15 ms·
San Francisco has nearly five empty homes per homeless resident
- 3fe9a03ccd14ca5 7y agoIs this comparison (homeless vs vacancy) a headline thing or is there actually a healthy metric to compare the two? Isn't the number much higher in places with less homeless, such as Oklahoma City? "Healthy" vacancy rates (according to citylab) are approximately 7-8% (people moving in, people moving out, remodeling, etc). With SF's vacancy rate at 6%[2], shouldn't the vacancy rate be higher? 1. https://www.citylab.com/equity/2018/07/vacancy-americas-other-housing-crisis/565901/ https://www.citylab.com/equity/2018/07/vacancy-americas-othe... 2. https://www.statista.com/statistics/430104/office-vacancy-rate-san-francisco/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/430104/office-vacancy-ra...
- boyadjian 7y agoEmpty homes is not a problem.
- Tiktaalik 7y agoThere's no real attempt here to explain what all the empty houses are about. Second homes? Pied-à-terre's for the rich that live elsewhere? In nearby British Columbia, recently as property values were spiking there was increased scrutiny of "empty homes" amongst the fact that many new condo developments were luxury developments being explicitly marketed in international magazines and foreign cities. Drilling down to the individual neighbourhood level, some places were more than 20% 'empty'. When the government shifted to the social democratic NDP, the new government brought in a "Speculation Tax" which was really more of a vacancy tax. The tax essentially makes it substantially more expensive to have a secondary, empty, home in certain parts of the province. Places that are obvious tourism towns like Whistler are exempt. https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/british-columbia/b-c-s-speculation-tax-increased-to-2-1.5391309 https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/british-columbia/b-c-s-specul... > Introduced Dec. 31, 2018, the tax targets homes in the most populated areas of B.C. that are not declared as a primary residence or are not rented out for at least three months a year. More than 99 per cent of British Columbians are exempt.
- christopherbalz 7y agoNot surprising; the Fed is intent on ever-inflating the housing asset bubble.
- pmdulaney 7y agoIt was within the last month that I first saw a Hacker News headline like this, only that time -- though I would not be surprised if on that occasion it was also a link to curbed.com -- it was making a similar claim about Los Angeles. The mere headline reflects either the insanity or the anarchism of the far left. One might as well say: "The one hundred wealthiest San Franciscans have enough disposable income to buy a $10 million dollar house for every homeless person in the City." How do you put up a headline like that with a straight face, unless you are willing to assert -- as I suppose curbed.com is -- that the cognoscenti proletariat should be empowered to confiscate all property and redistribute it as they wish? I went to Berkeley (albeit a long time ago) and I've known many liberals. But I only believe the truly lunatic fringe of the left are going to get on board with this kind of thinking.
- suprfsat 7y agoWhat? Do you think it's insane to say that billionaires should be put to death?
- cf141q5325 7y agoTheir numbers look sound to me. Did you read the article? >The ten most populous Bay Area cities listed above have a combined point-in-time homeless total of 63,527, and, margins of error notwithstanding, a census-estimated 92,800-plus homes vacant, a ratio of about three units for every two persons. >The census’ annual American Communities Survey defines a home as vacant if there is either no occupant or a temporary occupant—temporary meaning “people who will be there for two months or less.” >Vacancy rates are estimated by in-person visits to properties or by interviews via mail, email, or phone. The upcoming 2020 census will employ more exact methods and should result in housing and vacancy estimates with less room for error.
- TacticalTable 7y agoIt doesn't seem they're questioning the data, they're questioning the motives of the title, and the implication that the housing should be redistributed to the homeless. I absolutely disagree with their position, but I can see their point of view. Personally, my (rough) idea would be to increase property taxes dramatically for unoccupied residences, which would encourage them to be put on the market for rental at least, and drive prices down a bit.
- Jamwinner 7y agoBut lets continue taking public policy talking points from them. /s
- happytoexplain 7y agoFrom whom? And who is doing the "taking", and how do you know where it is "taken" from? What is the relationship between the umbrella concept of all public policy and this specific issue?
- biznickman 7y agoWhen I lived in San Francisco, the newly built condo building across from me was fully empty (but fully sold) for all the years I lived there. This is a tower in SOMA. There was only one apartment which appeared to be a corporate one that was occasionally utilized. The rise of foreign money parking money in real estate has screwed things up on a global level. San Francisco has felt the brunt of this due to their insanely restrictive development laws. Frankly, for the 7+ years I was in San Francisco I was always saying they should pass laws to prevent foreign investment in real estate or at a minimum require people live there for X% of the year.
- aaronbwebber 7y agoI call bullshit. Say what tower it was, and when it was built, and what time frame you are actually talking about so we can verify for ourselves whether it was actually empty or not, or even if it was empty whether it was empty for a good reason (e.g. not having it's habitability permit). Otherwise this is the worst kind of anecdata - not even enough detail to verify that the anecdote is true, nevermind whether it is actually a representative sample of a larger issue or just an odd case.
- cmclaughlin 7y agoI'm all for backing up claims, but drive through Pac Heights and Cow Hollow at night - you won't see many lights on in those mansions. Drive by during the day and all you see is construction workers and gardeners tending to the properties there. It's pretty obvious people don't live there more than a couple months a year. These are the ultra rich with property in the most expensive cities all over the world.
- robbyking 7y ago> I'm all for backing up claims, but [...] you won't see many lights on in those mansions. I'm with you 100%. I lived in SF from 1998-2006, then again for a few years in the 2010's, and when rental prices are high landlords seem to prefer holding out rather than lowering their rates. I assume this is to avoid locking a potentially valuable rental unit into a low, rent-controlled lease. (On a side note, this is why many economists believe rent control is bad overall for rental markets: http://freakonomics.com/podcast/rent-control/ http://freakonomics.com/podcast/rent-control/)
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- gradys 7y ago> The census’ annual American Communities Survey defines a home as vacant if there is either no occupant or a temporary occupant—temporary meaning “people who will be there for two months or less.” So this is counting AirBnBs and other short-term rental spaces as vacant. > Vacancy rates are estimated by in-person visits to properties or by interviews via mail, email, or phone. I clicked through to the definition from census.gov: > Mail and computer-assisted telephone and personal-visit interviews. All group quarters responses are obtained by personal visit interview. Most vacant units are not identified until the third month of data collection (the first personal visit). In that month, a 1-in-3 subsample of all addresses for which responses have not been obtained are visited by field representatives. I'm curious how well you can distinguish permanent residents not being home when field representatives happened to drop by from actually vacant. My house looks like it could be vacant when nobody is home.
- Psyladine 7y ago>So this is counting AirBnBs and other short-term rental spaces as vacant. by definition tourist or transient, so correctly so. Unless you want to call every room at the hilton an apartment...
- refurb 7y agoThat’s a dishonest definition of “vacant” because vacant implies the unit is available for someone to live in. Obviously you don’t include hotels because those were never intended as housing in the traditional sense.
- dragonwriter 7y ago> Obviously you don’t include hotels because those were never intended as housing in the traditional sense. Low-end residential hotels (i.e., the ones not catering primarily to extended white-collar business travel) are, in major function, very hard to distinguish from traditional housing. And what stops any other hotel (particularly higher-end residential / extended-stay hotels) from selling into that market is the expectation that doing so (even with units that are otherwise vacant) would sacrifice the opportunity for more rent from richer people, so it very much is a continuous market.
- human_banana 7y agoMaybe they should build something other than luxury condos. But that would require SF to change their insane zoning laws. And SF cares more about zoning laws than they do about people.
- earlINmeyerkeg 7y agoGod forbid NIMBY has to deal with a better house than theirs a block away...
- wskinner 7y ago> “The census’ annual American Communities Survey defines a home as vacant if there is either no occupant or a temporary occupant—temporary meaning “people who will be there for two months or less.” I wonder why they didn’t mention one simple explanation - many of these are Airbnbs or other short term rentals.
- ahelwer 7y agoYou can't build yourself out of the housing crisis when the problem is one of distribution, not one of supply. The idea that housing should be treated as an investment is, itself, the problem. How can you want housing to be affordable while also wanting housing to gain in value, i.e. increase in cost? These are completely contradictory aims. Zoom out for a second and consider how wild it is that we turned a life necessity (shelter) into a speculative plaything.
- gimmeThaBeet 7y agoI think there's truth there, but housing distribution solutions never seem to be very elegant. The way it tends to boil down in my mind is more general philosophical concepts. Starting with the price and cost of housing to me isn't very interesting because market dynamics are what got you here. You want a different city. I want to learn more about what people think that city looks like, and then think about solutions from there. How do you decide who gets to live in SF (or insert city here)? Prioritize people who were born there? Whose family has history? People who have jobs there? What about self-employed people? People with kids? A lottery system?
- harryh 7y agoYou can't build yourself out of the housing crisis when the problem is one of distribution, not one of supply. This is wrong. There is no distribution problem with housing. It's not that people can't find a house to live in, or a house has to be shipped across the country and the rail line is broken. The problem is that people can't afford housing. And they can't afford it because demand has increased dramatically while supply has been artificially constrained by government. The solution is to remove the government constraints on supply which will lower prices. Now obviously the trick is that existing owners don't want to do this, and they have a lot of political power. So I don't really see this happening, but if it somehow could happen that would be the path to the answer.
- ahelwer 7y agoI think you misunderstand what I mean by "distribution" - there is already enough housing for everybody (see article), it is just not distributed in an equitable way among people who need it. Nothing to do with shipping houses.
- sigstoat 7y agoas some of the comments on the article note, you've got natural churn in residency, uninhabitable structures, renovations, etc. also it's not like you can let someone live in a house for free and just call it a wash. anyone who has ever rented a home to folks knows that tenants can be _extremely_ hard on a rental property.
- cuillevel3 7y agoalso some of them might not want to be registered? having a home might not be enough to be able to deal with bureaucracy and such
- kurthr 7y agoThis is the expected result of prop-13. It's true all over california. You can make money on capital gains without any continuing investment/income or significant tax... why bother with tenants. Just sell out to the developer who wants to put in another high-rise apartment complex when the price is higher. In the mean time... screw the neighborhood. https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2020/jan/09/san-francisco-gentrification-second-wave https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2020/jan/09/san-fr...
- martin_bech 7y agoIn Denmark this would be impossible as we have “bopælspligt”. It means if you buy a home or apartment in an area like this, you are required by law to live in it.
- ryanSrich 7y agoThere are several condo buildings in Portland (OR, US) that do this as well. I don't think it's city or government regulated, but it's required by certain buildings. I don't know if SF has anything like this, but I imagine it's easy to get around it.
- martin_bech 7y agoIn Denmark its hard to get around, as you have to register your official postal adress for the government using your CPR nr (kinda like social security numner).
- s0rce 7y agoNot free enough for America, maybe? Also, most of the politically active residents own homes here that they are counting on to continue dramatically appreciating in value, having investors buy up new property supports this goal.
- earlINmeyerkeg 7y agoDoes Europe (more or less as whole) have a philosophy that rental properties are a regulated enterprise that is solely to be managed by a established company? I mean I really do like the idea but I've heard of incredibly long waiting lists for apartments in places like Germany simply because there just isn't enough supply to meet demand.
- martin_bech 7y agoNo no, you can buy an apartment, and rent it out, and then the renter registers the apartment as official address etc. So the apartment isnt empty. There are some laws you have to follow, but its pretty easy to do. I dont know the details of Germany, but mostly what i have seen here is not enough supply, and big demand.
- fuzzinator 7y ago> The ten most populous Bay Area cities listed above have a combined point-in-time homeless total of 63,527 If you add up all the homeless numbers listed for each city in the article this number is actually 23,528. What is considered a healthy occupancy rate for a city? 100% occupancy would obviously not be ideal since there would be no places for people to move to. Are there any direct stats on vacant home ownership as a means to hold money?
- perseusmandate 7y agoAs I understand it typical occupancy rate is 95%. Looks like there are ~400K housing units in SF (not total bay area). That would imply there are 20K vacant units just for frictional reasons. I expect the number of these type of vacancies exceeds the number of homeless in almost every city in the US
- lrajlich 7y agoCounter argument: SF has one of the lowest vacancy rates in the country. https://sf.curbed.com/2019/3/21/18276227/vacancy-rate-san-jose-san-francisco-lendingtree https://sf.curbed.com/2019/3/21/18276227/vacancy-rate-san-jo... This article is promoting a bad faith argument used by anti development activists.
- happytoexplain 7y agoI can see why somebody might view that as a counter argument intuitively, but as somebody who cares about the problem in a real, practical sense, it's immediately obvious to me that the point isn't to criticise the city's vacancy rate in a void, but to compare it to the potential waste. In a city where prices are disgustingly high and homelessness is appallingly common, the vacancy rate becomes much more sensitive to pragmatic criticism. Simply pointing out that other cities have a higher rate doesn't affect the criticism. Perhaps those other cities wouldn't benefit as much from lowering the vacancy rate. Perhaps those other cities would benefit a comparable amount, and we should hold them to the same criticism rather than declaring the criticism invalid.
- forwhomst 7y agoIt's basically impossible to increase housing utilization to 100%. It's pointless to even try. 10% is a healthy vacancy rate. Build 110% of the housing your city needs.
- logfromblammo 7y agoMathematical nitpick. A vacancy rate of 10% is an occupancy rate of 90%. To house everyone with a 90% occupancy rate, you need to have 100 / 90 in available housing stock, which is 111.1% of occupation requirements. If you only build 110% of what is needed, and no one is homeless, the vacancy rate would be 9.1%, or ( 1 - 100/110 ) . The point still stands. Cities need more housing than strictly required for residents.
- forwhomst 7y ago
- lacker 7y agoHow do they tell if a home is vacant? Mail and computer-assisted telephone and personal-visit interviews. All group quarters responses are obtained by personal visit interview. Okay, so if you don't answer spam calls, or you aren't home when some random person knocks on your door, your house might be considered to be vacant. This data seems pretty worthless.
- s0rce 7y agoThat seems like an extremely obvious shortcoming of this survey methodology. I'm willing to give the authors the benefit of the doubt and assume they aren't completely incompetent and that they've attempted to account for this occurrence.
- metalliqaz 7y agoare you sure you're interpreting that correctly? I think they don't count a no-answer in the data. More like someone answers and then provides responses about their own home and their neighbors. I know exactly which homes are occupied in my neighborhood, so I could accurately answer for them if someone asked me.
- flaque 7y agoMany of these homes probably aren’t “empty” in the sense that someone’s just holding on to them long term. This article is citing the vacancy rate, which includes rentals where someone left and the landlord is trying to find a new tenant. Any city will have some % of empty rentals, if it didn’t, no one would ever move around. According to the US Census, [1] San Francisco’s vacancy rate is 5.4%, New York’s is 4.5%, and Seattle is 4.8%. But many cities have 10%+ or higher. It’s pretty disingenuous to say these homes are truly empty or that they’re a sign that “we don’t have a housing crisis” as the Moms 4 Housing group suggested in the article. It’s just a misunderstood statistic being weaponized against building more housing. If you want to help homeless folks, build more housing and put them in it. If you want your rent to go down, build more housing. If you want your cost of living to go down, build more housing. [1] https://www.census.gov/housing/hvs/data/ann18ind.html https://www.census.gov/housing/hvs/data/ann18ind.html
- earlINmeyerkeg 7y agoIsn't like 90% of the homeless population people with a significant mental illness that they cannot provide for themselves? That's because the normal competent people don't remain homeless long and just need short term temporary assistant. Whereas the large portion of homeless actually are not competent enough to support themselves.
- huevosabio 7y agoIt's about 26% Source (pg 22, Mental Illness + Alcohol / Drug Use): http://hsh.sfgov.org/wp-content/uploads/FINAL-PIT-Report-2019-San-Francisco.pdf http://hsh.sfgov.org/wp-content/uploads/FINAL-PIT-Report-201...
- yesenadam 7y agoIt sounds like by "it" you mean the percentage of homeless with a significant mental illness..."that they cannot provide for themselves" (whatever the sentence was meant to mean). But the only 26% on that page is this: "Over one-quarter (26%) of respondents identified job loss as the primary cause of their homelessness. "
- macinjosh 7y agoOffer property tax incentives to real estate owners who have empty homes if they lease them to tenants that have issues with housing stability at rates they can realistically afford. The owner gets tax benefits. People in need get a home to live in. The city has fewer homeless. All lease income could go towards upkeep.
- Psyladine 7y agoHow about punishing malingering misuse of resources rather than offering a carrot. Owners incentivized to utilize land, more real estate available, foreign investment squatting suffers.
- macinjosh 7y agoWho gets to decide what is or isn't a misuse of resources? People like you would rather use force to bend others to your worldview than actually execute on realistic solutions.
- Psyladine 7y agoVacancy taxes are hardly authoritarian. If government has any purpose it is to address the irreconcilable conflicts of individual self-interest vs the benefit of all. And your 'realistic solutions' leads to exploitive loopholes for people who already benefit enough without additional tax incentives, like communities that go in on luxury senior developments to meet their low-income/transient housing obligations.
- forwhomst 7y agoThis is a bad-faith argument advanced by the opponents of construction (landowners, essentially). The facts are that San Francisco vacancy rate is among the lowest in the nation, stands near the all-time low for that city, and is way below the level required for a healthy housing market. You need liquidity for a functioning market, and liquidity means vacancy. The NIMBY groups who advanced this exact narrative in Los Angeles had to retract their "study" because it was BS. https://thehill.com/changing-america/respect/poverty/471675-in-los-angeles-vacant-homes-outnumber-the-homeless https://thehill.com/changing-america/respect/poverty/471675-...
- newnewpdro 7y agoTenant rights are so strong in CA that I prefer to leave my home vacant when I travel for half the year, despite having locals asking if their friends can rent it for that duration. It would only take a single deadbeat choosing to not pay rent, trash the place, and refuse to leave to make it all not worth my trouble. In another state where tenant rights are weaker I'd collect rent and kick the tenant out on their ass the same month they stop paying rent. CA is a great state to be a tenant, not so great for being a landlord. Developments like Airbnb also change the game drastically. Now you can get rental income without even taking the risks of tenants rights by keeping the terms short enough. Are Airbnb rentals considered "empty" by these metrics?
- kdamica 7y agoIt's so troubling to see a statistic misused like this. The vacancy rate includes all 'frictional' vacancies, such as the period between someone moving out of an apartment and the owner finding a new tenant, or the period between a new unit being built and a tenant moving in. Because of this, though the vacancy rate can be stable, it's not the same units that are vacant from month to month, and in fact, San Francisco's vacancy rate is extremely low compared to less problematic housing markets.
- cartercole 7y agoI don't understand why this statistic matters... its private property and you have no say how they use their homes... if you want to help people get homes lower the regulations so the barrier to entry lower... oh ya and repeal dumb zoning laws :)
- dmitrygr 7y agoAlso, Maserati dealerships have 5 cars for every person who has no car. So?