8 ms·
I agree with many of the other posters: JetBrains has succeeded because their products are generally awesome, and I am a happy personal subscriber. People shoul
by hn_throwaway_99 7y ago
I agree with many of the other posters: JetBrains has succeeded because their products are generally awesome, and I am a happy personal subscriber. People should especially remember what the Java IDE landscape looked like when they first came out with IntelliJ: using IntelliJ after using NetBeans or Eclipse was like using Google for the first time after being familiar with AltaVista - it was just a night and day better product.
Still, I wonder if they could have been successful without funding if they were a US or Western European company. Especially in the early days, I'm sure the much lower salaries in Prague allowed them to be more competitive with a lower burn rate. My point is I think their VC-less success would have been much more difficult in a place with higher salaries and cost-of-living.
- hugi 7y agoI'm an outsider fan. I've attempted to use IntelliJ on multiple occasions, but it just can't really compete with Eclipse as far as my requirements are concerned. But the competition from and innovation in IntelliJ has no doubt made Eclipse better (and modern Eclipse is kind of awesome and just keeps getting better).
- chris_j 7y agoWhat is it about your requirements that means that IntelliJ can't compete with Eclipse?
- itronitron 7y agobeing able to organize things into separate projects in Eclipse, in the same window, is very nice
- ivan_gammel 7y agoEclipse project = IntelliJ module Eclipse workspace = IntelliJ project
- Majestic121 7y agoThat's possible with intelliJ as well (at least in the pro version)
- hugi 7y agoI'm a contractor working on many projects. Using Eclipse, I can keep my entire universe of all projects I have deployed (about 30 of them), as well as their dependent libraries, as well as every open source project I use and contribute to, open at all times. I almost never close a project and I never open a project. It's just all there. If I need to use or modify a piece of code, written by me or someone else, it's all accessible to me at all times with a single keystroke. No project switching. Close to no context switching. IntelliJ doesn't even come close to this kind of power.
- shagie 7y agoI believe you're seeing a conceptual mismatch between workspace and project from how Eclipse and IntelliJ model working. Try creating an empty project in IntelliJ and then add each of your Eclipse projects as a module to the IntelliJ empty project.
- hugi 7y agoYeah, tried that. Multiple times. IntelliJ just doesn't handle it performance wise, and it feels awkward because IntelliJ just isn't designed as well for working on multiple projects simultaneously. It's probably great for people working on a single project with some dependencies (modules). IntelliJ really wants you to open a project, work on it, then you close it and open the next project. That doesn't fit me. Doesn't mean IntelliJ is bad, it's just a bit limited in that regard. My dozens of projects are not a single project with "modules". I have a universe of code in multitudes of interrelated projects, closed source and open source. I want to refactor openly, not having to care how I'm moving code between projects. Eclipse works perfectly for this. IntelliJ does not.
- AnthonBerg 7y agoIntelliJ really wants you to open a project, work on it, then you close it and open the next project. That doesn't fit me. This does not match my experience at all, fwiw. I keep all manner of projects open simultaneously.
- 7y ago
- jillesvangurp 7y agoI switched from Eclipse to Intellij only three years ago because it actually used to be pretty good but just fell behind too much. Gradle & Spring Boot were the reason I gave up on Eclipse. I just couldn't get a project imported correctly without running into a lot of bugs. So, when a new project came up I just switched over and started using Intellij. Before that, for doing vanilla maven + Java projects Eclipse was awesome and generally running circles around intellij in terms of performance, which is still something that is off by order of magnitudes in Intellij and something I miss a lot. Intellij users are always surprised when I bring that up and say it is fine on their machine. And then I point out that 5-20 seconds to run a unit test after a 1 letter code change is obscenely slow compared to Eclipse because it finishes incremental compilation a few ms after you lift your finger and is ready to run your test. Intellij attempted to integrate the Eclipse incremental compiler but it is not used by default and generally not that well integrated. Their compilation strategy depends on a lot of caching, which is hard and frequently gets in an inconsistent state (i.e. your IDE lies to you about things compiling or not compiling), which is why people routinely rebuild their whole project, or worse invalidate caches and restart (a top level menu option because it needs to be).
- aedron 7y agoThere are, despite the often very aggressive IntelliJ proponents, many areas where Eclipse beats IntelliJ, and incremental compilation is indeed one of the most important. It is also possibly the most important feature in a Java IDE. Ctrl+s and you know the whole codebase is compiled. Go to another file and any code change is available in the code completion (like new or changed methods signatures). Any errors from the change you just saved is shown immediately from across the entire codebase. I just can't live without a core thing like this missing, and compounded with a number of other things that Eclipse does better, I stay on Eclipse. Unfortunately many younger developers think IntelliJ is all there is.
- dathanb82 7y agoWhen's the last time you checked out IntelliJ? It does incremental compilation these days, plus auto-save-and-compile whenever you switch tabs (not just when you save the current tab, which bit me many times in Eclipse; though I haven't used Eclipse in at least four years now), so code completion is immediately updated. I'm pretty sure this has been the case for a few years now.
- pharaohgeek 7y agoThere is a single Eclipse plugin that keeps me married to that IDE: log4e (http://log4e.de http://log4e.de). It makes it a breeze to add logging statements to your code. One click puts start/end statements on all methods. One click lets you log a particular variable. And all the statements are templatized, making it dead simple to ensure your logging adheres to your company's logging standards. I WISH this plugin (or something comparable) was available for IntelliJ or even NetBeans. I'd drop Eclipse in a heartbeat.
- Rapzid 7y agoYou might be on to something but their product philosophy just seems to be.. different. Compare TeamCity to Bamboo; it's in a different league. Maybe that does come down to the extra human resources they can throw at stuff. Their products are/were ambitious in an MVP environment.
- sharken 7y agoSome TeamCity details are a bit odd, for example you are not allowed to run a development server and a production server with one license. Instead you should get an evaluation license, that is only valid two months at a time. Conditional build steps have been requested by users for years and even though it's the most requested feature, nothing has happened for years. But it's still way way ahead of the alternatives.
- anon73044 7y ago>But it's still way way ahead of the alternatives Like Jenkins, Bamboo, TFS, VSTeam, TravisCI, CircleCI, GitLabCI, UrbanCode? Maybe it's just me, but the CI/CD space is pretty crowded these days, and Jenkins is still #1 for a reason. I don't find myself fighting TeamCity as much these days but there's alot if things I wish it could do better.
- sharken 7y agoIn fairness I have only tried Jenkins, CruiseControl and Azure DevOps. What sets TeamCity apart is the use of Kotlin. You do have to invest a fair amount of time to get the most of it, but when you do the return is great. Putting together a pipeline in Azure DevOps with tons of YAML is not a great experience. As far as Jenkins is concerned I think that it's biggest selling point is that it's free.
- Zetoke 7y ago>I'm sure the much lower salaries in Prague allowed them to be more competitive with a lower burn rate It's a russian company with the most people (especially engineers) in St. Petersburg. It's only technically registered in Prague. They have only 50 people there. And around a thousand people distributed across Russia (St. Petersburg, Moscow, Novosibirsk), Munich, Boston and brand new office in Amsterdam.
- SmirkingRevenge 7y agoI never knew they were a Russian company. That kind of makes me rethink my support, this day and age. Trusting a Russian company for such fundamental tooling seems really unwise.
- lghh 7y agoWhy is that? And, alternatively, who would you trust?
- SmirkingRevenge 7y agoRussia is a malevolent authoritarian regime. Russian companies (like Chinese companies) have no power to resist the dictates of their authoritarian governments. I don't trust anyone completely, but democratic countries where government authority is checked/constrained by the people and competing forces are far more trustworthy.
- grzm 7y agoAt least some of Jetbrains' offerings are open source. If you have security concerns, you may be able to alleviate some of them by your own examination. I'd also encourage you to consider separating your concerns about the Russian government and individuals living in Russia, just as you might other governments and their citizenry.
- SmirkingRevenge 7y ago
- goatherders 7y agoWhich is a pretty strong vote for building your company somewhere with lower salaries and lower cost of living. There are a LOT of great engineers in places other than SV, Austin, Boston, etc.
- xtracto 7y agoThis has been the bet of the company I work for: Contract Engineers in GDL, Mex. Paying 1/3rd the price of SV payments and still getting awesome talent, while being able to provide very competitive benefits for the region.
- tootahe45 7y agoI'd say it's a strong vote for building an actual product people want, which SV startups seem to struggle with.
- ternaryoperator 7y ago>remember what the Java IDE landscape looked like when they first came out with IntelliJ: using IntelliJ after using NetBeans or Eclipse was like using Google for the first time after being familiar with AltaVista You're skipping over several commercial Java IDEs available when IntelliJ first came out: Most notably, Borland JBuilder, which was an excellent product. Symantec had Visual Cafe as well, which was not really in the same league as JBuilder, but still had some magic. IMHO, JetBrains succeeded by having a product as good as JBuilder (and revving it so it got better quickly) and not cratering as a company the way Borland did.
- stevoski 7y ago> Most notably, Borland JBuilder, which was an excellent product. I switched from JBuilder to IntelliJ in 2002 I think. JBuilder was good but on oh so expensive, if you wanted the full-featured version! IIRC it was 5 or 10 times the price of IntelliJ. What blew me away when I tried IntelliJ for the first time, in comparison to JBuilder, was the refactoring tools. For the first time I felt I could safely rename classes and methods and move classes without manually searching my codebase.
- prepend 7y agoIntelliJ was much faster than JBuilder. This is what I remember most, IntelliJ was as fast as using Visual Studio. I liked JBuilder, but VisualCafe was a nightmare. But IntelliJ was much more responsive and much cheaper.