6 ms·
> "The Santa Hat on vscode insiders and pushing of religion is very offensive to me, additionally xmas has cost millions of Jews their lives over the centuries,
by gwbas1c 7y ago
> "The Santa Hat on vscode insiders and pushing of religion is very offensive to me, additionally xmas has cost millions of Jews their lives over the centuries, yet even if that was not the case, pushing religious symbols as part of a product update is completely unacceptable," the user wrote. "Please remove it immediately and make it your top priority. To me this is almost equally offensive as a swastika."
Santa is about as non-religious as you can get. IMO, I think Microsoft really put their foot in their mouth on this one.
Edit: Because I can't let this go, it's important to point out that what we find offensive is subjective. I wonder if whoever wrote that is really just trolling Microsoft, or just has an axe to grind.
- kick 7y agoI think the person who posted this was a bit silly, but you can't be serious about Santa being non-religious, can you? He's literally a saint in every form of Christianity that has saints. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Saint_Nicholas https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Saint_Nicholas
- felixfbecker 7y agoAre you sure Santa and Saint Nicholas are the same? In Germany we celebrate Saint Nicholas on December 6th, while Santa brings presents on December 24th (Christmas Eve).
- tomnipotent 7y agoThe modern mythos of Santa is based on Saint Nicholas: https://www.history.com/topics/christmas/santa-claus https://www.history.com/topics/christmas/santa-claus
- goto11 7y agoYes it is the same. Santa Claus comes from Sinterklaas which is Dutch for Saint Nicholas.
- DonHopkins 7y agoWe should be relieved that the Visual Studio Code icon didn't feature one of Sinterklaas's "Zwarte Piet" subservient, gaudily costumed, large gold earring wearing, afro-style wig sporting, red lipstick smeared, childishly clown-like acting, naughty-child-kidnapping, Spanish Moor originating, full blackface wearing assistants, whose traditionally racist hooligan fans throw eggs, shout racist insults, wield clubs and fireworks, storm peaceful meetings and protests, trespass on property, assault people, and vandalize cars, all in the name of traditional celebration of the birthday of Christ Our Lord. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zwarte_Piet https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zwarte_Piet https://www.theguardian.com/world/2019/sep/18/netherlands-ban-blackface-makeup-zwarte-piet-black-pete-christmas-parade https://www.theguardian.com/world/2019/sep/18/netherlands-ba... https://www.dutchnews.nl/features/2019/12/open-letter-rutte-talk-to-kick-out-zwarte-piet-about-racism/ https://www.dutchnews.nl/features/2019/12/open-letter-rutte-... >The act of terrorism at our national conference (8/11), where hooligans armed with clubs and heavy fireworks barged in on the meeting, formed a dangerous and all-time low in the list of hostilities perpetrated on KOZP. The school building, which was the venue of the conference, and cars (including the car of one of the organisers) were severely damaged. We were lucky that no one got physically hurt. >[...] How would you have reacted if a group of hooligans with clubs had stormed a congress of the VVD or another political party?
- txcwpalpha 7y agoSaint Nicholas is hardly the same as "Santa", which has his own wikipedia page [1]. Modern day Santa has some partial roots in Saint Nicholas (as well as a few other figures), but other than the sometimes-used moniker of "Saint Nick", has very little to do with the actual saint. Santa is the one associated with the red hat, while Saint Nicholas has no such association. The only real link between the two is that Saint Nicholas was known for gift-giving and so is Santa, but I hope we aren't about to label gift-giving as a religious activity... 1: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Santa_Claus https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Santa_Claus
- goto11 7y agoI'm not sure it makes sense to ask if Santa Claus is "the same" as Saint Nicholas. It is a mythic figure which have developed over time. It is like asking if Dracula is "the same" as Vlad Tepes.
- onion2k 7y agoThe red hat has nothing to do with Christianity though. It was created in the late 1800s and then popularised by Coca Cola in the 1930s. If the VS Code team had put a bishop's mitre on the update cog the complaint would be more reasonable.
- goto11 7y agoThe red hat is clearly associated with Christmas which is a Christian holiday. The complaint is silly, but we should not counter that by ridiculous claims like saying a Santa hat has nothing to do with Christmas. I think the red had originates from "Father Christmas" rather than Sct Nicolaus, but in any case it is clearly associated with Christmas.
- atonse 7y agoAnd so what if it is (even if slightly)? What's offensive about that? Who is hurt by that? (I'm an atheist, so I’m hardly a defender of shoving religious values down people’s throats)
- goto11 7y agoHonestly I think he is trolling, but if you are interested you can read the original complaint.
- rrss 7y agoSaint Nicholas, the bishop who lived in ancient Greece, is a saint, venerated in every form of Christianity that has saints. I don't think that Santa Claus, the mythological person who lives at the North Pole and has elves to make toys, is venerated by any Christian denomination.
- goto11 7y agoProtestants in Germany introduced the tradition of "Kristkind" (Baby Jesus) bringing gifts at Christmas because the tradition of Saint Nicholas was problematic for protestants.
- rrss 7y agoWas that the tradition of St Nicholas, the saint, or "Saint Nicholas"/Kris Kringle/Father Christmas = Santa Claus, the cookie-eating guy with a red hat thatdeveloped mostly after the 18th century?
- goto11 7y agoI'm not sure I understand what you are asking - are you considering St Nicolas and "Saint Nicholas" two unrelated figures? Obviously the figure developed over time.
- Phylter 7y agoThough he was a saint the symbology has been non-religious for some time. It's not just Christians that celebrate with Santa. In fact, most of the non-religious people I know celebrate with Santa. Even when you tie it to a saint the overall meaning of Santa has nothing to do with God or Christians. People like to be offended and will ruin things for other people. It's sad that we're in such a sensitive society but tolerance isn't what is practiced, sensitivity is. As a Christian I find the idea of Santa offensive, honestly. Santa and his powers (as presented in media) are a replacement for God. I'm not going to go crying to anybody because they have Santa as an icon.
- crooked-v 7y ago> the symbology has been non-religious for some time In the US, sure. In many other countries the related symbology is still heavily linked to "Saint Nicholas", not "Santa Claus".
- Phylter 7y agoThe name doesn't make it religious though, it's the people that celebrate Christmas and their use of Saint Nicholas/Santa Claus/etc.
- buckminster 7y agoSanta drives around in a grossly polluting truck delivering obesity-water to children. He's a monster, not a saint.
- spritecranberry 7y agoI legitimately cannot tell: is this a joke?
- duelingjello 7y agoAnd it's powered by high-sulphur diesel made from fermented reindeers and children's tears. ;) Don't forget getting children drunk on rum eggnog made from molested cows and unfertilized dinosaur descendant's ovums.
- tomnipotent 7y ago> Santa is about as non-religious as you can get. Of course he's religious, it's a mascot for a Christian holiday. Don't confuse American commercialism's exploitation of Christmas & Santa with its religious roots.
- gwbas1c 7y agoChristmas's roots are from pagan traditions around the new year's. They were christianized for many reasons. Gift giving around the end of the year has been around since before 0 BC. (And before someone screams "citation needed," I'll just say that it's well known, and if you didn't know it by now, there's a thing called Google and Wikipedia that you can go look at.)
- spritecranberry 7y agocITaTiOn NEEdeD
- tomnipotent 7y ago> Christmas's roots are from pagan traditions So? Most religious traditions were stolen, whoop de do. What matters is how they're practiced in 2019, in which case Christmas is almost synonymous with Christianity. > I'll just say that it's well known There is no actual confidence in how all of this stuff came to be, just a lot of conjecture - and so no, it's not well known at all.
- gwbas1c 7y agoTake a look at the comments in this thread about how non-christians observe Christmas. Christianity has no monopoly on Christmas.
- tomnipotent 7y agoExcept they practice gift-giving without any of the rest that comes along with - that's not Christmas, that's commercial exploitation. Big difference.
- kevingadd 7y agoMy IMO is that if you're getting heat from users over the equivalent of an easter egg it doesn't really matter whether they're trolls or not, it's much easier to just remove or tone down the egg to make the problem go away. Having arguments about it is a waste of energy. Yes, it's kind of depressing or frustrating, but this is the nature of online discourse in 201x. Whether or not the complaint is genuine is also much harder to figure out than "is it sufficient to replace this with a snowflake"
- userbinator 7y agoIt would've been far easier to just ignore it. As the old saying goes, "don't feed the trolls".
- adventured 7y agoIt's entirely unnecessary to make the problem (Santa hat) go away. The complaining person is displaying abusive behavior and should be treated as such. Warn them. Then ban them if they persist. You stand up to bullies or you drown in them. Mods can trivially and entirely disregard the non-problem (as it actually is). They're choosing not to and are making a community handling mistake in the process. The only proper response is to ignore the complaint as not meaningful enough to warrant action. Otherwise you'll eventually have to remove every possible symbol. Somewhere, someone's mother was murdered by a cog and they feel very, very sensitive about the matter. Abusive behavior in communities occurs at both extremes. You can be too sensitive in social situations in fact, to such a degree that you abuse other people with your need to control your environment specifically to your aggressively selfish satisfaction.
- spullara 7y agoIt amuses me that it is an 'Easter egg' another similarly confusing conflation of a Christian holiday with the commercialization of that holiday.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- SkyBelow 7y ago>xmas has cost millions of Jews their lives over the centuries Can someone fill me in on what this is referring to. I know my history knowledge is a bit lacking but I normally am able to get references like this so I must have missed something.
- buckminster 7y agoChristmas is the birthday of Jesus. Jesus was killed by the Jews. (Or the Romans egged on by the Jews?) So Christians historically didn't like Jews. So anti-Semitism is rooted in Christianity. And anti-Semitism led to the death of millions of Jews. Or something. These aren't my beliefs. Hope that helps!
- DonHopkins 7y agoYou literally don't believe that "anti-Semitism led to the death of millions of Jews"? You know what that makes you.
- lxe 7y agoThis was an obvious troll. Looks like they succeeded. A shame.
- krilly 7y agoRight? Clearly riffing on the 'happy holidays' message. I think it's a pretty funny post, and it's even more funny that it was taken seriously. Someone could go stalk their account to check, I can't be bothered with that right now.
- big_chungus 7y agoThey guy hasn't actually created much, though the account is fairly old. Most of the repos are forks of others with no changes. It looks like a real person, but his name is Christian, which is not a likely name for a Jew. His repos got brigaded and he claimed his grandfather fought for the Germans on the Eastern front after "kick[ing] some Gestapo ass" [0]. This part is obviously malarkey, and convinces me he's a troll. [0] https://github.com/Christian-Schiffer/servicelayer.chat/issues/21 https://github.com/Christian-Schiffer/servicelayer.chat/issu...
- userbinator 7y agoIt looks like a real person Appearances can be deceiving... even the profile photo could be generated and not a picture of a real human, as this other item currently prominently on the front page reveals: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21847051 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21847051
- neonate 7y agoNo need for all that effort. The profile photo was just lifted from somewhere else; see https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21847902 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21847902.
- nikolay 7y agoI am an Eastern Orthodox Christian and I am offended by Santa, which has nothing to do Christianity and it's nothing but a blatant display of overconsumption, wastefulness, not to mention the environmental impact of all this, which, against, goes well against Christianity, modesty, and actually conflicts with the Nativity Fast. Will I file an issue? No, never. It's childish, it's silly, it's not something an engineer should ever do. By the way, I'm offended by the plastic eggs and bunnies around Easter as well. None of these holidays are religious and here in Orange County, Southern California, I see many Muslims and Jews decorating their houses with the pseudo-Christian symbols as well. Every act will affect at least one person - I expected Microsoft to think about this starting this tradition and ending it. You can't make everybody happy, period!
- rhacker 7y agoI disagree with you. What's childish about filing an issue with something that offends you? > it's not something an engineer should ever do. But what if it wasn't Santa but it was like a different religious icon - like a menorah? I feel like literally thousands of American christians would have banned using VSCode or even Microsoft products for something like that.
- nikolay 7y agoBut what if I am offended that somebody finds my beliefs offensive?! I am not offended by other religions in any way whatsoever - I respect their rights as much as I want them to respect mine. The whole America is decorated for Hellowing, Christmas, and Easter - VS Code is people's least problem! And, as I stated, I can feel totally offended, but I'm not. I feel offended by Helloween, which all liberals celebrate, although it's has Roman-Catholic origins, it's against Christianity's principles, it has a huge environmental impact, and it greatly disturbs me personally, but I honor the rights of others to enjoy it. Should I be offended by nowadays Germans because in the past they killed my ancestors? Please, grow up! History is to learn from it, not to avenge for things way back in the past. Enough snowflakes among the engineers! I can't forget that master-slave "offensiveness" still!
- thatswrong0 7y ago
- mgolawala 7y agoI dont understand why the response "Dear <user>, We apologize if you found the icon offensive. Please be assured that no offense was intended. Thank you for bringing up the issue so we could clear things up." Was not a sufficient response and an end to the conversation? Leave the icon where it is. Now that the user knows that the icon wasn't meant as an offense, he can move on with his life. If he finds the swastika offensive, he shouldn't visit India. Swastikas are everywhere. The context matters.
- DonHopkins 7y agoI find non-apology apologies offensive. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Non-apology_apology https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Non-apology_apology >Saying "I'm sorry you feel that way" to someone who has been offended by a statement is a non-apology apology. It does not admit there was anything wrong with the remarks made, and may imply the person took offense for hypersensitive or irrational reasons. Another form of non-apology does not apologize directly to the injured or insulted party, but generically "to anyone who might have been offended". >Ifpology: Attorney and business ethics expert Lauren Bloom, author of The Art of the Apology, mentions the "if apology" as a favorite of politicians, with lines such as "I apologize if I offended anyone". Comedian Harry Shearer has coined the term Ifpology for its frequent appearances on "The Apologies of the Week" segment of Le Show.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- mgolawala 7y agoI am sorry you find non-apology apologies offensive, but that is all we have to offer. We're sorry we couldn't do better. ;) On a more serious note though. It is cool that there is a label for something like this, but to me it is just a polite way of de-escalation. You could be confrontational and say "I didn't do anything wrong, you're the one who is wrong to think what I did was wrong!" or you can say "I'm sorry you thought what I did was wrong, but my intention was not to wrong you or anyone.". There is nothing wrong with being polite and tactful.
- johnchristopher 7y ago> Santa is about as non-religious as you can get. Not really, see https://www.nationalgeographic.com/news/2018/12/131219-santa-claus-origin-history-christmas-facts-st-nicholas/ https://www.nationalgeographic.com/news/2018/12/131219-santa... and https://www.sefaria.org/sheets/51928?lang=bi https://www.sefaria.org/sheets/51928?lang=bi for very different perspectives.