4 ms·
> to manipulate public opinion Was Buzzfeed trying to manipulate people or just get clicks?
by duxup 7y ago
> to manipulate public opinion
Was Buzzfeed trying to manipulate people or just get clicks?
- kevingadd 7y agoIf your goal is just to monetize your website (via ads or perhaps sponsored content), manipulation doesn't really seem like it's in your wheelhouse. I suppose it's not utterly implausible that a political party or other major player could attempt to pay off an outlet's owners to use them for manipulation, but that seems a lot more expensive than just astroturfing on twitter and facebook. One notable counter-example to my POV though would be that the Koch family has a tendency to hand big chunks of money to think-tanks, websites and universities for promoting their agenda. Not really sure what the best take-away from that is, though.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- Vrondi 7y agoYes. Manipulate people to click. Once you get that down, you can point the manipulation in different directions.
- alamaslah 7y agoI would suggest looking into the history of the organisation. And the operations of the organisation. Who do they target? How do they target them? etc. I've noticed on this forum that anything tangentially connected to a "right-wing" or "alt-right" organisation or figure should be considered suspicious...So it is worth noting that the founders of buzzfeed, also founded huffpost, alongside Andrew Breitbart. You know, of brietbart fame.
- SkyBelow 7y agoIsn't getting clicks manipulating people into clicking? We might want to say it is categorically different than manipulating people in other ways such as getting them to buy certain products or vote certain ways, but if we go down that path then I think we can begin saying that about most forms of manipulating people and thus we would need to spend a bit more time working on a standard of how acceptable different forms of manipulation are. There is also a question of how do you draw the line between manipulating someone, tricking someone, educating someone, and convincing someone. If scientists are trying to warn the public about the dangers of climate change are they trying to manipulate public opinion, educate the public, or convince the public?
- shkkmo 7y ago> If scientists are trying to warn the public about the dangers of climate change are they trying to manipulate public opinion, educate the public, or convince the public? Depending on the person, the methods used, and the level of integrity maintained, some combination of all three. If you suppress legitimate criticism and intentionally distort facts, you are engaging in trickery. If you correct misinformation and do your best to present an accurate representation of your understanding, you are educating. Generally, scientists tend to do a pretty good job of focusing on education, but the dynamics of the discussion around the information they share tends to cloud that distinction. The problem is that many groups have decided that trickery is more convincing than education and that should make compromising ethics and integrity mandatory. (While other groups seem to have had no integrity to start with.) As a result, the discussion of the distinction between education and trickery and accusations of trickery often drown out the actual attempts at education.
- SkyBelow 7y agoWe might have a problem because scientists spend too much time just giving the information and not on working on the 'manipulation' side of it. For example, take any news site dedicated to scientific news and look at how much even they will twist the facts to make it easier to digest and more interesting. Scientist: Chemical XYZ seen to reduce growth rate of cancer ABC cultured in a petri dish compared to control group. Around 10% reduction average, p < .01, see table 4. Not statistically significantly better than chemical MNO which was also being tested. Further research needed. Science News: Chemical XYZ helps fight cancer ABC. Normal News: Does <something that contains chemical XYZ> cure cancer? If scientists were better at manipulating education to be engaging to the public they wouldn't lose out as often to those pushing fake (or at least far more questionable) information.
- bostik 7y agoAnd then we get science reporting like this: https://www.smbc-comics.com/comic/science-journalism https://www.smbc-comics.com/comic/science-journalism
- 7y ago
- ergothus 7y ago> just get clicks Just because you have one goal (in this case traffic) doesn't mean your actions dont have other effects. Generate clickbait that, for example, leverages the distrust the public has in a group, or is based on the desire to see someone/some group get their comeuppance, or the desire to hear tales about how your group is being exploited, etc, and you start manipulating public opinion about those things. Fox News, for example, started conservative but far less radical...I dont know if they were radicalized by the success of their own success by this sort of manipulation, but it is certainly an option. Once you have success at manipulation, even if that wasn't actually your intent, a financial incentive appears to MAKE it your intention.
- SiempreViernes 7y agoI think intent is pretty important to the concept of "manipulation": you don't often hear the sun being accused of manipulating the weather, despite the overwhelming influence it has over it.
- ameister14 7y agoThat's because manipulate implies active control, which the sun doesn't have. As a different example, you can manipulate the levers of a machine and, if you are not skilled or paying attention, get a result you did not plan for.
- SiempreViernes 7y agoThat is simply poor manipulation: intent was there but understanding was lacking, and so the outcome was not as desired.
- ameister14 7y agoan intent was there, but not the intent to create what became the eventual outcome. Buzzfeed has an intent - to create clicks. What GP was saying was that this creates an unintended effect, that of political and social manipulation, which unfortunately ends up as an incentivized loop for Buzzfeed.
- PhasmaFelis 7y agoWhat's the difference, practically speaking?
- duxup 7y agoGetting clicks and trying to change public opinion I think are different.
- raxxorrax 7y agoI would say yes, but I think BuzzFeed and BuzzFeed News should be separated here, because there is indeed some good investigative work. Also the reliance on Boulevard as a news source is probably the fault of the reader.
- StuffedParrot 7y ago> Was Buzzfeed trying to manipulate people or just get clicks? Publishing is an act of manipulation, including caring about what's happening around them (which is typically considered a good thing).