHOIS and DNS requests are made to nameservers run by the registry (not registrars), it's possible for the registry to front-run domains if they intend to.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- herpderperator 7y agoAlthough the current issue with the irrecoverable data loss is terrible, I thought (in this case, at least) that they were surprisingly honest. They straight up said the data is gone (a VERY hard thing to publicly admit), and informed people they need to restore from their own backups. That seems pretty No Bullshit to me, no?
- LeonB 7y agoReports of reputable registrars front-running are persistent, but unfounded. Anytime I’ve looked into it, I’ve never seen any evidence for it. If proven it would be a major blow to their business, so why would they try to snatch pennies from in front of a steam roller? So I call b.s. on any reports of “the registrar noticed me searching for a domain and registered it”.
- jlgaddis 7y agoUm, NetSol settled a $1MM class action suit over exactly this about a decado ago. It absolutely has happened and quite possibly still does.
- hwj 7y agoWould `whois` be any better to prevent leakage of domains you intend to register?