12 ms·
U.S. Supreme Court keeps ruling barring prosecution for sleeping in public
- hirundo 7y agoCongrats to the Supremes for doing justice and compassion by doing nothing.
- AaronFriel 7y agoThere was no circuit split here and the status quo did not involve any pressing constitutional controversy or original jurisdiction, so it was unlikely they would grant cert (take the case). The law as it stood was protecting a right that may or may not exist, but the court is unlikely to weigh in on lower courts creating rights or interpretations of rights that enable individuals. Had the lower court's decision involved criminalizing hundreds of thousands of people's daily lives, that might create the sort of controversy the court would consider vital to resolve.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- DoreenMichele 7y agoI have no idea if that was intended as snark. But: Sometimes doing nothing is the best answer. Sometimes, it takes enormous wisdom and personal restraint to act on that fact by doing nothing. It's why sayings like "The only way to win is not to play" are popular. (Entire blog post about that right here: https://raisingfutureadults.blogspot.com/2019/01/the-hand-licking-incident.html https://raisingfutureadults.blogspot.com/2019/01/the-hand-li...)
- munk-a 7y agoA nice hidden gem in this ruling - the supreme court didn't refute or counter the 9th circuit court's statement to the effect of > The 9th Circuit noted that those facilities could still refuse to shelter homeless people who exceed limits of the number of days they can stay or who object to mandatory religious programs. It'd be quite problematic for folks to be jailed for refusing mandatory religious programs - even if those people were homeless. I'm happy to see that this group of people managed to stand up for their rights against Boise - and maybe the city just needs to put out a bit more money toward health and safety by supplying adequate secular shelter options[1]. 1. As an aside, I really dislike that so many of the US domestic charities are religiously driven.
- justinclift 7y agoYeah. This sounds like another case of religious organisations picking on the vulnerable for "conversion" / indoctrination purposes (aka brainwashing). :(
- curiousgal 7y agoEven if that's true, at least they're helping them. I'm sure when given a choice between being "not brainwashed" and being fed, most homeless people would go for the latter. Also, if you're homeless you literally have nothing, what's wrong with finding solace in religion? At least you'd have some comfort.
- SolaceQuantum 7y ago"Also, if you're homeless you literally have nothing, what's wrong with finding solace in religion?" A significant portion of homeless people are actually 'invisible' homeless people- people living out of their cars, or sleeping on couches. They arguably do have things, up to and including a sense of identity and self for which any attempt of indoctrination must erode. I don't think someone who is sleeping on a friend's couch would be down for sleeping on a bed instead for the low low price of conversion therapy. (FTR: I don't think religion is brainwashing/conversion therapy or whatever. I also just think this take is also very bad.)
- daeken 7y agoThis line of reasoning doesn't defend their practices nearly as well as you think it does. For instance, paying homeless people to fight each other will certainly make sure they have money for food, and it might provide them some much-needed organized activity! If the reason you help someone is because you want to sell them something or use them, you're doing help wrong.
- brycesbeard 7y agoNot everyone agrees that intention is relevant. For me, it’s important to help while minimizing harm and trying to respect the agency and wishes of the recipient, which the fighting analogy violates. that is a challenging balance in practice, but we are talking about ethics, where there is more grey than b&w. I suppose you could argue that religion is harmful.. but even as an atheist, that’s a stretch for me to agree with.
- hprotagonist 7y agoat least we're still a little step above this: "In its majestic equality, the law forbids rich and poor alike to sleep under bridges, beg in the streets and steal loaves of bread." -- Anatole France
- reaperducer 7y agoLas Vegas has the same law as Boise (the subject of this ruling). https://www.reviewjournal.com/news/politics-and-government/las-vegas/las-vegas-passes-controversial-homeless-camping-ban-1887290/ https://www.reviewjournal.com/news/politics-and-government/l... Hopefully this will convince cities that putting people in jail is not a solution to homelessness.
- enjo 7y agoWhat is the solution then? All I know is my city (Denver) is being destroyed by it. I have a disgusting camp on my block full of trash, puke, and needles. I can no longer actually use of of the public spaces my tax dollars pay for because we’ve fully given them over to the homeless. Everyone will post that article about Utah but Denver instituted the very same program at the very same time with far less effective results. I try really hard to maintain my compassion but I see a problem with seemingly no solution and am just not sure what we can even do at this point.
- kmonsen 7y agoMaybe research why Denver's program is not working is the solution? This SC decision seems pretty clear in saying that if shelters are provided but not used, that can be illegal. It is only not possible to say people cannot sleep outside if there is no other options.
- Frondo 7y agoI used to live in a city (Portland) with a pretty sizeable homeless population. Last time I went back there, I was astonished at how the homeless population has grown. Tent cities everywhere. It really is shocking. I want to remain compassionate, too. What it comes down to for me is, I can't be too angry at the people living in these tent cities -- that's no one's first choice (barring, of course, that in any population some very small percentage of people want an itinerant life like that; certainly not this many). So I wondered, how has society broken down that this is it for so many people? How has the city, the state, and the federal government skewed the great societal playing field, that so many people must live like this? The safety net has a lot of holes, more than it seems like it used to, and who gains? For whom is this status quo the preferred one? I don't have answers (outside the usual economic stuff like, real wages haven't risen alongside the big three economic sinks for most people, education, health care, housing; a lot of attainable jobs have been sent overseas or replaced by technology), but where my compassion goes is, it can't be this many people's bad choices that got them here -- or, if it is, how has society been restructured that bad choices get people here, where falling this far didn't used to be such a readily available option? I do know that, doing the same thing we've been doing isn't going to get things to be better. And, intuitively, I don't think that smashing up tent cities (like they frequently do in Portland, in "sweeps") or jailing these people is going to solve the problem. I like what Utah has done. It's unfortunate that that hasn't worked in Denver; I wonder why. I don't like what Portland does (sweeps, moving people from encampment to encampment, tossing out what little stability and possessions they have). But I don't know what else we could do, locally or nationally. Definitely open to hearing options.
- turk73 7y agoMy wife works at a library. The homeless are a problem that the city and the county refuse to address because the library is "open to all" but does bad behavior have to be acceptable? Public drunkenness, abuse of other patrons, messes in the restrooms, smelly, nasty people sleeping in the chairs, just constant problems. They basically turn the library into a place nobody wants to visit in order to not offend a particular demographic. That's not fair to the community any more than the opposite is. I prefer the old days when the cops would show up and roust them out of there and tell them to go be a pain in the ass someplace else. I feel the same way about crime, too--the cops should be busting heads, instead we have muggers at the mall parking lot because "racism."
- minikites 7y ago>I feel the same way about crime, too--the cops should be busting heads They definitely still are: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Death_of_Eric_Garner https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Death_of_Eric_Garner https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shooting_of_Philando_Castile https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shooting_of_Philando_Castile https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Death_of_Freddie_Gray https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Death_of_Freddie_Gray
- downerending 7y agoThis has happened in my small city as well. The main library is no longer a safe place to visit, and has become a homeless shelter of sorts (with the accompanying smells and infestations). The good news, I guess, is that kids now have the Internet to learn from, and libraries are no longer a foundation of civic life.
- Pfhreak 7y ago> The main library is no longer a safe place to visit, Is this born out by an increase in crime at the library? Or are you just not feeling safe?
- downerending 7y agoIt's my feeling and a widely felt sentiment among the locals. Certainly the surrounding 300m area is a higher-crime area. A few weeks ago, I had to walk through and witnessed a woman pull down her pants and defecate on the sidewalk, about 50m from the library entrance. This wasn't in an alley or something--it was the main sidewalk, easily visible from the library entrance. I would not bring kids there.
- zer0faith 7y ago"The justices left in place a 2018 ruling by the San Francisco-based 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals that fining or jailing homeless people for staying outside or in unauthorized places if a bed at an emergency shelter is not available is unconstitutional" It is no secret that San Francisco has a homelessness crisis and if they can't prosecute how are they expected to clean up their city of homeless people? Edit: This is a legit question why all the down votes?
- seriesf 7y agoHrmm, what is a way to solve the problem of HOMElessness, other than throwing people in jail? Trying to think here, just brainstorming. Here's my list of top solutions to HOMElessness: 1) Zone 90% of the city for detached single-family homes? 2) Mandatory decade-long design review for every new home? 3) Lots of parking lots? 4) Designate every extant building a "historical resource"? Some combination of those policies should eventually solve the housing crisis, I think.
- gamblor956 7y agoYou're confusing the underhoused with the homeless. The underhoused cannot find affordable housing near their places of work. This is a serious problem in CA, and even with the intense residential building of the last 3 years CA is not making much headway. But homelessness of the kind at issue in this case is a very different thing. The vast majority of these homeless are mentally ill, drug addicts, or both. Re-zoning single-family lots won't do anything to address this problem, because most of them have families with homes who've simply given up on trying to take care of them.
- alistairSH 7y agoThe vast majority of these homeless are mentally ill, drug addicts, or both. Citation? That's a much repeated trope, but I've yet to see actual numbers to support it.
- gamblor956 7y ago
- gamblor956 7y agoSCOTUS and 9th Circuit judges would feel (and rule) quite differently if they were confronted with unbathed, tweaking drug users jerking off in front of them and their children every morning, refusing treatment and shelter because they'd rather be high than housed. The best solution is probably to redirect a number of the homeless to their tony neighborhoods. We would likely have rulings overturning shit decisions like this one in days.
- seriesf 7y agoThere are other laws against those things. We don't need one against sleeping outside.
- gamblor956 7y agoIn its infinite wisdom, the 9th Circuit has also decreed that we cannot force homeless drug users into rehab against their will, or to commit mentally ill homeless for treatment unless they represent an immediate danger to themselves or others...though the first sign of that is usually when they kill themselves or some innocent bystander, like has happened a dozen times in the past year.
- MisterBastahrd 7y agoHow often have people who have the comfort of homes killed people during the course of the past year?
- seriesf 7y agoI'm sure that's a gross exaggeration. In any case there have only been 33 homicides in SF in 2019, which is down by about 20% vs. the prior year.
- e1ven 7y agoYou're talking about people. Regardless of if they are annoying you, you shouldn't try to treat this like a pest-control situation. I urge you to re-think your position, with the understanding that they are real in the same way you are.
- 4ntonius8lock 7y agoThe title is inaccurate and makes it sound like homeless can't be prosecuted for any small or petty crime. It seems biased in making the ruling seem ridiculous. That is not the case. The ruling is hardly a huge win for civil liberties. It's pretty narrow and specific. A better title would be: "States can't jail people for sleeping in public if there's no homeless shelters." Of course such a title would seem reasonable and normal and wouldn't produce a click-bait news title that stokes the flames of national division.
- kmonsen 7y agoIt is actually even narrower, "States can't jail people for sleeping in public if there's no homeless shelters and they can prove they had no funds to provide alternative arrangements." If you can pay for a hotel room or other accommodation you the city/state can make it illegal for you to sleep outside.
- Bostonian 7y agoI don't the think ban on "cruel and unusual punishment" was meant to cover this: "Each had been fined between $25 and $75. Five of them were sentenced to time served, while one twice served a single day in jail."
- reaperducer 7y agoWhen you have $0, a $25 fine is cruel and unusual. Especially since not paying that fine that you can't pay means you go to jail.
- dv_dt 7y agoAnd tragically, we seem to always fund space in jails ahead of space in homeless shelters.
- oasisbob 7y agoAs I understand the issue, it's not fining someone who is indigent which is the constitutional issue. The core issue is punishing someone for something they are, vs punishing them for their behavior. The courts have said its cruel to prosecute someone for not having a home, when you're pretending that it's their behavior which is under attack. Shelter is essential to life.
- troydavis 7y agoI posted this in another comment (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21796211 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21796211), but the ruling is specific to sleep much more than homelessness, let alone camping on streets indefinitely. Here’s most of my other comment: The decision was that because sleep - not camping, but sleep - is a biological necessity, there must be a practical way for homeless people to obtain it. If that method isn’t shelters (because they’re full or inaccessible), then there needs to be places and/or times when sleeping is allowed and practical. The justices explicitly noted that this doesn’t mean municipalities can’t enact and enforce significant restrictions on when, where, and how (for example, no multi-day camping or no erecting structures) this can happen, including when no shelter beds are available. There needs to be a viable way to obtain sleep, though, whatever that way is. https://sccinsight.com/2019/04/08/what-the-9th-circuit-actually-said-about-criminalizing-homelessness/ https://sccinsight.com/2019/04/08/what-the-9th-circuit-actua... has an excellent unbiased explanation, though the core part of the decision is not that long. Here’s the footnote which explicitly carved out this stuff: > Naturally, our holding does not cover individuals who do have access to adequate temporary shelter, whether because they have the means to pay for it or because it is realistically available to them for free, but who choose not to use it. Nor do we suggest that a jurisdiction with insufficient shelter can never criminalize the act of sleeping outside. Even where shelter is unavailable, an ordinance prohibiting sitting, lying, or sleeping outside at particular times or in particular locations might well be constitutionally permissible. See Jones, 444 F.3d at 1123. So, too, might an ordinance barring the obstruction of public rights of way or the erection of certain structures. Whether some other ordinance is consistent with the Eighth Amendment will depend, as here, on whether it punishes a person for lacking the means to live out the “universal and unavoidable consequences of being human” in the way the ordinance prescribes.
- oasisbob 7y agoThat SCC article is really helpful, thanks! > The Ninth Circuit panel then walks through several important cases that touch on this question of what can be made criminal. Those cases highlight distinctions between criminalizing “status” and criminalizing “conduct,” beginning with a 1962 case, Robinson vs. California, in which the Supreme Court found that the State of California could not criminalize the state of being addicted to the use of narcotics (as opposed to the actual use of narcotics)
- peterwwillis 7y ago> the formation of encampments that can lead to unsanitary conditions and crimes such as drug dealing and gang activity Yes indeed, because of those ruthless gangs of homeless drug dealers, what with their effective means to procure and transport expensive products without being noticed, and their total lack of any profit from said enterprise keeping them homeless.
- cgriswald 7y agoYou’re railing against a straw man. Homeless people are vulnerable and many have drug habits. How could a homeless encampment NOT draw drug dealers and related criminal activity?
- peterwwillis 7y agoI'm hardly railing. In response to your question, they aren't a steady source of income for drug dealers, and drug dealers aren't just wandering the streets trying to sell drugs to people with no money. They stay on their turf and sell to people who come to them. And "related criminal activity"? Homeless people aren't criminal masterminds who collect all the city's neer-do-wells. They're just broken down people who need a place to lie down.
- cgriswald 7y agoI don’t think you have any experience with one of these encampments. They bring crime, perpetrated both on and by homeless people. These are facts. No one has implied that homeless people are criminal masterminds operating vast syndicates.
- peterwwillis 7y ago> They bring crime, perpetrated both on and by homeless people. These are facts. There is crime anywhere there are lots of people who have needs they can't meet, but even so, the crime rates aren't significant compared to other populations. Analysis such as this one by the Guardian show that the existence of homeless encampments don't have a direct link to crime rates: https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2018/may/23/homeless-villages-crime-rate-seattle-portland https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2018/may/23/homeless-vil... Sometimes crime rates may increase slightly, and sometimes they decrease slightly. Reports like these go back decades: http://community.seattletimes.nwsource.com/archive/?date=20040521&slug=tentcrime20m http://community.seattletimes.nwsource.com/archive/?date=200...
- djsumdog 7y agoAll the money spend to fighting for this legislation could have gone into actually housing people; real permanent housing for those too poor. Utah has shown that housing people first alleviates a lot of stress. It takes away that fear of not having a basic, consistent place to sleep and be somewhat secure. Cities that implement housing first programs save a lot of money, as it's easier for those people to get to find work and get themselves out of the system. Will some people abuse it and stay in government housing forever? Sure. But even with those people, municipalities still save money because a good chunk of the people can build their way out once their basic needs are met.
- gamblor956 7y agoAll of the money would then be spent fighting the NIMBYs who would prevent any homeless shelters from being built anywhere close to their neighborhoods...and indeed several tens of millions have been spent in courtrooms fighting off NIMBY lawsuits to the more than 2-dozen potential shelters that could have been built since the passage of Measure H. The fundamental failure of Measure H was that while there is the money to build the necessary housing, and the general political will to build somewhere....there is intense political opposition to any specific place that gets proposed as the location for homeless or transitional housing.
- malandrew 7y ago> All of the money would then be spent fighting the NIMBYs who would prevent any homeless shelters from being built anywhere close to their neighborhoods If this is an expected outcome, I would consider it fiscally irresponsible to propose building housing shelters in NIMBY neighborhoods and instead choose other places where money won't be wasted on litigation. There's no good reason for homeless shelters and other charitable services to be located on extremely valuable real estate and in NIMBY neighborhoods.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- 7y ago
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- Keverw 7y agoI wonder if this will effect van life. In some cities sleeping in your car is illegal even if in a valid parking spot minding your own business. Some places even illegal to take a break and sit on the ground. I think living in a van would be cramped, but maybe a RV would be nice but watched some of the van life channels and think it's insane sleeping in your van is a crime. I think some cops want to ID people who live different lifestyles because maybe they assume you are a criminal on the run for living in a van. But still insane you could go to jail or get your car impounded for sleeping in a parking spot... In some places sleeping on a bench too, putting people in Jail over sleeping which is a needed human function. Then many states won't let you have a license if you are homeless, unless you get help from a shelter and also try to make it harder to vote too. So you have to pretend you live with a relative or go to Texas or South Dakota to setup a mail forwarder and declare domicile since they recognize full time RVing. Plus heard some shelters won't help you if you still own a car, got to sell it first to receive services. I have heard though South Dakota only lets you vote for federal and state elections though, not local(city and county) but not sure how true that is... For example one of the counties doesn't have a "Wheel Tax", which would effect people registered there if ever passed, so RVers would vote no of course on it. Yet they say you can still be called for Jury Duty as mentioned on the affidavit, but heard the popular county for mail forwarders exempt those addresses, so you won't get picked in the first place but even if you do just call and tell them you are traveling full time to be exempted... But kinda interesting you are like a resident but not really a resident. I guess no states really considered people could retire and RV full time or younger people could live in a van and work remotely online. I guess kinda the same with college though... If you lived in California but your parents retired early and moved to Florida or Nevada, yet you wanted to stay in California to go to school with your high school friends then California would consider you a resident for DMV, taxes but no longer a resident for tuition since they go by your parents domicile until a certain age, yet until after a full year or two FL or NV wouldn't consider you a resident for school either, so I guess you could technically not be a resident of any state for tuition proposes.
- throwawaysea 7y ago> In some cities sleeping in your car is illegal even if in a valid parking spot minding your own business. It should be illegal. Parking spaces are by and large meant to primarily serve the needs of legal, taxpaying residents. When they get taken over for use as housing, it diminishes the ability for others to travel and visit friends/family/businesses. And street parking is taken away from those who live locally who may need to park overnight. All this is still leaving aside the fact that it is super creepy to have someone living out of an RV on your block, watching everyone's arrival/departures, casing their joints. Especially because a number of these RV dwellers are permanently-nomadic drug-addicts who engage in property crime to fuel their habits. No thanks.
- jdkee 7y agoWe did a great disservice to the mentally ill when we closed (rather than reform) our mental institutions. The mentally ill would greatly benefit from compassionate custodial care. For those who merely make bad personal choices then enforcement of no urban camping laws by disposing of unoccupied campsites along with the availability of low cost simple barracks type shelters for overnight use should ease the situation without resorting to arrests or fines. Society can be firm and compassionate at the same time. The current situation in some of our cities is intolerable to all concerned.
- einpoklum 7y ago"make bad personal choices" - somehow, people in the US make bad personal choices in direct correlation to government economic policy. And in many other countries almost nobody "makes bad choices". I guess public welfare inspires astute personal choice-making!
- merpnderp 7y agoWhat option was there to reform? The Supreme Court said people who weren't a danger to themselves or others couldn't be held against their will. I'm all for trying to figure out how to help the mentally ill, but that often comes in the form of treating chemical addiction, which seems to have a long term success rate of around ~10%, a number so low that in a hierarchy of responsible spending, treatment wouldn't make the top of the list.
- asdff 7y agoLiving on the street is a danger to yourself. Mental illness get worse without treatment, and coupled with a life on the street without intervention, will end up with your death.
- aSplash0fDerp 7y agoMental illness has been on display in the media 24/7 for quite some time, so functional crazy is not a pipe/pill dream after all.... If any hardworking individuals were given the same accountrements in a high-cost city (permanent housing with housekeeping), there would be a huge waiting list. With a possible impending retirement crisis, able-bodied may not be the best term for qualification. As an aside, recycling is not profitable anymore, but the pre-existing obligations prevent dramatic or even drastic change on that front. This is no different. If I were to throw something on the wall for homelessness, I'd say keep it simple and build 3 new regional cities in the west, central and east with a clean slate design and throw up a sign that says "give us your tired, your poor" and see what happens. That way, several states, cities and counties are pooling their resources/budgets, you give everyone a red/white/blue moment, but in the true American Spirit, you make it someone elses problem overnight (aka. Make it disappear) for something you were going to pay for anyway. If we limit "extreme economy/political/welfare/climate experiments" to only these 3 regional areas, we may actually get lucky and build something resilent enough to be a runway for future generations, while being strong enough to be a safety net for the current gens. I say all of this in jest, but if it becomes a question of millions of old people dying with dignity, instead of homeless in the streets, there will be enough "zeros" to build it (nimby lingo).
- throwawaysea 7y agoThis is a terrible decision by the Supreme Court. People do not have a right to sleep wherever they want, whenever they want. If they cannot join a community and be a productive/contributing member, there has to be a disincentive for that. Right now, many cities like Seattle and SF have law-abiding tax-paying residents who have to see their beautiful cities ruined by tents/trash/needles, put up with unsafe conditions, see their property value diminish, and amenities take over (like parks with tents). No one has a right to live where they want at whatever price point they want. This is the strongest economy of all time. Unemployment is at an all time low. And there are many locations where someone can do a job (not necessarily the one they want) and earn a living, instead of picking the more desirable locations. I believe every jurisdiction should be able to set its own rules governing where/when people can sleep. And taxpayers should not be obligated to pay for someone else's life due to their lack of personal responsibility. The refusal to hear the challenge here is simply enabling the permanently-nomadic to take over land they do not own at no cost and with no consequence.
- greglindahl 7y ago> People do not have a right to sleep wherever they want, whenever they want. Indeed, and this court ruling doesn't say that. The limitations of the circuit court ruling are described in the article, which I'm sure you've read. Second paragraph.
- einpoklum 7y agoThe US Supreme Court is infamous, especially in recent years, for favoring the interests of the powerful, the moneyed and the landed over those of, well, other people (see: https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/22715946-injustices https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/22715946-injustices). So, at least we know there is some bar - albeit very low - beyond which they're not willing to let local authorities victimize the poor. That is - you are at least allowed to sleep outside on the cold hard floor. Thanks SCOTUS.
- int_19h 7y agoHave you considered that it is rather the constitution and the laws that favor the interests of the powerful, and the courts (by design) rule according to the laws?
- einpoklum 7y agoWell, yes, you're right that a lot of it is in the constitution and the laws - but certainly not all of it. There is a vast space for interpretation.
- int_19h 7y agoThere is, but I'd rather the courts go with the most obvious interpretation of the law, then start from a premise of what should be done (as they see it), and then try to stretch the law to fit. Courts are not for making policy, and when they're appropriated for that purpose, it quickly spirals out of control. If the problem is with the laws and the executive policies - and it really is - then let's fix those.