13 ms·
This doesn't solve the number one problem of kids content on YouTube -- they are leaving it up to the creator to decide if it's kids content. It's still not hu
by jedberg 7y ago
This doesn't solve the number one problem of kids content on YouTube -- they are leaving it up to the creator to decide if it's kids content. It's still not human curated.
The nice thing about Netflix/Hulu/Amazon/PBS/etc. is that a human decides if the content is for kids.
YouTube is still trying to get away with "letting the machines do it", which works for most aspects of their business, but not this.
I used to let my kid watch YTKids while I supervised. But no more. Even with my supervision it just jumps to some insanely inappropriate video, too quick for me to shut it off in time, and it's already done damage.
When a scary clown jumps out and screams, that's traumatizing, even just for a moment.
I have no trouble letting them watch all those other platforms. Heck, I let them watch PBS unsupervised.
But YouTube Kids will never play in my house again until I know that every piece of content on there has been reviewed by a human before it goes live.
- Traster 7y ago>YouTube is still trying to get away with "letting the machines do it", which works for most aspects of their business, but not this. Citation needed. I mean, they do use AI for lots of stuff, but let's not describe it as working. It has routinely caused massive aggravation for their biggest content creators, it has been one in a group of changes that has basically made Youtube an unsafe monetization platform and driven the creation of places like Patreon, Sure, this is the only AI fuck up that is going to get them sued in federal court and face charges of exploiting children, but it's not like the other AI stuff is working well. Basically, their AI is doing a bad job everywhere, it's just that this area is where they face legal liability and so they can't pull out their usual "but the machines told us to!" defence.
- jedberg 7y agoHeh, I was giving them the benefit of the doubt. They've been running on "algorithms" since 2005, and are still around, so I assume it works for them for some definition of working. But you have a point. YouTube and Google get a lot of flack for things that are emergent properties due to their lack of humans.
- NotATroll 7y agoTo be fair, they're the largest non-pornographic video platform. Making them an endless target for any and all abuse possible to grow channels quickly and earn ad revenue. It's inevitable that in such an environment the system they come up with ends up making less and less sense over time. It's death by a thousand cuts, and I don't think there's a good way to really avoid it.
- nocturnial 7y agoThat's a really schizophrenic argument. On the one hand because they are this large, they cannot currate content. On the other hand they are arguing because they are this large they are the only ones who can currate this content. I would feel more sympathetic to your argument if the companies wouldn't argue both cases at the same time.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- NotATroll 7y ago> I would feel more sympathetic to your argument if the companies wouldn't argue both cases at the same time. I don't really care about sympathy, so much as I care about reality. The companies will do as all companies do. Try to make money by garnering confidence in their product & abilities. Even if they have to lie through their teeth. Reality is, there isn't a good system (currently) to really curate massive amounts of user submitted video content, in an environment where anyone anywhere can submit said video content. The problem's scale is always going to lead towards either a compromise of being an open video platform, or a compromise in relation to curation.
- bduerst 7y agoThis is survivor bias. YouTube doesn't release many of the details of the methodology or even the content that they block because it can then be circumvented by the people who create and/or circulate it. It can create a streisand effect which only makes that type of content worse by drawing attention to it. Some of what you can see is in the child sexual abuse material (CSAM) APIs that Google is now sharing to help other organizations detect CSAM material en-masse in their content. These services that were originally built to do so on GMail, Drive, and Youtube.
- xmprt 7y agoAI is really bad ad making judgement calls on things like fair use, advertiser friendliness, controversial content (eg. LGBTQ content), and now whether or not a video is directed to kids. See https://www.cs.princeton.edu/~arvindn/talks/MIT-STS-AI-snakeoil.pdf https://www.cs.princeton.edu/~arvindn/talks/MIT-STS-AI-snake...
- w0m 7y agosame - too much curated content available to let the kids watch random YouTube videos
- senderista 7y agoJust whitelist channels or specific videos.
- jedberg 7y agoThat's called human curation. You're just putting the curation onus on me. Too much work. I'll just watch one of the many other services that do it for me.
- wolco 7y agoUse the family approved whitelist bundle your church has put out? It still can be someone else's problem.
- bduerst 7y agoIsn't that what playlists are for?
- jedberg 7y agoBut why? Every other streaming service for kids does this for me. YouTube definitely doesn't have anything special enough to warrant any special effort. Also, they still don't make it easy to lock down to just that content on every platform. I don't have to worry about this with the PBS Kids app. I know that no matter where it runs it will be safe. My house, grandma's house, whatever. Same with Netflix Kids. I don't have to worry about it having bad content anywhere my kid figures out how to use it.
- mda 7y agoThere are other things but first thing that comes to mind is tgat Youtube has several orders of magnitude more content than others. Netflix is not a similar service.
- ballenf 7y agoIt feels strange to me to compare a user-generated content site with a more traditional media platform. And then complain that the former doesn’t work like the latter. I’ve never really understood how YouTube Kids was even a thing.
- proc0 7y agoYou can't compare Netflix/Amazon with Youtube. The amount of content YT must deal with is multiple magnitudes larger. There is no way humans can handle that much content, that quickly and accurately. They really don't have a choice at that volume. Either machines learn to do it properly or there won't be any filtering at all as humans wouldn't be able to keep up.
- kenhwang 7y agoDo it by channel. Either a channel is approved for children content by a human or it isn't. Then just rereview periodically. There's much less churn in channels compared to the content.
- jedberg 7y agoThat wouldn't be good enough. The freaks who like to game the system with scary shit would just game that system too. They wouldn't care that they burned their channel. The only way this works is to have a human review every piece of content before it goes live, like every other streaming service with a kids section does.
- thekyle 7y agoWhy not just whitelist channels and disallow ones with less than say 500,000 subscribers. Surely nobody with that large of a following who produces kid targeted content would burn their own channel down just for the "lolz".
- wolco 7y agoThe fear is that unkid friendly video could get through so it would need to happen per video.
- Despegar 7y ago>You can't compare Netflix/Amazon with Youtube. Yes we absolutely can. YouTube's business model depending on user generated content is their choice. Not being able to review all the content is entirely a problem for Google to solve. Maybe they should stop optimizing for growth and put up some hurdles to who can upload content? That's for them to figure out.
- deith 7y agoI don't understand that thing with the scary clown jumping and screaming, or any other shocking content like that. What do they earn with those videos? Or are they just psychopaths?
- Izmaki 7y agoIt's entertainment meant for an older audience than small children, I suppose.
- bigcorpshill 7y agoYou can use the YouTube Kids app which has been hand curated. albeit, it's not as good yet but at least it's safe.
- jedberg 7y agoYouTube Kids is what I use and it is most certainly not hand curated. Or if it is, they need better hands, because they're terrible at it.
- Izmaki 7y agoDare I ask why you put your guards up against YouTube instead of either deciding that your kids are too young to use a tablet/smartphone/PC in general, or that sometimes contents is scary but it's OK to talk about? Ps: I'm not trying to change your mind, I'm trying to understand the reasoning behind it, coming from a more liberal raising and as a result a more relaxed attitude to what is banned and what is not banned.
- hamaluik 7y agoNot the OP, but we tried that with my daughter. It turns out that’s only a viable strategy if you’re willing to absolutely never use a phone or tablet or computer or tv in their presence, ever.
- jaxr 7y agoWhy is that? My daughter has an extremely restricted access to screens. I code for a living. She understands that is my work. She understands we consider she is too young to decide the contents she watches. And even when she doesn't understand, she understands it's not her call.
- Izmaki 7y agoThis. I was also not allowed to watch certain TV shows if they happened to air at a time where I wasn't put to bed yet. And don't get me started on magazines in the supermarket. I didn't understand why not, but I knew that disrespecting the rule was not worth getting my curiosity satisfied.
- hamaluik 7y agoYou were still allowed to watch TV shows then, I presume? Just like pretty much everyone I know? Our daughter is too, and we absolutely control what she can and can not watch. But in HN terms, YouTube is a massive foot-gun compared to other services. Auto-play very quickly leads you to trouble, and you can never quite trust YouTube to not re-enable it, or show thumbnails for inappropriate content at the end of a video. At our daughter's previous day home, the provider started letting her watch a YouTube channel called babybus (against our previous agreement of no TV, which was the straw that caused us to quit her service). At first glance the show is innocent enough, it's just a bunch of cartoon characters singing and going on adventures. But if you actually pay close attention to some (not all) of the episodes, its a weird fear-based morality show from China that threatens death if you don't behave a certain (rather authoritarian) way. The frustrating part about it is that there is a ton of really great kids' programming on YouTube that simply wouldn't be possible without it. It just takes an order of magnitude more effort to sort it out than pretty much any other service that provides content because you have to curate everything yourself.
- s3r3nity 7y ago> I used to let my kid watch YTKids while I supervised. I think this is where you lose me - why is allowing a child access to have un-tethered access to a content portal appropriate? i.e. why is the responsibility on the content portal (YouTube) and not the parent or supervisor? I might be a tad too much on the individual responsibility side of the spectrum here, but just like the old argument from the 90's ("The TV ain't a replacement for a babysitter...") I'm not sure the responsibility necessarily needs to be on the platform here over the parent/supervisor. One suggestion: You can create a white-list or playlist of pre-approved content creators and/or videos, and offer access that way.
- smt88 7y agoThe TV can't replace a babysitter, but it's still reasonable to expect content labeled for kids to be filtered. If YT can't and won't do it, they shouldn't label it as kids content. They have a separate product/brand for it, so it should be what it claims to be.
- meheleventyone 7y agoAnd the expectation is absolutely there because the YouTube Kids app is filtered but does a terrible job of it.
- powowow 7y agoWe generally trust that every page of a kids book will be roughly as expected given the title and author of the book. We trust the same of things like PBS kids programs. The same trust cannot be extended to YouTube.
- throwaway100773 7y agoIt’s easier and more fool proof to just not use it. That’s the point - their service isn’t working and it’s better for many parents to just tune it out. That’s parenting - avoid the shitty services that can’t put out a good product so you can focus your effort on something more meaningful. Or YouTube can fix the problem and it will be allowed in my household.
- 7y ago
- tssva 7y agoYouTube Kids allows you to select which specific channels your kids can watch including selecting from a list of "trusted partner" channels such as PBS Kids. When you 1st install YouTube Kids it leads you through these options.
- jedberg 7y agoThat's just putting the onus of human curation on me. Too much work. I'll just use one of the many other services that does it for me.
- deadmutex 7y agoIsn't it the same thing -- Whether you use PBS Kids app or choosing PBS Kids Channel on YT?
- nulbyte 7y agoI think the onus for curating a child's video content rightfully belongs on the one raising the child. How can YouTube (or any content creator) come up with a policy appropriate for everyone? Parents and guardians have different ideas of what their children should and should not watch.
- thret 7y agoFear of something that is not real like a scary clown could be seen as a good parenting opportunity. There are crocodiles.
- Cthulhu_ 7y agoWe're dealing with two year olds here, you know, the type that doesn't even have the ability to run away from danger even if they're able to recognize it, and even if they do they wouldn't be able to do much about it because, again, they're small children. They're children, not small adults.
- femiagbabiaka 7y agoThink about the depth of human suffering you’re asking to unlock with this request? Millions of YouTube videos get uploaded everyday, at least hundreds or thousands of those must be YTKids flagged. A white list of channels as offered now is much better until machine learning backed filtering gets a bit better.
- hinkley 7y agoYou're using a lot of words to say that Youtube doesn't have a viable business model. They don't. The cost of providing the service they pretend to provide would greatly exceed the income on that service. Even with the most aggressive advertising one could imagine.
- femiagbabiaka 7y agowhat? that's a wild strawman, but I think it's instructive -- I think this is actually a blind spot for a lot of techies. Point blank: I don't care if their business model is viable or not, I care about the service they provide to society. the service they provide (video hosting for free for anyone) is incredibly valuable, almost incalculably so for the amount of creation that it has inspired. the fact that kids can see it is just a side effect of the core value, and so they should provide tools for users to help them protect their children from content they don't want to see. But does that mean that they need to hire an ARMY of humans to do that? No, in fact even if they could afford it, that would be terrible!
- anticensor 7y agoThey might profit if automated modification of videos to insert covert advertising was permitted.
- danShumway 7y agoYou don't need to make a whitelist decision on everything though. Youtube Kids doesn't need to be like Facebook, it doesn't need to moderate everything that's posted. You can be highly exclusionary, you can ignore posts by smaller creators. It's fine for Youtube Kids to be a much smaller selection of manually curated videos from specific partners, because Youtube Kids isn't replacing Youtube as a whole. Given that their current solution basically kills ad revenue on those videos anyway, it's not like creators are going to be clamoring to be included on Youtube Kids in the first place. There's no harm in having a subset of Youtube that is highly gatekept, the same way that subsets like Youtube Red were. Go ahead and let Youtube itself stay as a kid-unfriendly, algorithmically moderated wild west with hidden bombs of objectionable content spread around. That doesn't need to be gotten rid of, just have one corner on a separate subdomain that's nice and safe for kids.
- maxk42 7y ago> they are leaving it up to the creator to decide if it's kids content. It's still not human curated. The word for this is "parent".
- Arbalest 7y agoUnless you are able to watch them every waking hour, this is simply not possible. At some point you have to cook, clean and generally do all the stuff that needs doing without worrying too much about your child hurting itself.
- wolco 7y agoWhat generally happens is you set rules and teach what is acceptable or not. When you are not around the kid is expected to follow the rules. Many kids do not follow these rules. They get punished and have valued things taken away. Some learn a lesson and will follow the rules and others do not. The ones who still don't listen have to be with you when you cook and clean. If you go out another parent/babysitter/old children will watch them.
- macintux 7y agoYou’re missing the point, I believe. What rules can you set in place such that your kids don’t accidentally see something explicitly targeting them with gore or other traumatic content? The only rule that seems to make that possible is “don’t use YouTube Kids”.
- maxk42 7y agoUnless you are able to watch them every waking hour, there's nothing preventing your child from clicking on a video which is NOT labeled child-friendly. It is not Youtube's responsibility to raise your children.
- Zenst 7y ago> This doesn't solve the number one problem of kids content on YouTube -- they are leaving it up to the creator to decide if it's kids content. It's still not human curated. You can imagine how Google would automate some nightmares otherwise. Say they look at the age of the people viewing it and if enough people below a certain age view it, they automatically class it as content for children. Of course ideally something in the middle would be a start, so they could see, what are children watching, let's check that out and see if it is in need of some 18+ filter or not. Given they must be doing some checks, as in age for logged in accounts and making sure adverts are not something not for children. >But YouTube Kids will never play in my house again until I know that every piece of content on there has been reviewed by a human before it goes live. Yes, as it stands the systems Google have in place are not secure and by that, unsuitable content could find its way to your children when you have done all the right things to prevent that. Equally there is the accountability. If PBS drops a boob at the wrong time when children are watching, it will get dealt with and process in place. If YourTube kids do that, nobody else may know as nobody is checking an individual's stream over a network broadcast. Let alone the same level of accountability and process.
- GillBates666 7y agoHeaven forbid our children see clowns or boobs. Think of the irreparable damage that has been done to them! NEVER AGAIN YOUTUBE
- Arbalest 7y agoMaybe it's time for piracy and people power to take over. Parents curate for other parents, perhaps parents that know each other. Use youtube-dl and other things. Have an open source app (You might have to get away from iOS for this) on a tablet that can watch this community curated content. wrt to piracy: keep in mind that parents are often relatively financially disadvantaged as well as being the most financially targeted group. Some parents turn to youtube rather than (say) disney+ for a reason. Those that can afford it do because it is less mind time and real time than having to do even community curation.
- xwowsersx 7y agoThe creator deciding isn't human curated?
- meheleventyone 7y agoNot when talking about platform curation.
- downandout 7y agoBut YouTube Kids will never play in my house again until I know that every piece of content on there has been reviewed by a human before it goes live. I don’t have kids, but this seems a bit over the top. Children live in the world with the rest of us, and are exposed to things every day that haven’t been reviewed and approved as child safe. Angry drivers on the road may flip you off or yell at you while your kid is in the car, or someone at a stop light may be blaring music that you find to be offensive and not approved for consumption by children. Both of these things would objectively be scarier than a clown on a computer screen, yet kids see and hear these things every day and somehow most of them don’t grow up to be serial killers. Sure, try your best to shield them from harmful content, but completely shutting down something that is 98% clean, educational, child friendly content seems like throwing the baby out with the bath water.
- zadokshi 7y agoYou clearly have never seen the type of content psychopaths splice into child targeted YouTube videos or you would not be making this argument. We are not talking about some mildly offensive or violent behaviour. We are talking about things that would be illegal to show on prime time TV (child and adult timeslots) 10 great child videos does not make up for 1 psychopathic murder scene spliced into video 11
- downandout 7y agoOP made no mention of “psychopathic murder scenes”. He referred to clowns coming out unexpectedly, which seems in poor taste on the part of the video creator but is a far cry from a “psychopathic murder scene”. I am quite certain that if such a scene were spliced into any video I watched, even as an adult, I would never watch YouTube again, and I would make some mention of it on social media. We live in a culture where even the slightest faux pas sparks widespread outrage across social media, yet I have never heard of this being a significant issue. So it seems like this is not a common occurrence. Have you ever personally witnessed a “psychopathic murder scene” being spliced into a YouTube video? Do 10% of videos really have this in them? I have never seen it once, in well over a decade of relatively heavy YouTube use. Most of my friends are in the tech scene and have children, and none of them have ever mentioned this as an issue either.
- awinder 7y agoDid the inappropriate content happen with a certain age range set? I totally believe this happens / feel like a bad parent for not cutting it off, but we have the app set on 2 year old and under and I’ve seen a lot of dumb stuff but nothing inappropriate yet. I’m just curious if this becomes an issue that boils down to where you set the age range or if I’m just playing an epically long game of Russian roulette right now.
- developer2 7y agoYou replied to a comment where their primary concern is, quote: "When a scary clown jumps out and screams, that's traumatizing". Not porn, sexual innuendo, or pedophiles looking for potential victims. Not war, or violence, or even brainwashing advertisements. It's clowns... their primary fear about YouTube's content is the possibility their sensitive child will be exposed to a clown. It's impossible to satisfy everyone, regardless of the content rules, and no mater how curated. YouTube could spend a billion dollars curating content, along with surveys where 90% of parents have to approve a video before it is included, and the remaining 10% would still be the vocal minority ruining it for everyone. Sure, YouTube probably doesn't do quite enough. But when you have parents looking to let YouTube babysit their 2-8 year old children without supervision, whose fault is that? YouTube's, I'm sure. /s
- _AzMoo 7y agoA scary clown. Like Pennywise. Randomly popping up and loudly screaming in the middle of an educational video about buses. I don't want my kids being exposed to that either, and I don't know any parents that would. The commenter wasn't talking about letting their children watch unsupervised, even supervising your children won't stop this type of thing from doing damage.
- barry-cotter 7y agoA video of a scary clown? Doing damage? Do you realize how insane you sound? That’s unpleasant. That’s scary. That could lead to nightmares. But damage? Even two year olds aren’t made of cotton wool.
- ajross 7y agoHow old are your kids? I watch my 8 and 11 year olds on YT Kids fairly routinely, and while lots of the content is kinda junky and of questionable quality (so many toy unboxings and eat-a-disgusting-thing videos...) I haven't personally seen anything I'd call "inappropriate". My complaint is the opposite: lots of good, sensible content (most recently I was trying to set up my youngest to watch drum cover videos) just isn't there because no one thought to put it there.
- xeonoex 7y agoI'm not the person you're replying to, but my daughter was able to use my wifes iPad when she was turned 1. I decided we should 'baby proof' it, remove YouTube (along with a few other apps), and add YouTube Kids. In many ways YouTube kids was worse than YouTube, since YouTube would have shown our suggestions. YouTube Kids is full of addicting, low effort content. Think toy unboxing, surprise eggs, videos with colors. Nothing thought provoking or educational. They're mindbogglingly boring, but they turn kids into zombies. And they get outraged if you take it away. You have to whitelist a few channels, then it works ok. Though my daughter is only 3 now, and would be happy watching Blippi all day. Seems like it would be more complicated to whitelist channels as kids get older.
- ajross 7y ago> Nothing thought provoking or educational. OK, that's just not true. There's a ton of great stuff on YT Kids (though as I mentioned not enough). But yes, you have to find it for them and show it to them yourself. Left to their own devices most kids aren't going to make good choices. They're kids, that's the point. This is just the "be a parent" thing, really. There's absolutely no way to get around the need to educate your own children. Certainly Google isn't going to do it for you. And Google certainly didn't invent junky content; I remember staring at Hanna-Barbera garbage constantly as a child.
- xeonoex 7y agoI didn't mean to say that there was nothing thought provoking or educational, just that YouTube wasn't showing it. It shows high view count, mindless, addictive videos. Even if you start with a good one. The funny thing is, I had to choose my child's age range (or enter the birth year or something) when setting up the app. Then, when I went to whitelist channel by channel, it had a bunch of recommended channels full of good/decent content. That should have been the default whitelist out of the box. It isn't just about "being a parent". My daughter is very smart for her age. My wife used to be a teacher, but since we had kids, she stays at home with them. She has taught my kids a lot. She has learned a good amount from content on YouTube, Netflix, and Disney. I think it's good that she can use an iPad better than my parents (even though she can't read). She also can solve puzzle games on her own. Of course we guide her and limit her usage. My point is that an app marketed to kids should not be full of garbage content.
- tmaly 7y agoYouTube still has some amazing content for kids. My solution has been to curate specific videos then embedd them in html pages and turn off the suggestions that would normally run at the video. Yes, it’s more work, but I see real benefits in this approach.
- mixmastamyk 7y agoAnd not just the content itself. Often enough the commercials are about movies brandishing guns and shooting folks. What in the f’ing f…? First thing I do on a kids device is ban the YouTube and similar apps and set web to a whitelist. Check the screen time settings.