21 ms·
Gun violence research is a good example of how science can be skewed to make different political points. For example, one of the new tactics gun control advocat
by rayiner 7y ago
Gun violence research is a good example of how science can be skewed to make different political points. For example, one of the new tactics gun control advocates have adopted is lumping homicides and suicides together into “gun deaths” even though the policy implications of the two things are quite different. (Suicides accounting for the large majority of “gun deaths,” but bans on semi-automatic rifles and high capacity magazines will have little effect on suicides. Likely red flag laws as well. Those are the three most viable gun control laws on the table right now.)
Measuring homicides versus “gun deaths” also changes whether there is an observed correlation between gun ownership rates and “gun death”/homicide rates: https://medium.com/handwaving-freakoutery/everybodys-lying-about-the-link-between-gun-ownership-and-homicide-1108ed400be5 https://medium.com/handwaving-freakoutery/everybodys-lying-a... (there is no correlation for homicides; there is a moderate correlation for suicides). So, for example, whether you research homicides or “gun deaths”/“gun violence” is already a politically significant choice that will alter the results.
So yes, more research and more data is always good. But this data will get twisted and abused for political grandstanding. People need to be prepared to cut through that.
I’d also point out that, at the end of the day, gun rights derive from the Constitution. Gun control is therefore not merely a policy choice to be made based on facts and data. In fact, there are lots of areas where we are quite reasonably sensitive to research efforts being misused for political ends.
- susijdjdjxa 7y agoI’m a little confused on your overall point here - are you saying that it’s only good to reduce gun homicides, not suicides?
- freeone3000 7y agoIt seems like the point is that different policies would affect suicides versus homicides, so grouping them into one category is not as useful as if they were separate.
- glenstein 7y agoIt's just a weirdly nitpicky place to decide to start the conversation, just to state something that's already going to be obvious to anyone researching the subject, something that sure as heck seems to be coming from a place of not wanting the research to be done at all. A better way of stating the point without letting the perfect be the enemy of the good and thereby losing sight of the underlying need for further research, would be to say something like the following: "This is great news. I hope the studies account for x,y, and z, and I look forward to their publication. I also look forward to supporting the legislation this research may make possible and to the safety benefits that stand to be gained. Anyone have any links for ways I can effectively pressure my local legislator and ask them to support even more funding in the future?" That way it's not ambiguous whether the research is supported. If, on the other hand, people just don't want more research, we would all benefit from having that clearly stated at the outset as well.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- ryeights 7y ago> Suicides accounting for the large majority of “gun deaths,” but bans on semi-automatic rifles and high capacity magazines will have little effect on suicides. Likely red flag laws as well. At the risk of sounding grim, if you're looking to commit suicide, a 12-gauge shotgun (very common for bird hunting) is probably your best bet. Nobody's looking to ban those.
- virmundi 7y agoEven then there is 15% chance of failure. Best option is a really tall building in the middle of a city far away from a body of water. That way there is less chance of your corpse being eaten by crawfish and crabs and birds.
- kasey_junk 7y agoIt’s actually likely an inverse relationship to this. Suicides are more likely to be successful where guns are prevalent compared to where they are hard to get. Meanwhile homicides are rare so no matter what tool you have access to you can get it done. https://www.hsph.harvard.edu/news/magazine/guns-and-suicide/ https://www.hsph.harvard.edu/news/magazine/guns-and-suicide/
- vorpalhex 7y agoThe US and UK suicide rates are extremely comparable, and the UK has far fewer firearms. Let's not even touch on Japan.
- kasey_junk 7y agoNo they aren’t. Most recent data suggests that the US has twice the suicide rate of the U.K. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_suicide_rate https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_suicide... Japan & Korea are interesting _because_ they are outliers.
- vorpalhex 7y agoThe US suicide rate per the CDC is 14/100k (2017). The UK suicide rate is 11/100k per the office of National statistics (2018). I'm not sure why the Wikipedia page dramatically disagrees with the UK's own stats.
- randogogogo 7y agoI think the poster is saying they don't like that some people conflate gun deaths with gun murders and use that as a justification for gun control.
- thawaway1837 7y agoThe OP’s argument is basically completely irrelevant to the actual point. If we banned any research that could be misinterpreted or abused because they are on political issues, we’d might as well ban all research...at the very least, research on climate change, vaccinations, health effects of pollution, research on deaths due to obesity, causes of obesity should be banned immediately. But if we go back a few centuries it gets a lot worse, because almost all science today, especially that which went against what the church believed, should have been banned by this logic. That being said, the OP’s specific point is also really bad. If gun control leads to reduced deaths, but the reduced deaths are entirely due to reduced suicides (they’re not...but hypothetically), that would still be an argument in favor of gun control, not against. It may not be a good solution to reducing the mass murder of toddlers, but hey, we won’t know that until we actually do the research on it. Which is the whole point.
- glenstein 7y agoBoth can be independently valid justifications for gun control without involving any conflation of one for the other. (I know that you're just elaborating on what the poster is saying rather than expressing your own views, so treat this as a reply to their comment rather than yours.)
- DuskStar 7y agoThere are two ways to reduce suicide - reduce the reasons to commit suicide, and increase the difficulty of committing suicide. As someone who views suicide as a bad choice - possibly the worst choice someone can make - I think the overall goal reducing suicide is good. But I don't think increasing the difficulty of suicide is the way to go about it. Imagine a prison, where every prisoner is held within solitary confinement - no contact with others at all. A lot of prisoners commit suicide each year, and the warden needs to reduce this. Is putting every prisoner on suicide watch - removing shoelaces, toilet paper, strong sheets, anything that a prisoner could use to kill themselves - a moral option? After all, it would reduce suicide - sure, the desire for suicide might go up, but no one would be able to act on it, so suicides would go down! But to me... That's just prolonging torture, and that's NOT ok. We've all got life sentences in this prison, and there's no hope of parole. I personally find life here on Earth to be great! But I can't support preventing people in worse situations from finding a way out. And when you reduce suicide by taking away a way out, instead of providing a better way...
- minikites 7y ago>gun rights derive from the Constitution Many people conveniently leave out the "well regulated militia" part of the second amendment.
- googlesux 7y agoMaybe you don't understand what a prefatory clause is? But it's a good talking point.
- sigzero 7y agoMeaning what? The SCOTUS has ruled several times that the individual right to bear arms is separate from the "militia" statement and both are covered in the 2A.
- Ididntdothis 7y agoWhy is the phrase "well-regulated militia" in there then? Is it just fluff that can be ignored?
- ryeights 7y agoWell, you can read the Supreme Court opinion to find out exactly why: https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/554/570/#tab-opinion-1962738 https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/554/570/#tab-opi... In short, the clause is there as a justification/motivation, and not a precondition, for the right to bear arms.
- Pinckney 7y agoIs pornography uncopyrightable because it's not a "science or useful art"? (I.8.8)
- Ididntdothis 7y agoI don't think that compares.
- jdkee 7y ago
- kasey_junk 7y agoBanning research funding is a decidedly more political act. One that people don’t have the opportunity to cut through. Also as an aside your point about existing data not correlating with homicide rates is particularly non compelling because it doesn’t normalize for firearm kind (handguns are more likely to be used in homicides than other forms of firearm) nor victim type (firearm ownership is massively correlated with domestic murders) statistical collection bias (the Las Vegas mass shooting was not included in national homicide statistics) or the massive scale difference of the US vs the rest of the world (we have a lot more murders of all type). But here is the thing bad data is _easier_ to manipulate. Every good actor should be cheering expanded research into this issue because it gives all of us a better framework to reason from.
- roenxi 7y ago> Banning research funding is a decidedly more political act. Possibly but not probably. Once a situation becomes politically interesting any action or inaction could potentially be the more political act. If only highly political actors are asking for more research then doing nothing is simply fiscal prudence and not an especially political act. I expect a lot of research on violence has already been conducted and the answers to any questions are probably already known. I don't normally see people in this debate saying 'we don't know X', they say 'we know X' and someone else says 'that is true but misleading/not important enough to justify Y/think of the children', etc.
- kasey_junk 7y agoWe weren’t “doing nothing”. We were actively discouraging research.
- anon9001 7y agoImagine if there was an initiative to research the use of cryptography in crimes, because obviously cryptography does have an impact on public safety. Also, as you know, there's powerful people that would love to see encryption regulated in ways that aren't in the public interest. That's how gun people feel about researching gun violence.
- dx87 7y agoAnother way I've seen statistics misused when advocating for gun control is bringing up the high number of "mass shootings" any time an event makes the news. The majority of "mass shootings" are gang violence, but gun control advocates will bring it up when there is a school/mall/etc. shooting to play on people's fears and make them believe that almost every day there is someone killing a bunch of kids in a school. I'm not trying to imply that gang shootings are acceptable, but it's misleading to lump them in with school shootings to push the "think about the children" angle.
- bluedino 7y agoOne thing I don't get is Mother Jones excludes shootings that result from domestic violence, drug deals and gang activity.
- surge 7y agoProbably because those shootings are probably in high gun control areas like Chicago, NJ, CA where laws are strictest, so it shows that gun control doesn't really work to stop those, and those deaths are usually the result overwhelmingly of handguns, not AR-15's or "assault style rifles" which are just semi-automatic rifles that look militaristic and no one would freak out about if they had wooden stocks. In this case, the numbers don't help their agenda. The most effective forms of gun control should be focused on guns used in the majority of crime, which are handguns, but that's not the discussion that's being had because the gun debate is media driven, which is centered around mass shootings (greater shock factor, better ratings), which statistically are the rarest and of least concern by numbers (I think gun death/homicides by rifle < 300 even including mass shootings). https://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-41488081 https://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-41488081 AR-15s are also very popular because they're a platform you can take an AR-15 lower, and or buy a cheap one and build up slowly over time until you have a very nice and accurate rifle. They look militaristic because their metal exterior but when people say they're identical functionally to hunting rifles, they're not lying when it comes to the part that handles firing the bullet. I'll also leave people with this: https://twitter.com/BillGates/status/1138520780042465280 https://twitter.com/BillGates/status/1138520780042465280
- spamizbad 7y agoI feel like gun fans are trying to have it both ways. Why are semi-automatic rifles common targets for gun control advocates? Well, they make the news. So maybe people need to recognize that handguns are far more deadly. But wait: We don't want those banned either because we like them for self defense. So keeping the public ignorant so we can operate in an infinite "well, actually.." loop is preferable. But I can see why this research is scary: someone should take a close look at the impact mass shootings have on our social fabric compared to say, random violence. Sandy Hook Shooting claimed the lives of 28 people, most of them children. But afterwards, there's been multiple suicides from the parents of their kids. In no small part because of nutty conspiracy theories that they're all crisis actors. Or, again touching on Sandy Hook, why was Adam Lanzas mother, an NRA-trained gun owner and enthusiast, permitting her troubled son access to dangerous firearms while knowlingly letting his mental health go untreated. Again, I'm not a member of the club, but I'd love for a sociologist to explore and understand gunowner's reasoning around stuff like that.
- kube-system 7y agoI think you have common ground with many in “the club” with your comment on the sociology of the situation. I think this is a situation where the quantitative research gets most of the attention, but the root cause of the problem will be hidden deep in the qualitative research. Premeditated mass murder is not a simple crime of opportunity. There are some difficult social issues that are driving people to want to take these actions.
- melling 7y agoThe entire 2nd Amendment claim is hotly debated, of course. Chief Justice Warren Burger’s epic rant: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=Eya_k4P-iEo https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=Eya_k4P-iEo There’s also an excellent episode about the Second Amendment on WNYC. https://www.wnycstudios.org/podcasts/radiolab/articles/radiolab-presents-more-perfect-gun-show https://www.wnycstudios.org/podcasts/radiolab/articles/radio... When people tell you the Constitution is clear about gun ownership and that it’s settled, they are lying.
- pstuart 7y agoGun advocates are easily "triggered" by any perceived threats to their toys.
- aalleavitch 7y agoThose toys let them imagine they have power. Take that away, and they might accidentally realize that they don't and get angry at the real boots stepping on their throats.
- rayiner 7y agoThe scope of the second amendment is surely debatable. But Burger’s “epic rant” expresses a view of the second amendment that’s not only rejected by Heller, but was wrong from inception. The idea of the Second Amendment as protecting a collective right is irreconcilable with the text: http://www2.law.ucla.edu/volokh/common.htm http://www2.law.ucla.edu/volokh/common.htm. See also: https://www.nytimes.com/2007/05/06/us/06firearms.html https://www.nytimes.com/2007/05/06/us/06firearms.html. Reading the contemporaneous works of the Founders leaves little doubt that the second amendment protects the collective right to self determination through the individual right to own weapons of war: > Before a standing army can rule, the people must be disarmed, as they are in almost every country in Europe. The supreme power in America cannot enforce unjust laws by the sword; because the whole body of the people are armed, and constitute a force superior to any band of regular troops. - Noah Webster, An Examination of the Leading Principles of the Federal Constitution, October 10, 1787 I’m not sure if the “collective rights” view is as shoddy as “penumbras,” but it’s surely more offensive to the Constitution to read a right out of it than to read rights into it.
- joshuamorton 7y agoI'm just going to note that in the responses, there are people saying that gun control advocates are abusing statistics when they ignore gang violence ("because it happens in high gun control areas") and when they include it ("because they can't tell the difference between a hand gun and assault rifle"), and of course it's not like you're being totally honest either: actual public health researchers who aren't some dude on medium repeatedly come to the opposite conclusion [0]. [0]: https://www.hsph.harvard.edu/hicrc/firearms-research/guns-and-death/ https://www.hsph.harvard.edu/hicrc/firearms-research/guns-an...
- datashow 7y agoI'm not sure how the link support your point.
- joshuamorton 7y agoGP claims that there is no correlation between gun ownership and homicide. That's a list of studies and meta-studies that directly refute that claim.
- CompanionCuuube 7y agoThe Medium article covers why using that correlation to assume causation is a problem, using other experimental variables that were shown to have a correlation with homicides.
- joshuamorton 7y agoNo it doesn't. Because there are other studies that back up the causal relationship. He's taken one that shows a clear correlation and explained why that's not enough to craft policy from, and that's true. But studies that show cross time correlation between homicide and gun ownership also exist. It might not be the only cause, but it being a cause makes sense: another poster showed a news story of a man who had killed 3 black kids who were trying to break into his house. Had he not had a gun, it's unlikely anyone would have died (most home intrusions, even with armed assailants, don't end up killing anyone). Guns provide means for homicide that basically no other tool provides.
- NotSammyHagar 7y agoscience or anything else humans do can be skewed. Saying things like 'we should do gun research because it can be skewed', well that's just a way to avoid it.
- NotSammyHagar 7y agotoo late to edit, I meant to say "we should not do gun research ..."
- benjohnson 7y ago>>gun rights derive from the Constitution. For me, I would say that the 2nd amendment reflects the natural right to self defense that all humans have.
- jki275 7y agoYes -- gun rights do not "derive from the Constitution", the Constitution codifies natural rights -- and that goes far beyond self defense.
- paggle 7y agoAlso, not all gun suicides should be prevented. My friend's grandfather was dying of Parkinson's and had a very horrible and unpleasant 3-6 months ahead of him. He blew his head to pieces with a gun. It was a massive quality of life improvement for him. Nobody in the family was really that upset -- they were glad that he didn't have to suffer, and he took care to do it in a way that none of his family had to discover the gruesome scene.
- pcwalton 7y agoMy stomach churned just reading that. If you want to make a point about death with dignity, consider some wording other than "he blew his head to pieces with a gun".
- paggle 7y agoCare to explain why? My point was that, the availability of a painless way to die was a very big blessing for that man at that time. Do you disagree?
- nl 7y ago> Care to explain why? My point was... Because the unsympathetic and blood thirsty description of his death distracted from your point.
- intopieces 7y ago>I’d also point out that, at the end of the day, gun rights derive from the Constitution. Gun control is therefore not merely a policy choice to be made based on facts and data. That it was written in the Constitution (which also counted black people as three fifths of a person and failed to enshrine voting rights) should not reduce the value the facts and data to "mere" status. You are right about the statistics, though.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- tomlockwood 7y ago> For example, one of the new tactics gun control advocates have adopted is lumping homicides and suicides together into “gun deaths” even though the policy implications of the two things are quite different. That's assuming that the reason for lumping them together is an attempt to justify policy. One counter argument to gun control seems to be that gun ownership is a way to preserve liberty and defend the home. It has been repeatedly and consistently found that gun ownership leads to an increase in gun related injuries and deaths for the owners - which undermines those arguments about liberty and home defence, regardless of the type of injury or death. It's hard to defend anything or have liberty when you're dead.
- ryeights 7y agoSo we should curb people's rights to self defense because some people might hurt themselves with the tools involved? You can apply a similar line of reasoning to the banning of fast food and cars. Why should the people be held to the standard of their least common denominator?
- yongjik 7y agoPersonally I see it the opposite way: America's infatuation with guns reflects a world where your fellow citizens are wild animals to be fended off with lethal threat, and your government is run by dangerous criminals ready to take you and your freedom by brute force. This is a world built upon the lowest common denominator of civilization.
- tomlockwood 7y ago> your government is run by dangerous criminals ready to take you and your freedom by brute force. Even more interesting to me is the idea that the American government has such a hold over the patriots in the military that they could be commanded to enforce tyranny. Or, that owning an assault rifle is some antidote against the best funded military in the world, which has been fighting armed insurgencies for years.
- fulafel 7y agoDo you think emphasizing all-cause mortality is questionable in fields where that metric is used? I think these metrics can be better for scientific NPOV because they don't presuppose so much.
- racnid 7y agoFor anyone reading along at home: Gun rights do not derive from the Constitution, they derive from the natural right of a being to protect itself. The second amendment is codifed there to attempt to limit the power of the government to take away that right. Despite what you may have been told it is not a collective right (there's no such thing), it is an individual right. Just like every other right enumerated in the Constitution.
- aalleavitch 7y agoYou give the individual too much credit. If the majority wanted to take away your guns, they would. The majority also can take away your right to self-determine, that's the entire basis of law and criminal punishment. If laws were based on fundamental moral truth they wouldn't change, and yet laws change all the time, that's one of the fundamental strengths of the US constitution (because time often shows laws to be unjust).
- ryeights 7y agoThat's true, but only so because democracy is the best option we have, i.e., it is the "least bad".
- sdinsn 7y agoBut many people (including myself) don't believe in the concept of "natural rights". I accept that rights only exist if they are granted to you and protected under law. Therefore, my rights to own guns is in fact derived from the Constitution.
- racnid 7y agoWhile you're certainly welcome to that opinion, it's incompatible with the origins and philosophy of the US Constitution at the very least. Your rights still exist even if someone hasn't told you they do.
- standardUser 7y agoWhile it is true that different gun policies may impact certain types of guns more than others, it is also true that widespread availability of firearms results in more fatal suicides. No conversation about gun violence can ignore the very significant role firearms play in suicide deaths.
- cadlin 7y agoThat Medium post isn't arguing in good faith either. He criticizes a bunch of graphs on Vox or Mother Jones, but doesn't bother engaging with any actual academic research. The news websites may be imprecise, but their underlying point isn't wrong.[1] Similarly, if I were to argue that anti-gun control people deliberately argue in good faith, I wouldn't use a random Hacker News commenter as evidence, but would instead point to the fact that John Lott fabricated survey evidence[2]. [1]https://www.hsph.harvard.edu/hicrc/firearms-research/guns-and-death/ https://www.hsph.harvard.edu/hicrc/firearms-research/guns-an... [2] https://web.archive.org/web/20130304061928/http:/www.cse.unsw.edu.au/~lambert/guns/lindgren.html https://web.archive.org/web/20130304061928/http:/www.cse.uns...