8 ms·
I wish EU work visa restrictions would be as high as the US ones. Tech salaries in Western Europe are low enough as it is and the whole developer shortage the e
by ChuckNorris89 7y ago
I wish EU work visa restrictions would be as high as the US ones. Tech salaries in Western Europe are low enough as it is and the whole developer shortage the employers keep crying about to the media is a scam to justify lax visa restrictions for cheaper workforce from abroad.
Under current conditions EU companies can hire pretty much anyone across the globe. Do you think SV salaries would be as high as they are if they could import any workers hassle free?
My ex employer was low balling everyone and after failing to recruit anyone locally due to low pay he the focused on hiring exclusively Indians and Chinese who were just happy to be in Europe accepting any wage citing the good air quality and social services compared to back home.
Don't get me wrong, I'm happy for them, and glad they're happy here but flooding the market with people who are happy to earn anything as long as they're allowed to live here is not a market I'd like to compete for work in as it increases the inequality putting all the gains in the hands of the employers.
We have enough skilled workers in the EU. Importing people with wages under €50k disincentivizes employers from paying fair wages and investing in local workforce and increases income inequality. If we're talking about a shortage of truly highly skilled people we have to import then probably we should be talking about setting the bar way higher than €50k.
- blue_box 7y agoOf course, people who come from abroad have some effect on the salaries but I think the main reason is that life quality is really high in Europe (especially in Germany) so employees don't negotiate properly for their salary. When I talk with my colleagues, most of them are saying that the money that they earn is enough, there is no reason to ask for more. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
- ChuckNorris89 7y agoDepends what your family can provide you and what your goals in life are. If you're set to inherit properties/money from your parents or you're ok with being a renter for life at the mercy of your landlord then any salary in Europe is fine. If you have to buy a property on your own where you could raise a family in then salaries are far from fine. Anytime I her someone in Western Europe say salaries are fine and shrug it off, usually it's because they will receive an inheritance or significant financial assistance from parents when the time comes to buy a house so they never feel underpaid.
- blue_box 7y agoyou can get a mortgage credit with a really low interest rate. If you have a family, your rent probably will be higher than your mortgage payment. (5% rule) so without earning a high salary, you can still buy a house.
- samsonradu 7y ago> You can still buy a house Read `take a 30y mortgage` with plenty of downside risk is quite a low bar for one of the best paying industries in the world. The disconnect between salaries and the housing market in western EU is pretty much at an all-time high. If these are the expectations for tech salaries then how about the rest of the (middle-class) workforce?
- ChuckNorris89 7y agoDon't know why you're being downvoted. If people would look at the property prices in German cities for example they'd get it. Unless you and your partner are very high earners you're priced out of buying anything family worthy in all cities with tech jobs.
- aclsid 7y agoGermany is the poster child for controlled rent working well for everybody, to the point where it is more of hassle to buy.
- csunbird 7y agoWhat are you talking about ? Are you even living in Germany? The rent prices here in Berlin are bonkers, landlords are asking 800 Euros warm for 35 sqm "flats" and they are able to get away with it because every flat in the area has at least 30+ applicants. Even if it is rent controlled and the contracts are illegal, you can not report it otherwise you get kicked and no other landlord will rent you their property. They literally ask you if you had any legal conflicts with your previous landlord and they can actually refuse your application because of this.
- watt 7y agoThere might be also a thing where we see how it plays out in Switzerland and Norway where salaries are very high indeed, but your money does not go nearly as far.
- blue_box 7y agoThat's the reason why people work for a company in Switzerland and live in Germany.
- vinay427 7y agoYour money doesn't go as far if you live the same lifestyle (eating out, or generally labor-intensive services) but you definitely can live relatively cheaply in Switzerland because the prices of most essential goods don't vary as much between countries as some like to claim. What is expensive in Switzerland is labor. If you cook, you won't be spending much more on groceries than you would in Germany or Italy. Factoring in personal taxes, which are generally much lower in Switzerland, makes them virtually equal in my experience. I can't comment on Norway as I have never been, but I live in Switzerland right now and I, along with other students I know here, typically live relatively cheaply by avoiding most optional services.
- playing_colours 7y agoIf your company does not pay above market rate, you may naturally end up with employees who are satisfied with their salaries. The quality of living in Germany is in decline in recent years, unfortunately, as our government knows only how to waste money when economy boomed, but is completely incompetent what to do with growing challenges, and how to ensure its relevance and growth in future. Introducing new taxes every week is not a mark of competence.
- CalRobert 7y agoI used to scoff but this might be part of it. I think asking for money is considered vulgar, at least subconsciously. Tall poppy syndrome is real too.
- ailideex 7y ago> I think the main reason is that life quality is really high in Europe (especially in Germany) so employees don't negotiate properly for their salary. I think it is mainly supply/demand issue.
- mac_was 7y agoWhich country are you talking about?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- zerr 7y agoIf we follow that route, Spanish, Portuguese or Italians shouldn't be allowed to work in Germany... Germans shouldn't be allowed to work in Switzerland, etc... Also, there are plenty of 50K-70K tech jobs in US - not everyone works in FAANG or lives in Bay Area.
- blue_box 7y agoCompanies in Germany already have branches in those countries and they are paying almost half for the same job.
- mping 7y agoBesides, in tech, most of the time you get what you payed for. So if you lowball you will probably get low talent. This is a global market, so you can also grab US jobs for half the pay and make alot of money anyway.
- ChuckNorris89 7y agoDepends, my ex employer got a really good deal on some workers from China who are working like crazy even on overtime, being grateful to just be in Europe even on below market salaries so it worked for him hence his focus to just recruit from there exclusively. Most tech companies already have enough thinkers, to scale fast they just need more doers that execute orders quickly without rocking the boat or challenging the status quo.
- ChuckNorris89 7y agoYou're not correct. EU citizens should be allowed to work anywhere in EU member states. That's fine, it's one of the founding principles of EU membership. The problem is when EU companies have virtually no restrictions on hiring people outside the EU putting even more downward pressure on local salaries in high COL areas.
- hos234 7y agoCompanies will outsource, move development centers elsewhere etc etc. Visa restrictions alone aren't going to save anyones job. The world is too competitive.
- anovikov 7y agoProblem is, there is internal migration in Europe which you can't possibly close this way. Romania is as poor as China and has better tech talent speaking European languages a lot better. No amount of visa restrictions will protect you from that. "hire pretty much anyone across the globe" - well only if you are prepared to pay 1.5x average salary in your country (Blue Card), so not for cheap positions, will start from some like 50000 EUR net a year in Germany for example. Otherwise it's really pain in the ass procedure to get a normal work visa, or not possible at all (in some countries).
- ChuckNorris89 7y agoRomania or Eastern Europe is not the reason tech salaries are low in Europe as the country may be poor but tech workers there make almost as much as their counterparts in western Europe due to low taxes and high competition for talent. A Romanian tech grad can make €2k NET salary out of University which factoring the low COL is one of the reasons very few chose to migrate west nowadays.
- anovikov 7y agoReal reason of course, is that they can't pay more. Value they create is so much smaller due to the lower investment-driven leverage. Anyone who tried to raise VC funding in EU will confirm that.
- simula67 7y agoSalaries may not improve in Europe even if Visa restrictions are tightened, companies may set up offices in countries where wages are lower. I think the reason that western countries encourage high skill immigration is because it creates additional jobs to service the new workers: every new software engineer will need restaurants, cars, etc. These jobs can go to locals. Also, the taxes paid will go to the western governments to improve services for westerners.
- ChuckNorris89 7y agoEU companies rarely set up shop abroad since the culture here, driven by the lack of a common language like English prefers cultural similarly and physical proximity. That's why German companies prefer to do business with Swiss and Austrian companies and vice versa or how Norwegian companies prefer Danish or Swedish firms for example. And if they do outsource something abroad it's usually nothing exciting, so local salaries should not dive. For example, Microsoft has offices in Eastern Europe and India as well yet Seattle workers still make a killing.
- _pmf_ 7y ago> every new software engineer will need restaurants, cars, etc. These jobs can go to locals. That's the most absurd thing I read today.
- negamax 7y agoOf course they spend in the local markets and pay taxes. No?
- brij0102 7y agoH1 tightening is suggested as a reason for reduction in house prices in SV ... the uncertainty keeps folks from making the commitment. Prices of course are still high in the valley but multiple offers outside of a few cities are a thing of the past
- raverbashing 7y agoI don't think it should be as hard as the US, but then again, there's endless abuse from the consulting companies there, and I believe that the salary floor, while it could be higher, goes a good way in curbing the abuse (in the EU) I also think companies act naively in hiring, thinking it's just a matter of bringing people to fill seats (which might make sense for the "consulting companies"), also that cultural differences are easy to deal with (that goes both ways and it can either be good or bad)
- vijaybritto 7y agoThis is true. I live in Bangalore and I see European companies paying like 30 - 40% more than what we get paid in India. This is so little when the cost of living and the cost of moving with your family are considered. It inevitably leads to the reduction in spending in those cities in Europe.
- ossworkerrights 7y agoThis eu madness, mainly drive by germany, to allow mass migration due to a lack “of labour” needs to end. I welcome immigrants but they are heavily abused by means of lower wages, and it depresses local wages as well.
- chpmrc 7y ago> Do you think SV salaries would be as high as they are if they could import any workers hassle free? Yes, given there are many companies paying SV salaries to remote devs from all over the planet. (Off the top of my head: Buffer, HotJar, Superside, Stack Overflow)
- inertiatic 7y agoI thought HotJar positions advertised 70-90k, a number that would also be adjusted further based on cost of living.
- chpmrc 7y agoThat's in EUR, 90k EUR is ~100k USD.
- SamReidHughes 7y agoThat’s a big multiple below an SV salary.
- chpmrc 7y agoSV != FAANG Also everyone is conveniently picking the lowest paying company in the bunch.
- Znafon 7y ago> Importing people with wages under €50k disincentivizes employers from paying fair wages Why would €42k not a fair wage? Looking at INSEE data, the median salary in France is €38409, 42k-50k to write API endpoints seems fair to me, what do you think would be appropriate?
- ChuckNorris89 7y agoYou made my point. €42k may be a fair wage for writing APIs but it's in no way a skill or a salary you can claim there's a shortage on within the EU workforce like doctors for example, to justify importing external workers. You say you have a shortage for API devs? Then either: 1) pay more at which point you'll be flooded with aplicants and if not then you have a real claim for skill shortage with the government and can secure visas for immigrant workers or 2)train them yourself, there's plenty of motivated people of all ages willing to learn something that's in demand. Simples. But what's that?! Investing in the workforce is too expensive for the shareholders?! Boo-hoo, my heart bleeds for the poor companies and their offshore accounts.
- Aperocky 7y agoIf there were not a shortage of API devs, salary for programmers wouldn’t have gone through the roof. You can’t just say because there are a couple million programmer there are definitely no shortage of them. The market demand just happened to be higher.
- ChuckNorris89 7y agoSince when is €42k salary considered as being through the roof?
- Aperocky 7y agoThat’s more of a chicken and egg problem. As you’ve said, if there were no foreign talent availability, prices would have been lot higher. Just look at the USA. Whether you want to keep that is another thing in itself. From what I see, the availability for large amount of beginners (Not necessarily foreign, see bootcamp) does not affect the market value for experienced programmers at all.
- Jagat 7y agoYou're decrying inequality, and supporting the ridiculous SV salaries in the same paragraph. >> Do you think SV salaries would be as high as they are if they could import any workers hassle free? There's nothing great about the wealth generated by the entire global digital industry being concentrated in a few cities.
- Isinlor 7y ago> as it increases the inequality Really?! Speaking about inequality is so hypocritical in this context that it just boils my blood. I could understand if you were having trouble to earn a living. But you can easily live in the Western Europe on even €30k. EASILY! And happily, and stress free. Your kids will get free education, free collage. You will get tons of vacations, 38 hours work week. But no, you want more. You want luxury life, you want to keep the rest of the world underneath you. Letting poor people compete with you on fair terms does not increase inequality. It undermines your position of power. Western Europeans and their ancestors benefited greatly from conquest all over the world. Are Indians and Chinese somehow second rate people? They do not deserve to even compete with the White Elite of Western Europe? You should stop being egoist. Start your own company if you do not like being employee.
- drharby 7y agoI get the impression from your rant that you're dismissing the parents comments core complaint about the adverse impact of increased labor supply on the middle class and then follow on to namecalling. This style of commentary seems beneath HN's aspirational high signal low noise.
- pnako 7y agoI think you're attacking a straw man here. Chinese and Indian people can certainly compete with European people, and they do it everyday. But they can do it from China and India.
- huffmsa 7y agoThe GP thinks its about "getting even", as if China and India were naive, noble backwaters the devious Europeans pulled the wool over and secretly exploited in 1700s. When really, they got out competed in trade and on the battlefield by the Europeans.
- rock_v 7y agoSo, it’s fair if a European gets out competed in the labor market today.
- blue_box 7y ago> We have enough skilled workers in the EU. No you don't. Companies have to prove that they couldn't find a person who fits the position before hiring. Otherwise they have to hire someone in EU.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- ChuckNorris89 7y agoTho whole we couldn't find anyone in the EU for this job spiel that companies play is just a immigration scam approved with a rubber stamp by the authorities. Let me fill you in on how it works: Company puts up job ad with a salary so low no one in their right mind would even consider applying for. After 30 days of no applications(what a surprise) company goes to the local authorities and tells them that no one in the EU applied and that it's already hurting their business an suddenly, BAM!, working visa secured for the next gullible fool who doesn't know the market. This abuse is so easy, every company does it and the government is ok with it as it keeps the companies happy.
- Hitton 7y ago>Company puts up job ad with a salary so low no one in their right mind would even consider applying for. After 30 days of no applications(what a surprise) company goes to the local authorities and tells them that no one in the EU applied and that it's already hurting their business an suddenly, BAM!, working visa secured for the next gullible fool who doesn't know the market. Exactly this. And to make sure that no one applies, they add bogus requirements to the job like fluency in Russian/Hindi when hiring programmers. From the companies that I see doing this here, Red Hat seems to be the most egregious.
- playing_colours 7y agoIn Germany, local market check is not required for Blue Card applicants.
- thbr99 7y agoIf Indians and Chineese can live there with the salary they get. Why can't you ? What makes you different ? Indians & Chineese are buying foreign products in their countries. Why can't other countries accept goods(human resources) in return ? It's a global economy.
- foepys 7y agoIndian and Chinese immigrants don't have family in the EU. They might have one later but they don't need a higher salary to support them when they first move to the EU.
- thbr99 7y agoForeign products flood the local market and destroys local businesses. Eg: Walmart crushing local grocery stores in another country. Here the product is human resources. Why is that a problem in the global economy. Have anti dumping or counter vailing for foreign labour too then ?
- tzone 7y agoThis seems kind of backwards to be honest. The crackdown on H1-Bs will definitely have long term negative consequences on US tech economy, not positive consequences. A lot of major progress in tech was possible specifically because it was very easy to get h1-b visas especially for immigrants who came to study in US colleges. Imo the issue with European immigration system is that it isn't welcoming for permanent immigration. So high skilled people go to Europe, earn some money and then go back home because they are never accepted as equal citizens in most wester European countries (both by law, but even more importantly, by culture). In US on the other hand, immigrants can settle in much more easily and call it their new home, and become full fledged part of the society both by law and culturally. Especially in areas like SV and New York. When you look at leadership (i.e. C-titles, VPs, Founders) of a lot of tech companies in SV and New York, first and second generation immigrants are vastly over-represented. EDIT: also guess what is going to happen if immigration becomes harder? the outsourcing companies will get better and do the job cheaper remotely from India, so even more of the tech work will just get outsourced, meaning there will be even less tech jobs in Europe. You really can't stop the inevitable consequences of the global free market, unless you want to go full protectionist. So acquiring and KEEPING skilled labor through immigration is probably a much smarter long term choice compared to protectionist immigration strategies.
- thbr99 7y agoThis. The culture part. I have worked in US,CA,EU. I felt US was more accepting than any other country. There is a feeling of being part of US society even though you are a temporary worker. There is very less cultural discrimination in the US. EU,CA are a conservative xenophobic bunch. Many immigrants in Canada who are now citizens still stick their native countries flags on their cars. I have only one question for them, if you like your native country so much, why don't you go back ? If you accepted Canadian citizenship, be like one.
- brij0102 7y agoI remember reading a while back that CA encourages retaining native identity (comparisons were made between a quilt and a melting pot ...)
- throwaway15884 7y agoThrowaway because I founded a startup in Europe and don't want the name associated. I blame European R&D subsidies for this. Basically anything you can imagine a software engineer doing can be subsidised by an EU Grant. These grants are usually paid as a reimbursement for hours worked, i.e 42% up to a maximum of 100€/h including overheads. Therefore companies maximize hours by favoring multiple cheap engineers. My hunch is that more jobs are salary capped due to this than immigration, and if the salaries actually went up then the job positions would basically evaporate. Don't get me started by the ridiculous wastes that go into administrating these grant programs. I tell my European friends: Europe administrates its wealth away and saves whatever is left over.
- nine_zeros 7y agoI hear you! But let's engage in a conversation. Would you rather believe in your own mental model of supply/demand or would you rather look at what happened in the real world? There are really only 3 places in the world with booming tech. USA, China and India. EU is nowhere. One might ask why does China and India (with so-called flood of supply of engineers) developed technology so much faster than already developed EU? The answer lies in answering that question. Why do you think EU is left behind?
- rolltiide 7y agoI’m glad EU visa standards are super low. But for me thats just for access, European salaries are unattractive. Outside of the EU but still Schengen area, tech hubs like Zug, Switzerland pay just as much as Silicon Valley, without massive federal income taxes all while the neighboring Eurozone is super cheap. State tax in Zug is like 7% I’d never leave the sauna clubs!
- Isinlor 7y ago> flooding the market with people who are happy to earn anything as long as they're allowed to live here is not a market I'd like to compete for work in as it increases the inequality putting all the gains in the hands of the employers. Look at it from another perspective. You earn a lot, you have skills. You can save money, you can start a company yourself. As you say, people will be willing to work cheaply for you. This will allow you to provide cheap services to other people and you will get to benefit from it as much as you will want. I understand that you personally may not want to start company. Too much risk, too much effort. But maybe some of your colleagues would want to take on the challenge. Why would you want to make it more difficult for them to hire people? Think about the good that can be achieved by giving people opportunities. Why this is not what everyone should want?