8 ms·
> a jetbrains ide can do are just much better than what my custom setup could do I get frustrated by people who insist on a complex vi/emacs setup for somethin
by dehrmann 7y ago
> a jetbrains ide can do are just much better than what my custom setup could do
I get frustrated by people who insist on a complex vi/emacs setup for something Jetbrains IDEs do better out of the box. Or people who insist Sublime is good for editing their complex React project.
- personjerry 7y agoHello! I use Sublime for my complex React project. What should I be using instead?
- maushu 7y agoI don't know what OP uses but I use VS code and it's pretty good for a free editor.
- justsid 7y agoOP is litereally ranting about people using text editors for tasks that IDEs excell at, and you are suggesting another text editor.
- gatherhunterer 7y agoVSCode has out-of-the-box support for JS and TS including autocomplete, visual debugging and variable definition lookup. VSCode is an IDE.
- _bxg1 7y agoVSCode markets itself as a text editor, but really it's an IDE, especially if you're using TypeScript.
- lonelappde 7y agoVScode calls itself a Code Editor, not text editor
- rco8786 7y agoVSCode is way closer to IDE than text editor on that spectrum
- michaelmrose 7y agoBy that definition Emacs is also an ide just in a kit you spend a few hours putting together.
- Aeolun 7y agoVS code qualifies as an IDE for React. Just not a very good one. Most things can be solved with plugins though.
- fgonzag 7y agoSo nobody can give the opposing view point? I use both IDEs and Text Editors depending on the language. I use jetbrains for kotlin/java, and moved from vim to vscode for javascript and any other scripting language (also switched from VS to VSCode for .net) I find developers who try to force their tools on others annoying. I'm much more productive on scripting languages with an editor. They just feel more responsive.
- justsid 7y agoOf course you can disagree with that! I have written great amounts of all sorts of projects in text editors instead of an IDE. And yes, text editors come in different flavours. VS Code/Sublime Text isn’t the same as Notepad. That being said, the person I replied didn’t make a case of VS Code in any way. The OP asked what to use instead of a text editor like Sublime Text, and the reply was simply “Just use VS Code”. That’s not an argument in any way, that’s just a statement.
- clintonb 7y agoWebStorm is the JetBrains tool for JS development.
- winrid 7y agoWebStorm is where it's at.
- leeman2016 7y agoVSCode is good for a free editor. But the difference between VSCode/Sublime and Webstorm is night and day.
- edanm 7y agoI mainly use vim and occasionally use Jetbrains. My setup in vim is super complex. I can tell you exactly how I feel about it: Vim is a better text editor than anything else. By far. Unfortunately, vim is terrible at basically everything else. The problem is, once you learn to use vim's text editing capabilities, then editing code using anything else feels like a pain. I'm not talking about variable lookups / etc. I'm talking the pure "move the cursor to a certain place and enter some text" aspect of it. If you don't know vim, then it's hard to understand how slow editing text feels without it - it's kind of like going from not knowing how to type properly to being a solid touch typer. (not that extreme, but that's what it feels like). Unfortunately, because vim sucks at everything else, my setup has to be complex to actually get it to do the other things a good IDE does out of the box. If I could do it the other way around, I would - I'd love to be able to use vim-like editing inside of an IDE, but every vim-mode I've tried so far just doesn't work properly (except one - evil mode in Emacs - which is why I recently switched to Spacemacs, but that's another story).
- janderland 7y agoThe vim emulation for the IntelliJ tools worked very well for me. Used to use only vim with a complex setup. Have been using Goland, and IntelliJ for about a year now.
- edanm 7y agoI actually haven't tried it (just started using PyCharm again very recently). But I gave it a go right after posting my comment. And like almost every other emulation I've ever tried, within 1 minute, I found 5 things that didn't work correctly. And I'm not exaggerating here - I literally spent 1, maybe 2 minutes and found 5 things. I'll have to use it for a while to find out whether it's just a few minor annoyances, or much worse than vim.
- libria 7y agoCan you briefly enumerate some of them here? I'm a casual vimmer and have plateau'd on the basic vim features that are good enough, so I'm curious what advanced commands are useful day-to-day.
- zo1 7y agoThat or "VSCode". It does not compare to a proper IDE. And so far my attempts at meaningful discussion regarding it not being the right tool for anything except TS just ends up in "voodoo" arguments about how it can "debug anything", etc.
- michaelmrose 7y agoPresumably they value aspects of their environment over the features that jetbrains provides. The complexity is usually overstated and a sunk cost besides.
- RHSeeger 7y agoI use both emacs and Intellij, depending on the circumstances. There are some things for text editing that are just faster in emacs. For example, - I can be somewhere, jump around to a bunch of files, copy something, and then jump back to whereever I was last actually editing quickly (the "jump back to last edit" is 2 strokes). - I wrote a custom mode, with tabification and fontification for the query language used by the cms I work with. I expect I could do that in IntelliJ but it would take a lot more effort. - Things like kill-rectangle and the like; some of which may have parallels in IntelliJ, but I don't know then... and decades of experience in emacs means I do know them (or how to find them) there. I really like IntelliJ, but I also really like emacs. Which to use depends on what I'm doing. I also really like _make_ and wrap my other commands (mvn, gradle, etc) in Makefiles. I get jokingly mocked a lot at work :)
- gnulinux 7y ago> I also really like _make_ and wrap my other commands (mvn, gradle, etc) in Makefiles. I get jokingly mocked a lot at work :) I do this as well. I put my scripts in a make file. E.g. to ssh into a machine X, I write a Makefile with .PHONY rule "X" so I simply run "make X".
- syspec 7y agoI believe that’s a shortcut in intelli-j products. It’s like cmd+[ for last viewed location and cmd+shift+[ for last edit location
- root_axis 7y agoI have the reverse opinion. I find jetbrain users are so eager to extract the dollar value from their IDE that they try to shoe-horn the use of every available feature into their workflow just because they exist, whereas with vim, the features I use are a laser focused toolset I have accumulated over the years based on the need to solve specific problems. Vim accommodates my desired workflow while many jetbrains users attempt to shift their workflow into webtstorm's feature-set.