4 ms·
(Edit: We don't know what caused this incident. Speculation follows. It's best to not form conclusions until the experts examine the evidence.) It looks like i
by echelon 7y ago
(Edit: We don't know what caused this incident. Speculation follows. It's best to not form conclusions until the experts examine the evidence.)
It looks like it was shot down with an air defense missile. You can see the plane on fire as it falls to the earth.
Video taken during the crash, the plane is clearly engulfed in flames:
https://mobile.twitter.com/isna_farsi/status/1214756225293979648 https://mobile.twitter.com/isna_farsi/status/121475622529397...
Video of the aftermath / wreckage:
https://twitter.com/Looper_i/status/1214772061580615681 https://twitter.com/Looper_i/status/1214772061580615681
https://twitter.com/Looper_i/status/1214773020885041152 https://twitter.com/Looper_i/status/1214773020885041152
It might have been mistakenly triggered as part of Iran's anti-aircraft missile defense or a similar system. The plane probably wasn't safely diverted from an active war zone, and Iran is already in a heightened state of watchful defense.
Similar incidents:
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iran_Air_Flight_655 https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iran_Air_Flight_655 (TIL; caused by the USA)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Malaysia_Airlines_Flight_17 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Malaysia_Airlines_Flight_17
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- xster 7y agoHard to be conclusive with that video. Iran's own state media says the engine was on fire. Not necessarily contradicted by the video. https://en.irna.ir/news/83625750/147-Iranians-32-foreigners-lose-lives-in-Boeing-737-crash https://en.irna.ir/news/83625750/147-Iranians-32-foreigners-...
- sparkling 7y agoA fire in the engine is not enough to turn a 737 into a huge burning fireball that crashes within 20 seconds. Regarding the missile theory: if it was a missle, it was probably accidential. The majority of passengers on board were Iranian citizens.
- shuckles 7y agoRemember Stuxnet?
- dilyevsky 7y agoPretty sure russian/chinese SAMs don’t run windows
- iamaelephant 7y agoWhat makes you pretty sure of that?
- dilyevsky 7y ago* Most of them were made before it was even a thing * Precisely for reason above
- mikejb 7y ago> Regarding the missile theory: if it was a missle, it was probably accidential. The majority of passengers on board were Iranian citizens. Unless it was a non-Iranian missile, or a rogue actor. (At this point, it's all speculation)
- est 7y ago> turn a 737 into a huge burning fireball From a suggested twitter video. No affirmative source yet.
- p_l 7y agoUnless the engine blades detaching ripped apart something critical, as happened several times on different aircraft, and crucially, twice on exactly this model with this engine from similar manufactuer time.
- techie128 7y agoDon't you think it should take them at least a few days to determine a preliminary cause of the crash?
- ra7 7y agoThe Ukranian embassy in Tehran already have a statement on their website saying it's an engine malfunction and are ruling out a terrorist/rocket attack (reported by CNN and NYT).
- cjbprime 7y agoRight, but the question is whether that's a reasonable conclusion for them to have made already.
- paxys 7y agoAn independent investigation is impossible in the current environment. You either choose to believe Iran or not.
- Majestic121 7y agoIt would take everyone a few days to determine the cause, especially the people spreading unverified informations such as 'it was shot down by a missile'
- bitcoinbutter 7y agoIt wouldn't take very long for the relevant parties to know whether they accidentally shot a missile at a 737. For a mechanical issue, there would be much more uncertainty (although it's possible the pilot reported the issue to ATC).
- cjbprime 7y agoAnd even then, "ATC, we have a catastrophic engine failure" from the pilots doesn't discount that the catastrophic engine failure was caused by a missile. The pilots don't magically get to know what caused the engine to blow up.
- saberdancer 7y agoPilot should be able to communicate even if engine is on fire (especially then). Transponder doesn't suddenly stop working if your engine erupts in flames.
- doersino 7y agoAviate, navigate, communicate. They would have been rather occupied with the first two.
- saberdancer 7y agoGood point. I concede. I'd still expect them to declare an emergency but it's possible that the event was so catastrophic they didn't find the time.
- sandos 7y agoIts even fairly common, one guys is reading checklists and the other is, you know, flying the airplane.
- EForEndeavour 7y agoTo be fair, communication is different from ADS-B transmissions, which end abruptly at the flight's maximum speed and altitude: https://www.flightradar24.com/data/flights/ps752#23732569 https://www.flightradar24.com/data/flights/ps752#23732569
- iso947 7y agoUnverified video There’s a lot of disinformation going on online. We saw this in the recent UK election, there are many players wanting to spread lies. I just hope our reputable journalists are up to the job. https://www.buzzfeednews.com/amphtml/janelytvynenko/false-and-unverified-information-iraq-attack https://www.buzzfeednews.com/amphtml/janelytvynenko/false-an...
- jcaprani 7y agoYou mean the reputable journalists at BuzzFeed?
- tozeur 7y agoApparently they’ve evolved quite a bit: https://www.pulitzer.org/finalists/chris-hamby-buzzfeed-news https://www.pulitzer.org/finalists/chris-hamby-buzzfeed-news
- Gigablah 7y agoNo, the reputable journalists at BuzzFeed News, which has produced two Pulitzer Prize finalists so far. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BuzzFeed_News https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BuzzFeed_News
- jcaprani 7y agoI think you mean activists rather than journalists.
- otalp 7y agoAny writer of news someone doesn't like can be an "activist" rather than a journalist, it's a pointless distinction
- sitkack 7y agoPlease don't.
- thereare5lights 7y ago
- sschueller 7y agoThis is all speculation at this point. Let's hope we find the definite cause as some point.
- iso947 7y agoMore important than finding out the cause is ensuring we don’t find out the wrong cause. We’ll likely never know MH370s cause. That’s annoying, and heartbreaking Dott those affected. In itself it doesn’t lead to tens of thousands of more deaths.
- rococode 7y agoEdit: Never mind! I commented about a tweet that suggested the fireball was maybe a missle but it looks like people who know better agree that's not the case
- vecter 7y agoNo way that's true. Missiles are generally pretty small. That fire in the air was BIG, and was lit in the way that a fireball is, not the way that a missile burns. Also, missiles travel incredibly fast, way faster than that fireball is going.
- saberdancer 7y agoInteresting idea but I don't think it's true. Unless I am missing something, the "plane dot" is at or almost at horizon level. After the explosion you can see that at the position of the "dot" is something that looks like a building or a tower. Light from that could be the dot that we saw. Another thing is that the "fireball" seems to be losing parts, I'm not sure if missile trails leave puffs of flames behind, but this one looks like it did. Having flaming pieces fall off from a plane would look like that.
- altacc 7y agoAgree. Rockets are quicker and with more compact engines, not flaming fireballs. The parts falling from the fireball could be the result of an engine fire caused by structural failure of the engine or collision with something (such as a bird strike, although I think that is less likely as it's nighttime).
- t0mas88 7y agoThat's also what an engine fire / turbine stall looks like. However, a 737 is able to climb on one engine so there was absolutely more wrong than "just" en engine failure/fire.
- mikejb 7y agoThe Ukrainian embassy reported preliminary information indicates engine failure, and excludes a rocket or terrorist attack as cause. [1] Particularly at this time, I wouldn't trust random sources on the web to provide accurate information about events. [1] https://edition.cnn.com/middleeast/live-news/iran-plane-crash-live-intl-hnk/h_c4db6b3d3977a627d6139ccda956f998 https://edition.cnn.com/middleeast/live-news/iran-plane-cras...
- allovernow 7y agoHow much can you trust government agencies in times like these? With so many competing intelligence agencies, quite possibly sitting on the brink of WWIII, I don't think it's outlandish for an official source to lie, intentionally or not.
- AtlasLion 7y agoThen why even talk about anything at that point if you were not there yourself.
- mikejb 7y agoThe amount of trust put into any conclusion at this point should be minimal, and whilst I understand and partly share the lack of trust in embassy statements, I posted this to counter the blind "looks like it was shot down, someone on twitter said so" conclusion.
- ptr 7y agoThey might not even be lying: would it be classified as a "terrorist attack" if it's a mistake by the Iranians? A "rocket attack" wouldn't hit an airplane, you need guided missiles for that.
- a012 7y agoI see it's too immature to conduct an engine failure in this situation without investigation report.
- mikejb 7y ago
- JumpCrisscross 7y ago> It looks like it was shot down with an air defense missile. You can see the plane on fire as it falls to the earth. Come on. Don't do this. Planes are complex machines. They're pressurized and propelled by a continuous explosion. There are lots of ways for things to go wrong. A good rule of thumb in aviation is to ignore the first 24 hours of news. There are no facts. Everyone is an armchair crash investigator. And mindshare is competed for with salaciousness. It could be an attack. It could be an air-defense error. Or it could be a mechanical error. One of countless possible mechanical errors. Either way, it's a tragedy to which no service is done by baseless speculation.
- Kiro 7y agoThen we should just close this thread since literally everything will be speculation at this point.
- JumpCrisscross 7y ago> I don't see the problem with speculation It's intellectually dishonest, particularly when baseless speculation is framed by an "it looks like." It crowds out fact-driven discussion. It's disrespectful and potentially hurtful. It could be mistaken for informed commentary, in which case it's misleading. (When I’ve done it, the first victim is myself.) And to top it off, it's useless. Totally useless. Nobody walks away with a deeper understanding. No new perspectives. Just screaming into a void.
- echelon 7y agoI appreciate this. I've modified my post.
- wayneftw 7y agoYou stop because what you are doing is typing a lot of words without saying anything useful. You’re being a bully. Observations are useful. Even mistaken ones. Saying "It looks like..." is stating a fact. What else is someone supposed to say if that’s what it looks like to them? It doesn't crowd out "fact-driven discussion". It's not disrespectful or potentially harmful. Anything could be mistaken, even empirical evidence. Even what you think is a fact...can be wrong. > And to top it off, it's useless. Totally useless. Nobody walks away with a deeper understanding. No new perspectives. Just screaming into a void. That's you. You're being ridiculous. You're over-reacting. You haven't produced any evidence to backup your opinion that speculation is harmful or crowds out your so-called "fact-driven" discussion, or that what is said here on HN has any effect whatsoever on anything going on with this story. Just stop it.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]