11 ms·
NSA's Backdoor Key from Lotus Notes (2002)
- Lammy 7y agoPrevious discussions: - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5846189 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5846189 (June 2013) - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9291404 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9291404 (2015)
- TeMPOraL 7y agoJune 2013 discussion's top post is by the person involved in making Lotus Notes (Ray Ozzie). His comment - which tangents into issue of privacy and data control - is also prescient, and could have just as well been written today, which is a sad testament to how things didn't get any better in the past 6 years.
- jacquesm 7y agoAs well in this thread.
- xvector 7y agoThank you for the link. I found barrkel’s comment[1] particularly moving: > A non-authoritarian government is an historical anomaly. It's a ball balanced on top of a hill, pushed there by the deaths of millions, and kept there by the vigilance of those who care. Please start caring. [1]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5847789 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5847789
- monoideism 7y ago> It's a ball balanced on top of a hill, pushed there by the deaths of millions, and kept there by the vigilance of those who care. I feel like the ball has started to roll downhill, and is rapidly gaining speed, but that the only folks who can stop it are too dug into their own partisanship to take a look around them and do something. That, or they desire authoritarianism. I've frankly been surprised at the number of people I've talked to in the past few years who seem to like the idea of a strongman leader. I always assumed everyone but the most extreme wings of the right and left believed in liberty and democracy, but I now see that was I mistaken.
- adventured 7y agoMy experience has been the opposite. I've rarely met anybody in the center ~80% or so that didn't have a little dictator inside of them, yearning to come out and strangle the masses under behavior controls, dictating how everyone else is to live. I find it doesn't take more than a few minutes of conversation with moderates, before you can see the gleam of dictator in their eye, where you can get them to openly state something about wanting to directly or indirectly control other people and how they live. And when it comes to the extreme partisan wings, the dictator is giant rather than little. You don't have to engage them in conversation for it to come out, they project it all the time willingly, openly.
- monoideism 7y ago> My experience has been the opposite. What you describe isn't the opposite. It's mostly the same. And if 100% of the people you encounter are displaying either a little authoritarianism or a lot, you need to spend more time with libertarians.
- Taek 7y agoEveryone wants to believe that they know how other people should be living their lives. And everybody believes that they themselves know where to draw the line between freedom and order. Freedom means something different to every person on the planet, and that makes it difficult to protect.
- dclowd9901 7y agoAuthoritarianism only looks like authoritarianism if you don’t agree with who’s in charge.
- monoideism 7y agoClever, but not borne out by evidence. You're not going to claim that Stalin's Russia and Thatcher's Britain (to take two arbitrary governments) were equivalent in authoritarianism, with the only difference being who agreed and who disagreed with said governments, right? Or are you?
- reanimus 7y agoThey embedded an entire X.509 cert in it? I wonder if the Lotus devs just made an X.509 cert out of key material they were given or if the NSA actually minted it with that subject.
- dclowd9901 7y agoI have to think the engineers were maliciously complying with the directive. It's far too dark a joke to be honorific.
- jsjohnst 7y agoRay Ozzie confirmed in a thread below that it was done by Charlie/Al/him as a joke.
- dclowd9901 7y agoLike laughing at a funeral?
- acqq 7y agoLike "we do what we have to do because it's currently a law, but we can't be forced to give a nice name to it, let them know what we think of it:" https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21859950 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21859950 See the other comments here for a historical context: "exporting" stronger crypto software from the U.S. had the same status as exporting weapons of war.
- marcan_42 7y agoThe cert has to be signed by something, usually its own key. If it was self-signed then the NSA signed it with those details.
- Ericson2314 7y agoI thought at first the NSA made the Orwell reference, but it looks just the lotus notes devs did? I guess that's...reassuring.
- Lammy 7y agoThat's why Ray Ozzie's comment on a previous submission is so significant: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5847189 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5847189
- acqq 7y agoThe part written in 2013, not less urgent today: "For example, did you really intend to yield your 4th amendment rights when you granted a 3rd party access to your files as a part of Mac Software Update, Windows Update, Virus Scanners, etc., or when you started using a service-tethered smartphone? Anyway, unlike 'web tracking' issues which seem to be broadly ignored because of our love for ad-supported services, I hope we all (especially the young readers of reddit, hackernews, etc) wake up to the fact that these privacy and transparency issues are REAL, and that they truly will impact you and the country you live in, and that even if you don't consider yourself an activist you really should get informed and form an opinion. Again, this is a non-partisan issue, and let's all work to ensure that it stays this way. Two great organizations where you can learn are EPIC and EFF. (Disclosure: I am on the board of EPIC.) Take it in, and think. Your contributions are needed and would of course be quite welcome. http://epic.org http://epic.org http://eff.org http://eff.org " Ray Ozzie https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ray_Ozzie https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ray_Ozzie
- jacquesm 7y agoThat's a super comment and yet not a day goes by here on HN that I read the exact opposite: that privacy is dead and that we should all just roll over and enjoy our Amazon, Google, Apple and Microsoft telemetry because it isn't going to change back.
- 7y ago
- almindor 7y agoThis is a bit spooky. I wonder if the engineers responsible were just trying to be cute, or "reaching out" in a way.
- mindfulhack 7y agoProbably just having a joke. Human psychology is complex, no matter what positive or negative things we do to each other.
- jsjohnst 7y agoPosted by the man himself before your reply: > Charlie, Al, and I were just trying to maintain a sense of humor in fairly tough times, knowing that the first who would see the key would be the folks we were working with at the ministry.
- refset 7y agoI think Lotus Notes has a fascinating history, cryptographic shenanigans asides. As far as I'm aware it is still the most successful "offline first" / "local-first" application platform in widespread use today, complete with multi-master document replication, highly-configurable conflict resolution and rapid application development. These were revolutionary capabilities during the dialup era. The email client just happens to be the most popularly recognised groupware application outside of individual corporate firewalls. The original vision was very lofty: https://web.archive.org/web/20180225100127/http://www.kapor.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/12/Notes-Project.pdf https://web.archive.org/web/20180225100127/http://www.kapor.... "Notes should take the first major crack at the area of idea processors, textual databases, and hypertext systems." I would love to see where an open source equivalent built for the modern age could take us... (CouchDB gave it a good shot!)
- EricE 7y agoI strongly agree! When I was first thrust into Notes administration (version 3 no less!) I hated it. But combined with version 4 and using it more, the power hiding behind the ugly GUI became more and more apparent. I've yet to find a system that can handle unstructured data or workflows with field level replication, role based security and encryption as quickly or as elegantly as with Lotus Notes - UI warts and all. Indeed I have some workflows that I could probably automate myself in a week or so but am in the process of getting dev support to accomplish some other way. It's too bad IBM didn't really fix the non-windows feel of Notes until version 8. By then Exchange had clearly won - should have never happened. The Notes server back end is still far more robust than Exchange. Oh well...
- lstamour 7y agoNot open source, but it strikes me that Notion.so, Coda and AirTable might be examples of centralized, online "Notes-replacements", all inspired by how Google Docs (Writely) let you collaborate and perform conflict resolution in the cloud a bit over a decade ago.
- paulddraper 7y agoCan't speak for the others, but Notion.so conflict resolution is significantly less sophisticated than Google Docs' operational transforms (I think that's what they're using).
- userbinator 7y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/RSA-768#RSA-768 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/RSA-768#RSA-768 was factored almost exactly 10 years ago. I wonder if anyone has tried factoring this one? Hopefully the NSA doesn't still use this key...
- haecceity 7y agoSo the fact that most crypto export controls are gone now means NSA can crack everything now right?
- nullc 7y agoThe export controls weren't relaxed particularly willingly. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bernstein_v._United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bernstein_v._United_States
- acqq 7y agoAlso: https://www.wired.com/1995/03/the-continuing-investigation-of-phil-zimmermann/ https://www.wired.com/1995/03/the-continuing-investigation-o... https://www.nytimes.com/1996/01/12/business/data-secrecy-export-case-dropped-by-us.html https://www.nytimes.com/1996/01/12/business/data-secrecy-exp...
- schappim 7y agoDoes anyone else find it ironic that cypherspace.org doesn't support https?
- DonHopkins 7y agoInslaw's legal case-management system "PROMIS" also had a back door, put there by Michael Riconosciuto, under the direction of Earl Brian of Inslaw's competitor Hadron. Attorney General Edwin Meese's Department of Justice drove Inslaw out of business, pirated their software, and distributed it with the back door to Israel and 80 other countries so the US could spy on them. Danny Casolaro was investigating it, but suddenly died of an unlikely apparent suicide. If Trump really wanted to investigate corruption in the deep state, he should start by interrogating his good buddy Edwin Meese, instead of honoring him with the Medal of Freedom. He could also ask his own Attorney General Bill Barr why he whitewashed the Justice Department last time he had it investigate itself. (Actually, maybe that's why he hired Barr!) https://www.npr.org/2019/10/08/768136964/trump-to-honor-former-reagan-attorney-general-who-left-government-under-ethics-c https://www.npr.org/2019/10/08/768136964/trump-to-honor-form... >Trump To Honor Former Reagan Attorney General, Who Left Government Under Ethics Cloud http://nothingmajor.com/journal/775-meese-is-a-pig-returns/ http://nothingmajor.com/journal/775-meese-is-a-pig-returns/ >Experts Agree! MEESE is a PIG https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1179701030520524801.html https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1179701030520524801.html >INSLAW/PROMIS links >Barr refused to appoint an independent counsel to the Inslaw case, relying instead on a retired federal judge, in this case Nicholas Bua, who reported to Barr alone. In other words, the DOJ was responsible for investigating itself. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PROMIS_(software) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PROMIS_(software) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inslaw https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inslaw https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Michael_Riconosciuto https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Michael_Riconosciuto https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Earl_Brian https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Earl_Brian https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Danny_Casolaro https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Danny_Casolaro >The Justice Department had dishonestly conspired to "drive Inslaw out of business 'through trickery, fraud and deceit'" by withholding payments to Inslaw and then pirating the software. >The Justice Department had done so in order to modify PROMIS, originally created to manage legal cases, to become a monitoring software for intelligence operations. >"PROMIS was then given or sold at a profit to Israel and as many as 80 other countries by Dr. Earl W. Brian, a man with close personal and business ties to then-President Ronald Reagan and then-Presidential counsel Edwin Meese." >"There appears to be strong evidence, as indicated by the findings in two Federal Court proceedings as well as by the committee investigation, that the Department of Justice 'acted willfully and fraudulently,' and 'took, converted and stole,' Inslaw's Enhanced PROMIS by 'trickery fraud and deceit.'" >A book written in 1997 by Fabrizio Calvi and Thierry Pfister claimed that the National Security Administration (NSA) had been "seeding computers abroad with PROMIS-embedded SMART (Systems Management Automated Reasoning Tools) chips, code-named Petrie, capable of covertly downloading data and transmitting it, using electrical wiring as an antenna, to U.S. intelligence satellites" as part of an espionage operation. >"another undeclared mission of the Justice Department's covert agents was to insure that investigative journalist Danny Casolaro remained silent about the role of the Justice Department in the INSLAW scandal by murdering him in west Virginia in August 1991." >Inslaw's new allegations described the Justice Department dispute with Inslaw as part of a broad conspiracy to drive Inslaw into bankruptcy so that Earl Brian, the founder of a venture capital firm called Biotech (later Infotechnology), could acquire Inslaw's assets, including its software Promis. Inslaw owner William Hamilton told PSI investigators that Brian had first attempted to acquire Inslaw through a computer services corporation he controlled, called Hadron. Hamilton said that he rejected an offer from Hadron to acquire Inslaw, and that Brian then attempted to drive Inslaw into bankruptcy through his influence with Attorney General Edwin Meese. https://www.wired.com/1993/01/inslaw/ https://www.wired.com/1993/01/inslaw/ >The INSLAW Octopus >Software piracy, conspiracy, cover-up, stonewalling, covert action: Just another decade at the Department of Justice >The House Judiciary Committee lists these crimes as among the possible violations perpetrated by "high-level Justice officials and private individuals": >> Conspiracy to commit an offense >> Fraud >> Wire fraud >> Obstruction of proceedings before departments, agencies and committees >> Tampering with a witness >> Retaliation against a witness >> Perjury >> Interference with commerce by threats or violence >> Racketeer Influenced and Corrupt Organizations (RICO) violations >> Transportation of stolen goods, securities, moneys >> Receiving stolen goods https://www.muckrock.com/news/archives/2017/may/16/FBI-promis-part-1/ https://www.muckrock.com/news/archives/2017/may/16/FBI-promi... >The Undying Octopus: FBI and the PROMIS affair Part 1 35 years later, file reveals dropped leads and confirmed allegations in “the scandal that wouldn’t die”. >Inslaw’s attorneys, which included Elliot Richardson, who had previously resigned from the DOJ rather than comply with President Nixon’s orders to fire the Watergate Special Prosecutor Archibald Cox, repeatedly demanded a special prosecutor be appointed to investigate the matter, along with its numerous connections that implicated officials such as Ed Meese, who were in turn allegedly connected to affairs such as Iran-Contra and Reagan’s October Surprise.
- vectorEQ 7y agoO=MiniTruth CN=Big Brother :D love it
- EddieCPU 7y agoWell DOH!
- wpskidd 7y agoI have to chime in that I too have a love/hate relationship with Lotus Notes. I started using it back in ‘98. It was massively empowering to build functional and secure workflow apps, and do so faster than you could wireframe on other platforms. I rolled it out to thousands of users successfully. It was truly visionary in scope. However, the performance was mediocre and there were many really poor oversights and omissions. Often I would go to program some base operation and find out you just “can’t get there from here“. It seemed their QC process hadn’t really given much though to global calendar synchronization or to very basic needs like printing landscape. I still use it daily for a large (funeral) industry specific app. and it has run flawlessly for a decade (albeit making API calls to MS Office and the web). I go to program new things in React or even Rails and am disappointed that you have to reinvent things that were built into Notes 20 yrs ago.
- DoctorOetker 7y agoWas it systematically leaking the same 24 bits (encrypted to the NSA public key), or a random contiguous selection of 24 bits? in the second case having just a few documents would result in only the NSA being able to decrypt without even brute forcing...
- tripzilch 7y ago> the NSA public key had an organizational name of "MiniTruth", and a common name of "Big Brother" > the Ministry of Truth was the agency who's job was propaganda and suppression of truths that did not suit the malignant fictional future government in the book, and "Big Brother" was the evil shadowy leader of this government. "Are we the baddies?", said nobody at the NSA. Seriously, this is kind of blatant. I could see them using the phrase "Big Brother", because it has become a common saying and lost some of its edge. But not Ministry of Truth, that only has one meaning and it's terrifying. It literally means "ministry of lying to the people and denial of truth". There is no reading of the book, no matter how superficial, that the term "Ministry of Truth" is anything but overtly sarcastic. What does this come from? Is it edgy young people (young back then), picking these names? Even if tongue-in-cheek, it has enormous consequences on the culture inside a rather insulated work environment of a job that really should be one of solemn responsibility.
- jsjohnst 7y ago> What does this come from? Do some reading of the threads here + links to previous discussions. Ray Ozzie (one involved) has been commenting.