11 ms·
The FAA Proposal for Drone Remote ID
- mgrennan 7y agoHas anyone seen a RID device? Are any available? Approved? Will this be a "LAW before the device" like CA Gun Microstamping?
- madengr 7y agoIs there an aircraft size where ADS-B is required?
- Zombieball 7y agoI don’t believe aircraft size matters. It depends on what airspace you operate the aircraft within.
- CrazyStat 7y agoNo. In fact the proposed regulations specifically disallows drones from using ADS-B unless they have filed a flight plan and the pilot is on radio with ATC, or certain other exceptions. This is due to concerns about overcrowding the ADS-B spectrum.
- jrockway 7y agoIt is unfortunate that “NextGen ATC” hit its scalability limit just a few days before it became mandatory. Maybe ADS-B-v6 will save us ;)
- markbnj 7y agoPerhaps relevant: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gnSeOR3nnx0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gnSeOR3nnx0 [avweb discussion of ADS-B requirements]
- pg_is_a_butt 7y agoThe YouTube video explaining how to disable it will be here in 20 minutes.
- CrazyStat 7y agoDirect link to proposed regulations (PDF): https://s3.amazonaws.com/public-inspection.federalregister.gov/2019-28100.pdf https://s3.amazonaws.com/public-inspection.federalregister.g...
- awalton 7y agoYikes. Was kinda hoping to see it just be an NFC sticker you have to slap on your drone after registration, but this reads like they want an active radio and per-flight generated IDs, the devices need internet connections and all kinds of business that precludes entire categories of lightweight UASes. This is definitely going to be stifling to the market if it's enforced in the slightest. It also rules out using ADS-B on drone aircraft entirely, which is a bit perplexing.
- sixdimensional 7y agoDid you hear that they are having privacy concerns for the 24 bit ICAO aircraft address which is broadcast by ADS-B transponders now?? There are a bunch of companies petitioning for a temporary anonymous private address process that only the FAA would be able to track. Why did they bother to invent a publicly broadcast address if it wasn't intended to be used that way!?
- Maxious 7y ago> The Privacy ICAO Address (PIA) program is now available. https://www.faa.gov/nextgen/equipadsb/privacy/ https://www.faa.gov/nextgen/equipadsb/privacy/
- blantonl 7y agoThis will be easily defeatable with a crowd-sourced database. It is not even close to easy to be able to change an ADS-B out ICAO address in avionics right now, so periodically changing these addresses won't happen in production. When will people realize that security by obscurity doesn't work?
- tjohns 7y agoADS-B has always had an "anonymous" option for aircraft using the UAT uplink, as long as they're squawking 1200/VFR. (Similarly, there's long been a way to request that specific aircraft are hidden from the FAA's public radar feeds.) Aircraft using the 1090ES uplink can't take advantage of the privacy mode, because it's based on top of Mode S, which is an older protocol and never had privacy built in - it didn't need it before because Mode S just didn't include position data. (We'll ignore Mode S multilateration, which is a recent development.) The private ICAO addresses are a hack to provide similar functionality as UAT. > Why did they bother to invent a publicly broadcast address if it wasn't intended to be used that way!? Because those addresses were invented for Mode S, which didn't broadcast position. It was part of the secondary radar (transponder) system, and needed to be paired with primary radar to get something useful.
- TrueDuality 7y agoStandard remote identification UAS would be required to broadcast identification and location information directly from the unmanned aircraft and simultaneously transmit that same information to a Remote ID USS through an internet connection. Limited remote identification UAS would be required to transmit information through the internet only, with no broadcast requirements; however, the unmanned aircraft would be designed to operate no more than 400 feet from the control station. This requires all drones to be internet connected. That's a crazy requirement, and a crazy extra risk.
- zeta0134 7y agoBlock quote for mobile users. Please use block quotes (>) for quotes, rather than indenting which causes horizonal scrolling on mobile > Standard remote identification UAS would be required to broadcast identification and location information directly from the unmanned aircraft and simultaneously transmit that same information to a Remote ID USS through an internet connection. Limited remote identification UAS would be required to transmit information through the internet only, with no broadcast requirements; however, the unmanned aircraft would be designed to operate no more than 400 feet from the control station.
- TrueDuality 7y agoMy bad I tried that at first but it didn't seem to work. I'll use them in the future.
- kbenson 7y agoAngle brackets don't actually create block quotes here, but if you just put one in front of the long wrapping text people will get the idea. The indent formatting works best for code, as it doesn't wrap and preserves newlines, but on mobile it will cause scrollbars within the comment for the same reason, making it very hard to read. It feels weird to use a single angle bracket for it all because we're conditioned by mail clients to do one per line, but that just doesn't work well here. Alternatively, italicizing quoted text with asterisks around the block usually works, since the core of what you usually want is just to visually distinguish something you are repeating for context and your own comments on it.
- yellow_lead 7y agoEnforcement of this should be interesting. Probably can't do much besides restricting sale.
- sillysaurusx 7y agoWhat penalties would someone face if they ignore this particular regulation? I didn’t see any listed on the site. But are we talking a few thousand in fines, or prison time?
- blhack 7y agoI wish all these rules just said: does not apply when flying below 200’ AGL. Very frustrating to see that this industry is likely going to get stopped before it even gets started.
- userbinator 7y agoExcept around places like airports, of course.
- janoc 7y agoWell, the entire problem is that in the current situation the "below 200' AGL" is completely unenforceable. The same with the line of sight restrictions, not flying around airports, etc. That's why they are creating regulations because the current softball rules are simply being ignored and the law enforcement and regulators have no means to catch the violators nor to prove their guilt. The result is this heavy-handed nonsense, but the drone owners have only themselves to blame here. E.g. RC plane/heli pilots were never this kind of nuisance requiring such heavy handed regulation. The other aspect is that this regulation isn't being made just for hobby pilots. It is likely meant to cover the upcoming commercial services (e.g. goods delivery by a drone, TV crew drone usage, etc.) that are impossible today without waivers issued on a case by case basis. A transponder on a large 10-20kg drone is nothing.
- godelski 7y agoWhy not just limit drones to class G air space? Even in dense locations this gives plenty of room to fly in. This also restricts drones from flying too close to airports. This is unrestricted air space anyway.
- NovemberWhiskey 7y agosUAS (flown either as either hobbyist flights or under Part 107) are already restricted to Class G airspace without a LAANC authorization.
- burfog 7y agoIt's long past time to raise the altitudes. Aircraft typically need to stay above 500, and toys below 400. We could move aircraft up to a minimum of 2000, move the toys up to a maximum of 1000, and let the serious fancy big drones have 1200 to 1800.
- mdip 7y agoI'm curious about how dramatically this will affect the price of drones. I did a skim-read of the PDF but couldn't find specifics about what size of craft/properties of the craft this would apply to. Would it apply to the little hand-held $14 thing that was used for exactly one hour on Christmas before it was destroyed? Even outside of the "disposable/toy" market -- Amazon has a number of $100-$200 drones that are quite capable, with video/GPS and a lot of the features that would have been found only on $1000 drones a couple of years ago. Adding regulation[0] greatly affects hobbiest builders. I'm going to avoid tinkering around with things that could result in me having to explain myself to a judge. And it affects the target market for these $100/$200 drones. Do I want to go through the trouble of ensuring I'm not violating a hundred-page rule just "for my own entertainment"? I'm not saying the regulation isn't needed. Frankly, I haven't spent time understanding the problem well enough to make that determination. I'm just wondering how well this balances preventing a drone-related catastrophe against the harm it will cause to the overall sector. [0] Especially if it's the sort that are required to be complied with in order to be offered for sale
- TrueDuality 7y agoThere are no size restrictions, the only exception is hobby built ones but this also proposes those can only fly in certain designated places. limited exceptions, which include certain amateur-built UAS and UAS manufactured prior to the compliance date, operators flying UAS without remote identification capabilities would be permitted to fly only at certain specific geographic areas established under this rule specifically to accommodate them.
- gibolt 7y agoThe Mavic Mini that was released last month is a fully-capable drone. It is one gram less than the 250g classification requiring registration. I assume that will be the limit here as well
- avip 7y agoThe mini is exempted for recreational activity only [0]. DJI is aware of remote identification requirements, it's on their product roadmap. [0] https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2019/05/17/2019-10169/exception-for-limited-recreational-operations-of-unmanned-aircraft https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2019/05/17/2019-10...
- kick 7y agoThe way this is implemented, it would be trivial to spoof, wouldn't it? It seems like only a matter of time before the people who pushed this regulation feel the brunt of that.
- awalton 7y ago> The way this is implemented, it would be trivial to spoof, wouldn't it? Yeah but that's pretty much the case with anything flying today. The idea that it's breaking federal law to spoof the ID and that it's relatively easy to catch the guilty party due to the short range of the transceiver is deterrent enough. It's the equivalent of swapping car license plates, only with a greater likelihood and penalty of being busted.
- alasdair_ 7y ago>it's relatively easy to catch the guilty party due to the short range of the transceiver There are lots of GPS-guided drones that don't need to talk to a transceiver mid-flight.
- TrueDuality 7y agoThere is a lot of content in here that seem like its intentionally created for getting money out of people and the government. * Drones will require an internet connection (might be able to get away with a connection via a cell phone or something, but that'll likely prove unreliable) * Additional radio hardware will be required in some cases as well * The FCC will subcontract out to a specific company receiving all of the drone reports * No discussion of protocol, so will largely be designed and specified by the internet contractor... Which history has proven will be a heavy protocol... So larger CPU requirements to comply...
- cjbprime 7y agoThe fact that complying with a regulation will involve spending money does not imply that a purpose of the regulation is to extract money. It costs money to make buildings fire-safe, too.
- robomartin 7y agoAll legislation tends to be reactive rather than proactive. The drone industry, in my opinion, has been rather irresponsible about educating their customers. As a result you have people flying drones in places, at times and altitudes they should not. A few years ago, where I live, we had a rash of new drone owners doing stupid crap like flying over homes, roads, highways, parks and supermarket parking lots, to name a few. This culminated with the inevitable. Someone got hurt, badly, when a drone fell out of the sky. The drone owner/operator got arrested. They ended-up in jail and lost their home in the lawsuit that followed. Pretty f-ing stupid behavior if you ask me. As someone who has been designing, building and flying all kinds of remote controlled aircraft for somewhere around 35 years, I have been looking at what the consumer side of the drone industry has been doing with horror. I have crashed so many aircraft and helicopters I can't even list them. I am not talking about cheap toys either. My highest cost crash was $6,000 in one day. The point is these things are toys made with toy-grade electronics. They are nowhere near reliable enough to dare fly over structures, people or roads unless the pilot is willing to face the consequences of killing one or more people and possibly burning down an entire neighborhood. Having done extensive work in aerospace I know full-well what proper fault-tolerant design looks like --cause I have many fault-tolerant designs under my belt. These things are not even close to being safe enough to fly over a crowd of kids at the park or above a neighborhood. And yet it happens all the time. The industry has had an opportunity to address these issues, either technologically, through education or both. And they have note. Therefore, they are slowly being constrained through precisely the legislation they deserve to have to face. One of the things I said years ago as drones started to become popular and people started to do stupid things with them was that "these people are going to ruin the model aircraft hobby for everyone". I am sad to say I was right. They are doing precisely that and more. Not sure if there are any solutions at this point other than the kind of legislation responsible drone owners do not need and do not want. Oddly enough this is precisely the same situation we have in the US with the firearm issue. Responsible firearm owners don't need legislation to be, well, responsible law-abiding citizens who harm nobody. Those who are in a range between careless and demented are the one's who ruin it for everyone else. This is now happening to drones. Same thing. Different hardware.
- akersten 7y ago
- dehrmann 7y agoIs this stricter than rules for small, manned propeller aircraft? Arguably, they should be because there's a cost and training hurdle to being a pilot that isn't there for drones, so the risk drones pose to safety is greater than the average Cessna pilot.
- EGreg 7y agoI support this Because think of all the rogue actors who can deploy anonymous drones including from other countries Right now all our skies are clear but once we have a lot of drone traffic, we may have really bad stuff happen. It takes just one drone flying over a crowd to cause massive problems. Let alone a coordinated attack in multiple areas. If you don’t know who to go after, to make an example of, after a crime (what if a drone drops grenades??) then you should be catching this drone with a net and disabling it. Drones are the first type of robot that will be in PUBLIC PLACES which is cheap to produce. Autonomous cars are dangerous but expensive so we will not likely encounter cars which are unregistered and we don’t know who made them. But w drones it’s easy!! To the downvoters: can you speak about how you would address the danger? Let’s have a conversation
- ceejayoz 7y agoYou think folks making a coordinated drone attack are going to willingly install Remote ID in their drones, under their real, traceable identities? If a drone drops grenades, you'll probably have little trouble tracing the grenades.
- mileycyrusXOXO 7y agoReminder: downvotes are for comments that do not add value to the conversation, not for opinions you disagree with. Instead, if you disagree with someone you should contribute to the conversation by leaving a comment stating why you disagree.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- ggreer 7y agoThis will not deter competent attackers or help catch them. Disabling remote ID will be as easy as jailbreaking your phone. The hard part of a drone attack would still be sourcing explosives and modifying drones to carry and deploy such payloads.
- godelski 7y ago> To the downvoters: can you speak about how you would address the danger? Let’s have a conversation. Your concern seems to be about bad actors. Yet you also mention how easy and cheap drones are to build. There's thousands of online tutorials showing how to build them for extremely cheap. So how does this solution address the problem of bad actors? Bad actors are just not going to install the identification methods or remove them from commercial bought drones. With a radio based system the only way you have to track these people down is arrays of radios to track signals (automated fox hunting). But that doesn't scale well. Tracking drones is really a difficult problem. So considering that, what does this do other than harm good actors? Most of the problems are really uninformed actors. Punishing people doesn't resolve the issue of uninformed actors because you are being reactionary and not proactive, meaning the damage is done. I also find it ridiculous that drones are being regulated more than private aircraft. Drones have such a lower potential for harm.
- dependenttypes 7y agoMore power to the goverment and less freedom and privacy for the citizen, what could go wrong?
- mgrennan 7y agoNo man's Life, Liberty, or Property is safe while the legislature is in session. - Will Rogers
- CamperBob2 7y agoWait until someone is assassinated with one of these puppies. They will end up prohibited entirely. :( Collective punishment: it's OK when the government does it!
- greenerpastures 7y agoThis falls into the same gotcha as many laws. Someone with ill intentions is not going to follow this law, so this law doesn't really stop this from happening.
- Analemma_ 7y agoThe FAA is clearly taking a much longer view of this than most people on this thread, and describing a system which scales safely to having huge drone fleets in the sky, which most of the "just wing it, it'll work itself out" counter-proposals here do not.
- 1996 7y agoThe counterpoint being, the FAA rules will kill the chances of a future where there would be huge drone fleets in the sky
- james-mcelwain 7y agoGood. Drones are incredibly annoying and have already ruined many things like a pleasant day in the park. I don't want to live in a future with huge drone fleets buzzing around every time I step outside.
- ggreer 7y agoPeople said the same thing about technologies such as automobiles, airplanes, and cell phones. Yes, they have some annoyances and safety issues, but overall they have made our lives much better. I would rather let each state and municipality decide on whether to ban drones than to limit the future of the entire country.
- ggreer 7y agoIf anything I'd think that drones would save lives on net. Right now we get our packages delivered via multiton diesel trucks that speed through neighborhoods as fast as they can manage. Sometimes people step in front of these vehicles and are maimed or killed. Some of these people are children. All so we can get our AirPods delivered on launch day. Drones could be a substitute for many truck deliveries, but the FAA has banned such uses. This endangers more lives, creates more pollution, and increases delivery costs.
- mrfusion 7y agoThis seems complicated but it’s a step in the right direction. I think requiring a full pilots license to fly any drone would be best.
- illgenr 7y agoNow that's flat out ridiculous.
- snuxoll 7y agoI think training similar for what commercial drone pilots require isn’t far fetched, however. A hobbyist probably doesn’t need to read aerospace maps, METAR reports, etc., but should be able to answer the safety questions with ease before they start flying their equipment. I’ve held off on getting my Part 107 certification because I’m too lazy to drive to the testing center, but this shit isn’t rocket science and puts up a high enough barrier of entry to keep the skies reasonably safe. I wish the FAA had gone this route first before debating potentially expensive electronics on every consumer drone, I think it’s going to hurt more than it helps.
- bisrig 7y agoAm I reading this right that the standard remote ID broadcast is specified as "something in an unlicensed band, everything else about it you figure it out"? Isn't the point of this to be interoperable with other receiver systems for things like BVLOS operation? Seems like a funny place to throw in a shoulder shrug.
- comex 7y agoQuote: > With regard to direct broadcast capabilities, the ARC recommended the FAA adopt an industry standard for data transmission, which may need to be created, to ensure unmanned aircraft equipment and public safety receivers are interoperable, as public safety officials may not be able to equip with receivers for all possible direct broadcast technologies. So the final rule will probably name a specific standard, but it’s TBD for now.
- jopolous 7y agoI think what some people don't understand here is how working with the FAA is fundamentally different than the DMV. The DMV has to keep as many people driving as reasonably possible, since in the US it's practically impossible to live life normally without a car (excepting major cities) Flying, on the other hand, is viewed as a privilege by the FAA. You do not have a right to fly anything. And the FAA will do everything it can to make sure flying is safe, even if it means barring the majority of the population from ever qualifying to fly. I don't think they will treat drones any differently. So to everyone who is shocked at how hard the FAA is being about drones, welcome to flying. This is par for the course for us pilots.
- gmiller123456 7y agoYour assertion that people don't have a right to fly is fundamentally flawed. Whether or not I have a legal right assigned by the government is unrelated to fundamental human rights. Most people would agree the government doesn't have the right to tell people not to do something without a very good reason. And that's where the disagreement is. No one is saying the FAA doesn't have the legal authority to tell people what to do, the complaint is they don't have a good reason for the rules they're trying to implement.
- mattmaroon 7y agoYou must be a commercial pilot! They seem surprisingly lax to me about general aviation.
- jopolous 7y agoDefinitely lax in some ways, but medically it's incredible what they will latch on to and disqualify people for Things are getting better though, they're getting less rules-minded and more safety-minded. But the proposals around drones don't seem out of the ordinary for FAA regulations to me
- mattmaroon 7y agoSome of their regs are pretty antiquated. They can disqualify people for using prescribed ADD meds for example with would actually make one a better pilot. But the bar for a PPL was surprisingly low to me in many ways and the sport pilot license is shocking.
- madrox 7y agoIn general, I don't think drone aviation has reached its tipping point, so I'm glad things like this are happening in advance to control airspace. We can't even agree about where scooters belong in cities, so I don't want "move fast and break things" to be happening over my head. Whether or not it's the right thing will get figured out in the long run.
- exabrial 7y agoThis is stupidly complicated. Why not just an iff tag?
- GiorgioG 7y agoNope, no thanks. You don't get to intrude on my privacy because you want to make it easier on you to catch some bad actor that is breaking the law. For you gun owners out there, how would you like your concealed weapons tracked this way. F* that noise.
- macintux 7y agoHow exactly are you exercising your privacy by flying a dangerous object with a camera over other peoples' property?
- GiorgioG 7y agoIf I’m on my property flying at 50 feet, the government does not have a right to keep tabs on my activity without a warrant. Do you disagree?
- salawat 7y agoI'd say the better way to think about it is "The government has no implicit right to be aware of my whereabouts at all times." Stuff like automated license plate scanning is controversial because of the fact it enables this type of wholesale surveillance. And if the government doesn't do it, it just availed itself of third-party doctrine. I'm personally torn. I don't generally agree with any scheme through which a surveillance infrastructures implemented; heck, I don't even like what license plates have become used for. Yet I do sympathize with the problem of lack of employable measures against drones in emergencies. Hell, I'd probably be happier with less license B.S. and more implicit acknowledgement that if your drone gets in the way of something major, it will be slagged, and you're out a drone. Then again, that approach just encourages arms races...
- Roark66 7y agoThis is how they define the tech required "Remote ID is the ability of a UAS in flight to provide identification information that can be received by other parties". I wonder if this definitely means the drone itself has to have an extra transmitter or is an app running on the operator's smartphone enough. In Europe people flying drones use an app that lets you "Check In" with local airspace authority if you are operating in controlled area (where I am close to 50% of airspace in 50km radius is some kind of controlled area). If you don't want to use an app it is required to phone the area admin before flying in controlled airspace. Also it is good to have a given day's map as it shows today's low altitude military routes. One of those routes is nearby and it is not uncommon to see F16's flying at ridiculous speeds at what appears to be around 200m altitude. It is interesting that they don't show those routes on US airspace maps I saw.
- bapp1236 7y agoThese rules appear to make FPV race drones impractical and make older, pre this BS drones very valuable
- bapp1236 7y agoThese rules appear to make fpv racing drones impractical and all older, pre BS rules drones very valuable.
- upofadown 7y agoADS-B[1] was and is somewhat pointless because it was not designed to accommodate smaller flying things... the sort of things that there are a lot more of. So now we have a whole whack of incompatible systems like FLARM[2] to address that segment. The FAA is actually promoting another incompatible system for drones. This system won't actually allow anyone in the air to know the drone is there. It will only be for the purposes of law enforcement ... because that is the main priority right now... [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Automatic_dependent_surveillance_%E2%80%93_broadcast https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Automatic_dependent_surveillan... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FLARM https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FLARM