19 ms·
Psilocybin found safe for consumption in largest ever controlled study
- sawyerjhood 7y agoI'm personally excited to see what sorts of new treatments will come out of using psychedelics medically. I've always been on the skeptical side of medical marijuana usage in all but the most extreme cases, but I have a feeling that LSD and psilocybin can really provide mental turning points and help people break out of depression.
- freedomben 7y agoI'm very optimistic as well. My family has hard-to-treat depression and there's a lot of reason to be optimistic about psilocybin. Michael Pollan's "How to Change Your Mind" was a fantastic read. It only makes me wonder what other possibilities have been out there but banned and therefore unavailable for study and experimentation. Luckily the days of censoring and hoarding information seem to be coming to an end. Of course as a society we love the pendulum effect. We'll swing it too far and then it will come back the opposite way too far (so much for my optimism :-P)
- tempsy 7y agoFrom my experience it's incorrect to think of psilocybin as some magic pill that will magically make your depression go away. I'm in the camp that depression is rarely just some "chemical imbalance" in the brain that you were unlucky to be born with, and yet that is how we currently think of it and treat it. It's most often the case there is something in one's past, very often from one's childhood, that has been avoided, and creates a chronic sense of worry/anxiety/depression that lingers. Psilocybin has the effect of ego death - it feels as though the subconscious hold you have on your brain that pushes down uncomfortable feelings or memories just goes away. This paired with therapy can be very powerful because you naturally become much more open to talk through distressing things that you otherwise normally numb over and helps you process past traumas much more efficiently.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- filoleg 7y agoAgreed. Imo, psilocybin won't just magically fix a chemical imbalance in your head. But it can open you up (for the duration of its effect) to some thoughts and ideas that could help you resolve your internal issues causing you depression, and those thoughts and realizations are what can help with getting rid of depression, as those realizations can stay with you even after the trip is over. Which is somewhat similar to what i have read about the ketamine therapy, which essentially just makes certain areas of your brain more neuroplastic for a short duration, helping you get out of your routine thought patterns and help create new neural pathways and reshape the existing ones easier. Note: I am not a brain researcher myself at all, so what I said could totally be just some pseudoscientific bs, but that's what I got after reading a bunch on both of the topic in a lot of places, including other HN threads. If you want to correct some misunderstandings in my post, please feel free to reply. I will be very happy to correct my misunderstandings.
- tempsy 7y agoyeah not sure why my comment was downvoted tbh. i guess there is a large segment of the population that thinks of illness as something that happens to them, and doesn't want to take responsibility in controlling or mitigating it without a so called magic pill.
- freedomben 7y ago> From my experience it's incorrect to think of psilocybin as some magic pill that will magically make your depression go away. I don't think you are accusing me of saying that, but just to be clear I completely agree with this. Michael Pollan's book also doesn't paint it as a "magic pill." No doubt some people assume that, but I don't believe it exists. I do wonder about the accuracy of Freudian ideas, such as something in ones childhood being the cause or at least playing a role. It's certainly possible. Being raised by depressed people sucks, and there's a lot of scars that probably contribute to why depression seems to be inherited.
- yarg 7y agoMagic mushrooms were the first substance to make me feel like myself after years and years of deep depression. But I didn't get quite the one hit, life changing state of mind that is often attributed to psychedelics. One thing that I have read is that the whole life-changing thing requires a transcendental experience - and that participants who failed to reach that echelon didn't experience long term improvement. I can't really comment on that - because I simply never reached that breakthrough dose. The biggest issue for me is that magic mushrooms taste kinda bad - it's rather hard to eat enough of them. Truffles on the other hand, are completely inoffensive - tasting (in some way) like a slightly off nut. I could quite happily snack on a big-ass bowl of those things, and watch enthralled as the world turned weird.
- pmoriarty 7y ago"Magic mushrooms were the first substance to make me feel like myself after years and years of deep depression. But I didn't get quite the one hit, life changing state of mind that is often attributed to psychedelics." Did you take them under the supervision of a trained psychedelic therapist, with the appropriate dose, with the right intention, in a therapeutic context, over multiple sessions, using a protocol designed for maximum therapeutic effect (which usually includes talk therapy both before and after the sessions)? Having the right set and setting are both absolutely critical to get the most out of psychedelics.
- dx87 7y agoThey're not talking about multiple sessions, they're talking about people advocating psychodelics who often claim that magic mushrooms are a wonder drug that you take once and it completely changes your outlook on life.
- pmoriarty 7y agoThere's no way to guarantee a powerful, life-changing experience. Some people do have one on their first try, some take more tries, others never do. All one can do is optimize the dose, set and setting to increase the odds that it'll happen.
- amelius 7y agoCurious about the mind-changing aspect. Will these drugs transform my personality type, e.g. from INTJ to ESFP?
- ergothus 7y ago> I've always been on the skeptical side of medical marijuana usage in all but the most extreme cases, Really? I've always found the milder claims fairly believable (fighting nausea or chronic low level pain relief). As an anecdote, I can attest to dealing with kidney stone pain well (rather than stopping the pain it reduced how much I noticed it) and it ended up more effective and felt less dangerous than the opiods I had used in the past. Some of the more "miracle" claims, however, seem pretty suspect to me and I'd want some reliable reseach. What makes you skeptical of so many claims?
- grawprog 7y agoI've definitely experienced the anti-inflammatory properties and the anti-nausea effects allowed my mom to keep food down while going through chemo. It was the only thing that would take away her nausea. I do agree with the parent poster about the more miraculous claims though and I think, personally those more miraculous claims create skepticism for the actual benefits. I kind of wish everyone took a more level headed approach to drugs in general. Every drug out there has some benefits and drawbacks. Without proper study, we're potentially missing many benefits and won't fully understand all the drawbacks. This includes approved pharmaceutical drugs too. Too many drugs get rushed out without fully understanding the side effects until people start suffering or dying.
- yarg 7y agoThe treatment of Dravet syndrome with CBD seems to have genuine damned near miraculous results. And yes, the pain relief is very real.
- derefr 7y agoPersonally, I'm a skeptic that 1. CBD+THC offers any additional medical† benefits over CBD used alone; 2. that it makes any medical sense to prescribe a (non-dose-controllable) plant over a pill, or at the very least an extract with tested dosage. I'm not skeptical of the medical benefits of (some of) the compounds in marijuana; I'm just a skeptic of prescribing marijuana itself as a way of delivering those compounds. It's like prescribing willow bark for a headache when aspirin exists. † For what it's being prescribed for, I mean—pain, nausea, anxiety, etc. THC, in its function as a psychedelic, may function as a treatment for certain psychiatric disorders (i.e. for much the same purpose LSD/MDMA/etc. are being investigated for.) But nobody's prescribing medical marijuana for this use-case right now; they're prescribing it for things where the presence of THC seems pretty irrelevant to the goal.
- mataug 7y ago> I've always been on the skeptical side of medical marijuana usage in all but the most extreme cases Really? A friend of mine had a similar experience to what @ergothus described in their comments. The friend had a biking accident and got stitches. To ease the pain the doctor prescribed Aadvil / Tylenol, but those drugs just caused diarrhea. So he tried edible marijuana[in a legal state] and it helped him a lot through a few weeks of painful recovery without any side effects. I find miracle claims suspect as well, I don't think marijuana cures cancer.
- ArtWomb 7y agoLow hanging fruit here may be ayahuasca / ibogaine treatment for symptoms of withdrawal from chronic opioid abuse. It sort of makes sense intuitively. If you you can just make it through the agony of junk sickness. You are in the clear. A 36-hour dose seems preternaturally suited. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5773453/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5773453/
- adamsea 7y agoThere’s a great book by Michael Pollan, called “Change Your Mind”, I think, which talks a lot about the history of psychedelic research in the US. Great read.
- alexpetralia 7y agoThis is a fantastic book. If anyone is interested in exploring the therapeutic uses of psilocybin in a safe, controlled setting, one of my best friends runs the Atman Retreat (recommended here by Pollan: https://michaelpollan.com/resources/psychedelics-resources/ https://michaelpollan.com/resources/psychedelics-resources/) Edit to add link: https://atmanretreat.com/ https://atmanretreat.com/
- say_it_as_it_is 7y agoSativa-dominant strains have psychedelic qualities, offering dramatic introspective, frame-shifting experience. It isn't as profound an experience as one from psilocybin, but that's not necessarily a bad thing. I've experienced realizations while under the influence of sativa dominant strains similar to, if not greater than, those uncovered during therapy with a psychologist. However, other times the re-framing of reality was simply fiction or not as epic as what it felt like while under the influence. Since the experience is so introspective for me, I partake in it sparingly, in the right settings where I can get the most medicinal value from it.
- yawned 7y agoThrowaway because I don't like to tell people I smoke. I must echo this entire post. I'm able to learn so much about myself when high. Far more personal than a therapist ever gets. I do introspection sessions after smoking. I smoke twice a week and do at most 5 hours of introspecting every week. This year I'm doing every other quarter. After smoking I think about how to better myself and insights just flow in perhaps about 3 really good ones a session. And while yes about 10% of my insights are incorrect it's not a problem to write them all down in your phone and verify in a couple hours. Doesn't seem like many people have similar experiences.
- say_it_as_it_is 7y agoTry listening to cognitive behavior therapy audio books while under the influence. I can't go too far into a chapter without pausing and losing myself in contemplation. Listening while under the influence is a great way to trigger introspection.
- yawned 7y agoHave any recommendations?
- throwbackThurs 7y agoSativa makes me go pretty bonkers, not in a good way. On the other hand Mushrooms and LSD are much more mild and therapeutic for my mind, even though the visual hallucinations are stronger. Personally I think weed is much more dangerous than LSD and mushrooms because it's done to such extreme quantities. E.g. the "smoke weed every day" motto is very dangerous for some.
- teslaberry 7y agoeverything is safe or unsafe depending on dose-age and frequency of use. click-bait stupid analysis / catchphrases /headlines about drugs are why the average conservative is quite rational in their approach to just thinking that the better advice for younger people is to simply abstain. the same applies to coffee. if you don't know how to use a drug properly you shouldn't use it. saying it 'is safe' is nonsense. TOTAL ABSURD NONSENSE. morphine is safe. it is used tens' of thousands of times a day by people in intensive care units around the u.s. , maybe millions. 'safe'. nothing is safe. everything is safe. what isn't safe is listening to nonsense.
- MobileVet 7y agoThis could dramatically improve my family’s life. Been following and supporting the research at Johns Hopkins since Tim Ferris brought attention to it.
- internet_user 7y agoSome charts and data: https://compasspathways.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/12/poster.pdf https://compasspathways.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/12/poste... "Psilocybin administration to healthy participants: safety and feasibility in a placebo-controlled study" "Poster presented at the 58th Annual Meeting of The American College of Neuropsychopharmacology, Orlando, FL, USA, 8–11 December 2019"
- arkades 7y agoThis is NOT a trial that was designed to assess the safety of psilocybin. This was a trial meant to show that a particular dosage of psilocybin is /safe enough/ to pursue further research in that dose range. This was a /phase one/ clinical trial. Phase One: administer small doses under very close supervision in a tiny number of people to determine whether it's immediately dangerous, or safe enough /for further study/. They used 89 - initial randomization of 30 each to placebo, 10mg, and 25mg. That's a good number for a phase one trial. But when we look at the sort of things that start hurting people when released to market, they're the sort of adverse effects that go undetected in trials with thousands of participants, and would need an infeasible large trial (>10k patients) to detect. This trial does not prove safety. This trial is meant to establish a dosing range that is /safe enough/ to participants to allow for further study. They found no "serious" adverse effects, in healthy volunteers - that is, not depressed patients. Can drugs like this have different effects in people w and without depression? Yes they most certainly can, in particular if those people are on concurrent medications (which they will be, since this is being developed for treatment-resistant depression). “We wanted to look at the safety and tolerability profile of our psilocybin, and to look at the feasibility of a model where up to six one-to-one sessions are held at the same time." No they didn't /want/ to - they /had/ to. This is article is just a press release. Phase 2 is generally a range of doses, within the range established in phase one, wherein we attempt to determine, to a rough level of accuracy, which doses show toxicity, which show therapeutic benefit, and at roughly what proportions. This phase is meant to determine what dose will be used in a phase 3 trial, if any dose exists with an appropriate proportion of therapeutic benefit to side effect. Phase 3 - a dose (or couple of doses) of a drug in a regimen meant to reflect real-world proposed usage is distributed and compared against either a currently used drug or a placebo. Depending on how big an effect is expected, how common the disease, etc. we'd look at trials of hundreds to thousands of patients. This is the trial where we get a real sense of safety, side effect profiles, efficacy, etc. This is the make-or-break line for getting your drug to market. Phase 4 "trial" - aftermarket surveillance. Goes on for years after a drug hits market, because there's no trial that comes to close to capturing the rare side effects that may be visible when applied to the general population. This was, also, presented to a neuropsychopharm conference, not published data. Which is to say, they're ready to brag about it, but they're not ready to submit themselves to close scrutiny.
- maxkwallace 7y agoRelated: How To Change Your Mind is worth reading. It covers the history of psilocybin & LSD research including the early parts of this recent resurgence in interest.
- kasperni 7y agoNow that mainstream club drugs such as MDMA, Ketamine, and LSD/Magic Mushrooms are finding their way into therapeutic usage. I'm wondering if and how governments will change the current narrative about "all drugs are bad for you". Edit: I'm not advocating recreational drug usage. Just saying, that if mum is on magic mushrooms and studies like these have established safety dosage and clear therapeutic benefits. You can't really tell your teenager that they are going to go crazy if they try some.
- mikelyons 7y agoMDMA, Ketamine and LSD sure, but mushrooms have been in use for spirituality far longer than mainstream clubs have even been a concept.
- kasperni 7y agoRight, but they haven't been classified as an illegal drug in most countries until recently.
- scarejunba 7y agoAnd K started with medical use.
- warent 7y agoAs long as it's popular understand and opinion of drugs, then ultimately democratic/representative governments are going to have to start changing the narrative if they want to stay in office
- vmchale 7y agoI don't think Psilocybin mushrooms or LSD are used as a club drug.
- kasperni 7y agoI think it depends on the definition, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Club_drug https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Club_drug includes them
- mothsonasloth 7y agoI'm gonna sound really cliched but I have become really fascinated with Psychedelics thanks to the Joe Rogan podcast. I wouldn't say I am depressed but as someone who doesn't drink, smoke, drugs or take caffeine. I really want to try them. The fact that mushrooms have been used by shamans all around the world since neolithic times, is truly fascinating. I hope to try them at some point although at the moment I have been trying Sensory Deprivation Tanks and it really has reset my mind and emotions.
- ianai 7y agoI’d steer you toward kava kava as a legal and otc way to change your mind and emotions for the better or more open. Also St. John’s wort.
- r00fus 7y agoWhat source would you recommend? I've tried some name-brand kava tea and it didn't seem to do much.
- ianai 7y agoI’ve had extracts that didn’t do much. Pills of the powder have helped. The biggest experience I had was with the full on blending of the powder in a blender following a YouTube recipe video-wakacon from amazon.
- orasis 7y agoIf you want to get high, by the bulk kava powder from Amazon, but it tastes absolutely terrible. For day to day use try the Yogi Tea with kava in it. It has cardamom so actually tastes good. The dose is very low so you’d need 3+ teabags to feel anything.
- markdown 7y agoAvoid any product called "kava tea". It's not tea and can't be drunk like tea. Kavalactones aren't water soluble so simply steeping a teabag filled with powdered kava root in water won't do anything. Head over to /r/kava and the read the FAQ in the sidebar which includes a list of recommended vendors (and which ones to avoid).
- iseedumbpeople 7y agoOh please this is pure propaganda. Even the great Terrance McKenna had to stop doing shrooms later in life because a bad trip fucked him up so badly. The potential for misuse and serious psychological dissociation is huge for anyone who is depressed and abusee psilocybin. Micro dosing and/orhaving a few wondrous trips is great if you come at it with a good headspace. Use it as a crutch after a break up or while surrounded by toxic people and you are most likely in for a very bad time that many may not be equipped to deal wih.
- iseedumbpeople 7y agoBe warned the... the SF crazies are flagging anything critical of this article.
- iseedumbpeople 7y agoWhy is critical discussion being flagged?
- iseedumbpeople 7y agoSad to see the censorship on this website flagging all critical thought. It's a good example of the dangers of censorship pushed by the so called "liberals" who are really just dangerous facists.
- aargh_aargh 7y agoThe study seems to be this one: https://doi.org/10.3389/fphar.2017.00974 https://doi.org/10.3389/fphar.2017.00974 Would it kill the PopSci article to include the DOI to the actual study?
- yellow_lead 7y agoPossibly of interest to others > Post capsule ingestion, patients lay with eyes closed and listened to music pre-selected by the research team (Kaelen et al., 2017) (https://www.mixcloud.com/MendelKa/playlists/psilocybin-v13/ https://www.mixcloud.com/MendelKa/playlists/psilocybin-v13/).
- oceliker 7y agoA more relevant poster from last month: http://www.compasspathways-posters.com/ACNP2019_Rucker_poster.pdf http://www.compasspathways-posters.com/ACNP2019_Rucker_poste... I don't think these results are published in a paper yet.
- dang 7y agoOK, we've changed to that from https://www.independent.co.uk/news/health/magic-mushroom-depression-psilocybin-trials-kcl-mental-health-addiction-a9251451.html https://www.independent.co.uk/news/health/magic-mushroom-dep.... Thanks!
- driverdan 7y agoThat's not the correct study. That one is from 2017 and published in 2018. The newest one used 89 patients.
- iseedumbpeople 7y agoThere is a dangerous pro drug agenda being pushed here. The owners of this website are not good people.
- every 7y agoI was performing my own informal tests on various psychoactive agents in the late 60's and early 70's and can attest to the efficacy of psilocybin, as best as I can remember...
- say_it_as_it_is 7y agoDon't rush out and take mushrooms. If you're not taking it in a clinical setting, you're doing it wrong.
- jonfw 7y ago> If you're not taking it in a clinical setting, you're doing it wrong. I'd be interested to see some support for this statement.
- throwawaypa123 7y agoif you take mushrooms you will abandon the simplistic view implied by your statement.
- mikelyons 7y agoIMO There is a much better case for: if you're not taking it in a spiritual setting you're doing it wrong. Anecdotally I've had the bad experience and the life-changing transcendent experience, all self-directed. In my experience. It's not good for partying, but it's very good for meditating and inquiring deep into the nature of your being, what reality is, what Love is and what God is. I've had long periods in my life of being a hard-line rationalist atheist. And I've had direct encounters with God. If there is one thing I learned it's this: You can't take anything as a belief you have to validate it in your direct experience.
- cityzen 7y agoAwesome! Can't wait until 2030 when it is legal in a handful of states in the US.
- newnewpdro 7y agoOne day we'll be able to buy Psilocybin supplements on the shelves of stores like CBD, 5-HTP, and St. Johns Wort today. In small doses it's super useful and seems to be relatively benign.
- goldcd 7y agoThis is sub-anecdotal, I know - but I recently after many years of "don't mess with my head" took mirtazapine for mild-depression/over-awareness-of-the-actual-state-of-the-world-around-me. I feel better. Only noticeable effects were that I fell asleep much faster and woke up (refreshed) remembering all manner of weird clear dreams. Previously was one of those people who for the last decade couldn't recall a single dream (and had trouble nodding off). My random guess is that dreaming/tripping just loosens the mind up.. maybe like a deep tissue massage for the mind.. allowing things to mentally move about a bit and drop back into place (or mentally gives your mind a chance to beat the previous day into manageable lumps)
- pmoriarty 7y ago"I fell asleep much faster and woke up (refreshed) remembering all manner of weird clear dreams. Previously was one of those people who for the last decade couldn't recall a single dream (and had trouble nodding off)." Just another anecdote, but I've found many techniques that have worked for me to greatly enhance my dream recall that don't require any drugs. The first technique is just to get interested in dreams, read up about them, study techniques of dream recall, dream analysis, the science of sleep/dreams, etc. The second is to have an intention to remember your dreams when you wake up, and consciously focus on that intention before you go to sleep. Third, when going to sleep try to remember your day in reverse, from the moment you laid down in bed back through your day to when you got up that morning. The theory is that you're kind of priming your mind to think back to your dream when you wake. Next, as soon as you wake up write even the smallest little thing that you remember about your dreams down on paper. Alternatively, you can record your dream in a voice recorder, which is what I do as I find it much faster and more convenient than writing. Something else that I've noticed is that if I move my body when I wake, it can adversely affect dream recall, so I try to stay as still and as much as possible maintain the exact body position that I woke up in while I record the dream. Also, when I have a really long dream to record, I found that I would often forget the end of dream while writing it down, as writing all the details down would take too long and by the time I got half-way through I'd forget. So I suggest writing down some key words and images first, and then go back and fill in the details afterwards. The words and images you've written down will help you remember. Then, what's helped me is to go over my dreams and try to make sense of them, look for patterns in them, and try to see the connection between them and my waking life. I've found they have a lot of meaning and aren't just "random neuronal noise" that some people make them out to be. Using these techniques and others, and just taking dreams seriously and being interested in them led me to go from remembering maybe one dream every three months to remembering three long dreams every night, and filled up hundreds of pages in my dream journal with records of dreams and dream analysis. The downside is that doing this takes a lot of time, so I stopped after a while, and lost interest in dreams, and went back to very rarely remembering my dreams.
- proc0 7y agoRecently tried shrooms for the first time and was a bit underwhelmed, but not sure if I'm micro-dosing or what. Tried the regular variety and some other allegedly Thai shrooms, which definitely had a stronger effect. I tried a few stems at first, and then ramped up the dosage with slightly more 'visuals', but it's like I have to eat a whole handful or just let my body learn to process it or something.
- curryst 7y agoFrom what I've heard (no real scientific data to back this) the stems contain very little psylocibin. And the dosage for mushrooms is surprisingly high. For run of the mill strains, I believe 3.5 grams is considered a standard dose. Which is still not a blast you off the planet amount, but enough to experience visual distortions and euphoria.
- mnm1 7y agoThe stems are the most potent part of the specimen. The caps have less psylocibin than the stems. If you bruise the fresh (and sometimes dry) specimen, you can see it turn blue. That indicates the presence of psylocibin. The smaller the specimens, the more psylocibin per gram you will have in a dose as there is significant psylocibin even in tiny specimens, including ones that have barely formed caps.
- orasis 7y agoOn some strains 3.5 grams is a serious therapeutic dose requiring a sitter. My last trip was about this much with another 1.5 set aside but I was blasted out of time and space and opted not to re-up. It all depends on the strain.
- tnecniv 7y agoTypically you have to eat a whole bunch if your goal is to trip. Since they don't taste very good, people often eat them with other fun to help mask the taste (pickles, peanut butter, etc). I'm sure you can find dosage guides online easily enough.
- bookAlot 7y agoI'm posting as fast as I can
- stefek99 7y agoMajority of my mental energy in relation to drugs, some consideration: - having a mortgage and life insurance attached to it - parents prevented contact with their children due to government intervention - people in jail for possession of drugs - safe driving limits - undoing 50+ years of propaganda and social conditioning
- ngokevin 7y agoCould become legalized? https://www.forbes.com/sites/tomangell/2019/12/16/andrew-yang-wants-to-make-psychedelic-mushrooms-more-freely-available/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/tomangell/2019/12/16/andrew-yan...
- wolfspider 7y agoYes no doubt they’ve found it safe when allowing for the effects to fully wear off and at a certain dosage. Chemicals of this class are similar in structure to serotonin itself and do the opposite of SSRIs. This would mean the therapy is meant to go straight through problems regarding depression not simply make one happier. Generally speaking psylocibin is more prone to culminate in a really bad trip than delysid if the participant doesn’t have their mind settled! This is also dependent on how it’s isolated and from what. Oregon azurescens raised in wood chips is much more mellow and yet stronger than other varieties for example. Migraines are an extremely good use case but factors of depression can vary so wildly I’m not really convinced it would be a silver bullet. If nothing else works then maybe it would do the trick. Don’t play with magic unless you want to be tricked.
- pmoriarty 7y ago"Generally speaking psylocibin is more prone to culminate in a really bad trip than delysid if the participant doesn’t have their mind settled" One of the most interesting interviews about psychedelics that I've heard is one with Stanislav Grof, who personally supervised over 4,500 LSD sessions throughout his life (many of them during his research in to its effects, back when LSD was legal) and at about 1 hour and 56 minutes in to the interview he said: "If somebody has a bad trip that means they are dealing with a difficult aspect of their unconscious and when it's coming up, it's coming up for healing... people can benefit from bad trips. I saw many of those situations where people experience what they would be hospitalized for in the psychedelic sessions, and if we stayed with it, it would actually be a major healing, a major transformation."[1] I also found in my own experience that my bad trips were the ones that I learned the most from and the ones that I found the most beneficial, because they would force me to face my demons and other major issues that I would avoid facing in my sober state of consciousness. Interestingly, the study this HN post links to seems to refer to something like this: "Recent work has sought to develop and validate a measure that is sensitive to difficult or challenging psychedelic experiences (Barrett et al., 2016; Carbonaro et al., 2016) and there is some evidence that the intensity of such experiences is predictive of positive long-term outcomes, whereas the duration of struggle is predictive of negative outcomes (Carbonaro et al., 2016). This is presumably because the successful resolution of conflict brings with it, insight and relief, whereas the failure to breakthrough perpetuates suffering." My impression from listening to and reading many interviews with veteran psychedelic researchers (who did studies with pretty massive doses of psychedelics back in the 60's) is that they seem to believe that an inability to "break through" was due to having too low a dose, and I wonder if that's the case in the unresolved difficult experiences this study refers to. On the other hand, too high a dose of psychedelics can result in post-trip amnesia (and current psychedlic researchers seem to be erring on the side of caution and give moderate doses). So there's probably some good middle ground. [1] - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3mdYUmvTeig https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3mdYUmvTeig
- coffeemug 7y agoCounter-anecdote: I've experimented with this stuff extensively in various settings and have known many other people who did, and in my experience it's unequivocally bullshit. Here's what happens. First, any given trip alleviates depression for about a month or two. That makes sense to me in a sense that the word "trip" isn't a coincidence-- a really fun intense vacation in a foreign country also alleviates depression for a month or two. You swear that when you come back things will be different, but then you have to answer slack messages at 9pm, and your project is slipping at work, and your wife is flirting with strangers every time you go to a bar, and well... in a month or two you're back to feeling exactly the same way you did before (until you take the next vacation). Second, people who discover psychedelics go on a multiyear quest for enlightenment. They keep taking various drugs, keep feeling like they understand things better and better, get sucked into the psychedelic social vortex of other truth-seekers, and generally believe that their life is full of meaning and is going to turn around at any moment. Except by any objective measure they're still nervous wrecks-- they have every physiological symptom of stress and depression, and aside from temporary alleviation of their symptoms (see part one), they always regress to the mean. Third, after a few years of this people eventually reach a fork. Most people realize that their psychonautic journey is at best leading them in circles, and at worst is causing their life to spiral down the drain. So they give it up, get a job without 9pm slack messages (or find a better way to adjust to stress), marry someone who isn't constantly on the verge of cheating, start doing regular exercise, and generally find a way to settle into a reasonably balanced life. A small minority of people double down, grow out their (usually grey by then) hair down to their shoulders, go to festivals and workshops, talk of energy and chi and chakras, stare into the eyes of strangers, and touch each other's faces. Generally speaking, I haven't run into anyone yet who found a third path. So, while I'd be the first to admit I'm wrong and celebrate if this proves to actually work, if I were a betting man I'd bet against at any reasonable odds and sleep secure in the knowledge that my money is safe.
- pmoriarty 7y agoCounter-counter anecdote: I was just listening to an interview[1] with Dennis McKenna[2] (brother of Terence McKenna[3]) in which he said: "If I'm going to take it [a psychedelic substance] I'm going to pay attention to it. It's sort of like you have an opportunity to sit with someone who's very wise and they have stuff to tell you and so they deserve that respect. That's what's changed. I give it my respect. "And sometimes people say, well, you've been doing this 50 years haven't you got the lesson yet? .. there's one perspective that says 'once you get the message hang up the phone'. "Well, maybe I'm a slow learner but I'm still learning from these things. They're not like an answering machine. It's not like there's only one message. "It's like if you had a mentor, a teacher, someone who you respect you're not going to reach a point where you say, 'well, basically I've learned everything you have to tell me so thank you very much and I'll be on my way.' Chances are they still know more and they always will know more than you will know. "Every time I take ayahuasca or mushrooms I learn something new or I am reminded of what I've forgotten, what's easy to forget in the day-to-day hustle of life. I just feel it's still valuable. In some ways it's a touchstone. It's a way of getting back to that place, that sacred space, sacred time environment where you can remind yourself of the eternal truths." Second counter-anecdote: Ram Dass[4], in his 80's after suffering a stroke, when asked in an interview that I can't find at the moment about what LSD has done for him replied "I'm happy. I've had a stroke and I'm happy. That's LSD." [1] - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KGYm5OdvwNs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KGYm5OdvwNs [2] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dennis_McKenna https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dennis_McKenna [3] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Terrence_McKenna https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Terrence_McKenna [4] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ram_dass https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ram_dass
- mgarfias 7y agoHow the hell do I get into one of these trials?
- zimbu668 7y agoI got in to one of those trials when someone posted the sign up link on HackerNews and I applied. If you're near Baltimore you could see if you are a match for any of their current studies: https://hopkinspsychedelic.org/ https://hopkinspsychedelic.org/ Other in process research studies: https://maps.org/other-psychedelic-research/211-psilocybin-research/psilocybin-studies-in-progress/research/psilo/passiepsilocybin1.html%7D https://maps.org/other-psychedelic-research/211-psilocybin-r...
- mistermann 7y agoI'm curious what the sample size is in this study?
- mikelyons 7y ago6th paragraph > ... 89 healthy volunteers.
- mistermann 7y agoSorry, I was tongue-in-cheekly referring to @coffeemug's study.
- mikelyons 7y agoYou're fine, I just wanted to be helpful :)
- csstanton 7y agook boomer
- uyuioi 7y agoAlways safe. Only it can’t be patented is why you never got it!